Saturday April 1st, 2023 12:45AM

In soaked California, few homeowners have flood insurance

By The Associated Press

ACAMPO, Calif. (AP) — On Sunday morning, Kyle Starks woke up to floodwaters that reached the door of his Jeep after yet another heavy rain storm drenched California. Emergency crews showed up with boats to float Starks and other residents of his rural mobile home park in Acampo to safety.

Beyond the physical destruction, the storm could pack a financial hit: Starks does not have flood insurance.

“I didn’t think it would flood this bad,” he explained from an evacuation center, worried that water damaged wiring and air conditioning equipment.

In California, only about 230,000 homes and other buildings have flood insurance policies, which are separate from homeowners insurance. That means only about 2% of properties are covered against flooding. The federal government is the insurer for the bulk of them – about 191,000 as of December. Private insurers issued the rest, according to the most recent state data from 2021.

In California, 32 trillion gallons of rain and snow fell since Christmas. The water washed out roads, knocked out power and created mudslides by soaking wildfire-charred hills. It caused damage in 41 of the state’s 58 counties. At least 21 people have died.

It takes targeted study to know the role of climate change in specific weather, but warmer air means storms like the ones that deluged California in recent weeks can carry more water.

Yet California's drought has dulled people's sense of the risk of flooding. People usually buy insurance after disasters when the risk is visceral, said Amy Bach, the executive director of insurance consumers group United Policyholders.

“People think the only people that need flood insurance are people who live right on the beach or on the banks of a river that has a history of flooding," Bach said. In reality, far more people are threatened by rushing or rising water.

When you buy a home, a key document will be official Federal Emergency Management Agency maps that tell you if it's in a high risk flood zone. If it is and you have a federally-backed mortgage, you are required to buy flood insurance that costs on average $950 a year. Many banks require it too.

Yet FEMA maps are limited and only take into account certain kinds of flooding — they don't really predict flood risk. Flooding caused by heavy rains that back up storm drains is not counted, for example. The limitations mean flood risk is underestimated nationally. The maps particularly lowball the chance of disaster in California, according to Matthew Eby, executive director of First Street Foundation, a risk analysis organization.

The FEMA maps don’t show Stark’s mobile home in a high risk area. And three years before his neighbor Juan Reyes bought his house, a series of storms dumped record amounts of rain on the state and flooded their neighborhood.

Reyes knew this, but he still did not buy flood insurance. It was too expensive, he said, and wasn’t required. Plus, he thought local officials had improved the storm drainage system so that a similar flood wouldn't happen again. But it did and Reyes also had to be rescued by boat. He's staying at the same evacuation center, hoping his home isn't too badly damaged.

The storms damaged several thousand homes so badly they'll need to be repaired before people can live in them again. But Nicholas Pinter, a professor at the University of California, Davis who researches watersheds, said California needs to be prepared for even bigger events and that requires far more investment in flood defenses and more awareness of its danger.

“It is worrisome that there was as much damage as there was for what was extreme but not catastrophic flooding,” he said.

State officials said even without flood coverage, they try to help people pursue claims — flooded cars, for example, are sometimes covered under auto insurance policies.

Also trying to figure out how to recover is David Enero in Merced, a community of roughly 90,000 in California's Central Valley that flooded badly. Water rose ankle-deep in his house. The laminate floor in his living room floated.

“It was kind of like you were walking on a wave or a trampoline” he said. The house smells like a mix of mildew, rotted hay and septic system overflow.

Enero lives in an area that is designated high risk where people have to buy flood insurance. He says paying for the damage on his own would be unimaginable. In retrospect, he wishes he had insured his belongings as well.

Although the maps force Enero and others in certain areas to buy coverage, FEMA no longer uses its famous maps to set the prices.

The agency updated its pricing in 2021 to more accurately reflect risk and dubbed it Risk Rating 2.0. FEMA says these revised prices -- and not flood maps -- are what communicate flood risk to consumers. The old system placed more emphasis on simple metrics — a home's elevation and whether it was in a mapped flood zone. Risk Rating 2.0 considers distance to water, damage caused by heavy rain and many other factors. It raises rates for about three-quarters of policyholders and offers price decreases for the first time.

FEMA has long said the new ratings would attract new policyholders with prices that reveal a property's true risk, and are more precise. Yet since they went into effect in California, the number of policies has dropped by roughly 5%, continuing a years-long decline nationwide.

Some aren't aware of their risk.

Jay Laub, one of Reyes’ neighbors, also rescued from the floodwaters, said when he bought his house the insurance companies were mostly trying to sell him earthquake coverage. He said he assumed his house was covered for flood. He learned this week it wasn’t.

Laub said he’s worried his mobile home might have sunk in the soggy ground, which could require him to relevel it. He said he’s not sure how he would pay for it.

“What do you do? You’re on social security, like I am,” he said. “But you know what? You take it one step at a time. You’ve just got to stay strong.”

Trevor Burgess, CEO of the private insurer Neptune, said there's been a run on new policies with the storms. During the first 10 days of 2022, the company sold 53 in California. This year, Neptune sold 313 -- a roughly 500% increase.

“Storms, even as they are this terrible tragedy – human tragedy and tragedy for property – it does have the effect of reminding people that they are vulnerable and need to protect themselves,” said Burgess.


