Thursday February 2nd, 2023 7:58PM

Trump team dismisses records probe, opposes arbiter picks

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Donald Trump’s lawyers dismissed as a “storage dispute” the former president's retention of top-secret documents at his Florida home, urging a judge Monday to keep in place a directive that temporarily halted key aspects of the Justice Department’s criminal probe.

The Trump team referred to the documents that were seized as “purported ‘classified records,'" saying the Justice Department had not proven that the materials taken by the FBI during its Aug. 8 search of Mar-a-Lago were classified or remain so now. The lawyers also asserted there is no evidence that any of the records were disclosed to anyone and argued that Trump, as a former president, had an “unfettered right of access” to presidential documents.

“This investigation of the 45th President of the United States is both unprecedented and misguided,” they wrote. “In what at its core is a document storage dispute that has spiraled out of control, the Government wrongfully seeks to criminalize the possession by the 45th President of his own Presidential and personal records.”

The 21-page filing underscores the significant factual and legal disagreements between lawyers for Trump and the U.S. government as the Justice Department looks to move forward with its criminal investigation into the retention of national defense information at Mar-a-Lago and into the potential obstruction of that probe. Department lawyers in their own filings have rejected the idea that the documents, many of them classified at the top-secret level, belonged to Trump or that Mar-a-Lago was a permissible place to store them.

The Trump team also said Monday that it opposed the candidates the Justice Department proposed for an independent arbiter who is to be tasked with reviewing the documents seized during the FBI's search. The Justice Department responded by telling the judge that, in addition to the two retired judges it put forward, it would also be willing to recommend one of the Trump team's selections for the job.

The investigation hit a roadblock last week when U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon granted the Trump team's request for the appointment of the arbiter, also known as a special master, and prohibited for now the department from examining the documents for investigative purposes.

The Justice Department has asked the judge to lift that hold and said it would contest her ruling to a federal appeals court. The department said its investigation risked being harmed beyond repair if that order remained in place, noting that confusion about its scope had already led the intelligence community to pause a separate national security risk assessment.

But Trump's lawyers said in their own motion Monday that Cannon should not permit the FBI to resume its review of classified records. It said the government had unilaterally determined the records to be classified but had not yet proven that they remain so.

“In opposing any neutral review of the seized materials, the Government seeks to block a reasonable first step towards restoring order from chaos and increasing public confidence in the integrity of the process," the lawyers wrote.

In the meantime, both sides on Friday night each proposed different names of candidates who could serve in the role of a special master, though they disagreed on the exact scope of duties the person should have. Cannon has said the yet-to-be-named arbiter would be tasked with reviewing the documents and weeding out from the investigation any that could be covered by claims of either executive privilege or attorney-client privilege.

The Justice Department recommended either Barbara Jones, a retired judge in Manhattan who has served as special master in prior high-profile investigations, or Thomas Griffith, a retired federal appeals court jurist in the District of Columbia who was appointed to the bench by former President George W. Bush. The department said in its proposal that the special master should not have access to classified documents, or be empowered to consider claims of executive privilege.

On Monday, the Trump team told the judge it was objecting to both of those candidates but was not prepared to say why publicly at the moment.

Trump's lawyers have proposed either Raymond Dearie, a senior judge on active status in the federal court in Brooklyn, or prominent Florida lawyer Paul Huck Jr., and have said the arbiter should have access to the entire tranche of documents and should be able to evaluate executive privilege claims.

The Justice Department said it supported Dearie's selection, in addition to the two names it put forward, but it opposed the selection of Huck because of what it said was a lack of relevant experience.

In its filing Monday, the Trump team again voiced a broad view of presidential power, asserting that a president has an “unfettered right of access" to his presidential records and absolute authority to declassify any information without the “approval of bureaucratic components of the executive branch" — though it did not say, as Trump has maintained, that he had actually declassified them.

The Justice Department has said Trump had no right to hold onto the presidential documents. And the criminal statutes the department has used as the basis of its investigation, including one criminalizing the willful retention of national defense information, do not require that the records be classified.

In any event, the Justice Department says more than 100 documents with classification markings were found in last month's search. It has made public a photograph that agents took inside Mar-a-Lago showing the cover pages of a smattering of paperclip-bound classified documents, some marked as top-secret.

Trump, who often spends time at his various properties, was at his Virginia golf club Monday.


Associated Press writer Meg Kinnard in Columbia, South Carolina, contributed to this report.

