clearn.png
Monday July 4th, 2022 1:32AM

It’s Chief Justice Roberts' Court, but does he still lead?

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — John Roberts is heading a Supreme Court in crisis.

The chief justice has already ordered an investigation of the leak this week of a draft opinion suggesting the court could be poised to overturn Roe v. Wade, the 1973 case legalizing abortion nationwide. What comes next could further test Roberts' leadership of a court where his vote already appears less crucial in determining the outcome in contentious cases.

“This is a time when the court is under siege, both externally and internally now,” said Roanoke College professor Todd Peppers, who writes about the court. "I just don't think the spotlight has ever been brighter on the court in recent history.”

Speaking Thursday at a judicial conference in Atlanta, Roberts called the leak “appalling,” according to CNN.

Roberts' court was facing challenges even before the leak, which the chief called a “betrayal of the confidences of the Court.”Polling has shown a notable decline in the public's approval of the court. And there have been recent calls for term limits for the justices and for increasing the number of justices as well as for a code of ethics, particularly following reports that Justice Clarence Thomas' wife, Virginia, implored Donald Trump’s White House chief of staff to act to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election. Confirmation hearings for the court's newest justices have been contentious.

The addition of three conservative justices during Trump's presidency also means there are now five conservative justices to Roberts' right who no longer need his vote, and perhaps his moderating influence, to prevail in a case. The abortion decision could be another example of that, with the court's other conservatives prepared to go further than Roberts.

Roberts, 67, has noted the limits of his position in the past. Asked during a 2018 appearance how it’s different to be chief, Roberts responded: “In many ways it’s different. In the most important it’s not. I have one vote. I participate in the decision-making of the court like any of the associate justices.”

Still, there's a reason that the chief is called the “first among equals” and that historians refer to time periods at the court using the chief justice's name: the Marshall Court, the Rehnquist Court, the Roberts Court. The chief is the first to speak when the justices discuss cases at their private conference and guides that discussion. The chief decides who writes the opinion of the court when the chief is in the majority.

Roberts, an appointee of President George W. Bush, has faced other challenging times in his 16 years as chief. He's led the court through contentious cases on gay marriage, on President Barack Obama's health law and on Trump-era policies including building a U.S.-Mexico border wall and the travel ban.

In 2020, Roberts was in the spotlight presiding over Trump's first impeachment trial, though his role was modest. At the beginning of the coronavirus pandemic, he led the court through a period where it decided to postpone arguments for the first time in more than 100 years and then to conduct them by telephone for more than a year and a half.

Early in his tenure, in a speech at Georgetown's law school graduation and elsewhere, Roberts explained his philosophy in guiding the court and his preference for decisions where there could be broad agreement on narrow grounds.

“There are clear benefits to a greater degree of consensus on the court. Unanimity or near unanimity promote clarity and guidance for the lawyers and for the lower courts trying to figure out what the Supreme Court meant," he said in 2006. He added: “The rule of law is strengthened when there's greater coherence and agreement about what the law is."

Artemus Ward, a professor at Northern Illinois University who is one of the editors of a book of scholarly research on chief justices, said Roberts has been “trying to achieve consensus, trying to rule narrowly.” But following the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, a liberal, and her replacement by conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett, “Roberts' vote is less powerful” because there are five conservative votes even without him, Ward said.

There's been some evidence of the impact of that already.

Before Ginsburg's death, Roberts joined with the court's four liberals to reject a challenge to attendance limits California imposed on religious services because of the coronavirus pandemic. But about a month after Barrett joined the court, the justices ruled 5-4 the other way in a case about similar limits in New York, with Roberts and the liberals in dissent.

In September of last year, the court decided 5-4 not to block a new Texas law banning most abortions in the state. The dissenters were once again Roberts and the three liberal justices.

It was the same lineup in February when the Supreme Court put on hold a lower court ruling that Alabama must draw new congressional districts before the 2022 elections to increase Black voting power. And in April when the court reinstated a Trump-era water rule.

"Roberts Has Lost Control of the Supreme Court," was the title of an article written that month by professor Stephen I. Vladeck of the University of Texas School of Law.

It remains to be seen how divided and how sweeping the court will be in other decisions, including a major gun ruling, that are still to be released before the court breaks for summer.

