clearn.png
Thursday August 11th, 2022 11:37PM

Judge rules Georgia must end statewide PSC elections

By The Associated Press

ATLANTA (AP) — A federal judge ruled Friday that Georgia's statewide election of its five public service commissioners illegally dilutes Black voting power, ordering the state to not prepare ballots for two races that had been scheduled in November.

The ruling by U.S. District Judge Steven Grimberg, if it stands, would mean that state lawmakers would have to draw single-member districts for the body that regulates Georgia Power Co. and other other utilities, subject to court approval. An election would be held later.

However, higher federal courts have shown significant skepticism about Voting Rights Act litigation in recent years, and the state could appeal. It could also argue that the ruling is too close to the election and seek a delay, an issue that Grimsberg considered and rejected in his opinion.

Attorney General Chris Carr's office said it was reviewing the decision, while the Public Service Commission declined comment. Plaintiffs said they hoped the decision would bring to the forefront concerns of Black voters, including people with lower incomes who pay high utility bills.

“Black voters will no longer be ignored and have their concerns about clean energy, pollution, and high power bills drowned out because of unfair archaic laws,” said Brionte McCorkle, executive director of Georgia Conservation Voters. Nico Martinez, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, called it "one of the most important decisions to advance voting rights in a generation.”

Grimberg had telegraphed his ruling months ago, finding at an earlier state of the lawsuit that statewide elections probably illegally diluted Black votes. The lawsuit was brought by leaders of the NAACP, Georgia Conservation Voters and Black Voters Matter.

At-large voting that preserves white control has long been subject to legal attack, but most cases have focused on at-large voting in local elections. But Grimberg said the same rules apply to statewide elections, rejecting the state's arguments that commissioners needed to be elected statewide because their decisions apply statewide. He also overruled the state's arguments that statewide elections couldn't be challenged under the federal Voting Rights Act and that district elections would impermissibly change Georgia's form of government.

Until now, commissioners have been elected statewide but required to live in a particular district. District 3 Commissioner Fitz Johnson and District 2 Commissioner Tim Echols, both Republicans, were seeking reelection. Johnson was being challenged by Democrat Shelia Edwards while Echols faced Democrat Patty Durand and Libertarian Colin McKinney.

Both Johnson and Edwards, running to represent a district that includes Clayton, DeKalb and Fulton counties, are Black. However, Grimberg ruled that the plaintiffs had clearly proved that Black voters have generally been unable to elect the candidate of their choice in statewide voting, noting Black candidates won eight of 164 nonjudicial statewide elections between 1972 and 2021.

The judge noted that white Republican Chuck Eaton beat Black Democratic incumbent David Burgess in a 2006 runoff in which Eaton won statewide but Burgess would have won if only voters in the Atlanta-area district had voted. The judge also noted that Eaton would have lost reelection in 2012 and 2018 if only voters in the district had voted.

Grimberg ruled that the Black electorate is large enough and geographically compact enough to create at least one single-member district, that Black voters are cohesive and that racial bloc voting by the white majority defeats Black-preferred candidates in Georgia. Those are all key tests in a Voting Rights Act lawsuit.

The state argued that Black voters aren’t getting the candidates they want because they’re Democrats, not because of their race. But the judge said the argument was faulty because it didn’t consider that race and party preference are entangled in Georgia.

“They are not selecting Democratic candidates because they are Democrats; they are selecting Democratic candidates because they perceive, rightly or wrongly, that those candidates will be more responsive to issues that concern Black voters," Grimberg wrote.

Grimberg wrote that his ruling would “regrettably cause disruption” to November’s elections, and agreed that Echols and Johnson would remain in office beyond the end of their six-year terms until new districts could be drawn. The order anticipates lawmakers drawing districts in next year’s regular session. If lawmakers don't act, Grimberg would draw the districts.

___

Follow Jeff Amy at http://twitter.com/jeffamy.