Phillis reported from St. Louis.


The Associated Press receives support from the Walton Family Foundation for coverage of water and environmental policy. The AP is solely responsible for all content. For all of AP’s environmental coverage, visit

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Financial Services
© Copyright 2023
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Inspections of Ukrainian grain ships halved since October
Inspections of ships carrying Ukrainian grain and other food exports have slowed to half their peak rate under a U.N.-brokered wartime agreement
10:01AM ( 3 minutes ago )
Police: Indiana shooter killed after injuring 1 at Walmart
Authorities in Indiana say a 25-year-old man opened fire in a Walmart store where he once worked, wounding at least one person before officers fatally shot him
9:57AM ( 6 minutes ago )
UK judge rejects Uyghur bid to halt Xinjiang cotton imports
A British judge has rejected a lawsuit that accused the U.K. government of allowing the import of cotton products associated with forced labor in China’s Xinjiang region
9:49AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Russia claims progress in eastern Ukraine; Kyiv craves tanks
Russia is claiming its forces have captured a village in an intense and monthslong push toward the eastern Ukraine city of Bakhmut
8:53AM ( 1 hour ago )
Google axes 12,000 jobs, layoffs spread across tech sector
Google says it’s laying off 12,000 workers,  becoming the latest tech company to trim staff as the economic boom that the industry rode during the COVID-19 pandemic ebbs
8:00AM ( 2 hours ago )
As Baldwin faces charges, gun safety on sets 'gets louder'
As actor Alec Baldwin faces a charge of involuntary manslaughter in the shooting death of a cinematographer on a New Mexico, gun safety on sets remains at the forefront of many in Hollywood
6:35AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP National News
Polar bear emerged unseen from snowstorm to kill mom, son
Officials in Alaska say a mother and her 1-year-old boy were killed by a polar bear this week as she walked about 150 yards from a school to a health clinic
12:03AM ( 10 hours ago )
Biden on classified docs discovery: 'There's no there there'
President Joe Biden says there is “no there there” following the discovery of classified documents and official records at his home and former office
11:44PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Top 25 Movies, ranking 2022's best: What made the cut?
With hundreds of new movies released each year, many of us depend on the expertise of film critics to help curate our own watching
11:25PM ( 10 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Paris Fashion Week channels historic men's styles
As Paris Fashion Week geared up for Dior Men, British designer Paul Smith went encyclopedic with his fall-winter menswear show
9:06AM ( 58 minutes ago )
Macron to hike military funds amid Ukraine war, new threats
French President Emmanuel Macron has proposed to boost military spending by more than a third by 2030 to face evolving threats
8:37AM ( 1 hour ago )
Wall Street appears headed for first weekly loss of 2023
Premarket trading on Wall Street is mixed as recession fears threaten to drag major indexes to their first weekly decline of the year
8:34AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
US stocks lose ground as recession fears weigh on market
Stocks fell on Wall Street as worries build that the U.S. may be headed for a painful recession
4:39PM ( 17 hours ago )
Wall Street retreat continues ahead of the opening bell
Wall Street is drifting lower in premarket trading, adding to the biggest retreat of the year one day earlier as government data showed a slowing U.S. economy, heightening worries about the possibility of a recession
8:31AM ( 1 day ago )
Global shares lower after biggest Wall St retreat of year
Global shares are mostly lower as investors grow cautious after Wall Street’s biggest pullback of the year
4:46AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Industries
Tokyo shares jump after Bank of Japan keeps policy unchanged
Share have advanced in Asia, with Tokyo gaining more than 2%, after Japan's central bank kept its lax monetary policy unchanged, dispelling speculation it would yield to pressure to tighten credit
1:10AM ( 2 days ago )
Asian shares decline as Bank of Japan keeps policy unchanged
Asian shares are mostly lower after Japan's central bank kept its lax monetary policy unchanged, contrary to speculation it would yield to pressure to tighten credit
11:01PM ( 2 days ago )
Stocks close mixed on Wall Street; Goldman weighs on Dow
Major U.S. indexes closed mixed on Wall Street at the beginning of a holiday-shortened, but earnings-heavy week
5:00PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Financial Services
Police: Indiana shooter killed after injuring 1 at Walmart
Authorities in Indiana say a 25-year-old man opened fire in a Walmart store where he once worked, wounding at least one person before officers fatally shot him
9:57AM ( 6 minutes ago )
UK judge rejects Uyghur bid to halt Xinjiang cotton imports
A British judge has rejected a lawsuit that accused the U.K. government of allowing the import of cotton products associated with forced labor in China’s Xinjiang region
9:49AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Wall Street opens mixed and is headed for a losing week
Stocks are off to a mixed start on Wall Street, keeping the market on track for a losing week after rallying for the first two weeks of the year
9:48AM ( 16 minutes ago )
In Senegal, Yellen talks about future of US-Africa relations
U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen is visiting Senegal with a message about the future of U.S.-Africa relations
9:45AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Coroner says actor Leslie Jordan died of natural causes
The Los Angeles County coroner's office says “Will & Grace" actor Leslie Jordan died from natural causes and not from a car accident last year
9:35AM ( 29 minutes ago )