Unknown too is how closely the final opinion in the abortion case will mirror the leaked draft, which was written by Justice Samuel Alito and distributed to other members of the court in February. Politico reported that Alito had the votes of four other conservatives to overturn Roe v. Wade and a later decision that reaffirmed a constitutional right to abortion services, Planned Parenthood v. Casey. The three liberals planned to dissent, Politico said, while Roberts' ultimate vote was unclear.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
US Cyber Command team helps Lithuania protect its networks
The Pentagon’s cyber arm says a team spent months working with officials in Lithuania to help protect government networks there from cyberattacks
12:04PM ( 10 minutes ago )
NASA climate research scientist wins World Food Prize
A NASA climate research scientist who has spent much of her career explaining how global food production systems must adapt to a changing climate was awarded the World Food Prize at a ceremony at the U.S. Department of State in Washington
12:00PM ( 13 minutes ago )
It’s Chief Justice Roberts' Court, but does he still lead?
John Roberts is heading a Supreme Court in crisis
11:55AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Once conflicted, Biden embraces role as abortion defender
President Joe Biden once said Roe v
11:20AM ( 53 minutes ago )
Next battle over access to abortion will focus on pills
More than half of abortions in America are now done with pills, rather than surgery
10:28AM ( 1 hour ago )
Fox chews through fence, kills 25 flamingos at National Zoo
Foxes are known to raid henhouses
9:55AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Attacks dominate Pennsylvania's Senate GOP primary debate
What could be the final primary debate between Republicans running for Pennsylvania’s open U.S. Senate seat devolved into a string of attacks
11:08PM ( 13 hours ago )
Attacks dominate Senate GOP debate in primary’s last stretch
What could be the final primary debate between Republicans running for Pennsylvania’s open U.S. Senate seat devolved into a string of attacks
10:20PM ( 13 hours ago )
Stacy Abrams raises $11.7 million in Georgia governor's race
Georgia Democrat Stacey Abrams says donors gave  $11.7 million to her campaign for governor in the three months ended April 30
9:35PM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Elections
Live updates l Midterm results show strong Trump influence
The midterm election season began in earnest Tuesday with primaries in Indiana and Ohio
11:27PM ( 1 day ago )
Live updates l Trump buoys Gilbert to Ohio GOP House win
Donald Trump-endorsed Republican Madison Gesiotto Gilbert has won a crowded primary for an open U.S. House seat in northeast Ohio
10:57PM ( 1 day ago )
Live updates l Green wins GOP bid for Indiana US House seat
Jennifer-Ruth Green has won the Republican nomination in a northwestern Indiana congressional district that the GOP is looking to capture after several decades as a Democratic stronghold
10:46PM ( 1 day ago )
General Election News
Election 2022: Ryan wins Ohio Democratic Senate race
Ohio Democrat Tim Ryan has cruised his way to his party’s nomination for an open Senate seat and will now take on the winner of one of the most contentious and closely watched Republican primaries in the nation
8:08PM ( 1 day ago )
FACT FOCUS: Gaping holes in the claim of 2K ballot ‘mules’
A film debuting in over 270 theaters across the United States this week uses a flawed analysis of cellphone location data and ballot drop box surveillance footage to cast doubt on the results of the 2020 presidential election nearly 18 months after it ended
7:47PM ( 1 day ago )
Election 2022: Voters to decide Ohio's heated Senate primary
Ohio Republicans are voting in one of the most contentious and closely watched Senate primaries in the nation
6:03PM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
US Cyber Command team helps Lithuania protect its networks
The Pentagon’s cyber arm says a team spent months working with officials in Lithuania to help protect government networks there from cyberattacks
12:04PM ( 10 minutes ago )
NASA climate research scientist wins World Food Prize
A NASA climate research scientist who has spent much of her career explaining how global food production systems must adapt to a changing climate was awarded the World Food Prize at a ceremony at the U.S. Department of State in Washington
12:00PM ( 13 minutes ago )
The AP Interview: Belarus admits Russia's war 'drags on'
Belarus’ authoritarian President Alexander Lukashenko is defending Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in an interview with The Associated Press, but he said he didn’t expect the 10-week-old conflict to “drag on this way.”
11:50AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Alabama's new transgender care felony faces federal test
Alabama’s law criminalizing the use of gender-affirming medications to treat transgender youth now faces a federal test
11:41AM ( 32 minutes ago )
Emma Stone finds relief in grim Greek silent movie
U.S. actress Emma Stone says she found starring in a new Greek silent movie to be a welcome professional challenge and a relief from the normal demands of her job
11:33AM ( 40 minutes ago )