Friday February 3rd, 2023 1:18AM

US, Trump team propose names for arbiter in Mar-a-Lago probe

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Justice Department and Donald Trump’s legal team each proposed candidates Friday for the role of an independent arbiter in the investigation into top-secret documents found at the former president's Florida home, but the two sides differed on the scope of duties the person would have.

Lawyers for Trump said they believe the so-called special master should review all documents seized by the FBI during its search last month of Mar-a-Lago, including records with classification markings, and filter out any that may be protected by claims of executive privilege.

The Justice Department, by contrast, said it does not believe the arbiter should be permitted to inspect classified records or resolve potential claims of executive privilege.

U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon had given both sides until Friday to submit potential candidates for the role of a special master, as well as proposals for the scope of the person’s duties and the schedule for his or her work.

The Justice Department submitted the names of two retired judges — Barbara Jones, who served on the federal bench in Manhattan and has performed the same role in prior high-profile investigations, and Thomas Griffith, a former federal appeals court jurist in the District of Columbia.

The Trump team proposed one retired judge, Raymond Dearie — also the former top federal prosecutor in the Eastern District of New York — and a prominent Florida lawyer, Paul Huck, Jr.

The back-and-forth over the special master is playing out amid an FBI investigation into the retention of several hundred classified documents recovered from Mar-a-Lago within the past year. Though the legal wrangling is unlikely to have major long-term effects on the investigation or knock it significantly off course, it will almost certainly delay the probe by potentially months and has already caused the intelligence community to temporarily pause a separate risk assessment.

The Justice Department proposed an Oct. 17 deadline for the special master to complete the review process, while the Trump team said the work could take as long as three months.

Though both sides met Cannon's deadline to provide potential candidates, their filings made clear that they have core disagreements about the job of special master. That's not surprising given that the Justice Department had strenuously objected to the Trump team's desire for such an arbiter, and gave notice Thursday that it would appeal the judge's decision to grant the ex-president's request.

Central to the dispute is precisely what documents the yet-to-be-named special master should be tasked with reviewing. Roughly 11,000 documents — including more than 100 with classified markings, some at the top-secret level — were recovered during the FBI’s Aug. 8 search. In granting the request for a special master, Cannon directed the department to temporarily pause its use of the seized records for investigative purposes.

The Justice Department had said a special master was unnecessary in part because it had already completed its own review of the seized documents, locating a limited subset that possibly involve attorney-client privilege. It has maintained that executive privilege does not apply in this investigation because Trump, no longer president, had no right to claim the documents as his.

Though the government does not believe the special master should inspect documents with classification markings, the Trump team maintains the arbiter should have access to the entire tranche of seized records. According to a summary of its position outlined in a filing Friday night, it disputes the idea that the Justice Department's “separation of these documents is inviolable” or that a document with classification markings should be forever regarded as classified.

And, the lawyers say, if any document is a presidential document then Trump has an “absolute right of access to it.”

"Thus, President Trump (and/or his designee) cannot be denied access to those documents, which in this matter gives legal authorization to the Special Master to engage in first-hand review," the filing states.

Executive privilege generally refers to a president’s power to shield information from the courts and public so as to ensure the confidentiality of presidential decision-making, though there are limits.

A separate dispute concerns the special master's fees and expenses. The Trump team has suggested splitting the costs evenly with the Justice Department. The government says the Trump team should bear the cost.

The two sides are also at odds over candidates, though three of the four are retired judges.

Jones, a former Manhattan federal judge and one of the government's picks, recently served as special master in two other high-profile cases related to Trump. She reviewed materials seized in FBI raids on Trump’s one-time personal lawyers Michael Cohen, in an investigation related to hush-money payments, and Rudy Giuliani, in a probe of his dealings in Ukraine.

Griffith, the other Justice Department selection, was named to the federal appeals court in Washington in 2005 by then-president George W. Bush, and previously represented the institutional interests of the Republican-led Senate during the impeachment case of former President Bill Clinton.

The Trump team recommended Dearie, who was nominated in 1986 by then-President Ronald Reagan to the federal court based in Brooklyn. He has also served on the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court.

The other Trump pick, Huck, served as general counsel to Charlie Crist when Crist was the Republican governor of Florida. He is married to Barbara Lagoa, a judge on the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which would hear any appeal in the Trump case from Florida. He is listed on the Federalist Society website as a contributor to the conservative legal group.

The Justice Department on Thursday filed a notice of appeal indicating it would contest the judge’s special master order to the Atlanta-based 11th Circuit. It asked her to lift her hold on their investigative work pending their appeal.

The department has been investigating the unlawful retention of top-secret records at Mar-a-Lago after Trump left the White House, as well as whether anyone sought to obstruct that probe. It is not clear if Trump or anyone else will be charged.


Associated Press writers Michael R. Sisak in New York and Curt Anderson in Miami contributed to this report.

