Wednesday October 5th, 2022 11:54PM

COVID shots still work but researchers hunt new improvements

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

COVID-19 vaccinations are at a critical juncture as companies test whether new approaches like combination shots or nasal drops can keep up with a mutating coronavirus — even though it’s not clear if changes are needed.

Already there’s public confusion about who should get a second booster now and who can wait. There's also debate about whether pretty much everyone might need an extra dose in the fall.

“I’m very concerned about booster fatigue” causing a loss of confidence in vaccines that still offer very strong protection against COVID-19’s worst outcomes, said Dr. Beth Bell of the University of Washington, an adviser to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Despite success in preventing serious illness and death, there's growing pressure to develop vaccines better at fending off milder infections, too — as well as options to counter scary variants.

“We go through a fire drill it seems like every quarter, every three months or so” when another mutant causes frantic tests to determine if the shots are holding, Pfizer vaccine chief Kathrin Jansen told a recent meeting of the New York Academy of Sciences.

Yet seeking improvements for the next round of vaccinations may seem like a luxury for U.S. families anxious to protect their littlest children — kids under 5 who are not yet eligible for a shot. Moderna's Dr. Jacqueline Miller told The Associated Press that its application to give two low-dose shots to the youngest children would be submitted to the Food and Drug Administration “fairly soon.” Pfizer hasn't yet reported data on a third dose of its extra-small shot for tots, after two didn't prove strong enough.


The original COVID-19 vaccines remain strongly protective against serious illness, hospitalization and death, especially after a booster dose, even against the most contagious variants.

Updating the vaccine recipe to match the latest variants is risky, because the next mutant could be completely unrelated. So companies are taking a cue from the flu vaccine, which offers protection against three or four different strains in one shot every year.

Moderna and Pfizer are testing 2-in-1 COVID-19 protection that they hope to offer this fall. Each “bivalent” shot would mix the original, proven vaccine with an omicron-targeted version.

Moderna has a hint the approach could work. It tested a combo shot that targeted the original version of the virus and an earlier variant named beta — and found vaccine recipients developed modest levels of antibodies capable of fighting not just beta but also newer mutants like omicron. Moderna now is testing its omicron-targeted bivalent candidate.

But there's a looming deadline. FDA's Dr. Doran Fink said if any updated shots are to be given in the fall, the agency would have to decide on a recipe change by early summer.


For the average person, two doses of the Pfizer or Moderna vaccine plus one booster — a total of three shots — “gets you set up” and ready for what may become an annual booster, said Dr. David Kimberlin, a CDC adviser from the University of Alabama at Birmingham.

After that first booster, CDC data suggests an additional dose offers most people an incremental, temporary benefit.

Why the emphasis on three shots? Vaccination triggers development of antibodies that can fend off coronavirus infection but naturally wane over time. The next line of defense: Memory cells that jump into action to make new virus-fighters if an infection sneaks in. Rockefeller University researchers found those memory cells become more potent and able to target more diverse versions of the virus after the third shot.

Even if someone who's vaccinated gets a mild infection, thanks to those memory cells “there's still plenty of time to protect you against severe illness,” said Dr. Paul Offit of the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia.

But some people — those with severely weakened immune systems — need more doses up-front for a better chance at protection.

And Americans 50 and older are being offered a second booster, following similar decisions by Israel and other countries that offer the extra shot to give older people a little more protection.

The CDC is developing advice to help those eligible decide whether to get an extra shot now or wait. Among those who might want a second booster sooner are the elderly, people with health problems that make them particularly vulnerable, or who are at high risk of exposure from work or travel.


It’s hard for a shot in the arm to form lots of virus-fighting antibodies inside the nose where the coronavirus latches on. But a nasal vaccine might offer a new strategy to prevent infections that disrupt people’s everyday lives even if they’re mild.

“When I think about what would make me get a second booster, I actually would want to prevent infection,” said Dr. Grace Lee of Stanford University, who chairs CDC’s immunization advisory committee. “I think we need to do better.”

Nasal vaccines are tricky to develop and it's not clear how quickly any could become available. But several are in clinical trials globally. One in late-stage testing, manufactured by India’s Bharat Biotech, uses a chimpanzee cold virus to deliver a harmless copy of the coronavirus spike protein to the lining of the nose.

