clearn.png
Saturday April 1st, 2023 12:33AM

Citizen journalist's lawsuit heard by federal appeals court

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW ORLEANS (AP) — An online citizen journalist from Texas asked federal appeals court judges Wednesday to revive her lawsuit against authorities who her arrested for seeking and obtaining nonpublic information from police — a case that has drawn attention from national media organizations and free speech advocates.

A state judge dismissed the criminal case against Priscilla Villarreal in 2018, saying the law used to arrested her in 2017 was deemed unconstitutionally vague, according to court briefs.

Villarreal, known online as "La Gordiloca," then filed a lawsuit against the city of Laredo, Webb County and the police officers and prosecutors involved in her arrest. She said she's entitled to damages because she never should have been arrested for posting information on her Facebook page, “ Lagordiloca News LaredoTx. ”

“I had to make the point that it's not right to get arrested for my freedom of speech and freedom of the press,” Villarreal said outside the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals building where arguments were heard Wednesday by the court's 16 active judges.

Among those on her side in the case are the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, the National Association of Hispanic Journalists and the Society of Professional Journalists.

“If the First Amendment stands for anything, it is the fundamental truth that the people, and the press on behalf of the people, must be able to ask questions of government officials without fear of harassment, prosecution, or imprisonment,” they say in a brief filed with Texas news outlets and media organizations.

In a competing brief, the state of Texas says the issues are more nuanced and rejects the notion that the woman known as La Gordiloca was arrested for simply asking a question.

Villarreal has not shown that the officials who had her arrested knew there was no probable cause to do so, the Texas brief states. It also says a magistrate judge issued the warrant and “the officers reasonably relied upon the neutral magistrate’s conclusion that there was probable cause to arrest Villarreal for violating a facially valid statute.”

Some of the judges hearing the case Wednesday asked questions about that point.

“Wouldn't judges know more than police officers do?” Judge Catharina Haynes asked Villarreal's lawyer, J.T. Morris, who said police and prosecutors had no probable cause to investigate or seek the warrant in the first place.

The law, according to court records, defines the criminal “misuse of official information” as using information that “has not been made public ... with intent to obtain a benefit or with intent to harm or defraud another." Authorities had argued that Villarreal could benefit from using the information — the identities of a person who killed himself and a family involved in a car accident — to gain fame on her Facebook page.

A 5th Circuit panel revived Villarreal's lawsuit in a 2-1 decision in November 2021. But the full court vacated that ruling, deciding to grant Wednesday's rehearing before all 16 active judges. In that decision, Judge James Ho wrote that Villarreal's arrest was “an obvious violation of the Constitution.”

Ho questioned lawyers for Texas and Laredo on Wednesday about scenarios in which seeking information from public officials can be criminalized.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines
© Copyright 2023 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Citizen journalist's lawsuit heard by federal appeals court
A Texas-based online citizen journalist wants a federal appeals court to revive her lawsuit against Laredo area officials over her 2017 arrest
1:35PM ( 4 minutes ago )
US, Germany sending battle tanks to aid Ukraine war effort
Germany and the United States say they will send tanks to Ukraine as part a coordinated effort by the West to provide dozens of the heavy weapons to help Kyiv break battlefield stalemates as Russia’s invasion enters its 12th month
1:26PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Boeing loses $663 million in 4Q despite higher revenue
Boeing is reporting a loss of $663 million in the fourth quarter
1:02PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
7 murder counts expected in Half Moon Bay farm killings
Prosecutors say they will charge a farmworker accused of killing seven people in back-to-back shootings at two Northern California mushroom farms with seven counts of murder and one count of attempted murder
12:51PM ( 48 minutes ago )
The AP Interview: Pope says homosexuality not a crime
Pope Francis has criticized laws that criminalize homosexuality as “unjust,” saying God loves all his children just as they are
12:51PM ( 48 minutes ago )
Lloyd Morrisett, who helped launch 'Sesame Street,' dies
The co-creator of the beloved children’s education TV series “Sesame Street,” Lloyd Morrisett has died
12:27PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Severe weather threat moves east after tornadoes hit Texas
A winter storm that brought severe weather to the Gulf Coast is heading east a day after tornadoes caused widespread damage and injured three people
11:20AM ( 2 hours ago )
Fatigue and despair build as California copes with massacres
California is reeling from three major mass shootings in just over a week
9:04AM ( 4 hours ago )
Prosecutors to Congress: Let state prisons jam cellphones
Top state prosecutors are urging Congress to pass legislation allowing state prisons to jam signals of cellphones smuggled to inmates
9:00AM ( 4 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
US, Germany sending battle tanks to aid Ukraine war effort
Germany and the United States say they will send tanks to Ukraine as part a coordinated effort by the West to provide dozens of the heavy weapons to help Kyiv break battlefield stalemates as Russia’s invasion enters its 12th month
1:26PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Boeing loses $663 million in 4Q despite higher revenue
Boeing is reporting a loss of $663 million in the fourth quarter
1:02PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Ukraine's Odesa city put on UNESCO heritage in danger list
The United Nations’ cultural agency has added the historic center of Ukraine’s Black Sea port city of Odesa to the list of World Heritage sites in danger
1:01PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Lawyer: Admins were warned 3 times the day boy shot teacher
An attorney says a Virginia teacher who was shot by a 6-year-old student during class plans to sue the school district
12:53PM ( 47 minutes ago )
7 murder counts expected in Half Moon Bay farm killings
Prosecutors say they will charge a farmworker accused of killing seven people in back-to-back shootings at two Northern California mushroom farms with seven counts of murder and one count of attempted murder
12:51PM ( 48 minutes ago )