clearn.png
Tuesday August 16th, 2022 6:55AM

Judge: Georgia county can't deny gender surgery to deputy

By The Associated Press

ATLANTA (AP) — A federal judge has found that a Georgia sheriff's office was illegally discriminating when it denied gender reassignment surgery to a deputy.

U.S. District Judge Marc Treadwell ruled June 2 that Houston County cannot exclude surgery for the transgender woman from its health insurance plan, citing a 2020 U.S. Supreme Court decision finding that a Michigan funeral home couldn't fire an employee for being transgender.

The case involves Sgt. Anna Lange, an investigator in the middle Georgia county who began her transition in 2017 after being diagnosed with gender dysphoria.

“I can confidently move forward with my life knowing that gender affirming care is protected under federal law," Lange said in a statement released by the Transgender Legal Defense & Education Fund, which represented her. "This decision is not only a personal victory, but a tremendous step forward for all transgender Southerners who are seeking insurance coverage for medically necessary care.”

David Brown, legal director for the fund, told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution that the ruling is believed to be the first of its kind in the South.

Neither Talton nor the county’s lawyers responded to requests for comment.

Treadwell wrote in his order that Lange, a 16-year-employee, told the sheriff and other county officials in 2018 that she wanted to begin dressing as a woman at work, while inquiring about whether Houston County's health plan would cover gender reassignment surgery.

Sheriff Cullen Talton, first elected sheriff in 1972, initially took it as a joke, Treadwell wrote, and then said he doesn’t “believe in sex changes,” before ultimately granting permission for Lange to dress as a woman, but warned she would need “tough skin” to deal with her coworkers.

But the county health plan had excluded sex change surgery and drugs since 1998. Lange was denied authorization for surgery in November 2018 after county personnel director Kenneth Carter told the insurer the county wanted to keep the exclusion, even though the insurer had advised Houston County in 2016 that the rule was discriminatory under the federal Affordable Care Act.

County commissioners voted unanimously to keep the exclusion in 2019, after Lange had asked them to pay for the surgery in a public meeting, claiming they were trying to keep health insurance costs low. The surgery she was seeking was estimated to cost $25,600 at the time.

Treadwell found it's undisputed that Lange's surgery “medically necessary" and questioned whether the concern about costs was just a smokescreen to discriminate against Lange.

“Certainly, the county now professes concern about costs, but that argument is undercut by the undisputed fact that the county built its cost defense after the fact," Treadwell wrote.

But the judge said the Supreme Court made clear in a 2020 case that treating someone differently because they are transgender violates a section of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex. For example, the judge noted the county health plan would pay for a mastectomy for cancer treatment, but not to treat gender dysphoria.

“Discrimination on the basis of transgender status is discrimination on the basis of sex and is a violation of Title VII,” the judge wrote.

Lange's case is not yet over. Treadwell must still rule on what remedies are appropriate. He also denied Lange's claims for money damages and for discrimination under the Americans with Disabilities Act.

Public records obtained by Lange's lawyers show the county has spend more than $690,000 defending the case.

“It just shows the length people are still willing to go to discriminate against transgender people,” Lange told the Journal-Constitution.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Online - Georgia News, AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Ukraine: Russia said to be using more deadly weapons in war
Ukrainian and British officials have warned that Russian forces are relying on weapons with potential to cause mass casualties as they try to make headway in capturing eastern Ukraine
9:22AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Slain Uvalde girl remembered as caring and opinionated
Alexandria Aniyah Rubio was opinionated like her mother, and she played basketball and softball like her father
9:09AM ( 36 minutes ago )
Curry scores 43 to beat Boston, Warriors tie NBA Finals 2-2
Stephen Curry scored 43 points to lead the Golden State Warriors to a 107-97 victory over the Boston Celtics in Game 4 of the NBA Finals
8:41AM ( 1 hour ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Why France's parliamentary elections are important to Macron
Emmanuel Macron saw off the far right’s Marine Le Pen in April’s presidential election, but now the French president is facing a threat from the other end of the political spectrum in the fight for parliamentary power
5:01AM ( 4 hours ago )
Trump endorses Katie Britt in Alabama Senate race
Former President Donald Trump has endorsed Katie Britt in the Republican primary for an Alabama U.S. Senate seat
1:55AM ( 7 hours ago )
Biden facing fire and anger during New Mexico visit
President Joe Biden is visiting New Mexico to talk about his administration’s efforts to tackle wildfires as residents smolder with anger over how federal officials allowed planned burns to spread out of control, leading to the largest blaze in recorded state history
12:28AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Dems confront criticism on crime after San Francisco defeat
Democrats are defending their record on crime a day after an election for district attorney in California exposed lingering vulnerabilities
5:54PM ( 2 days ago )
Same-sex marriage advocates push for post-Roe protections
LGBTQ advocates in states with same-sex marriage bans that were nullified by the U.S. Supreme Court seven years ago are sounding the alarm that overturning Roe v
7:28PM ( 3 days ago )
Abortion rights advocates say they need more men's voices
In the decadeslong struggle for abortion rights, some men have played an active supporting role, through organizations and as legislators and abortion providers
10:26AM ( 5 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
War, guilt and last kisses: A deceptive, uneasy calm in Kyiv
With war raging on fronts to the east and south, the summer of 2022 is proving bitter for the Ukrainian capital, Kyiv
9:36AM ( 9 minutes ago )
North Korean leader reaffirms arms buildup in party meeting
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un has doubled down on his arms buildup in the face of what he describes as an aggravating security environment
6:21AM ( 3 hours ago )
Survivor of abusive facility searches for lost Korean roots
Joo-Rei Mathieson was one of the lucky kids, escaping a brutal South Korean facility where thousands of children and adults — mostly grabbed off the streets — were enslaved and often killed, raped and beaten in the 1970s and 1980s
5:10AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business
Strider fans 8, Braves top Pirates 4-2 for 9th straight win
Spencer Strider outpitched Roansy Contreras in a matchup of hard-throwing rookies, Dansby Swanson had three hits, including a two-run homer and the Atlanta Braves beat the Pittsburgh Pirates 4-2 for their ninth straight win
11:33PM ( 10 hours ago )
Braves claim former Yankees 1B Ford off waivers from Seattle
The Atlanta Braves have claimed first baseman Mike Ford off waivers from the Seattle Mariners
5:53PM ( 15 hours ago )
Ryan finding perfect fit in Colts offense, locker room
Indianapolis Colts quarterback Matt Ryan has spent the past several months getting acclimated to a new offense, a new locker room and a new city
5:45PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online - Georgia News
AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
Ukraine: Russia said to be using more deadly weapons in war
Ukrainian and British officials have warned that Russian forces are relying on weapons with potential to cause mass casualties as they try to make headway in capturing eastern Ukraine
9:22AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Slain Uvalde girl remembered as caring and opinionated
Alexandria Aniyah Rubio was opinionated like her mother, and she played basketball and softball like her father
9:09AM ( 36 minutes ago )
Curry scores 43 to beat Boston, Warriors tie NBA Finals 2-2
Stephen Curry scored 43 points to lead the Golden State Warriors to a 107-97 victory over the Boston Celtics in Game 4 of the NBA Finals
8:41AM ( 1 hour ago )
New York fund apologizes for role in Tuskegee syphilis study
A New York-based philanthropy is publicly apologizing for its role in the infamous Tuskegee syphilis study
8:40AM ( 1 hour ago )
Census wants to know how to ask about sexuality and gender
Sexual orientation and gender identity
8:31AM ( 1 hour ago )