fair.png
Wednesday July 6th, 2022 12:35PM

Deliberations underway in trial linked to Trump-Russia probe

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — A lawyer for Hillary Clinton's 2016 presidential campaign hid his partisan interests from the FBI as he pushed “pure opposition research” related to Donald Trump and Russia in the weeks before the election, a prosecutor asserted Friday during closing arguments of the attorney's trial.

But Michael Sussmann's legal team denied prosecutors’ claims that he lied. And even if jurors believed Sussmann did lie, the defense said the alleged false statement did not matter because he was presenting national security information that the FBI would have looked into no matter the source. At the time of Sussmann's meeting with the FBI in September 2016, the bureau was already investigating whether Russia and the Trump campaign were colluding to sway the election won by Trump that November.

“It was a very contentious time. The Russians had hacked the DNC. They were leaking emails. And there was an ongoing FBI investigation irrespective of this," Sussmann lawyer Sean Berkowitz told jurors, referring to the Democratic National Committee. “And that was viewed as incredibly serious.”

The case is the first courtroom test of special counsel John Durham's work since his appointment three years ago to search for government misconduct during the investigation into potential ties between Russia and Trump’s campaign. Jurors began deliberating Friday afternoon.

A guilty verdict would be cheered by Trump and his supporters, who have looked to the Durham investigation to undercut the original Trump-Russia probe that they have long seen as politically motivated. But the case against Sussmann is narrow in nature, involves a peripheral aspect of that probe and alleges misconduct by a tipster to the government rather than by anyone at the FBI or any other federal agency.

Nonetheless, the two weeks of testimony in federal court in Washington have exposed the extent to which Democratic interests, opposition research, the media and law enforcement all came to be entangled in the run-up to the presidential election.

Prosecutors have portrayed Sussmann as determined to gin up investigations into Trump that could then be disclosed to the media and yield stories negative to his campaign.

“It wasn’t about national security,” said Jonathan Algor, a Durham team prosecutor. “It was about promoting opposition research against the opposition candidate, Donald Trump.”

Sussmann is charged with a single count of making a false statement. That charge carries a maximum five-year prison sentence, though if convicted, Sussmann is likely to get far less — if any — prison time. He did not take the stand during the trial.

The case turns on a Sept. 19, 2016, meeting in which Sussmann presented the FBI's top lawyer, James Baker, with computer data that Sussmann said suggested a secret communications backchannel between a Russia-based bank and the Trump Organization, the candidate's company.

Such a backchannel, if it existed, would have been explosive information at a time when the FBI was examining links between Trump and Russia. But after assessing the data, the FBI quickly determined that there was no suspicious contact at all.

Prosecutors say Sussmann lied to Baker by saying he was not participating in the meeting on behalf of a particular client. They say he was actually there on behalf of the Clinton campaign and another client, a technology executive whom the Durham team says tasked researchers with looking for internet traffic involving Trump associates and Russians.

Sussmann lied about his clients, prosecutors allege, to give the data extra credibility because he figured the information would not be investigated if the FBI thought it was mere opposition research being pushed by the Clinton campaign.

“The defendant knew he had to hide his clients if there was any chance of getting his allegations to the FBI — and that, ladies and gentlemen, is why the defendant lied,” Algor said.

To convict, prosecutors need to show not only that Sussmann lied but that the lie was material — namely, that it mattered or at least could have mattered to the FBI's work.

Algor said the fact Sussmann repeatedly billed the Clinton campaign for his work on the Alfa Bank matter is proof he was acting on the campaign's behalf when he met with the FBI. But Berkowitz noted that Sussmann billed his taxi ride to FBI headquarters for the meeting itself to his law firm, rather than to the campaign.

Berkowitz also tried to cast doubt on what exactly was said in the meeting. Prosecutors showed jurors a text message Sussmann sent Baker the night before the meeting in which he requested a sit-down on a sensitive matter and said he would be coming by himself and not on behalf of a client.

But Berkowitz reminded jurors that the only false statement that was charged took place during the following day's meeting, and that no one can be sure exactly what was said because Baker and Sussmann were the only participants and neither took notes.

Berkowitz also suggested it was technically accurate if Sussmann said he was not acting on behalf of a client because Sussmann never asked the FBI do anything with the information he was providing.

“When you go somewhere on behalf of a client, you’re advocating for the client, you’re asking for something,” Berkowitz said. “Mr. Sussmann didn't ask Jim Baker for anything.”

The two sides also quibbled over Baker's testimony, with Berkowitz citing dozens of instances in which Baker said on the stand that he did not recall or could not remember something. Prosecutors, meanwhile, seized on the fact that Baker said he was “100% confident” that Sussmann had told him that he was not acting on behalf of a client and that he probably wouldn't have taken the meeting if he had been told otherwise.

“Ladies and gentlemen, would James Baker come on the stand under oath, a former high-ranking FBI official, and subject himself to the penalty of perjury if it weren't true,” another prosecutor, Andrew DeFilippis, told jurors on Friday. “No, he wouldn’t do that. None of us would do that, would take that risk.”

Durham has so far charged three people. The case against Sussmann is the only one to have reached trial.