More on Donald Trump-related investigations: https://apnews.com/hub/donald-trump

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News
© Copyright 2023 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Casper Ruud wins 55-shot point to reach US Open semifinals
Casper Ruud has reached his second Grand Slam final of the year by claiming a 55-shot point to end the first set of his U.S. Open semifinal and beating Karen Khachanov 7-6 (5), 6-2, 5-7, 6-2
9:57PM ( 12 minutes ago )
US, Trump team propose names for arbiter in Mar-a-Lago probe
The Justice Department and Donald Trump’s legal team have proposed candidates to serve as an independent arbiter in the investigation into top-secret information found in an FBI search of the former president’s Florida home
9:54PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Alcaraz evens semis at 1 set apiece | US Open updates
Carlos Alcaraz has evened the second U.S. Open men’s semifinal against Frances Tiafoe
9:32PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
MLB adopts pitch clock, shift limits, bigger bases for 2023
Major League Baseball has adopted its first pitch clock, limits on defensive shifts and larger bases for next season in an effort to shorten games and increase offense in a tradition-bound sport
6:55PM ( 3 hours ago )
Trump team, Justice Dept. to make new Mar-a-Lago filing
The Justice Department and Donald Trump’s legal team are to stake out positions on the role to be played by an independent arbiter tasked with reviewing documents seized during an FBI search of the former president’s Florida home
6:00PM ( 4 hours ago )
UK watches to see if king departs from mother's traditions
As the United Kingdom mourns a beloved queen, the nation is already wondering how King Charles III will reign and whether his monarchy will depart from the traditions of his mother
5:55PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP National News
US counts millionth organ transplant while pushing for more
The U.S. has reached a medical milestone — counting 1 million organ transplants since the first success back in 1954
3:57PM ( 6 hours ago )
Ukraine claws back some territory; nuclear plant in peril
Ukrainian forces are claiming new success in their counteroffensive against Russian forces in the east, taking control of a sizeable village and pushing toward an important transport junction
3:53PM ( 6 hours ago )
Chief Justice John Roberts to speak at Colorado conference
U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts is set to make his first public appearance since the court overturned Roe v. Wade, speaking Friday night at a judicial conference in Colorado
3:21PM ( 6 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Planned Parenthood maps strategy to protect abortion rights
Planned Parenthood leaders from across the country are meeting in California to discuss how to defend abortion rights
6:06PM ( 4 hours ago )
High court blocks recognition of LGBTQ campus at Yeshiva U
The Supreme Court has temporarily blocked a court order that would have forced Yeshiva University to recognize an LGBTQ group as an official campus club
5:51PM ( 4 hours ago )
Proud Boys Hawaii leader, friend plead guilty in Jan. 6 riot
The founder of the Hawaii Proud Boys chapter and a Texas man who stormed the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, and posed for a picture in front of a door on which one of them had written “Murder the Media” each pleaded guilty Friday to a felony charge in connection with the riot
5:35PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
GOP nominee from Oregon cleared of campaign cash violation
Alek Skarlatos, a Republican nominee for Congress in Oregon, was cleared this week of violating campaign finance law
12:31PM ( 9 hours ago )
Biden at Ohio groundbreaking: Dems reviving manufacturing
President Joe Biden is putting the spotlight on a rare bipartisan down payment on U.S. manufacturing
11:57AM ( 10 hours ago )
Michigan board approves ballot measure on voting access
A Michigan election board has approved a November ballot question on whether the state should expand opportunities to vote
11:27AM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Elections
Rep. Katie Porter's university housing deal draws scrutiny
In Orange County, California, the typical house sells for $1 million
10:55AM ( 1 day ago )
Fetterman agrees to 1 debate against Oz in Pa. Senate race
Pennsylvania Democratic Senate candidate John Fetterman's campaign says he'll participate in just one debate
6:42PM ( 2 days ago )
Trump-backed Diehl to take on Healey in Mass. governor race
A former state representative endorsed by former President Donald Trump, Geoff Diehl, has won the Republican nomination for Massachusetts governor over a businessman, Chris Doughty, who was considered the more moderate candidate in the race
5:28PM ( 2 days ago )
General Election News
Bolsonaro turns Brazil's bicentennial into campaign rally
Brazil’s President Jair bolsonaro has transformed the nation’s bicentennial into a multi-city campaign event, amid concerns from critics he would use his appearances to undermine the upcoming election
12:09AM ( 1 day ago )
Massachusetts GOP voters size up Trump loyalist for governor
Polls have closed in Massachusetts, where Republicans are weighing which candidate has the best chance of keeping the governor’s office in GOP hands in Tuesday’s primary
8:02PM ( 3 days ago )
EXPLAINER: Bolsonaro knocks Brazil's voting system
President Jair Bolsonaro is feeding concern about Brazil's electronic voting system with the election just a month off
10:26AM ( 3 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
Casper Ruud wins 55-shot point to reach US Open semifinals
Casper Ruud has reached his second Grand Slam final of the year by claiming a 55-shot point to end the first set of his U.S. Open semifinal and beating Karen Khachanov 7-6 (5), 6-2, 5-7, 6-2
9:57PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Alcaraz evens semis at 1 set apiece | US Open updates
Carlos Alcaraz has evened the second U.S. Open men’s semifinal against Frances Tiafoe
9:32PM ( 38 minutes ago )
'The Crown' pauses production because of queen's death
“The Crown,” Netflix’s acclaimed series about Queen Elizabeth II and her family, has paused production due to the monarch’s death
9:15PM ( 54 minutes ago )
Tiafoe takes 1st set in tiebreaker | US Open updates
Frances Tiafoe has won the first set against Carlos Alcaraz by extending his perfect record in tiebreakers in this U.S. Open
8:46PM ( 1 hour ago )
Storm's fierce winds complicate California wildfire fight
A tropical storm nearing Southern California has brought fierce mountain winds, high humidity, rain and the threat of flooding to a region already dealing with wildfires and an extraordinary heat wave
8:29PM ( 1 hour ago )