rainn.png
Friday May 27th, 2022 1:29AM

Keeping schools out of NIL dealings opened door for boosters

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

By trying to limit how much schools can help college athletes cashing in on their fame, the NCAA seems to have inadvertently opened the door for boosters to get a foothold in a burgeoning market.

Now, as the NCAA and its highest-profile Division I member schools try to rein in booster-fueled organizations known as collectives, part of the solution could be taking down the firewalls between athletic departments and athletes when it comes to name, image and likeness compensation.

“The school is who helps the athlete when they have an injury″ said Jim Cavale, the CEO of INFLCR, a company that works with more than 200 Division I schools on NIL programming and compliance. ”The school is who helps the athlete when they struggle in school. The school is who helps the athlete with everything. And yet they’re not able to help here and it left a gap where the school can’t be involved and a booster and donor can."

Earlier this week, the NCAA handed down guidance that made clear collectives should be treated as boosters, which means they should not be contacting recruits — high school or transferring college athletes — and influencing where they go to school.

Boosters can, however, be involved in NIL deals with athletes after they have enrolled.

The latest guidance was developed by a group of college sports administrators that included Ohio State athletic director Gene Smith.

“The primary concern was exactly what has emerged. It is the recruiting space,” Smith said. “We've got to focus on the front door.”

Smith earlier helped craft a plan to regulate NIL compensation that was never implemented by the NCAA.

That 31-page report released in April 2020 was dominated by the idea that schools should not be involved in NIL transactions amid pay-for-play concerns and fears it would eventually lead to student-athletes looking more like employees. The report included this line: “Outside the context of providing financial aid up to cost of attendance as allowed by prevailing law, schools, conferences and the NCAA should play no role in arranging NIL activities or payments for student-athletes.”

That hands-off tone was reflected in many of the more than two dozen state NIL laws, including the one in Florida where schools are barred from any involvement in outside compensation for athletes.

"It’s ironic that the NCAA drafting rules but not setting them actually indirectly created a rule that opened the door for collectives to walk in and be a solution where the school could not," Cavale said.

What has emerged is collectives filling the role of deal maker and boosters operating with little or no accountability and oversight beyond the honor system.

“Any kind of outsourcing of benefits to athletes is not ideal. It's sub-optimal,” Florida athletic director Scott Stricklin said.

Stricklin said he and his staff communicate with the collectives working on behalf of Florida and are confident they are working within the rules. However, highlighting the line between what is and is not allowed with boosters and NIL is far easier than policing it.

“I don’t know what legal guardrails could be put in place where you could prevent donors being involved, boosters being involved on some level (with recruiting), even though none of us want that,” Stricklin said.

Louisiana and Missouri are currently trying to rework their state NIL laws to allow schools, and even coaches, to be more involved in how athletes are compensated.

If that happens, they will be talking with collectives that do not all operate the same way. Some are being set up to engage a university's supporters and alumni more broadly, but others are funded and operated by smaller groups of wealthy boosters.

“So the majority of collectives currently existing are being run by alumni ... boosters, people that were previous donors to the university," said attorney Jason Belzer, whose company, Student-Athlete NIL, is managing collectives at Penn State and Rutgers. "And I think the best way to describe it is like a money laundering machine: ‘How do we get as much dollars into the pockets of student-athletes as we can without actually having them deliver any real value in return?’”

Belzer said he and his clients are not concerned about the NCAA's warning "because we were never engaging in that type of conduct (in recruiting) anyway.” Garnet Trust, a collective that supports Florida State athletics, also released a statement saying it was already operating in compliance with the new guidance.

Smith, the Ohio State athletic director, said more involvement by athletic departments with NIL would help. Schools would be better off playing the role of matchmaker between athletes and brands while still staying out of the negotiation of any deals.

"To me," Smith said, “that's the line in the sand.”

