Tuesday July 5th, 2022 1:48AM

Iowa Supreme Court: Abortion not fundamental right in state

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — The Iowa Supreme Court on Friday cleared the way for lawmakers to severely limit or ban abortion in the state, reversing a decision by the court just four years ago that guaranteed the right to abortion under the Iowa Constitution.

The court, now composed almost entirely of Republican appointees, concluded that a less conservative court wrongly decided abortion is among the fundamental privacy rights guaranteed by the Iowa Constitution and federal law.

Friday’s ruling comes amid expectations that the U.S. Supreme Court will overturn the landmark Roe v. Wade decision that legalized abortion nationwide. If that happens, Iowa lawmakers could ban abortion without completing the lengthy process of amending the state constitution.

The Iowa decision stemmed from a lawsuit filed by abortion providers who challenged a 2020 law that required a 24-hour waiting period before a woman can get an abortion. A judge who struck down the law cited the state high court's 2018 ruling. The judge also concluded that the law violated rules prohibiting passage of bills with more than one subject.

The state Supreme Court action means those seeking an abortion in Iowa must abide by the 24-hour waiting period which means returning to the clinic for a second time, an obstacle that opponents said could place abortion out of reach for some.

“The court’s decision today is a devastating and shocking reversal. But abortion remains legal in Iowa and we will continue to fight to challenge the two-appointment, minimum 24-hour mandatory delay law under the undue burden standard that the court declined to overrule today,” said ACLU of Iowa Legal Director Rita Bettis Austen.

The court returned the legal battle over the 24-hour wait to district court for further proceedings.

“We definitely have a long fight ahead of us. It’s important now more than ever that Iowans engage, and step up, stand up, have their voices heard that they want to retain the fundamental right to abortion care," said Sheena Dooley, spokeswoman for Planned Parenthood North Central States

In its 2018 ruling, decided by a 5-2 vote, the court said “autonomy and dominion over one’s body go to the very heart of what it means to be free.”

The opinion released Friday and written by Justice Edward Mansfield said the court isn’t obligated to abide by precedent, especially in cases evaluating constitutional rights or in cases decided recently.

The reversal reflects a dramatic change in the court’s makeup. Gov. Kim Reynolds has named four justices since 2017, and six of the seven people on the court were appointed by Republican governors.

But Mansfield rejected the argument by legal scholars and law professors that said shifting opinions on such important matters within a short period of time feeds into the idea that courts are politicized.

“We do not agree that every state supreme court decision is entitled to some minimum try-out period before it can be challenged,” he said.

He said “courts must be free to correct their own mistakes when no one else can.”

Reynolds said in a statement that the ruling is a “significant victory in our fight to protect the unborn.” She and legislative leaders have not said whether they will call a special session this summer to take up a new abortion law.

Justice Brent Appel, the only Democratic appointee to the court, wrote a dissenting opinion saying “the right to reproductive autonomy should not be eviscerated by narrow textualism.”

Chief Justice Susan Christensen also disagreed with overturning the 2018 decision, saying little has changed and that since the Iowa Legislature has begun the process of amending the Iowa Constitution to say abortion is not a fundamental right, the people should decide the issue.

“If the majority truly wants to leave this issue to the will of the people, it should let the people have their say through the ongoing constitutional amendment process,” she said.

If lawmakers approve the amendment next year, a vote could come as soon as 2024.

Reynolds, an outspoken opponent of abortion rights, and Republicans in the Legislature have repeatedly said they hoped the court would overturn the 2018 ruling, and GOP lawmakers gave the governor more control over the panel that chooses nominations for court positions.

The 2018 decision made Iowa the sixth state — with Alaska, Florida, Kansas, Montana and Minnesota — where abortion rights were recognized by the state’s high court.

As in Iowa, Republicans control the Legislatures and governorships in Florida and Montana, where GOP leaders have been stymied from enacting abortion bans that could take effect if the U.S. Supreme Court overturns its 1973 landmark decision and puts decision-making power in state government hands.

