Wednesday August 17th, 2022 11:53AM

EXPLAINER: Does health care law protect emergency abortion?

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Biden administration has filed its first legal challenge to a state abortion ban since the end of Roe v. Wade, arguing Idaho’s restrictive abortion law leaves doctors facing criminal penalties for providing abortion-related medical care to women in life-threatening medical situations.

The Justice Department may have a strong argument in the Idaho case filed under federal health care law, but even if they win it wouldn’t allow full access to abortion there, legal experts said. It could, though, give doctors more latitude to provide an abortion in an emergency or a situation that could become one.

But Texas is already pushing back with another lawsuit over the same federal statute, arguing federal health-care law doesn’t allow for abortion-related care banned under state law.

Here’s a look at how the dueling cases could affect the fraught medical and legal landscape after the Supreme Court overturned the nationwide right to abortion:


The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act, or EMTALA, went into effect in 1986 and was aimed at making sure people could get emergency care regardless of their ability to pay. It’s been at the center of court battles before.

In the 1992 case of “Baby K,” for example, a court sided with parents who said the federal law required a hospital to keep treating a baby born without a cerebral cortex, even though doctors said it would be medically futile and cited a state law in support, said Lindsay Wiley, a law professor and director of the Health Law and Policy Program at UCLA Law.

Hospitals that violate the emergency treatment act could lose access to payments from Medicare, a major blow.

The Idaho lawsuit comes after the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services issued similar guidance, saying hospitals must provide abortion services in emergencies or situations that could become emergencies.


Many abortion bans, including the law set to go into effect in Idaho, are written to allow abortions if a pregnant person's life is at risk. But they don’t always say exactly what that means, and some doctors say the laws are so vague that it’s hard to know when the exceptions apply. Notably, Idaho’s exception is written so that it can only be used as a defense in a criminal trial, after the doctor has been charged.

The deep uncertainty and possible criminal charges against doctors have already had profound repercussions in reproductive medicine and other areas of medical care.

“The risk of criminal prosecution is one of the most extreme, most heavy handed things that law can do. It has a huge chilling effect,” Wiley said. “It’s not surprising that clinicians, if they were only focusing on state law, would be very hesitant to do what they’ve always done to provide standard of care.”

The federal emergency-medical treatment act, by contrast, has a wider definition of emergency care and stabilization, as well as a specific set of rules and policies developed over three decades.

Idaho Gov. Brad Little, a Republican, said the Supreme Court gave states the sole ability to regulate abortion and he would defend the law against federal overreach.


Federal law trumps state law under the U.S. Constitution, and that includes the federal emergency-care law, said Allison Hoffman, a law professor at the University of Pennsylvania Law School and expert on health-care law.

“That’s a pretty strong argument,” she said. “But I think that this case will get to the Supreme Court, and it’s really hard to predict what will happen when it gets there.”

James Blumstein, a health-care law expert at Vanderbilt University, said the emergency-care law tied to a federal spending program is fundamentally different from state abortion bans that carry criminal penalties. The federal law, meanwhile, applies mostly to hospitals while abortion bans are typically aimed at doctors. “I could not advise a doctor to violate state law under the circumstances,” he said in an email.

If the Justice Department wins, it would likely allow abortion care in a wider set of circumstances - but there would still likely be a big legal gray area for doctors and hospitals. “This is really squishy territory. What does it mean to have a condition so that the absence of immediate medical attention could be reasonably expected to result in placing the health of somebody in serious jeopardy?” Hoffman said.

Many other lawsuits are playing out in Idaho and the rest of the country over abortion. Democratic President Joe Biden is also taking other steps to allow people to keep getting abortions, including signing an executive order Wednesday aimed in part at making it easier for women to travel between states to get abortions.


Texas sued the federal government last month over the guidance from Department of Health and Human Services under the same federal law. The state argued the guidance disregards the state legislative process and leaves doctors and hospitals vulnerable to losing their licenses or being charged with crimes under state law.

Texas officials also argued that the administration wants to “transform every emergency room in the country into a walk-in abortion clinic” and the federal emergency care law should have doctors considering how to preserve “the life or health of an unborn child.”

A near-total abortion law enforced by the threat of civil lawsuits went into effect in Texas last year, and another law carrying criminal penalties is set to go effect in the coming weeks.

Those arguments could get traction with judges there, said Elizabeth Sepper, a professor at the University of Texas at Austin School of Law. If the Biden administration prevails, it would apply in an urgent but fairly narrow set of circumstances.