Follow Eric Tucker at http://www.twitter.com/etuckerAP

Follow AP’s coverage of Donald Trump-related investigations at https://apnews.com/hub/donald-trump

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News
© Copyright 2023 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Trump team dismisses records probe, opposes arbiter picks
Donald Trump’s lawyers are dismissing the former president’s retention of top-secret documents at his Florida home as a “storage dispute.”
4:33PM ( 8 minutes ago )
New York poised to strengthen oversight of nonpublic schools
New York is poised to strengthen its oversight of private and religious schools
4:03PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Wall Street rallies ahead of high-stakes inflation report
Stocks rose again on Wall Street ahead of a high-stakes report that will hopefully show inflation hammered the economy less hard last month
4:03PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Bezos rocket crashes after liftoff, only experiments aboard
Jeff Bezos' rocket company has suffered its first launch failure
3:34PM ( 1 hour ago )
State: Alabama nearly ready with untried execution method
Alabama could be ready to use a new, untried execution method to carry out a death sentence later this month
3:18PM ( 1 hour ago )
Ukraine reclaims more territory, reports capturing many POWs
Ukrainian troops have reclaimed a wide swath of territory from Russia and pushed all the way back to the northeastern border in some places
3:11PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
In a nod to JFK, Biden pushing 'moonshot' to fight cancer
President Joe Biden is set to channel John F. Kennedy on the 60th anniversary of the former president’s moonshot speech
1:00PM ( 3 hours ago )
Ukraine makes more gains, pushes back to border in places
Ukrainian troops have reclaimed more territory from Russia and pushed all the way back to the northeastern border in some places
12:39PM ( 4 hours ago )
Police believe 3 children drowned by mother at NYC beach
Police say three children have died after being found on a New York City beach and authorities believe the children may have been drowned by their mother
12:32PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Faculty, students sue Christian school over LGBTQ hiring ban
Divisions over LGBTQ-related policies have flared recently at several religious colleges in the United States
12:59PM ( 3 hours ago )
Prosecutor: R. Kelly predator who used fame to abuse minors
A prosecutor has described R. Kelly as a sexual predator who parlayed his fame to abuse minors
11:54AM ( 4 hours ago )
Trump's lawyers call Mar-a-Lago probe 'misguided'
Lawyers for former President Donald Trump say a criminal investigation into the presence of top-secret information has “spiraled out of control
10:13AM ( 6 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Malerba sworn in as 1st Native American in US Treasurer post
Mohegan Chief Marilynn “Lynn” Malerba was sworn in Monday, becoming the nation’s first Native American to serve as U.S. Treasurer
3:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
Biden's midterm self-edit: Less talk about inflation woes
In recent speeches, President Joe Biden has stopped talking so much about inflation worries
2:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
What's next for the UK as Queen Elizabeth II laid to rest
The death of Queen Elizabeth II has triggered a tightly choreographed series of ceremonial and constitutional steps, as Britain undergoes a national mourning and heralds the reign of King Charles III
2:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
GOP nominee for Kansas governor tries to flip abortion issue
The Republican nominee for Kansas governor is trying to make the Democratic incumbent's support for abortion rights a liability
5:26PM ( 1 day ago )
Chief Justice John Roberts defends legitimacy of court
Chief Justice John Roberts is defending the authority of the Supreme Court to interpret the Constitution, saying its role should not be called into question just because people disagree with its decisions
12:06PM ( 2 days ago )
US, Trump team propose names for arbiter in Mar-a-Lago probe
The Justice Department and Donald Trump’s legal team have proposed candidates to serve as an independent arbiter in the investigation into top-secret information found in an FBI search of the former president’s Florida home
11:53PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
New York poised to strengthen oversight of nonpublic schools
New York is poised to strengthen its oversight of private and religious schools
4:03PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Wall Street rallies ahead of high-stakes inflation report
Stocks rose again on Wall Street ahead of a high-stakes report that will hopefully show inflation hammered the economy less hard last month
4:03PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Queen hailed in Scotland as a 'constant in all our lives'
As Queen Elizabeth II’s four children walked silently behind, a hearse carried her flag-draped coffin along a crowd-lined street in the Scottish capital to St. Giles' Cathedral
4:02PM ( 40 minutes ago )
Live updates: King and siblings stand vigil to honor queen
King Charles III and his siblings have stood in silent vigil around their mother Queen Elizabeth II’s coffin in St Giles’ Cathedral in Edinburgh
3:51PM ( 50 minutes ago )
Illinois tax rebates are coming -- in time for the election
Democrats who run state government are celebrating because tax rebates totaling more than $1.2 billion are heading to 6 million taxpayers
3:49PM ( 52 minutes ago )