In Montana, a challenge to abortion restrictions that could test its high court opinion is before the Supreme Court.

In Iowa, Reynolds has demurred on questions of what exceptions she would accept. She said last month she is “proud of the legislation she signed in 2018,” including the ban on abortions once cardiac activity is detected, as early as six weeks and often before many women know they are pregnant. The measure included exceptions to protect the life of the mother and in pregnancies that result from incest or rape.

Yet more recently, she stopped short of specifying similar exceptions. “I’m not going to set any parameters,” she told reporters.

Iowa Department of Public Health data shows there were 4,058 abortions in Iowa in 2020 — 835 surgical abortions and 3,222 by medication. That was an increase over the previous year when 3,566 abortions were reported. Iowa averaged just under 3,500 abortions a year from 2015 to 2019.

Court documents show Planned Parenthood performs about 95% of Iowa abortions. Surgical and medical abortions may be obtained in clinics in Des Moines and Iowa City. Medication abortions are provided in other clinic locations including Ames, Council Bluffs and Sioux City.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Health, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
US adds $103M for wildfire hazards and land rehabilitation
The U.S. is adding $103 million this year for wildfire risk reduction and burned-area rehabilitation throughout the country as well as establishing an interagency wildland firefighter well-being program
4:51PM ( 12 minutes ago )
From dry to deluge, how heavy snow, rain flooded Yellowstone
A culmination of unique events led to the recent extensive flooding in the Yellowstone region
4:48PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Texas lawmaker: Uvalde police agree to cooperate with probe
A Texas lawmaking leading an investigation into the Uvalde elementary school shooting says local police have agreed to meet with his committee
4:42PM ( 21 minutes ago )
U.S. News
Wall Street closes worst week since 2020 with slight gain
Wall Street closed out its most punishing week since the 2020 coronavirus crash with a meandering day of trading Friday that left it a bit higher
4:37PM ( 26 minutes ago )
US Open updates: Morikawa moves into tie for lead at 5 under
Collin Morikawa has made a move at the U.S. Open in his attempt to win a major golf tournament for the third year in a row
4:24PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Avs franchise fortunes aren't MacKinnon's to shoulder alone
Colorado Avalanche superstar Nathan MacKinnon has upped his game by dialing it down
4:21PM ( 42 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Official in election standoff avoids prison in Capitol riot
An elected official who is a central figure in a New Mexico county’s refusal to certify recent election results based on debunked conspiracy theories about voting machines has avoided more jail time for joining the mob that attacked the U.S. Capitol
3:23PM ( 1 hour ago )
Stocks drift higher on Wall Street at close of a brutal week
U.S. stocks are drifting upward on Friday, as Wall Street nears the end of one of its worst weeks since the 2020 coronavirus crash
3:02PM ( 2 hours ago )
UK govt orders Julian Assange's extradition; appeal planned
The British government has approved the extradition of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange to the United States to face spying charges
2:37PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Report: Smoking bans no longer a threat to casino revenue
For decades, it was accepted wisdom in the casino industry that eliminating smoking would automatically lead to revenue declines and customer losses
11:39AM ( 5 hours ago )
Nebraska rushes to build horse tracks despite few fans
Horse races are regularly held in only two spots in Nebraska, but the tracks in Grand Island and Columbus are usually pretty quiet apart from the rumble of thoroughbreds that stomp past the often empty grandstands
10:45AM ( 6 hours ago )
Towns near Yellowstone fear impact of lost tourism season
The severe flooding at Yellowstone National Park has left business owners in some of the park’s gateway towns wondering how they’ll make ends meet without a steady stream of customers during what is normally peak tourism season
10:10AM ( 6 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
White House: Florida doctors can order under-5 COVID shots
The White House says Florida doctors will be able to directly order COVID-19 vaccines for children under 5 from the federal government
2:16PM ( 2 hours ago )
