Monday October 3rd, 2022 7:08AM

What's in the House, Senate bills overhauling Jan. 6 count

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — The central idea behind House and Senate bills to reform an arcane federal election law is simple: Congress should not decide presidential elections.

The bills are a direct response to the Jan. 6 insurrection and former President Donald Trump’s efforts to find a way around the Electoral Count Act, a 19th century law that governs, along with the U.S. Constitution, how states and Congress certify electors and declare presidential election winners. The House passed its version of the legislation on Wednesday, and a Senate committee will consider its bipartisan bill next week.

While the House bill is more expansive, the two bills would make similar changes, all aimed at ensuring that the popular vote from each state is protected from manipulation by bad actors or partisans who want to overturn the will of the voters.

House Administration Committee Chairwoman Zoe Lofgren, D-Calif., a lead sponsor of the House bill, says people who wanted to overturn the 2020 election took advantage of ambiguous language “to have Congress play a role that they really aren’t supposed to play.”

Supporters in both chambers — Democrats and some Republicans — want to pass an overhaul before the start of the next Congress and ahead of the 2024 presidential campaign cycle, as Trump has signaled that he might run again. Ten GOP senators have backed the legislation, likely giving Democrats the votes they need to break a filibuster and pass their electoral bill in the 50-50 Senate.

A look at what the two bills would do:


Lawmakers and legal experts have long said the 1887 law is vague and vulnerable to abuse, and Democrats saw Trump’s efforts to overturn his defeat ahead of Jan. 6, 2021, as a final straw. Supporters of the former president attacked the Capitol that day, echoing his false claims of widespread election fraud, interrupting the congressional certification of Joe Biden’s victory and calling for Vice President Mike Pence’s death because he wouldn’t try to block Biden from becoming president.

Both the House and Senate bills would clarify that the vice president’s role presiding over the congressional certification every Jan. 6 after a presidential election is “ministerial” and that he or she has no power to determine the results of the election — an effort to make that point emphatically in the law after Trump and some of his allies put massive pressure on Pence. He resisted those entreaties, but many lawmakers were concerned that the law wasn’t clear enough on that point.

The Senate bill states that the vice president “shall have no power to solely determine, accept, reject, or otherwise adjudicate or resolve disputes over the proper list of electors, the validity of electors, or the votes of electors.” The House bill has similar language and adds that the vice president “shall not order any delay in counting or preside over any period of delay in counting electoral votes.”


The two bills would also make it more difficult for lawmakers to object to a particular state’s electoral votes. Under current law, just one member of the Senate and one member of the House need to lodge an objection to automatically trigger votes in both chambers on whether to overturn or discard a state’s presidential election results. Both bills would significantly raise that threshold, with the House bill requiring a third of each chamber to object and the Senate bill requiring a fifth of each chamber to object.

The House bill goes even further, specifying very narrow grounds for the objections, such as if certain electors are ineligible under the law or if a state submitted too many votes.

Brookings Institution Fellow Norm Eisen, a legal expert who consulted with lawmakers writing the legislation, said the House bill puts tighter parameters around “opportunities for mischief” by lawmakers who may be taking sides.


Both bills would ensure that there is one “single, conclusive slate of electors,” as senators put it, a response to Trump allies’ unsuccessful efforts to create alternate, illegitimate slates of Trump electors in states that Biden narrowly won in 2020.

Each state’s governor would be required to submit the electors, which are sent under a formal process to Congress and opened at the rostrum during the congressional session on Jan. 6 after every presidential election. The House and the Senate bills would also establish legal processes if any of those electors are challenged by a presidential candidate.


The House and Senate legislation would also revise language in current law that wasn’t challenged during the 2020 election, but that lawmakers think could be vulnerable to abuse. The law now allows state legislatures to override the popular vote in their states by calling a “failed election,” but the term is not defined under the law.

The Senate bill says a state could only move its presidential election day if there are “extraordinary and catastrophic” events that necessitate that to happen. House lawmakers and legal experts like Eisen have argued that the Senate language is still too vague, and the House bill would only allow such a delay if a federal judge agrees that there has been a genuine catastrophic event affecting enough ballots.

The House bill would also limit such a move to the affected geographic area and would require the extension to last no longer than five days after Election Day.


The House bill would add language to try to prohibit state or local officials from refusing to count valid votes in a presidential election or refusing to certify a legitimate election — an attempt to assuage some lawmakers' fears that the next presidential candidate will follow Trump's lead and try to pressure lower-level officials to overturn the results. Presidential candidates could go to court to force such a count.

The Senate bill has no such language.


