Friday May 27th, 2022 3:25AM

In wild west of NIL, will NCAA crack down on collectives?

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Eleven months after the NCAA lifted most of its restrictions against athletes cashing in on their fame, college sports leaders are trying to send a warning to schools and boosters it believes have crossed a line: There are still rules here and they will be enforced.

But following last year's Supreme Court ruling against the NCAA in an antitrust case, is a crackdown on so-called collectives brokering name, image and likeness deals still possible?

“I didn't think (the NCAA) would not try at some point,” said Maddie Salamone, a sports attorney and former Duke lacrosse player. “That's why many attorneys have been kind of giving cautious advice in terms of what is and is not allowed. Especially when it comes to collectives and different NIL deals.”

The NCAA's Division I Board of Directors was expected as soon as Monday to hand down guidance to its member schools clarifying the types of NIL payments to athletes that could be considered recruiting violations.

The NCAA is neither changing its rules nor creating new ones.

“I don’t think they’re even necessarily clarifying the rules,” said attorney Darren Heitner, who helped craft Florida's NIL law. “My understanding is this is just certain individuals who have made up a working committee deciding that after almost 11 months we want to enforce our rules.”

The rise of booster-funded organizations known as collectives prompted the board in February to ask the DI Council to review the NCAA's interim NIL policy. The concern among many in college sports has been that payments from collectives are being made to high school recruits and to college athletes in hopes of getting them to transfer to a particular school.

“Some things look very much like pay-for-play,” Salamone said. “There are rules on the books within the NCAA around boosters. The fact that the NCAA has been hesitant to enforce anything I think has emboldened a lot of people around this issue to be a little bit more obvious.”

Last year, the NCAA removed its longstanding ban against athletes earning money from sponsorship and endorsements deals. What remained in place, however, were three pillars of the NCAA's amateur athlete model:

— Athletes could not be paid solely for playing their sport;

— Compensation could not be used to lure an athlete to a particular school;

— Financial arrangements must have some type quid pro quo agreement in which the athlete was being paid for services provided, like a social media post or appearance.

The NCAA did not ban boosters from being involved in NIL activity. However, without detailed NCAA rules and with state-level NIL laws differing across the country, it left both schools and the association struggling to determine what activities were impermissible.

Some state laws also prohibit boosters from engaging with recruits, but there has been little appetite for enforcement of those laws.

The latest guidance from the NCAA is intended to leave no doubt collectives should be treated as boosters. Whether that leads to lawsuits is among the questions should the NCAA start targeting collectives.

Mat Winter, a sports attorney in Kansas City, Missouri, said NCAA enforcement of these rules is not a clear-cut antitrust violation.

"So the question is, under antitrust law, is the rule that’s being enforced reasonable?" Winter said. “And from my reading of everything, the rule that they’re going to be enforcing is the rule that says boosters and other third parties like collectives cannot pay athletes in return for a commitment to a school.”

Heitner advises several collectives and businesses that have made NIL deals with college athletes. He said he has stressed to clients from the start to wait until athletes are at the school of their choice before getting involved.

“I don’t think it’s a collective issue,” he added. “I think it’s just a matter of the NCAA saying, ‘Hey, we’ve always been of the position that boosters cannot influence decision making of athletes, particularly high school athletes who have not yet enrolled at universities.’”

It is unclear whether the NCAA will now start investigating schools for possible violations committed over the last year as the NIL market was taking shape.

Gabe Feldman, the director of sports law at Tulane, said the NCAA should be forward-looking.

“I think that probably is a safer and probably more fair approach,” Feldman said. “Hindsight is 2020, but what might have been an even better approach is to have come up with clear rules earlier and started enforcing those so we didn’t get to a situation where it might be unfair to start enforcing the rules.”

College sports conferences and the NCAA have been frequent targets for lawsuits, and last June's Supreme Court ruling left the door open for even more.

Feldman said the NCAA could be opening itself up to more antitrust exposure by failing to enforce its existing rules. But both antitrust lawsuits and NCAA enforcement are notoriously slow moving.

“This would be able like the tortoise and the tortoise,” Feldman said. “Neither would get done quickly, but there’s a lot of risk in the interim.”


