Wednesday August 17th, 2022 12:13PM

Biden, Republicans spar over impact of Dems' economic plan

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Democrats call it the “Inflation Reduction Act.” Republicans say it's a “tax and spending spree.” And everyone has a study they say proves it.

Recent bipartisan action in Congress on matters ranging from producing computer chips to expanding NATO isn’t extending to the latest economic package from Democrats, which is generating a battle of dueling statistics and projections over whether it would help or hurt the economy.

For President Joe Biden, the Senate Democrats’ $739 billion package can help lower inflation, cut the budget deficit, address climate change and lower medical bills — a message that he’s trying to sell to the wider country amid intense Republican criticism.

Biden appeared at a virtual event Thursday to highlight the proposal with leaders from General Motors, Cummins, Kaiser Permanente and the AFL-CIO, among other organizations. He called on Congress to listen to the public, dig into the numbers and vote for the bill.

“Look at the facts,” Biden said. “Pass it. Get it to my desk. Pass it for the American people. Pass it for businesses and workers. Pass it for America.”

But GOP lawmakers have their own sets of numbers. They counter that the 15% minimum corporate tax included in the package would hit U.S. factories and middle-class workers. They say energy costs would increase. The number of approved prescription drugs coming onto market would decline because of price caps, according to a University of Chicago analysis. They say IRS audits would affect more people.

“This bill will slam manufacturing,” Sen. Mike Crapo, R-Idaho, said Wednesday. “The bottom line here is this tax is dangerous for America.”

Republican senators quickly cried foul after Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., and Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., struck the deal last week. Late Thursday, the agreement drew the backing Sen. Kyrsten Sinema, D-Ariz., a centrist seen as the pivotal vote in the 50-50 chamber.

What many economists say is that the plan could modestly reduce inflation in the long term and improve the federal government's financial outlook. But it's unknown whether a skeptical public will trust the experts or stick to their beliefs and the most emotionally resonant talking points.

The Congressional Budget Office estimates the proposal would reduce budget deficits by $305 billion over the next decade. That includes roughly $200 billion from increasing IRS funding by $80 billion. The tax agency will be able audit people making more than $400,000 and collect taxes that are owed but going unpaid.

But the size of the deficit reduction could be even greater.

The Treasury Department estimates indicate that IRS enforcement could raise a net $400 billion over the next decade, while improving customer service such that the agency could go from answering just 15% of its phone calls to all of them, according to a senior administration official who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss internal figures.

The private Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget estimates the deficit reduction could be as much as $1.9 trillion over two decades, largely because Medicare would be able to negotiate down the price of prescription drugs.

The Penn Wharton Budget Model estimates that inflation would decline after 2024, though the effect would be statistically negligible.

On Tuesday, congressional leaders were sent a letter signed by 126 economists that concluded: “This proposal addresses some of the country’s biggest challenges at a significant scale. And because it is deficit-reducing, it does so while putting downward pressure on inflation.”

Yet the measure carries some controversy because of how it relies on tax laws.

The roughly $370 billion devoted to climate change includes tax breaks for “clean” electricity and for manufacturing, as well as breaks for buying electric vehicles. It would impose a fee on methane and charge a minimum tax of 15% on companies with more than $1 billion in profits.

“It’s just a catalog of tax hikes and green boondoggles that Democrats have wanted for years, with a false new label slapped on the front,” Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky said Tueday.

Republicans say the corporate tax would violate Biden's pledge not to increase taxes on people making less than $400,000. Their evidence is an analysis by Congress' Joint Tax Committee, which assumes that part of the cost of the tax would be passed on to workers in the form of lower pay.

Columbia University economist Joseph Stiglitz, a Nobel prize winner who worked in the Clinton administration, said the corporate minimum tax is unlikely to place a burden on workers because of its design.

"That’s just what we just say is right wing rhetoric," Stiglitz said. “The argument that it will be shifted either to customers or wages is very, very weak."

Still, higher taxes are likely to come at a cost.

Based on estimates by the joint committee, Republicans note that nearly half of that minimum tax would hit manufacturers, a group that political leaders have often pledged to protect.

Kyle Pomerleau, a senior fellow at the center-right American Enterprise Institute, estimated that the minimum tax could undermine the benefits of existing tax incentives for companies to invest in new equipment and buildings.

Manchin has described the minimum tax as closing a "loophole" rather than a tax increase, while Pomerleau said the senator is inaccurate in his description.

The "minimum tax doesn’t close any loopholes -- it leaves all the loopholes open,” Pomerleau said. “It just subjects companies to a parallel tax. It’s an unideal ‘patch’ on the tax code.”

At the Thursday's roundtable, Biden specifically asked manufacturers whether the bill would hurt or help them.

Jennifer Rumsey, CEO of Cummins, which makes engines and power generation products, told him the bill would be “good for the economy and the environment.”

“We need the right policies,” she said. “And many of those market-based incentives that we think are needed are included in the Inflation Reduction Act.”

