Saturday August 15th, 2020 10:30AM

Lawyers for Georgia election officials deny clients destroyed evidence in election system lawsuit

By Associated Press

ATLANTA (AP) Lawyers for Georgia election officials are rejecting as frivolous allegations that their clients destroyed evidence in a case challenging the state's outdated election system.

Election integrity advocates and individual Georgia voters sued election officials, saying the voting machines the state has used since 2002 are unsecure and vulnerable to hacking. In a court filing Thursday, they said the state began destroying evidence within days of the suit's filing in 2017 and has continued to do so as the case moved forward.

Responding in a court filing Tuesday, lawyers for state election officials called those allegations ``a desperate attempt to distract the Court and the public from the complete lack of evidence of an actual compromise of Georgia's election system.''

The state's election system came under national scrutiny last year during the closely watched gubernatorial election in which Republican Brian Kemp, who was the state's top election official at the time, narrowly beat Democrat Stacey Abrams.

State officials on Monday announced that they have selected a new voting system and expect it to be in place in time for the presidential primary election on March 24. But the state still plans to use the outdated machines for special and municipal elections in the interim.

U.S. District Judge Amy Totenberg held a two-day hearing last Thursday and Friday on requests by the plaintiffs in the lawsuit that she order the state to immediately stop using its current voting machines and switch to hand-marked paper ballots. She hadn't ruled on those requests by Wednesday.

In their brief Thursday, lawyers for the Coalition for Good Governance accused state officials of destroying computer servers from the Center for Election Systems at Kennesaw State University after a security hole there that exposed Georgia voters' personal data and passwords used by county election officials was discovered. State lawyers then failed to ask the FBI for a copy of a forensic image the agency made of the server before it was wiped, despite saying they would, they say.

The brief also accuses state officials and their lawyers of deleting and overwriting data preserved on voting machine memories and on memory cards used to program the voting machines.

All of the evidence that the coalition's brief says was destroyed still exists and remains available for their review during the evidence gathering process, the state's lawyers wrote. They contend that the coalition was aware of this and made the allegations to get news media attention and promote its fundraising efforts.

The initial lawsuit filed in 2017 had nothing to do with elections conducted while the Kennesaw State server was in use, and the server was not identified as something that needed to be preserved until several months later when the plaintiffs announced their intent to file an amended lawsuit with additional claims, the state lawyers wrote. Nevertheless, they argue, an FBI copy of that server does exist and the state has requested a copy and told the plaintiffs in early July that they would provide it to them.

Past election data on memory cards and the internal memory of the voting machines isn't erased by later usage because each election is stored in folders on various election systems, and the plaintiffs are aware of that, the state lawyers wrote. Therefore, allegations that that evidence was destroyed are unfounded, they argued.

The coalition's allegations of evidence destruction amount to ``gamesmanship,'' and the judge should reject them, the state lawyers argue. 

  • Associated Categories: Homepage, Local/State News, Politics
  • Associated Tags: voting equipment, lawyers, election lawsuit , Georgia election
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Lawyers for Georgia election officials deny clients destroyed evidence in election system lawsuit
Lawyers for Georgia election officials are rejecting as frivolous allegations that their clients destroyed evidence in a case challenging the state's outdated election system.
3:22PM ( 10 minutes ago )
US stocks fall after Federal Reserve cuts key interest rate
Major U.S. stock indexes are falling after the Federal Reserve cut its key interest rate for the first time in a decade. Some believed the Fed might act more aggressively in cutting rates by half a percentage point
2:55PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Housing community for Northeast Georgia Medical staff coming spring 2020
The Norton Agency released a development plan near the intersection of Jesse Jewel and Limestone Parkways for a housing village designed for the new wave of medical residents at Northeast Georgia Medical Center.
2:15PM ( 1 hour ago )
Local/State News
2nd Dem debate will be some candidates' last chance to shine
The 2nd set of Democratic presidential debates will be a last chance for some 2020 candidates to be considered serious contenders
6:33AM ( 1 day ago )
Top aide says Trump's criticism of black lawmaker not racist
A top White House aide defends President Donald Trump's disparaging tweets about an influential black Democratic congressman and his Baltimore district as a justified response to the lawmaker's criticism of administration border policies
4:08PM ( 2 days ago )
Trump proposal seeks to crack down on food stamp 'loophole'
President Donald Trump's administration is proposing to end an option that has allowed states to exceed federal eligibility thresholds for food stamps by providing applicants with a government brochure
4:06AM ( 3 days ago )
Georgia high court to hear appeal in election challenge
Georgia's highest court plans to hear an appeal of the dismissal of a lawsuit challenging the outcome of the election for lieutenant governor in November
By Associated Press
5:10AM ( 2 months ago )
Critics say new voting system planned for Georgia is flawed
Critics of Georgia's outdated voting system told a judge on Tuesday that a new system outlined by lawmakers has many of the same fundamental flaws and is unconstitutional.
By Associated Press
7:27AM ( 3 months ago )
Gov. Kemp signs new touchscreen voting machines bill
Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp has quietly signed a wide-ranging elections bill authorizing the purchase of new touchscreen voting machines that print a paper ballot.
By Associated Press
12:05PM ( 3 months ago )
Georgia hearing on voting machines moves into day 3
A hearing on what type of new voting system Georgia should adopt will move into its third day after over seven hours of sometimes raucous public testimony.
By Associated Press
6:45AM ( 5 months ago )
Commission to discuss replacements for Georgia voting system today
A commission tasked with considering potential replacements for Georgia's voting system plans to discuss recommendations.
By Associated Press
5:14AM ( 6 months ago )