Sunday November 27th, 2022 11:31PM

EXPLAINER: Why Ukraine’s request to join is big test for EU

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

BRUSSELS (AP) — Ukraine’s request to join the European Union may advance Friday with a recommendation from the EU’s executive arm that the war-torn country deserves to become a candidate for membership in the 27-nation bloc.

The European Commission's endorsement, while only a tentative step on a path that could take decades to complete, would send a strong symbol of solidarity with Ukraine and further test the EU's united front against Russia amid the invasion of its neighbor.

Here is a look at what the commission's announcement on making Ukraine an EU candidate could mean for the region:


Ukraine applied for EU accession less than a week after Russia invaded the country and as the capital, Kyiv, faced the threat of capture and the Ukrainian government falling.

The urgency created by the war and Ukraine's request for expedited consideration could upend the bloc’s go-slow approach to enlargement.

On Thursday, the leaders of France, Germany, Italy and Romania visited Ukraine and vowed to back Kyiv’s bid to become an official candidate. Italian Premier Mario Draghi called EU candidacy for Ukraine “a very profound step” and noted that Ukraine would leapfrog Balkan nations, if the status is granted. But Draghi said the situation in Ukraine is “extraordinary.”

Giving Ukraine candidate status would challenge the EU’s normal playbook for adding members. The leaders of EU member nations are expected to consider the European Commission's recommendation next week.

The leaders face a delicate balancing act: signaling to Ukraine that the EU's door is ajar while reassuring other aspiring members and some of the bloc’s own citizens that they aren't showing favoritism to Kyiv.


The European Union was born in the 1950s to prevent another war between Germany and France. The six founding members were Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and Luxembourg.

Since then, the EU has steadily expanded while espousing the idea that economic and political integration among nations is the best way to promote general prosperity and peace. This approach paved the way for the creation of the euro currency in 1999 and for the addition in 2004 of 10 new member countries, most from formerly communist Eastern Europe.

The euro, which 11 countries initially adopted as their official currency, highlighted the EU’s capacity to deepen economic and political integration among EU nations. The “big bang” enlargement five years later showcased the bloc’s ability to widen its reach.

As the biggest military conflict in Europe since World War II unfolds on the bloc’s eastern border, the EU is grappling anew with enduring questions about its ability to deepen and widen, the informal benchmarks experts use to track the bloc's decades-long evolution.


The internal consensus underpinning such a dual-track approach to the EU's progression had weakened years before Russia invaded Ukraine.

The euro-area debt crisis that erupted in 2010, a wave of mass migration in 2015 and the U.K.'s shock 2016 referendum decision to leave the EU all contributed to EU skittishness toward expanding its ranks.

So, too, did the growth of euroskeptic political forces in many member countries, including Germany, France and Italy. Some EU nations have accused the governments in Berlin, Paris and Rome of showing insufficient political support for Ukraine as it defends itself from Russia.

The Thursday visit to Kyiv by German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, French President Emmanuel Macron, Italian Premier Mario Draghi and Romanian President Klaus Iohannis might help counter such criticism.


The leaders' meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and expressions of support for Ukraine coincided with behind-the-scenes European Commission negotiations over the forthcoming opinion on whether Ukraine merits candidate status.

A group of EU countries that included Poland wants maximum backing for Ukraine, while others, such as the Netherlands, favor a more cautious stance.

The commission plans also to issue its recommendations for Georgia and Moldova, which both rushed to apply for EU membership in March.

The degree to which Ukraine's request for a fast-track accession represents a change in the EU's standard operating procedure is evident from the experiences of other aspiring members.

Turkey, for example, applied for membership in 1987, received candidate status in 1999, and had to wait until 2005 to start talks for actual entry. Only one of more than 30 negotiating “chapters” has been completed in the years since, and the whole process is at a standstill as a result of various disputes between the EU and Turkey.


Six nations in the Western Balkans also have faced long waits on their EU membership journeys. North Macedonia, for example, submitted its entry bid in 2004 and gained candidate status the following year.

But even after subsequently changing its name to settle a longstanding dispute with EU member Greece, the country is still waiting for membership talks to begin because Bulgaria, another member, threw up a last-minute hurdle related to ethnicity and language.