Follow the AP's coverage related to the Jan. 6 insurrection at

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, General House Election News, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
UK government caps energy bills for businesses for 6 months
Britain’s government says it will cap wholesale energy bills for businesses this winter to ensure companies don’t go bust amid soaring energy prices
5:23AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Putin sets partial military call-up, won’t ‘bluff’ on nukes
Russian President Vladimir Putin has announced a partial mobilization of reservists in Russia
5:22AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Global shares decline ahead of Fed decision on rates
Global shares have mostly declined as investors await a widely expected interest rate hike by the U.S. Federal Reserve as it strives to squash the highest inflation in decades
5:04AM ( 38 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Opening statements set for trial against close Trump ally
A close ally of Donald Trump is in court fighting charges he secretly worked as an agent for the United Arab Emirates
1:12AM ( 4 hours ago )
The Muscogee get their say in national park plan for Georgia
Hundreds of Native Americans returned to their historic capital in Macon, Georgia, this weekend for the 30th annual Ocmulgee Indigenous Celebration
12:19AM ( 5 hours ago )
Trial opens for QAnon follower who chased officer at Capitol
A trial is underway for an Iowa man whose confrontation with police created some of the most memorable images from a mob's attack on the U.S. Capitol
8:47PM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Trump FBI search puts unusual spotlight on Archives nominee
The nominee to head the National Archives is set to face an unusually contentious Senate confirmation hearing this week
5:12PM ( 12 hours ago )
Manchin rails against 'revenge politics' on permit plan
Sen. Joe Manchin on Tuesday railed against what he called “revenge politics″ being used against him, as liberals in the House and Senate team up with Republicans to oppose his plan to speed permits for natural gas pipelines and other energy projects
5:09PM ( 12 hours ago )
Ethics board keeps 'action' secret on complaint against Noem
A South Dakota ethics board is keeping it a secret what action it took after finding there was evidence Gov. Kristi Noem improperly intervened in her daughter’s application for a real estate appraiser license
4:59PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
GOP's election-year standing with independents at risk
Some independent voters who began 2022 looking to Republicans for answers have drifted back to moving toward Democrats
2:18PM ( 1 day ago )
2022 could be a political watershed for Massachusetts women
The year 2022 is shaping up to be a watershed for women seeking political power in Massachusetts
12:06AM ( 2 days ago )
El Salvador president re-election bid draws strong reaction
In the hours after El Salvador President Nayib Bukele announced he would seek re-election despite a constitutional ban, opinion quickly divided
6:09PM ( 4 days ago )
AP Elections
Breaches of voting machine data raise worries for midterms
The revelation earlier this week that federal prosecutors are involved in investigations of suspected voting system breaches across the U.S. is fueling questions about the security of voting machines just two months before the midterm elections
5:58PM ( 4 days ago )
Biden, Dems see both political, economic wins in rail deal
President Joe Biden is hailing a labor agreement that avoided a strike that would have shut down railroads across the country as a win for America
6:17PM ( 5 days ago )
Oz, Fetterman both target suburbs in key Pa. Senate race
With the fall campaign election season in high gear, Democrat John Fetterman and his Republican rival for U
3:33PM ( 5 days ago )
General Election News
Michigan man gets 5 years in prison for role in Capitol riot
A Michigan man has been sentenced to five years in federal prison for his role in the U.S. Capitol attack by a mob that disrupted Congress from certifying President Joe Biden’s 2020 electoral victory
2:26PM ( 4 days ago )
Kenya’s new president promises ambitious climate plan
Kenya’s newly elected president William Ruto said that climate change will be key to the government’s agenda and made an ambitious pledge to ramp up clean energy and phase out fossil fuels for electricity by 2030
6:22AM ( 6 days ago )
MyPillow exec Lindell says FBI agents seized his cellphone
MyPillow chief executive Mike Lindell says federal agents have seized his cellphone
11:11PM ( 1 week ago )
General Presidential Election News
After cancellation, Dems look to reduce future student debt
House Democrats are proposing new legislation that would increase federal student aid, lower interest rates on loans and take other steps to make college more affordable
11:38AM ( 5 days ago )
Ashley Kalus wins GOP primary for Rhode Island governor
A businessperson seeking office for the first time, Ashley Kalus, has won the Republican primary for Rhode Island governor, defeating a rival who has served time in state prison
8:47PM ( 1 week ago )
Trump-backed Diehl to take on Healey in Mass. governor race
A former state representative endorsed by former President Donald Trump, Geoff Diehl, has won the Republican nomination for Massachusetts governor over a businessman, Chris Doughty, who was considered the more moderate candidate in the race
5:28PM ( 1 week ago )
General House Election News
Israel's Netanyahu campaigns aboard bulletproof 'Bibibus'
As he hits the campaign trail for the fifth time in less than four years, Israel's former Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is addressing supporters from a strange new vehicle dubbed the “Bibibus" after his popular nickname
2:23AM ( 6 days ago )
Rhode Island Gov. McKee narrowly wins Democratic primary
Rhode Island Gov. Dan McKee eked out a victory in his Democratic primary on Tuesday, beating back strong challenges from a pair of opponents as he seeks his first full term in office
11:57PM ( 1 week ago )
GOP's Graham unveils nationwide abortion ban after 15 weeks
Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham has introduced a bill calling for a nationwide abortion ban
9:22PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
UK government caps energy bills for businesses for 6 months
Britain’s government says it will cap wholesale energy bills for businesses this winter to ensure companies don’t go bust amid soaring energy prices
5:23AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Putin sets partial military call-up, won’t ‘bluff’ on nukes
Russian President Vladimir Putin has announced a partial mobilization of reservists in Russia
5:22AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Global shares decline ahead of Fed decision on rates
Global shares have mostly declined as investors await a widely expected interest rate hike by the U.S. Federal Reserve as it strives to squash the highest inflation in decades
5:04AM ( 38 minutes ago )
Some 230 whales beached in Tasmania; rescue efforts underway
About 230 whales are stranded on Tasmania’s west coast, just two days after 14 sperm whales were found beached on a nearby island
5:04AM ( 38 minutes ago )
Australian Indigenous traditional owners halt gas drilling
Indigenous traditional owners have won a court challenge that prevents an energy company from drilling for gas off Australia’s north coast
4:59AM ( 42 minutes ago )