___

Follow Eric Tucker on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/etuckerAP

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, General Presidential Election News, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Ukraine fears repeat of Mariupol horrors in the Donbas
Ukrainian officials and international observers are raising concerns that Russia's relentless attacks on the country's eastern Donbas region carry echoes of an earlier devastating assault on the port of Mariupol
4:13PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Oregon ballot fiasco highlights 'invisible' election chiefs
Voters in an Oregon county where a ballot-printing error delayed primary results for nearly two weeks have elected the same county clerk five times in the past 20 years despite missteps that impacted two previous elections and cost taxpayers $100,000
3:59PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Progressive ousts Biden-backed Schrader in Oregon primary
Seven-term U.S. Rep. Kurt Schrader has lost the Democratic primary in Oregon to progressive challenger Jamie McLeod-Skinner
3:57PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Deliberations underway in trial linked to Trump-Russia probe
Jury deliberations have begun in the Washington trial of a lawyer for Hillary Clinton’s 2016 presidential campaign who's charged with lying to the FBI early in the Trump-Russia probe
3:21PM ( 1 hour ago )
3 more funerals for Buffalo victims in week of goodbyes
A week filled with goodbyes continues for family and friends of victims of the racist attack on a supermarket in Buffalo, New York
3:17PM ( 1 hour ago )
NRA meets in Texas amid protests after school massacre
With protesters shouting outside, the National Rifle Association  has begun its annual convention in Houston, just days after a gunman killed 19 students and two teachers at an elementary school on the other side of the state
3:13PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
21 mass shootings. 365 dead. Here's where the guns came from
The suspects in the shootings at a Uvalde, Texas, elementary school and a Buffalo, New York, supermarket were both just 18 when authorities say they bought the weapons used in the attacks
2:36PM ( 1 hour ago )
Amid protests, NRA meets in Texas after school massacre
With protesters shouting outside, the National Rifle Association is beginning its annual convention in Houston, just days after a gunman killed 19 students and two teachers at an elementary school on the other side of the state
2:18PM ( 2 hours ago )
At long last, jury gets closing arguments in Depp trial
Johnny Depp’s lawyers have asked a jury “to give Mr. Depp his life back” by finding his ex-wife, Amber Heard, guilty of libel
2:12PM ( 2 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Cuellar, Cisneros runoff in Texas remains too early to call
The Texas primary runoff between Democratic U.S. Rep. Henry Cuellar and his progressive challenger, Jessica Cisneros, remains too early to call
3:27PM ( 59 minutes ago )
US: Turkey's NATO issues with Sweden, Finland will be fixed
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken says he's confident Turkey’s objections to Finland and Sweden joining NATO can be overcome swiftly
3:23PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trial tied to Russia probe ends with debate: Did lawyer lie?
A prosecutor has told federal jurors in Washington that a lawyer for Hillary Clinton's 2016 presidential campaign hid his partisan interests from the FBI as he pushed “pure opposition research” related to Donald Trump and Russia in the weeks before the election
1:42PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Oregon ballot fiasco spotlights clerk's troubled 20-year run
Voters in an Oregon county where a ballot-printing error has delayed primary results for nearly two weeks have elected the same county clerk five times in the past 20 years despite missteps that impacted two previous elections and cost taxpayers $100,000
12:26AM ( 16 hours ago )
Trump ally Zinke fights claim he's too liberal for Montana
When Republican Ryan Zinke first ran for Congress, the former Navy SEAL faced false accusations his military career had ended in disgrace
1:20PM ( 1 day ago )
Justices to rule in gun case with US raw from mass shootings
With mass shootings in Texas, New York and California fresh in Americans’ mind, the Supreme Court will soon issue its biggest gun ruling in more than a decade
12:54PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections
Live updates | Texas GOP to attend NRA convention in Houston
The National Rifle Association holds its annual convention in Houston, Texas, starting on Friday
11:54AM ( 2 days ago )
Jurors in trial linked to Russia probe shown billing records
A lawyer for Hillary Clinton's 2016 presidential campaign repeatedly billed to the campaign “general political advice” and legal work related to a since-debunked secret back channel between Donald Trump and Russia
11:14AM ( 2 days ago )
Trump rebuked with stinging losses in Georgia GOP contests
Gov. Brian Kemp of Georgia has easily dispatched Donald Trump’s hand-picked challenger in a Republican primary that demonstrated the limits of the former president and his conspiracy-fueled politics in a critical swing state
7:41AM ( 2 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
Midterm updates | Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey avoids GOP runoff
Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey has turned back eight primary challengers to win the GOP gubernatorial nomination without a runoff
12:01AM ( 2 days ago )
Midterm updates | Britt, Brooks in Alabama Senate runoff
Alabama’s Republican primary for U.S. Senate is going to a June runoff between Katie Britt and U.S. Rep. Mo Brooks
11:46PM ( 2 days ago )
Midterm updates | Arkansas' Sanders mourns Texas victims
Former White House Press Secretary Sarah Sanders mentioned the Texas school shooting during her victory speech upon winning the Republican primary for Arkansas governor
10:45PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Ukraine fears repeat of Mariupol horrors in the Donbas
Ukrainian officials and international observers are raising concerns that Russia's relentless attacks on the country's eastern Donbas region carry echoes of an earlier devastating assault on the port of Mariupol
4:13PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Oregon ballot fiasco highlights 'invisible' election chiefs
Voters in an Oregon county where a ballot-printing error delayed primary results for nearly two weeks have elected the same county clerk five times in the past 20 years despite missteps that impacted two previous elections and cost taxpayers $100,000
3:59PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Progressive ousts Biden-backed Schrader in Oregon primary
Seven-term U.S. Rep. Kurt Schrader has lost the Democratic primary in Oregon to progressive challenger Jamie McLeod-Skinner
3:57PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Herta walks away from crash during Indianapolis 500 practice
Colton Herta rolled his Indianapolis 500 car end-over-end during the final practice for Sunday's race
3:54PM ( 31 minutes ago )
At long last, Depp jurors hear closings, begin deliberations
Lawyers for Johnny Depp and Amber Heard made their closing arguments to a Virginia jury in Depp's civil suit against his ex-wife
3:53PM ( 33 minutes ago )