  • Associated Categories: Homepage, Local/State News, Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Online - Georgia News, AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Oregon's wildfire risk map emerges as new climate flashpoint
A new map in Oregon that rated the wildfire risk of every tax lot in the state — labeling nearly 80,000 structures as high-risk — generated so much pushback from angry homeowners that officials abruptly retracted it, saying they had not done enough local outreach before publicizing the ambitious project
11:48AM ( 6 minutes ago )
Pentagon denies D.C. request for National Guard migrant help
The Pentagon has rejected a request from the District of Columbia seeking National Guard assistance for the thousands of migrants being bused to the city from two southern states
11:31AM ( 22 minutes ago )
US employers add 528,000 jobs; unemployment falls to 3.5%
Defying anxiety about a possible recession and raging inflation, America’s employers added a surprising 528,000 jobs last month, restoring all the jobs lost in the coronavirus recession as the country’s hiring boom continued
11:26AM ( 27 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
China halts climate, military ties over Pelosi Taiwan visit
China says it is canceling or suspending dialogue with the U.S. on a range of issues from climate change to military relations and anti-narcotics efforts in retaliation for a visit this week to Taiwan by U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi
10:49AM ( 1 hour ago )
Meta mum on election misinformation efforts as midterms loom
Facebook owner Meta is quietly curtailing some safeguards designed to thwart voting misinformation or foreign interference in elections even as the U.S. midterms approach
9:47AM ( 2 hours ago )
Democrats say they've reached agreement on economic package
Senate Democrats say they have reached an accord on changes to their marquee economic legislation, clearing the major hurdle to pushing one of President Joe Biden’s leading election-year priorities through the chamber in coming days
8:48AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Pelosi: China cannot stop US officials from visiting Taiwan
U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says that China will not isolate Taiwan by preventing U.S. officials from traveling there
3:28AM ( 8 hours ago )
Far-right mayor wins GOP primary for Nashville US House seat
Far-right candidate Andy Ogles has won Tennessee’s crowded Republican primary for an open congressional seat in Nashville
2:16AM ( 9 hours ago )
Democrats could strip Iowa of opening spot in 2024 campaign
Democrats may be moving toward shaking up their presidential nominating process starting in 2024
1:18AM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Naquin's two homers, Diaz's two-inning save lift Mets
Deadline acquisition Tyler Naquin homered twice in his home debut, Edwin Diaz locked down his first two-inning save as a pro and the New York Mets beat the Atlanta Braves 6-4 to open a pivotal five-game series between the NL East rivals
10:16PM ( 13 hours ago )
Georgia begins national title defense with sweet fade
The Georgia Bulldogs aren’t resting on their laurels — or their locks — as they begin defense of college football’s national championship
5:17PM ( 18 hours ago )
Florida woman's lawsuit says Equifax error made loan pricier
A Florida woman has sued Equifax claiming she was denied a car loan because of a 130-point mistake she says was part of a larger group of credit score errors the ratings agency made this spring due to a coding problem
12:48PM ( 23 hours ago )
AP Online - Georgia News
AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
Oregon's wildfire risk map emerges as new climate flashpoint
A new map in Oregon that rated the wildfire risk of every tax lot in the state — labeling nearly 80,000 structures as high-risk — generated so much pushback from angry homeowners that officials abruptly retracted it, saying they had not done enough local outreach before publicizing the ambitious project
11:48AM ( 6 minutes ago )
Pentagon denies D.C. request for National Guard migrant help
The Pentagon has rejected a request from the District of Columbia seeking National Guard assistance for the thousands of migrants being bused to the city from two southern states
11:31AM ( 22 minutes ago )
US employers add 528,000 jobs; unemployment falls to 3.5%
Defying anxiety about a possible recession and raging inflation, America’s employers added a surprising 528,000 jobs last month, restoring all the jobs lost in the coronavirus recession as the country’s hiring boom continued
11:26AM ( 27 minutes ago )
Lady A postpones tour as Charles Kelley focuses on sobriety
Grammy-winning country trio Lady A is postponing its tour this year as band member Charles Kelley focuses on sobriety
11:22AM ( 32 minutes ago )
Israeli strikes on Gaza kill 8, including senior militant
Palestinian officials say Israeli airstrikes on Gaza have killed at least eight people, including a senior militant, and wounded 40 others
11:20AM ( 34 minutes ago )