Sunday September 25th, 2022 3:44AM

Court battles go down to count deadline in Pa. Senate race

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — Former hedge fund CEO David McCormick went to Pennsylvania's highest court Tuesday in an eleventh-hour bid to help him close the gap in votes with celebrity heart surgeon Dr. Mehmet Oz in Pennsylvania's neck-and-neck Republican primary contest for U.S. Senate.

McCormick’s request for the state Supreme Court’s intervention came less than four hours before Tuesday’s 5 p.m. deadline for counties to report their unofficial results to the state elections office.

A separate court battle could go to the U.S. Supreme Court, with the candidates separated by fewer than 1,000 votes.

Even so, counties will continue counting hundreds of ballots after the deadline — including provisional, military and overseas absentee ballots — and the contest is almost certainly headed for a recount that will drag into June.

In the filing with the state Supreme Court, McCormick asked justices to order counties to obey a brand-new federal appeals court decision and promptly count mail-in ballots that lack a required handwritten date on the return envelope.

There are hundreds — if not thousands — of such ballots sitting in county offices across the state, as McCormick scrapes for enough votes to overtake Oz. The justices ordered counties to respond by 4 p.m. Thursday.

The state and national Republican parties have signaled that they — like Oz — oppose counting the ballots in question.

In a statement, the Republican National Committee's chief counsel, Matt Raymer, said “election laws are meant to be followed, and changing the rules when ballots are already being counted harms the integrity of our elections.”

McCormick is doing better than Oz in mail-in ballots and has insisted that “every Republican vote should count.” McCormick's campaign chair, James Schultz, lashed out at the state party chairman, Lawrence Tabas, saying Tabas “cares so little” about Republicans who voted for McCormick.

Tabas is supposed to "grow GOP voters and bring the party together, not to cast them aside and drive wedges,” Schultz said.

Meanwhile, Tuesday, Gov. Tom Wolf’s administration issued guidance to counties saying that any ballots without dates must be counted, citing the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals' decision from Friday.

But it also said counties should keep those ballots separate — an acknowledgment that lawyers for defendants in the federal appeals court case said they will appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

McCormick’s lawsuit is the first — but likely not the last — court battle in the contest between Oz and McCormick.

Oz led McCormick by 987 votes, or 0.07 percentage points, out of 1,341,395 ballots reported by the state as of Tuesday afternoon.

The race is close enough to trigger Pennsylvania’s automatic recount law, with the separation between the candidates inside the law’s 0.5% margin. The Associated Press will not declare a winner in the race until the likely recount is complete. That could take until June 8.

Oz and McCormick are vying for the nomination to take on Democratic nominee John Fetterman in a presidential battleground contest that is expected to be among the nation's most competitive races this fall. The seat is open because two-term Republican Sen. Pat Toomey is retiring, creating the Democrats' best opportunity to pick up a seat in the closely divided Senate.

It’s not clear precisely how many mail-in ballots that lack a handwritten date have been received by counties.

Ruling in a separate case late Friday, the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said the state election law’s requirement of a date next to the voter’s signature on the outside of return envelopes was “immaterial.” The lawsuit emerged from a county judicial election last year, and the three-judge panel said it found no reason to refuse counting the ballots in that race.

The ruling went against the position that Republicans in Pennsylvania have taken in courts repeatedly in the past to try to disqualify legal ballots cast on time by eligible voters for technicalities, such as lacking a handwritten date.

The state law requires someone to write a date on the envelope in which they mail in their ballots. However, the envelope is postmarked by the post office and timestamped by counties when they receive it.

In the filing Tuesday urging the state Supreme Court to act, McCormick's lawyers wrote that county election boards “have not been forthcoming” about the actual number of ballots that lacked handwritten dates on envelopes. But that said they believe the number is likely in the thousands.

In previous court filings, they have said that the date the voter filled out the ballot envelope has nothing to do with whether they are qualified to vote or whether the ballot was cast on time.

The law does not even require the voter to write down the precise date they filled out the envelope or help prevent any hypothetical act of fraud, McCormick's lawyers wrote.

