rain.png
Tuesday August 9th, 2022 4:14PM

EXPLAINER: Watson discipline didn't require legal charges

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

When two separate Texas grand juries declined to indict Deshaun Watson on criminal complaints stemming from allegations of sexual assault or harassment by 24 women, it didn’t clear the three-time Pro Bowl quarterback from facing consequences from the NFL.

Watson and the Cleveland Browns found out the severity of his punishment on Monday, when he was suspended six games for violating the league's personal conduct policy. He won't be paid while suspended, though he won't lose as much as he would have if the NFL had its way.

Disciplinary officer Sue L. Robinson made the decision after the NFL pushed for an indefinite suspension of at least one year and Watson’s legal team argued for no punishment during a three-day hearing that concluded June 30.

A look at the issue:

WHY WAS WATSON DISCIPLINED IF HE NEVER FACED LEGAL CHARGES?

A player does not have to be convicted or even charged with a crime to be disciplined for conduct detrimental to the league, per the collective bargaining agreement between the NFL and the NFL Players’ Association. Ezekiel Elliott, Ben Roethlisberger, Jameis Winston and Kareem Hunt are among the many players who have received suspensions for various infractions despite not being charged criminally.

Some legal experts are critical of the process.

“Normally arbitration is reserved for civil matters in workplaces, which is what makes the NFL’s investigation of criminal allegations wholly unique and, in my opinion, potentially unfair,” said attorney Amy Dash, founder of League of Justice, a website that reports on sports and the law. “The determinations create a presumption of guilt by many people in the public forum. But so far courts have not wanted to disturb the outcomes because the whole process was negotiated and agreed upon in the CBA by the players’ union reps and the league.”

Dash also noted that sometimes players are being investigated for criminal allegations in the arbitration process and they “don’t have the same protections a defendant in the criminal courts would have such as presumption of innocence, a burden to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, the same rules of evidence and discovery, etc.”

But the league negotiated its disciplinary process with the union so it has the power, as an employer, to impose punishment.

WHAT WAS DIFFERENT ABOUT WATSON'S CASE?

The major difference in Watson’s case was the discipline came from an independent arbiter. The league and union agreed in the 2020 CBA that a disciplinary officer would determine whether a player violated the personal conduct policy and whether to impose discipline. Previously, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell had the authority to do it.

This was the first case for Robinson, who was jointly appointed by the league and the union.

However, Goodell still has the right to overturn her decision if either side appeals. Per the CBA, an appeal would be heard by Goodell or a person he designates and the written decision would be final.

After learning the ruling was imminent, the NFLPA issued a joint statement with Watson on Sunday night saying they would not appeal Robinson’s ruling and urged the league to follow suit.

Goodell wasn’t directly involved in Robinson’s decision, but the league made it clear it wanted an unprecedented punishment. The NFL is well aware of public perception. Fallout from its decision in the Ray Rice case in 2014 — when the league increased its suspension only after video of the former Ravens running back hitting his fiancee emerged — led the NFL to vow it would levy harsher penalties in cases involving violence and sexual assault against women.

WHAT IS THIS COSTING WATSON?

Watson settled 23 of the civil lawsuits from 24 women alleging sexual harassment and assault during private massage therapy sessions when he played for the Houston Texans.

Watson, who signed a fully guaranteed $230 million, five-year contract, will lose only $345,000 if the suspension is unchanged because his base salary this season is $1.035 million. His $45 million signing bonus is not affected by the suspension.

After one of the grand juries declined to indict Watson in March, Harris County District Attorney Kim Ogg said: “We respect our justice process. I love the law. It’s designed to get to the truth. That’s really what people want. I don’t think as a culture we can live with injustice. Remember, a grand jury no bill is not an exoneration. People, even when they clear the criminal justice system, often face accountability and repercussions in other parts of our legal system. And so I think to determine whether justice was done in this case you’re going to have to wait and see how it all comes out on the civil side of things and then through the NFL on the administrative side of things. And then people will determine whether that’s justice.”

The administrative part has now been decided.