Launching accession talks requires unanimous approval from all 27 EU nations

Another aspiring member in the Balkans is Serbia, which applied for EU membership in 2009, became a candidate in 2012 and began entry talks in 2014. So far, the country has completed only two of 35 negotiating chapters.

In this context, Ukraine is essentially asking the EU to abandon its better-safe-than-sorry enlargement strategy.


Follow AP's coverage of the Ukraine war at

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP World News, AP Business, AP World News - International incidents
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Wall Street gets back to tumbling after 1-day reprieve
Markets worldwide are back to tumbling on Thursday as worries about a fragile economy roar back to the fore
11:15AM ( 6 minutes ago )
Kevin Spacey 'strenuously' denies sex charges, granted bail
Kevin Spacey's lawyer has told a London court that the actor “strenuously denies” allegations of sexual assault
11:15AM ( 6 minutes ago )
Police: Amazon fisherman confesses to killing missing men
Brazilian authorities say a fisherman confessed to killing a British journalist and an Indigenous expert in Brazil’s remote Amazon region and took police to a site where human remains were recovered
11:12AM ( 9 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Leaders pledge arms and EU path for Ukraine in Kyiv visit
The leaders of four European Union nations visited Ukraine, vowing to back Kyiv's bid to become an official candidate to join the bloc in a high-profile show of support for the country fending off a Russian invasion
10:32AM ( 49 minutes ago )
Russian sanctions hurting small Italian fashion producers
Small Italian fashion producers are still allowed to export to Russia despite sanctions, as long as the wholesale price is under 300 euros
10:20AM ( 1 hour ago )
UK sanctions Russian Orthodox head; decries forced adoption
Britain has announced a new round of sanctions against Russia
10:16AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP World News
Floodwaters from Yellowstone surge through eastern Montana
Montana’s largest city has restarted its water plant after shutting it down amid record flooding that’s caused widespread damage in Yellowstone National Park and surrounding communities
10:32AM ( 49 minutes ago )
Revlon, beauty icon in crowded market, files for bankruptcy
Revlon, the 90-year-old multinational cosmetics company, is filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, weighed down by debt load, disruptions to its supply chain network and surging costs
10:30AM ( 52 minutes ago )
Wall Street gets back to tumbling after one day of respite
Markets worldwide are back to tumbling on Thursday as worries about a fragile economy roar back to the fore
10:16AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
GAO: US failed to track if arms used against Yemen civilians
A government report says the Pentagon and the State Department failed to investigate whether a Saudi-led coalition used arms bought from U.S. suppliers in attacks alleged to have killed civilians in Yemen
5:59PM ( 17 hours ago )
Seoul: North Korea fires suspected artillery pieces into sea
South Korea says North Korea has test-fired suspected artillery pieces into the sea
10:57AM ( 4 days ago )
Germany's Scholz tries to unblock North Macedonia's EU bid
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz has visited North Macedonia and Bulgaria in a bid to resolve the dispute between both countries that has seen European Union membership talks with both North Macedonia and Albania blocked
10:55AM ( 5 days ago )
AP World News - International incidents
Police: Amazon fisherman confesses to killing missing men
Brazilian authorities say a fisherman confessed to killing a British journalist and an Indigenous expert in Brazil’s remote Amazon region and took police to a site where human remains were recovered
11:12AM ( 9 minutes ago )
Firm behind popular US dollar stablecoin to launch Euro Coin
The cryptocurrency company Circle says it will start issuing its first euro-denominated cryptocurrency, a stablecoin known as Euro Coin, later this month
11:11AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Uvalde 11-year-old was avid runner, is remembered for energy
Layla Salazar adored Koala bears and loved the NFL's Dallas Cowboys and dancing to TikTok videos
11:05AM ( 16 minutes ago )
If Roe falls, some DAs won't enforce anti-abortion laws
Progressive prosecutors around the U.S. are declaring they won’t enforce some of the most restrictive and punitive anti-abortion laws that GOP-led states have waited years to implement
11:01AM ( 21 minutes ago )
US Open updates | Amateur, Morikawa in tie for early lead
Amateur Stewart Hagestad had back-to-back birdies on the seventh and eighth holes at The Country Club outside of Boston to move into a tie for the lead early in the first round of the U.S. Open
10:50AM ( 32 minutes ago )