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Economy, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
DeSantis suspends elected prosecutor over new abortion law
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis has suspended the elected state prosecutor of Tampa for pledging not to enforce the state’s new 15-week abortion ban and for supporting gender transition treatments for minors
4:14PM ( 1 minute ago )
US says Russia aims to fabricate evidence in prison deaths
The White House says new intelligence suggests Russia is working to fabricate evidence concerning last week’s deadly strike on a prison housing prisoners of war in a separatist region of eastern Ukraine
4:11PM ( 5 minutes ago )
China conducts 'precision missile strikes' in Taiwan Strait
China says it has conducted “precision missile strikes" in the Taiwan Strait as part of military exercises by its navy, air force and other departments in six zones surrounding the island
4:08PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Police change account of crash killing Indiana Rep. Walorski
Police have changed their description of the crash that killed Indiana Republican U.S. Rep. Jackie Walorski, saying that it was the SUV in which she was a passenger crossed a state highway’s centerline and caused the head-on crash
2:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
Florida governor suspends prosecutor over new abortion law
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis has suspended the elected state prosecutor of Tampa for pledging not to enforce the state’s new 15-week abortion ban and for supporting gender transition treatments for minors
2:45PM ( 1 hour ago )
US to declare health emergency over monkeypox outbreak
The U.S. will declare a public health emergency to bolster the federal response to the outbreak of monkeypox that already has infected more than 6,600 Americans
2:21PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
After Taiwan, Pelosi meets political leaders in South Korea
U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is meeting top South Korean political leaders in Seoul after she concluded her high-profile visit to Taiwan by renewing Washington’s “ironclad” commitment to defending democracy on the self-governing island despite vehement protests from China
1:03AM ( 15 hours ago )
GOP eyes Nashville seat for flip; Dems vie to face governor
Tennessee Republicans are set to settle a nine-way primary in a reconfigured congressional district in Nashville they are hoping to flip
12:14AM ( 16 hours ago )
On NATO, McConnell nudges GOP away from Trump-era approach
Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell played a pivotal role in the Senate ratifying NATO membership for Sweden and Finland
12:11AM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Feds charge 4 police officers in fatal Breonna Taylor raid
The federal government has filed civil rights charges against four Louisville police officers over the drug raid that led to the death of Breonna Taylor
3:24PM ( 52 minutes ago )
WNBA's Griner convicted at drug trial, sentenced to 9 years
A judge in Russia convicted American basketball star Brittney Griner of drug possession and smuggling
3:06PM ( 1 hour ago )
Judge shortens road to decide NFL racial discrimination suit
A judge has made it likely she'll rule in weeks rather than months whether NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell gets to decide the merits of racial discrimination claims made by Black coaches against the league and its teams
2:19PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
US stocks remain mixed amid earnings, economic updates
Stocks were mixed in morning trading on Wall Street Thursday as investors continued to review the latest updates on the economy and corporate earnings
10:43AM ( 5 hours ago )
Wall Street flat at open as layoffs continue modest rise
Stocks are opening nearly flat on Wall Street Thursday
9:43AM ( 6 hours ago )
Global shares rise on optimism on economic data, earnings
Global shares are mostly higher as investors welcome encouraging economic data and quarterly earnings reports from big companies
4:52AM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Employment market shows signs of cooling amid rate hikes
The employment market appears to have lost some of its sizzle, a development that could influence Federal Reserve policy and further raise concerns about an economic recession among investors
10:04AM ( 6 hours ago )
Applications for US jobless claims up again last week
More Americans applied for jobless benefits last week as the number of unemployed continues to rise modestly, though the labor market remains one of the strongest parts of the U.S. economy
8:42AM ( 7 hours ago )
US markets head for small gains ahead of jobs data, earnings
Wall Street is pointing toward small gains before the opening bell bell ahead of a double dose of U.S. jobs data while anxiety eased over U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan
8:21AM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Ukrainian cities shelled, including one near nuclear plant
Ukraine's presidential office says that powerful explosions have rattled the southern Ukrainian city of Mykolaiv and a city close to the country’s biggest nuclear power plant sustained a barrage of shelling amid Russian attacks in several regions
10:08AM ( 6 hours ago )
UN chief criticizes `grotesque greed' of oil companies
The United Nations chief is sharply criticizing the “grotesque greed” of oil and gas companies for making record profits from the energy crisis on the back of the world’s poorest people
8:34PM ( 19 hours ago )
EXPLAINER: Does health care law protect emergency abortion?
The Biden administration has filed its first legal challenge to a state abortion ban since the end of Roe v. Wade with a case that could allow hospitals to keep giving women abortion-related medical care in serious medical situations
7:01PM ( 21 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Steam bath weather adds to misery after Appalachian flooding
Temperatures are soaring in a region of eastern Kentucky where people are shoveling out the wreckage of massive flooding
12:18PM ( 1 day ago )
OPEC+ boosts oil output by slower pace than previous months
The OPEC oil cartel and its allies have decided to boost production in September by a much slower pace than in previous months
11:11AM ( 1 day ago )
Wall Street rising at open; PayPal, CVS in focus
Stocks are opening higher on Wall Street Wednesday
9:52AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Utilities
China conducts 'precision missile strikes' in Taiwan Strait
China says it has conducted “precision missile strikes" in the Taiwan Strait as part of military exercises by its navy, air force and other departments in six zones surrounding the island
4:08PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Hungary's autocratic PM Orban addressing US conservatives
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban is in the U.S. to speak to one of the nation's largest gatherings of conservative activists
4:01PM ( 16 minutes ago )
EXPLAINER: What will it take to get Brittney Griner home?
Now that WNBA star Brittney Griner has been convicted of drug possession and sentenced to nine years in prison, attention turns to the prospect of a prisoner swap between the United States and Russia that could get her home
3:44PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Efforts intensify to reach 10 trapped coal miners in Mexico
Efforts to rescue 10 miners trapped in a collapsed and flooded coal mine in northern Mexico have intensified with hundreds of people involved in the operation
3:39PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Autopsy: Family killed at Iowa park shot, stabbed, strangled
Autopsy results say three family members killed during a shooting last month at an eastern Iowa state park were shot, stabbed and/or strangled
3:25PM ( 51 minutes ago )