Wednesday November 25th, 2015 11:22AM

Court hears challenge to Obama recess appointments

By The Associated Press
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Republicans and business groups told a federal appeals court Wednesday that President Barack Obama violated the Constitution earlier this year when he bypassed the Senate to fill vacancies in his administration.

Attorneys for the groups told a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit that Obama abused his power in January when he made recess appointments to the National Labor Relations Board.

"I would suggest there is a huge cloud hanging over the National Labor Relations Board right now," said Noel Francisco, attorney for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other groups challenging the action.

The case is an important test of presidential power and could determine whether the Senate can indefinitely block presidential appointments by refusing to adjourn. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky came to watch the hearing in a packed courtroom. McConnell and 46 other Senate Republicans filed a friend-of-the-court brief arguing the appointments are invalid.

At issue: When is the Senate in session, when is it in recess and who gets to decide? Certain high-profile appointments must be confirmed by the Senate, but if lawmakers are away for the holidays or other breaks, the president can act on his own with a recess appointment.

Obama made the labor board appointments while the Senate was on a 20-day break over the Christmas and New Year's holidays. But his opponents claim it technically stayed in session because it was gaveled in and out every few days for so-called pro forma sessions. GOP lawmakers used the tactic specifically to prevent Obama from using his recess power.

Francisco said it's up to the Senate - and not the president - to decide whether lawmakers are really in session. The test can't be whether the Senate is busy, he argued, because "they were fully capable of conducting work" during the pro forma sessions.

Judge Thomas Griffith, who asked most of the questions, suggested the issue might be a purely political dispute into which the court should not intrude.

"Why drag us into it?" asked Griffith, who was appointed to the court by President George W. Bush.

Francisco said the court had to decide because the labor board is making hundreds of decision that would be invalid if the three board members were improperly appointed.

Griffith noted that the Senate itself could have taken an official position in the case but did not, raising questions about how to determine the Senate's intent.

"The court must defer to the Senate calling its work a session in the absence of evidence it's not," said Miguel Estrada, attorney for Senate Republicans. He said Obama was trying to evade the primary role of the Senate to advise and consent on nominations.

Deputy Assistant Attorney General Beth Brinkmann argued that the pro forma sessions - some lasting less than a minute - were a sham. Any other interpretation, she said, would frustrate the Constitution's intent to make sure the president can fill vacant offices at all times.

"There is a long, long history that would be disrupted," she said.

Griffith asked whether that meant the president could consider weekends or lunch breaks sufficient to make recess appointments. Brinkmann said those would not meet the basic requirement for a recess.

Griffith said it was clear that the reality of recess appointments had changed from that envisioned by the framers of the Constitution.

"Presidents have become frustrated by the way the Senate has treated their nominations" by holding some of them up for months, Griffith said. "That's not what the Recess Appointment Clause was about."

The two other judges on the panel are David Sentelle, appointed by President Ronald Reagan, and Karen LeCraft Henderson, who was appointed by President George H.W. Bush.

The case is being brought by Noel Canning, a Washington state bottling company challenging a labor board decision that it must enter into a collective bargaining agreement with a labor union. The company argues that the board did not have a quorum to issue a decision because the recess appointments are invalid.

The case is similar to dozens around the country that have been winding their way through the legal system since the Jan. 4 appointments. The 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago heard arguments challenging Obama's recess appointments in another labor case on Friday.

Obama has said he made the three recess appointments to prevent the labor board from being effectively shut down, unable to rule on unfair labor practices or referee labor-management disputes. Senate Republicans, infuriated at the board's pro-labor decisions, had vowed to block the appointment of any new members. The five-member board must have at least three members to conduct business.

Obama also invoked his recess appointment power in January - over strong GOP objections - to install Richard Cordray as director of the newly formed Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Cordray's appointment was not at issue in the case before the appeals court Wednesday but has been challenged separately.

Senate Democrats first began the practice of using pro forma sessions in 2007 to block President George W. Bush from making recess appointments.
© Copyright 2015
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Doctors: Blood clot located in Clinton's head
Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton developed a blood clot in her head but did not suffer a stroke or neurological damage, her doctors said Monday. They say they are confident that she will make a full recovery.
3:55PM ( 2 years ago )
Illinois Sen. Kirk to return a year after stroke
Nearly a year after a stroke left him barely able to move the left side of his body, U.S. Sen. Mark Kirk is expected to climb the 45 steps to the Senate's front door this week - a walk that's significant not just for Illinois' junior senator, but also for medical researchers and hundreds of thousands of stroke patients.
3:54PM ( 2 years ago )
U.S. News
Couch names administrative team
Ahead of his scheduled swearing in Friday, Hall County Sheriff-elect Gerald Couch named his top administrative team Monday.
6:28PM ( 2 years ago )
Tech beats Southern California in Sun Bowl
Tevin Washington threw a touchdown pass and ran for another score to help Georgia Tech beat Southern California 21-7 on Monday in the Sun Bowl.
5:54PM ( 2 years ago )
Hall Co. officials launch health-based initiative for employees
Hall County officials believe healthy county employees will be of greater service to the county. With that in mind, they have created a health-based fitness initiative to provide free fitness training for county workers.
5:46PM ( 2 years ago )
Local/State News
Ga. ethics legislation could end free tickets
General Assembly approval next year of a proposed ethics reform measure could endanger an important fall tradition for Georgia lawmakers - free football tickets.
6:26PM ( 2 years ago )
Abortion restrictions, tax changes loom in Ga.
Tax breaks for manufacturers and higher unemployment taxes for employers take effect with the new year in Georgia, but it remains to be seen whether the state's newest abortion restrictions will be enforced.
6:23PM ( 2 years ago )
Budget battle sends mixed signals on health care
Confused about the federal budget struggle? So are doctors, hospital administrators and other medical professionals who serve the 100 million Americans covered by Medicare and Medicaid.
6:20PM ( 2 years ago )
The Latest: UN Security Council strongly condemns 'horrifying' attack in Mali, urges probe
BAMAKO, Mali (AP) — The latest on the attack on a hotel in the Malian capital of Bamako. (All times local):___4:55 a.m.The U.N. Security Council is condemning "the horrifying terrorist attack" at the...
10:58PM ( 4 days ago )
World leaders vow vigorous response to Paris terror spree, but little indication of next steps
ANTALYA, Turkey (AP) — World leaders vowed a vigorous response to the Islamic State group's terror spree in Paris as they opened a two-day meeting in Turkey on Sunday, with President Barack Obama call...
2:14PM ( 1 week ago )
Rash of E. coli cases in Pacific Northwest highlights problem of foodborne illnesses
SEATTLE (AP) — As Chipotle prepares to reopen its restaurants in the Pacific Northwest this week after an E. coli outbreak that sickened about 45 people, health experts say foodborne illnesses are mor...
1:40AM ( 2 weeks ago )
Biden says he will not run for president in 2016, finalizing field of Democratic candidates
Vice President Joe Biden will not run for president in 2016, he said Wednesday, ending a months-long flirtation with a third White House campaign and setting him on a glide path toward the end of his decades-long political career.
1:34PM ( 1 month ago )
UN is next stop for Obama after success with Iran, pope; top issues are IS, Syria, Russia
NEW YORK (AP) — Fresh from successes on Iran and with the pope, President Barack Obama still carried heavy burdens into critical meetings this week at the U.N. General Assembly.They include the threat...
3:31PM ( 1 month ago )