Friday February 3rd, 2023 1:37AM

California sues Amazon, alleging antitrust law violations

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — California is suing Amazon, accusing the company of violating the state's antitrust and unfair competition laws by stifling competition and engaging in practices that push sellers to maintain higher prices on products on other sites.

The 84-page lawsuit filed Wednesday in San Francisco Superior Court mirrors another complaint filed last year by the District of Columbia, which was dismissed by a district judge earlier this year and is now going through an appeals process.

But officials in California say they believe they won’t encounter a similar fate, partly due to information collected during a more than two-year investigation that involved subpoenas and interviews with sellers, Amazon’s competitors as well as current and former employees at the e-commerce giant.

In the lawsuit, California Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office said Seattle-based Amazon used contract provisions to effectively bar third-party sellers and wholesale suppliers from offering lower prices for products on non-Amazon sites, including on their own websites. That, in turn, harms the ability of other retailers to compete.

The suit maintains merchants that do not comply with the policy could have their products stripped from prominent listings on Amazon and face other sanctions such as suspensions or terminations of their accounts. It alleges Amazon’s policy essentially forces merchants to list higher prices on other sites, helping it maintain its e-commerce dominance.

Among other things, the California lawsuit seeks to stop Amazon from entering into contracts with sellers that harm price competition. It also seeks a court order to compel Amazon to pay damages to the state for increased prices. State officials did not say how much money they are seeking.

The company has said in the past that sellers set their own prices on the platform. It has also said it has the right to avoid highlighting products that are not priced competitively. In a statement sent Wednesday, Amazon reiterated those points and said Bonta has it “exactly backwards.”

“The relief the AG seeks would force Amazon to feature higher prices to customers, oddly going against core objectives of antitrust law,” the company said. “We hope that the California court will reach the same conclusion as the D.C. court and dismiss this lawsuit promptly.”

Amazon controls roughly 38% of online sales in the U.S., more than Walmart, eBay, Apple, Best Buy and Target combined, according to the research firm Insider Intelligence. About 2 million sellers list their products on Amazon’s third-party marketplace, accounting for 58% of the company’s retail sales.

During a news conference on Wednesday, Bonta said some vendors have expressed they would offer lower prices on other sites with lower seller fees, but don't do so to avoid punishment from Amazon.

“Amazon has stifled its competition for years, not by successfully competing, but by blocking competition on price," Bonta said. "As a result, California families paid more, and now Amazon must pay the price.”

He said the lawsuit is also a message to other companies who “illegally bend the market at the expense of California consumers, small business owners and the economy."

The tech industry's allies also slammed the lawsuit. Adam Kovacevich, CEO of the industry trade group Chamber of Progress, which receives funding from Amazon and other tech companies, said the case would force Amazon to raise prices.

“That makes no sense while consumers shop for bargains to counter inflation, and it’s based on a legally unsound theory already rejected by federal courts," Kovacevich said.

Despite that defense, Amazon’s market power has been a subject of scrutiny from lawmakers and advocacy groups calling for stricter antitrust regulations. Earlier this year, congressional lawmakers urged the Justice Department to investigate if the company collects data on sellers to develop competing products and offer them more prominently on its site. Critics have also lambasted the increasing fees imposed on sellers, which makes it more difficult for merchants to enter the market.

Lawmakers on Capitol Hill have been pushing bipartisan legislation aiming to limit Amazon and other Big Tech companies, including Apple, Meta and Google, from favoring their own products and services over rivals. The bill has cleared key committees but has languished in Congress for months amid intense pushback from the companies.

Meanwhile, regulators have also been looking into Amazon’s business practices and deals. In July, the company offered concessions to settle two antitrust investigations in the European Union, including a promise to apply equal treatment to all sellers when ranking product offers on the site’s “buy box,” a coveted spot that makes items more visible to shoppers.