"In short, enforcing the dating requirement serves only one purpose—to gratuitously disenfranchise qualified Pennsylvania voters who have cast otherwise valid ballots on a timely basis," they wrote.


Follow Marc Levy on Twitter at


Follow AP for full coverage of the midterms at and on Twitter at

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Senate Election News, AP Entertainment, APOnline Celebrity News, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Financial Services
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Seoul: North Korea launches 2 ballistic missiles toward sea
South Korea says North Korea has fired two ballistic missiles toward the sea
6:03PM ( 57 seconds ago )
Georgia primary running smoothly despite new election law
Georgia’s high-stakes primary election appeared to be running smoothly with no reports of major problems
6:00PM ( 3 minutes ago )
New names for Fort Bragg, 8 other Army bases recommended
An independent commission is recommending new names for nine Army posts that now commemorate Confederate officers
6:00PM ( 4 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
After Cawthorn's loss, candidate challenge ruling reversed
Days after U.S. Rep. Madison Cawthorn lost his primary race, a federal appeals court has overturned a judge’s decision that blocked an elections board from examining whether he should be disqualified
4:44PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trial opens for Army reservist charged with storming Capitol
A trial has started for a U.S. Army reservist charged with storming the U.S. Capitol last year
4:43PM ( 1 hour ago )
US safety, savings rules set stage for baby formula shortage
A massive recall is getting most of the blame for the U.S. baby formula shortage, but experts say the products have long been vulnerable to this type of crisis
4:36PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Democrats: Google must protect privacy of abortion patients
More than 40 Democratic members of Congress are asking Google to stop what they see as the unnecessary collection and retention of peoples' location data
3:48PM ( 2 hours ago )
Trump’s bid to reshape GOP faces biggest hurdles in Georgia
Donald Trump hopes to avoid embarrassment in the Georgia governor’s race on Tuesday as Republican primary voters decide the fate of his hand-picked candidate to lead one of the nation’s chief political battlegrounds
3:37PM ( 2 hours ago )
Davos updates | Soros: New tech, AI help repressive regimes
Billionaire investor turned philanthropist George Soros has blamed new technology for helping repressive regimes like Russia and China exert greater control
3:02PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
GOP intervenes in Pa. Senate race vote-counting lawsuit
The national and state Republican parties are taking the side of celebrity heart surgeon Dr. Mehmet Oz in Pennsylvania’s neck-and-neck GOP primary contest for U.S. Senate and opposing a lawsuit by ex-hedge fund CEO David McCormick
10:04AM ( 7 hours ago )
Ex-White House press secretary Jen Psaki hired by MSNBC
Former White House press secretary Jen Psaki has officially landed at MSNBC, where she is expected to make appearances on the network’s cable and streaming programs as well as host a new original show
10:00AM ( 8 hours ago )
New Australian leader Albanese makes whirlwind world debut
New Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese walked into a global spotlight the day after his swearing-in
9:30AM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Elections
Pennsylvania's Fetterman released from hospital after stroke
Pennsylvania Lt. Gov. John Fetterman has been released from the hospital after a stay of more than a week following a stroke
4:59PM ( 2 days ago )
Pa. Senate GOP primary too close to call, recount likely
Pennsylvania’s Republican primary for an open U.S. Senate seat is too close to call and is likely headed for a statewide recount to decide the winner of the contest between heart surgeon-turned-TV celebrity Dr. Mehmet Oz and former hedge fund CEO David McCormick
8:55PM ( 3 days ago )
Oz, McCormick prepare for recount in Pa. GOP Senate race
Celebrity heart surgeon Dr. Mehmet Oz and former hedge fund CEO David McCormick have begun staffing up their campaigns with recount specialists as vote counting entered a fourth day in Pennsylvania’s Republican primary for an open U.S. Senate seat
4:32PM ( 4 days ago )
General Senate Election News
Cannes Film Festival, born out of war, grapples with Ukraine
The war in Ukraine took a starring role on the opening night of the 75th Cannes Film Festival and it has rarely been far out of frame since
4:26PM ( 1 hour ago )
Richard Gere helps Carnegie Hall raise money for Ukraine