Follow Ralph D. Russo at and listen at


More AP college football: and

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, College Sports, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Man committed after slayings shows up free in small SC town
The family of two sisters killed in their tiny South Carolina town in 2010 wants to know why the man who confessed to their slayings has suddenly shown back up in the community
4:18PM ( 10 minutes ago )
As Putin marks Victory Day, his troops make little war gains
Russian President Vladimir Putin marked his country’s biggest patriotic holiday without a major new battlefield success in Ukraine, and the Kremlin made little to no progress as the war ground through its 11th week on multiple fronts
4:11PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Wall Street's losses worsen as markets tumble worldwide
Stocks deepened their losses on Wall Street Monday, sending the S&P 500 to its lowest close in more than a year
4:08PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
New Era Cap CEO charged after parking lot altercation
New Era Cap Company's CEO faces a felony charge after allegedly driving his vehicle toward a man during an argument and hitting his car
1:46PM ( 2 hours ago )
Woodward regrets saying Yankees have 'Little League' park
A day after calling Yankee Stadium a “Little League ballpark” following Gleyber Torres’ game-winning home run over the right field short porch, Texas Rangers manager Chris Woodward said he regretted his postgame remarks
12:14PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP source: Jokic captures 2nd straight NBA MVP award
A person familiar with the decision says Denver’s Nikola Jokic has won his second consecutive Most Valuable Player award after a season in which he finished with numbers never before seen in NBA history
11:20AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Sports
As leaders lobby, NCAA searches for ways to rein in boosters
College sports leaders visited Capitol Hill, asking lawmakers to consider rules to govern name, image and likeness money for college athletes
7:56PM ( 3 days ago )
AP source: SEC, Pac-12 leaders to push for NIL law in DC
The commissioners of the Southeastern Conference and the Pac-12 are scheduled to meet with lawmakers in Washington They will lobby for federal legislation to regulate name, image and likeness compensation to athletes
12:25AM ( 4 days ago )
'Momentum' for dumping yearly scholarship limits in football
College football coaches are pushing for changes to NCAA rules to help stabilize rosters depleted by transfers
9:43PM ( 5 days ago )
College Sports
Russian envoy to Poland hit with red paint at war cemetery
Protesters have thrown red paint on the Russian ambassador to Poland as he arrived at a cemetery in Warsaw to pay respects to Red Army soldiers who died during World War II
3:33PM ( 55 minutes ago )
Live updates | Russia-Ukraine War
The leaders of Germany and France welcomed the fact that Russian President Vladimir Putin didn’t announce any steps to expand the war in Ukraine, including to other countries, in his speech marking the end of World War II
3:18PM ( 1 hour ago )
Sri Lankan prime minister resigns after weeks of protests
Sri Lankan Prime Minister Mahinda Rajapaksa has resigned following weeks of protests demanding that he and his brother, the president, step down over the country’s worst economic crisis in decades
3:13PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Face-scanner Clearview agrees to limits in court settlement
Facial recognition startup Clearview AI has agreed to restrict the use of its massive collection of face images to settle allegations that it collected people’s photos without their consent
1:56PM ( 2 hours ago )
Wall Street joins worldwide swoon on rate, China worries
Wall Street is tumbling toward its lowest point in more than a year on Monday
10:36AM ( 5 hours ago )
Global shares mostly fall as rate hikes, China slowdown loom
Global shares have fallen as interest rate hikes and a slowing Chinese economy weighed on investor sentiment
5:14AM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Man committed after slayings shows up free in small SC town
The family of two sisters killed in their tiny South Carolina town in 2010 wants to know why the man who confessed to their slayings has suddenly shown back up in the community
4:18PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Cortes takes no-hit bid into 8th, Yanks beat Rangers 1-0
Nestor Cortes took a no-hit bid into the eighth inning before Eli White singled, and Anthony Rizzo doubled in a run in the bottom half to lift the New York Yankees over the Texas Rangers 1-0 for their sixth straight series win
4:01PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Wisconsin anti-abortion office fire investigation ongoing
Police are asking for the public’s help in tracking down those who vandalized and threw two Molotov cocktails into the office of a prominent Wisconsin anti-abortion lobbying group’s office
4:00PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Putin's Victory Day speech passionate but empty
Vladimir Putin had no victories in Ukraine to proclaim on Victory Day
3:55PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Democrats want to boost Biden Ukraine aid plan to near $40B
Congressional Democrats are preparing a plan that would boost President Joe Biden’s requested $33 billion Ukraine aid package to nearly $40 billion
3:37PM ( 51 minutes ago )