Tuesday March 2nd, 2021 9:04PM

Decision could come by June in latest Supreme Court 'water wars' hearing

By Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court tried Monday to inject some mystery into its second consideration of a long-running dispute between Georgia and Florida over water that flows from the Atlanta suburbs to the Gulf of Mexico. A major part of the river basin is North Georgia's Lake Lanier. 

Invoking Agatha Christie and Arthur Conan Doyle, the justices puzzled over Florida's claims that blame for the decimation of the state's oyster industry lies with Georgia farmers who use too much water from the Flint river.

By the time the Flint joins with the Chattahoochee River to form the Apalachicola River at the Florida line, too little is left for Florida's once-lucrative oyster fishery.

Georgia says the fault lies with overharvesting of oysters, historic droughts and mismanagement, among other reasons.

Chief Justice John Roberts said many factors could have played a part, comparing the situation to Christie's “Murder on the Orient Express.”

“A lot of things took a stab at the fishery...But you can’t say that any one of those things is responsible for killing the fishery,” Roberts said.

Justice Clarence Thomas gave the dispute between the two states, and their differing claims about how much water even is at issue, a title in the manner of Doyle's tales about Holmes, "the case of the disappearing water.”

Florida is seeking a court order forcing Georgia to limit its use of water from the Flint. When the justices first heard the dispute three years ago, Florida also was claiming that the Atlanta area's consumption of water from the Chattahoochee river also played a big role in the reduced flows in Florida, but that claim has fallen out of the case, Gregory Garre, Florida's lawyer, said Monday in arguments that were held via telephone because of the coronavirus pandemic.

“I guess I would say in closing it’s hard to imagine New England without lobsters or, say, the Chesapeake without crabs, but, in effect, that’s a future that Apalachicola now faces when it comes to its oysters and other species,” Garre said.

Last year, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission voted unanimously to shut down oyster harvesting in Apalachicola Bay through the end of 2025 because of a dwindling oyster population.

Craig Primis, representing Georgia, urged the justices to end the case in his state's favor because Florida had not conclusively proved that its northern neighbor is to blame for the problems on the Apalachicola.

Florida's lawsuit against Georgia was filed directly in the Supreme Court, which is mainly an appellate court but hears disputes between states. The court appointed a special master to evaluate the case, and he initially recommended that Georgia should prevail.

But three years ago, the justices voted 5-4 to give Florida another chance to prove its case.

The court appointed a new special master, who also recommended the court side with Georgia. Florida's objections to that recommendation are at issue in the Supreme Court.

The outcome could come down to the views of the two newest justices, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett, who were not yet on the court when it heard the dispute in 2018.

The justices they replaced, Anthony Kennedy and the late Ruth Bader Ginsburg, both voted with Florida.

Kavanaugh asked similar questions of both sides that made it hard to assess how he might vote.

Barrett wondered whether Georgia could take some steps without incurring too much expense to help revive Apalachicola oysters. “How do we put a price on an environmental benefit like that?” she asked.

A decision is expected by late June.

  • Associated Categories: Homepage, Local/State News
  • Associated Tags: water wars, SCOTUS, Lake Lanier , Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint river basin, U.S. Supreme Court , Florida water lawsuit
© Copyright 2021
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Decision could come by June in latest Supreme Court 'water wars' hearing
The Supreme Court tried Monday to inject some mystery into its second consideration of a long-running dispute between Georgia and Florida over water that flows from the Atlanta suburbs to the Gulf of Mexico.
3:01PM ( 11 minutes ago )
NL MVP Freeman delayed to Braves camp by birth of twin boys
Freddie Freeman won’t report with the Atlanta Braves position players on Tuesday following the birth of his twin sons
2:46PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Death penalty trial delayed in Georgia prison guard killings
One of two Georgia prisoners accused of killing two guards had his death penalty trial delayed after his lawyers raised concerns related to the coronavirus pandemic
2:38PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Local/State News
Florida-Georgia water wars return to the nation's high court today
Oral arguments are scheduled before the U.S. Supreme Court today for the ongoing lawsuit Florida has filed against Georgia over Georgia's use of water in the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River (ACF) Basin.
By AccessWDUN Staff
7:07AM ( 8 hours ago )
U.S. Supreme Court sets Feb. 22 as date to hear water wars lawsuit
In October, the Supreme Court of the United States announced the high court would hear Florida's lawsuit against Georgia over Georgia's use of water from the Chattahoochee River Basin during its 2020-21 session.
By AccessWDUN staff
12:35PM ( 1 month ago )
Hall County wants to look at wording in EPD stormwater edict before final approval
Changes handed down by the Georgia Environmental Protection Division (EPD) regarding Hall County’s management of stormwater took a step towards realization with first reading of the resolution at Thursday evening’s Hall County Commission meeting, but there might be some changes in the works.
9:20PM ( 3 months ago )
'Water Wars' lawsuit included in U.S. Supreme Court order for 2020-2021 session
The ongoing water war between Florida and Georgia is expected to go back before the United States Supreme Court at some point in the 2020-2021 term.
By AccessWDUN Staff
7:55AM ( 4 months ago )
Collins, Woodall want to see a Lake Lanier water storage contract from Corps of Engineers
North Georgia congressmen Doug Collins of Gainesville and Rob Woodall of Lawrenceville said it's past time for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to finalize a contract with the state of Georgia over water storage in Lake Lanier.
By AccessWDUN Staff
11:28AM ( 7 months ago )