Actor Richard Gere hosted a benefit concert for Ukraine at Carnegie Hall that raised $360,000 for Direct Relief, a humanitarian organization providing medical aid
2:33PM ( 3 hours ago )
Kremlin critic Browder urges squeeze on oligarchs' enablers
Kremlin critic Bill Browder wants governments to step up efforts to get to the riches squirreled away by Russian oligarchs by forcing accountants, lawyers and others who set up murky legal and financial structures to become whistleblowers
1:47PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Surgeon: Johnny Depp's severed finger story has flaws
A hand surgeon has testified that Johnny Depp could not have lost the tip of his middle finger the way he told jurors it happened in his civil lawsuit against ex-wife Amber Heard
5:56PM ( 1 day ago )
'Top Gun' and Tom Cruise return to the danger zone
After sitting on the shelf for two years due to the pandemic, “Top Gun: Maverick” is flying full throttle into theaters this week
10:56AM ( 1 day ago )
Blaney wins All-Star race, $1M 2 laps after thinking he won
Ryan Blaney had to go two extra laps after thinking he had already won NASCAR's All-Star race and $1 million
12:21AM ( 1 day ago )
APOnline Celebrity News
Police shootout at Rio de Janeiro favela kills more than 20
Police in Rio de Janeiro have raided the Vila Cruzeiro favela in an operation that set off a fierce firefight
5:49PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Slumping technology stocks pull Wall Street lower
A slump in several big companies weighed down the stock market Tuesday, leaving most major indexes lower
4:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
Ukraine: 200 bodies found in basement in Mariupol's ruins
Ukrainian authorities say workers digging through the rubble of an apartment building in Mariupol found 200 bodies in the basement
4:51PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
In Asia, Biden pushes values he struggles to sell at home
Joe Biden spent his first presidential trip to Asia strengthening economic and military commitments
2:54PM ( 3 hours ago )
Economy bigger priority than punishing Russia: AP-NORC poll
Americans are becoming less supportive of punishing Russia for launching its invasion of Ukraine if it comes at the expense of the U.S. economy, a sign of rising anxiety over inflation and other challenges
1:10PM ( 4 hours ago )
Davos updates | SKorea official: North mum on vaccine offer
A top adviser to new South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol says North Korea hasn’t responded to a proposal to send COVID-19 vaccines to the reclusive country
12:55PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Davos updates | Urgent need in Afghanistan is saving economy
Two high-level speakers at the World Economic Forum gathering say Afghanistan’s most urgent need is saving its economy from complete collapse
3:21PM ( 1 day ago )
European Central Bank chief signals possible July rate hike
The president of the European Central Bank has given the clearest sign yet that policymakers will aim to raise interest rates as soon as July to ease surging inflation
3:08PM ( 1 day ago )
Davos updates | Egypt promises to push pledges as COP27 host
The president of the next U.N. climate change conference in Egypt says the event will push countries to make good on their pledges to sharply reduce greenhouse gas emissions, facilitate talks on compensating developing countries for global warming effects and allow climate activists to protest
2:42PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Financial Services
Georgia primary running smoothly despite new election law
Georgia’s high-stakes primary election appeared to be running smoothly with no reports of major problems
6:00PM ( 3 minutes ago )
New names for Fort Bragg, 8 other Army bases recommended
An independent commission is recommending new names for nine Army posts that now commemorate Confederate officers
6:00PM ( 4 minutes ago )
UCLA to pay record of nearly $700M in doctor abuse lawsuits
The University of California system has agreed to pay $375 million to more than 300 women who said they were sexually abused by a longtime UCLA gynecologist
5:51PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Pandemic-weary Americans plan for summer despite COVID surge
Surges in COVID-19 cases are causing disruptions in many parts of the U.S., but as the school year wraps up and Americans prepare for their summer vacations, many people have returned to their pre-pandemic routines
5:51PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Texas governor: 15 killed in school shooting; gunman dead
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott says 15 people were killed in a shooting Tuesday at an elementary school
5:51PM ( 13 minutes ago )