___

Follow Ralph D. Russo at https://twitter.com/ralphDrussoAP and listen at http://www.appodcasts.com

___

More AP college football: https://apnews.com/hub/college-football and https://twitter.com/AP_Top25

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, College Sports, AP Sports - College Football
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Live updates | US: Russia used UN council for disinformation
The United States is again accusing Russia of using the U.N. Security Council to spout disinformation about biological weapons in Ukraine to distract from its war against its smaller neighbor
1:49PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Hugo Chavez's ex-nurse-turned treasurer extradited to US
A Venezuelan woman who was the late President Hugo Chávez’s nurse and later the nation’s treasurer has been extradited from Spain to the U.S. to face money-laundering charges
1:46PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Keeping schools out of NIL dealings opened door for boosters
The NCAA seems to have inadvertently opened the door for boosters when it comes to college athletes cashing in on their fame
1:46PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Penguins' Sidney Crosby ruled out of Game 6 against Rangers
Pittsburgh Penguins captain Sidney Crosby will not play in Game 6 against the New York Rangers
12:38PM ( 1 hour ago )
Detention of WNBA's Griner in Moscow extended by 1 month
The lawyer for WNBA star Brittney Griner says her pre-trial detention in Russia has been extended by one month
12:01PM ( 2 hours ago )
PGA back at Southern Hills as Mickelson debates a return
Another major championship, another dose of anticipation
11:27AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Sports
Rams to host Bills to open NFL season; Broncos at Seattle
To the Super Bowl winner goes the spoils of opening the entire schedule at home
8:21PM ( 17 hours ago )
Top pick Travon Walker signs $37.4M rookie deal with Jaguars
No. 1 overall draft pick Travon Walker signed a four-year, $37.4 million rookie contract with the Jacksonville Jaguars that includes a $24.4 million signing bonus
8:00PM ( 18 hours ago )
Top pick Travon Walker signing $37.4M contract with Jaguars
No. 1 overall draft pick Travon Walker and the Jacksonville Jaguars agreed to terms Thursday on a four-year, $37.4 million contract that includes a $24.4 million signing bonus
3:48PM ( 22 hours ago )
AP Online Football
NIL expert predicts $50,000 minimum pay for Power 5 players
College football and men’s basketball players on scholarship in one of the major conferences can expect to soon earn a minimum of $50,000 each year he plays because of the influx of cash from booster collectives brokering name, image and likeness deals
3:04PM ( 2 days ago )
NCAA clarifies compensation rules but is crackdown likely?
College sports leaders are trying to send a warning to schools and boosters when it comes to paying athletes for endorsement and sponsorship deals: There are still rules and they will be enforced
6:16PM ( 3 days ago )
In wild west of NIL, will NCAA crack down on collectives?
College sports leaders are trying to send a warning to schools and boosters it believes have crossed a line when it comes to paying athletes for endorsement and sponsorship deals: There are still rules and they will be enforced
4:01PM ( 3 days ago )
College Sports
Candidates test skipping debates without upsetting voters
Former football great Herschel Walker has gone to great lengths to dodge tough questions during his run for the U.S. Senate in Georgia
5:47AM ( 1 week ago )
Cincinnati's Ridder is Falcons' pick as possible future QB
The Atlanta Falcons picked Cincinnati’s Desmond Ridder in the third round of the NFL draft, giving the team its possible future starting quarterback
12:03AM ( 1 week ago )
Seemed forever for QBs to go in 1st 2 rounds of NFL draft
It took 42 selections Friday before a second quarterback was taken in the NFL draft
11:58PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Sports - College Football
Live updates | US: Russia used UN council for disinformation
The United States is again accusing Russia of using the U.N. Security Council to spout disinformation about biological weapons in Ukraine to distract from its war against its smaller neighbor
1:49PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Hugo Chavez's ex-nurse-turned treasurer extradited to US
A Venezuelan woman who was the late President Hugo Chávez’s nurse and later the nation’s treasurer has been extradited from Spain to the U.S. to face money-laundering charges
1:46PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Passengers on German train overpower knife attacker
German authorities say three passengers on a regional train have overpowered an Iraq-born man who wounded five people with a knife
1:46PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Biden raised $7.8M since March ahead of bigger money push
The Democratic National Committee says President Joe Biden raised $7.8 million during a string of recent fundraisers held in and around Washington, Chicago and the West Coast
1:41PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Dodgers put Clayton Kershaw on IL with inflammation
The Los Angeles Dodgers have placed Clayton Kershaw on the injured list with inflammation in a pelvic joint
1:40PM ( 29 minutes ago )