US sanctions Nicaraguan gold mining firm over ties to Russia
The U.S. has imposed sanctions on Nicaragua’s state-owned gold mining company and the president of its board of directors partly over the Central American nation’s ties to Russia
12:57PM ( 4 hours ago )
Biden hosts climate meeting amid high gas price pressure
Equating the oil and gas industry to Big Tobacco, United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres says that “fossil fuel producers and financiers have humanity by the throat.”
11:56AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Biden signs new shipping law he says can cut consumer costs
President Joe Biden signed legislation Thursday meant to make shipping goods across oceans cheaper
7:25PM ( 21 hours ago )
Jan. 6 takeaways: 'Heated' Trump, Pence's near miss with mob
In its third public hearing, the House panel investigating the Jan. 6, 2021, insurrection has focused on former President Donald Trump’s pressure on his vice president to delay or reject the certification of President Joe Biden’s victory
7:17PM ( 21 hours ago )
Texas recount underway between Texas Rep. Cuellar, Cisneros
A recount is underway in a Texas primary race between Democratic U.S. Rep. Henry Cuellar and progressive challenger Jessica Cisneros
6:09PM ( 22 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Some clinics halting abortions while bracing for Roe's fall
Abortion providers are bracing for the final days of the U.S. Supreme Court’s guarantee of a right to an abortion
4:49PM ( 1 day ago )
Election 'deniers' quiet on fraud claims after primary wins
Dozens of Republican candidates who sought Donald Trump’s endorsement have spent months parroting the former president's baseless claims of 2020 election fraud
12:12AM ( 1 day ago )
Abortion amendment moving quickly in California legislature
Democrats are moving quickly to make sure abortions are a constitutional right in California
8:13PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
WTO ministers reach deals on fisheries, food, COVID vaccines
World Trade Organization members have reached a string of deals and commitments aimed to limit overfishing, broaden production of COVID-19 vaccines in the developing world, improve food security and reform a 27-year-old trade body that has been back on its heels in recent years
11:30AM ( 5 hours ago )
Residents say China used health tracker for crowd control
Angry bank customers who traveled to a city in central China to retrieve their savings from troubled rural banks have been stopped by a health app on their cellphone
11:12AM ( 5 hours ago )
UK: 50 new monkeypox cases in biggest epidemic beyond Africa
British health officials have reported another 50 cases of monkeypox across the country, for a total of 574 cases
9:45AM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Health
Malta activists protest, seek to decriminalize abortion
Abortion rights activists have filed a legal protest in Malta’s courts demanding the legalization of abortion
3:03PM ( 2 days ago )
Poland, with near-total abortion ban, to record pregnancies
The right-wing government in Poland, where a near-total abortion ban is in place, now faces accusations it is creating a “pregnancy register.”
12:52PM ( 1 week ago )
Doctor named in abortion case has nothing to do with lawsuit
Dr. Thomas Dobbs has never gotten involved in political fights over reproductive health, but his name has become shorthand for a legal case that could end abortion rights in the United States
8:35AM ( 1 week ago )
AP Health - Women's health
US adds $103M for wildfire hazards and land rehabilitation
The U.S. is adding $103 million this year for wildfire risk reduction and burned-area rehabilitation throughout the country as well as establishing an interagency wildland firefighter well-being program
4:51PM ( 13 minutes ago )
From dry to deluge, how heavy snow, rain flooded Yellowstone
A culmination of unique events led to the recent extensive flooding in the Yellowstone region
4:48PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Texas lawmaker: Uvalde police agree to cooperate with probe
A Texas lawmaking leading an investigation into the Uvalde elementary school shooting says local police have agreed to meet with his committee
4:42PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Montana governor under fire for vacationing during flood
Montana's governor was not in Montana — or in the U.S. at all — when punishing floods hit Yellowstone National Park and communities on its fringes this week
4:15PM ( 49 minutes ago )
FDA authorizes 1st COVID-19 shots for infants, preschoolers
U.S. regulators have authorized the first COVID-19 shots for infants and preschoolers
3:59PM ( 1 hour ago )