“EMTALA doesn’t create a right to treatment or a right to go around the abortion ban, but it will provide some reassurance to emergency room doctors,” she said.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Women's health, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Indiana Rep. Walorski, 2 staffers killed in head-on crash
Republican U.S. Rep. Jackie Walorski has been killed in a car accident in her northern Indiana District
5:45PM ( 1 minute ago )
NFL appeals 6-game suspension for Browns' Deshaun Watson
A person familiar with the filing told The Associated Press that the NFL is seeking an indefinite suspension of at least one year plus a fine in appealing a disciplinary officer’s decision to suspend Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson for six games for violating the league’s personal conduct policy
5:43PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Alex Jones concedes Sandy Hook attack was '100% real'
Conspiracy theorist Alex Jones says he now understands it was irresponsible of him to declare the Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre a hoax and that he now believes it was “100% real.”
5:21PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Update to electors law desperately needed, senators declare
Republican Sen. Susan Collins and Democratic Sen. Joe Manchin are making the case for overhauling the 1800s-era Electoral Count Act
4:49PM ( 57 minutes ago )
EXPLAINER: Does health care law protect emergency abortion?
The Biden administration has filed its first legal challenge to a state abortion ban since the end of Roe v. Wade with a case that could allow hospitals to keep giving women abortion-related medical care in serious medical situations
4:39PM ( 1 hour ago )
WH says falling gas prices matter more than OPEC numbers
President Joe Biden traveled to Saudi Arabia almost three weeks ago on the possibility that he could get some additional oil production out of OPEC+
4:38PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Michigan GOP Rep. Meijer loses reelection after Trump vote
Michigan Rep. Peter Meijer, who witnessed the Capitol riot days after taking office in 2021 and then cast one of the 10 Republican votes to impeach Donald Trump over the attack, has lost his reelection bid
2:58PM ( 2 hours ago )
French lawmakers OK $20.3 billion to help with rising prices
French lawmakers have approved a 20 billion-euro ($20.3-billion) package of measures to help struggling households cope with rising energy and food prices
2:08PM ( 3 hours ago )
Abortion court battles press on, even in deep red states
In deeply conservative Idaho, it's expected that abortion will be banned eventually, but abortion rights advocates are continuing their legal challenges
1:58PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
European court refuses to hear UK boy's life-support case
The European Court of Human Rights has refused a request from the family of a comatose British boy to intervene and prevent his life-support treatment being ended
2:13PM ( 3 hours ago )
EPA: Chemical in medical-device cleanser poses cancer risk
The Environmental Protection Agency is warning residents who live near medical sterilizing plants in 13 states and Puerto Rico about potential health risks from emissions of ethylene oxide, a chemical widely used in their operations
2:02PM ( 3 hours ago )
COVID cases drop 9% globally last week, deaths stable
New coronavirus cases fell 9% globally last week while deaths remained stable
1:11PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Health
US stocks rise following solid earnings reports
Stocks are closing higher on Wall Street Wednesday as investors reviewed a mostly encouraging batch of earnings from big companies
4:43PM ( 1 hour ago )
Inspectors OK 1st Ukraine grain ship but no sign yet of more
The first grain ship to leave Ukraine under a Black Sea wartime deal has passed inspection in Istanbul and is heading on to Lebanon
4:35PM ( 1 hour ago )
Scenic California river hamlet razed by deadly wildfire
The scenic Northern California hamlet of Klamath River was home to about 200 people, a community center, a corner store and a post office
4:29PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Overturning Roe v. Wade isn't the end for abortion opponents
Anti-abortion groups are looking to the courts, lawmakers and elections to facilitate more abortion restrictions and bans after a landmark U.S. Supreme Court ruling in June left the issue up to states
1:53PM ( 4 days ago )
Courts block abortion bans in Wyoming, North Dakota
Abortion bans set to take effect this week in Wyoming and North Dakota were temporarily blocked Wednesday by judges in those states amid lawsuits arguing that the bans violate their state constitutions
8:04PM ( 6 days ago )
Judge blocks Wyoming abortion ban on day it goes into effect
A Wyoming judge temporarily blocked the state’s abortion ban on the day it took effect, siding with a firebombed women’s health clinic and others who argued the ban would harm health care workers and their patients and violate the state constitution
5:10PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Indian government approves new emissions targets
Nine months after India announced its target of “net zero” emissions by 2070 at the United Nations climate conference in Glasgow, the country’s federal cabinet finally approved a new climate plan on Wednesday
1:00PM ( 4 hours ago )
Steam bath weather adds to misery after Appalachian flooding
Temperatures are soaring in a region of eastern Kentucky where people are shoveling out the wreckage of massive flooding
12:18PM ( 5 hours ago )
OPEC+ boosts oil output by slower pace than previous months
The OPEC oil cartel and its allies have decided to boost production in September by a much slower pace than in previous months
11:11AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Medicaid expansion breakthrough within reach in N. Carolina
A deal on Medicaid expansion in North Carolina is within reach after both legislative chambers passed competing measures before ending their annual session
8:30AM ( 3 days ago )
In race for monkeypox vaccines, experts see repeat of COVID
Public health officials warn that moves by rich countries to buy large quantities of monkeypox vaccine could leave millions of people in Africa unprotected against a more dangerous version of the disease
10:53AM ( 4 days ago )
California not ready to declare emergency over monkeypox
California's public health officer says officials are pressing for more vaccine and closely monitoring the spread of the monkeypox virus
9:12PM ( 4 days ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Alex Jones concedes Sandy Hook attack was '100% real'
Conspiracy theorist Alex Jones says he now understands it was irresponsible of him to declare the Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre a hoax and that he now believes it was “100% real.”
5:21PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Idaho's top court latest in red state to weigh abortion ban
In deeply conservative Idaho, it's expected that abortion will be banned eventually, but abortion rights advocates are continuing their legal challenges
5:12PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Open primary may save Trump's GOP targets in Washington
Two Republican members of Congress from Washington who drew interparty challenges due to their vote to impeach former President Donald Trump were leading other Republicans in the state’s top two primary
5:04PM ( 42 minutes ago )
NLRB: Mine workers to pay Alabama coal company over $13M
A federal oversight board is ordering the United Mine Workers of America to pay more than $13 million in compensation to an Alabama coal company where members have been on strike for more than a year
4:55PM ( 50 minutes ago )
Senate moves to decisive vote adding Sweden, Finland to NATO
Senators are moving toward what's expected to be an overwhelming bipartisan vote ratifying NATO membership for Finland and Sweden
4:53PM ( 53 minutes ago )