___

More AP NFL coverage: https://apnews.com/hub/nfl and https://twitter.com/AP_NFL

  • Associated Categories: Sports, Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Business, AP Sports - NFL
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
EXPLAINER: Watson discipline didn't require legal charges
Deshaun Watson and the Cleveland Browns found out the severity of the quarterback's punishment when he was suspended for six games for violating the NFL's personal conduct policy
12:39PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Dems seem headed for climate, health win after ups and downs
In a story published July 30, 2022, The Associated Press reported that the Congressional Budget Office estimated that an insulin bill would increase the price of the drug
12:33PM ( 18 minutes ago )
What to watch in primaries in Arizona, Michigan, elsewhere
Primary elections are being held in six states on Tuesday
12:22PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
AP sources: Browns QB Deshaun Watson suspended for 6 games
Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson was suspended for six games Monday for violating the NFL’s personal conduct policy following accusations of sexual misconduct made against him by two dozen women in Texas, two people familiar with the decision said
10:50AM ( 2 hours ago )
Donald takes over for Stenson as Europe's Ryder Cup captain
Luke Donald is Europe's new captain for the Ryder Cup in Italy next year
10:43AM ( 2 hours ago )
Notable suspensions under NFL’s personal conduct policy
Cleveland quarterback Deshaun Watson was suspended for six games for violating the NFL’s personal conduct policy following accusations of sexual misconduct made against him by two dozen women in Texas when he played for Houston
9:50AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Sports
AP sources: Decision in Watson discipline case coming Monday
A decision on discipline for Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson following accusations of sexual misconduct is coming Monday
8:12PM ( 16 hours ago )
Big 12's new boss Yormark learning NCAA issues in real time
New Big 12 Commissioner Brett Yormark has been learning the NCAA's issues in real time during a period of sweeping change and uncertainty
12:54PM ( 23 hours ago )
Cardinals prepare for 6 games without suspended star Hopkins
The Arizona Cardinals are preparing for six games without star receiver DeAndre Hopkins
7:25PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Football
Cities face crisis as fewer kids enroll and schools shrink
Across the U.S., COVID-19 relief money is helping to subsidize growing numbers of big-city schools with small numbers of students
10:55AM ( 1 hour ago )
Stocks waver in August start after best month since 2020
Stocks wavered between gains and losses in morning trading on Wall Street Monday as investors face another busy week of corporate earnings reports and economic updates
10:43AM ( 2 hours ago )
Pelosi starts Asian tour with speculation over Taiwan visit
U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has held talks with Singapore's leaders at the start of her Asian tour as questions swirl over a possible stop in Taiwan that has fueled tension with Beijing
10:31AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
AP sources: Deshaun Watson waiting game goes to next week
The waiting game in Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson’s discipline case will continue into next week
9:57AM ( 3 days ago )
Cardinals remove Kyler Murray's independent-study addendum
The Arizona Cardinals have removed an addendum to quarterback Kyler Murray’s $230.5 million, five-year contract that mandated at least four hours of “independent study” during game weeks
10:21PM ( 3 days ago )
AP sources: Seahawks expected to sign Metcalf to extension
Two people with knowledge of the deal say the Seattle Seahawks are expected to sign DK Metcalf to a three-year contract extension worth up to $72 million and $58 million guaranteed
9:57PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Sports - NFL
Dems seem headed for climate, health win after ups and downs
In a story published July 30, 2022, The Associated Press reported that the Congressional Budget Office estimated that an insulin bill would increase the price of the drug
12:33PM ( 19 minutes ago )
What to watch in primaries in Arizona, Michigan, elsewhere
Primary elections are being held in six states on Tuesday
12:22PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Flash floods close roads into Death Valley National Park
Officials have closed some roads in and out of Death Valley National Park after they were inundated over the weekend with mud and debris caused by by flash flooding
12:22PM ( 30 minutes ago )
Bumps, bipartisanship in long fight for semiconductor bill
President Joe Biden will soon be signing into law a major bill to revive the U.S. computer chip sector
12:20PM ( 32 minutes ago )
End of the beginning: England wants Euro win to lead to more
In soccer-mad England, which sees itself as the home of the world’s game, women and girls finally have a team full of heroes who look like them
12:19PM ( 33 minutes ago )