In the U.S., the Federal Trade Commission is investigating Amazon’s $3.9 billion acquisition of the primary health organization One Medical as well as the sign-up and cancellation practices of Amazon Prime, the company’s paid subscription service that offers deals and faster shipping.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Economy, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2023
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
California sues Amazon, alleging antitrust law violations
California is suing Amazon, accusing the company of violating the state’s antitrust laws by stifling competition and engaging in practices that push sellers to maintain higher prices on products on other sites
2:10PM ( 7 minutes ago )
EXPLAINER: Rail strike would impact consumers, businesses
A strike by railroad workers would have wide-ranging impact on consumers, commuters and businesses
2:09PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Petrino comes full-circle as Missouri State visits Arkansas
Bobby Petrino is 61 these days
1:56PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Disabled voters win in Wisconsin; legal fights elsewhere
Wisconsin voters with disabilities are celebrating a win after a federal judge, citing the Voting Rights Act, ruled that they may get assistance returning their ballots
12:07PM ( 2 hours ago )
Conservative Bolduc wins New Hampshire's GOP Senate primary
Retired Army Brig. Gen. Donald Bolduc has won New Hampshire’s Republican Senate primary and will face potentially vulnerable Democratic incumbent Maggie Hassan in November
12:05PM ( 2 hours ago )
Huge line to view monarch's coffin is queue fit for a queen
Britons famously love to line up, but marshaling hundreds of thousands of people who want to view the coffin of Queen Elizabeth II will test Britain’s famous capacity for queuing to its limit
12:04PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Procession of Queen Elizabeth II's coffin underway in London
Queen Elizabeth II has left Buckingham Palace for the last time
9:44AM ( 4 hours ago )
Close New Hampshire Senate primary tests direction of GOP
The Republican contest for Senate in New Hampshire remains a tight race between conservative Donald Bolduc and the more moderate Chuck Morse
8:48AM ( 5 hours ago )
Final preparations underway for procession of queen's coffin
Queen Elizabeth II’s coffin is set to leave Buckingham Palace for the last time as it is taken, amid somber pageantry, on a horse-drawn gun carriage past crowds of mourners to the Houses of Parliament, where the late monarch will lie in state for four days
8:47AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Text messages link Favre, welfare money, volleyball facility
New court documents show the Mississippi governor in 2017 knew of a plan for a nonprofit group to pay Brett Favre more than $1 million in welfare grant money so the retired NFL quarterback could help fund a volleyball facility
12:30PM ( 1 hour ago )
WHO: COVID end 'in sight,' deaths at lowest since March 2020
The head of the World Health Organization says the number of coronavirus deaths last week was the lowest reported number in the pandemic since March 2020, marking what could be a turning point in the years-long global outbreak
12:04PM ( 2 hours ago )
Leaky pen and staff job cuts: King Charles under scrutiny
Reports that up to 100 staff at King Charles III’s former residence could lose their jobs have drawn criticism of the British monarchy, within days of his accession to the throne
11:59AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
Jim Beam outlines expansion to ramp up bourbon production
Jim Beam plans to ramp up bourbon production at its largest Kentucky distillery
9:12AM ( 5 hours ago )
EU moves to ban products made with forced labor
The European Union has unveiled plans to ban products made with forced labor from the 27-nation bloc’s markets
8:27AM ( 5 hours ago )
German government could raise stake in gas supplier Uniper
German energy supplier Uniper says it is exploring the possibility of the government acquiring a majority holding in the company as its losses mount
8:13AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
US futures rebound slightly after Tuesday's rout
U.S. futures rebounded slightly before markets opened Wednesday, a day after Wall Street had its biggest single-day route in more than two years as a report showed inflation still has a surprisingly strong grip on the U.S. economy
8:00AM ( 6 hours ago )
UK inflation dips slightly in August to 9.9%
Inflation in the United Kingdom slowed slightly in August as a drop in gasoline and diesel fuel prices gave consumers the first glimmer of hope that Britain’s cost-of-living crisis may be beginning to ease
7:18AM ( 7 hours ago )
World shares fall, tracking Wall St dismay over price data
World markets have slipped after Wall Street fell the most since June 2020 as a report showed inflation has kept a surprisingly strong grip on the U.S. economy
4:57AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
EXPLAINER: Rail strike would impact consumers, businesses
A strike by railroad workers would have wide-ranging impact on consumers, commuters and businesses
2:09PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Petrino comes full-circle as Missouri State visits Arkansas
Bobby Petrino is 61 these days
1:56PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Queen Elizabeth II lies in state after solemn procession
Queen Elizabeth II has left Buckingham Palace for the last time, her casket borne to Westminster Hall by a horse-drawn gun carriage
1:56PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Defense suddenly rests case in Florida school shooter trial
Attorneys for Florida school shooter Nikolas Cruz have suddenly and surprisingly rested their case, leading to a shouting match after the judge accused them of a lack of professionalism
1:38PM ( 40 minutes ago )
Armenia, Azerbaijan trade blame for clashes that killed 155
Armenia and Azerbaijan say 155 troops from the two countries have died since hostilities reignited between the longtime adversaries this week
1:35PM ( 42 minutes ago )