“I certainly do not want to abandon the success we have had” with COVID-19 shots, said Dr. Michael Diamond of Washington University in St. Louis, who helped create the candidate that’s now licensed to Bharat.

But “we’re going to have a difficult time stopping transmission with the current systemic vaccines," Diamond added. “We have all learned that.”


The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute’s Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Health, AP Health - Children's Health, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
COVID shots still work but researchers hunt new improvements
COVID-19 vaccines still offer strong protection against severe illness and death, but Moderna and Pfizer are testing combination shots as a possible new kind of booster
8:55AM ( 2 minutes ago )
Remains of 17 French WWI soldiers buried at Gallipoli
The remains of 17 missing French soldiers who fought in the World War I Battle of Gallipoli have been handed over to French military officials and put to rest alongside other fallen comrades more than a century after their deaths
8:38AM ( 20 minutes ago )
Ukraine marks Orthodox Easter with prayers for those trapped
The sun came out as Ukrainians marked Orthodox Easter in Kyiv with prayers for those fighting on the front lines and others trapped beyond them
8:27AM ( 30 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Ukrainian steel plant bombed; Zelenskyy to meet US officials
Russian forces have called in airstrikes on a besieged steel factory in the southern city of Mariupol to try to dislodge the last Ukrainian troops holding out in the strategic port
5:45AM ( 3 hours ago )
Slovenians vote in tight race between populists, liberals
Slovenians are casting ballots in a parliamentary election that is expected to be a tight race between Prime Minister Janez Jansa’s ruling right-wing populists and liberals in the politically divided European Union nation
4:28AM ( 4 hours ago )
EXPLAINER: How France's old-school voting system works
French voters in the presidential election are using an old-school voting system that has defied calls for more flexibility or modernization
3:43AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP National News
Fires hit Southwest, New Mexico's season 'dangerously early'
New Mexico's governor says the state faces a long and potentially devastating wildfire season as Southwestern wildfires cause destruction and force people from their homes
7:55PM ( 13 hours ago )
Wildfires merge in New Mexico, threatening rural villages
Flames from wind-driven wildfires on Saturday were burning tinder-dry forest and grassland and putting numerous small villages in New Mexico in the path of danger
4:17PM ( 16 hours ago )
For Ukrainian Orthodox in US, war news casts pall on Easter
Many Ukrainian Americans are observing Orthodox Easter this Sunday, but they’re finding it difficult to be joyful when their ancestral homeland has been torn by the Russian invasion
3:11PM ( 17 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Biden admin to promote availability of COVID antiviral pill
President Joe Biden and his administration want Americans and their doctors to know that the country has an ample supply of the life-saving COVID-19 antiviral treatment Paxlovid and that it no longer needs to be rationed
7:06PM ( 1 day ago )
Plan to ban menthol cigarettes prompts late lobbying blitz
Dozens of interest groups have met with White House staffers to try to influence a long-awaited plan to ban menthol cigarettes
12:37PM ( 1 day ago )
Plan to ban menthol cigs prompts last-minute lobbying blitz
Dozens of interest groups have met with White House staffers to try to influence a long-awaited plan to ban menthol cigarettes
12:07PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Health
Rates for measles, other vaccinations dip for kindergartners
The portion of U.S. children getting routine vaccinations required for kindergarten dipped slightly during the pandemic
1:11PM ( 2 days ago )
EXPLAINER: What medical treatments do transgender youth get?
Transgender medical treatment for children and teens is under attack in many states, but it has been available for more than a decade and is endorsed by major medical associations
10:00AM ( 2 days ago )
Report: Hunger kills hundreds of kids in Ethiopia's Tigray
At least 1,900 children under 5 have died from malnutrition in Ethiopia’s embattled Tigray region in the past year, according to a study conducted by regional health officials and seen by the Associated Press
12:52PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Health - Children's Health
France's presidential rivals: Key moments, private lives
Voters are choosing between two visions of France and two very different people in Sunday's presidential runoff
6:26AM ( 2 hours ago )
Live updates | OSCE concerned about detained members
The Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe says it is extremely concerned about the detention of several Ukrainian members of its monitoring mission in the east of the country
6:12AM ( 2 hours ago )
2 more Polish coal miners dead; search continues for missing
Polish authorities say the death toll from accidents in recent days at two coal mines in southern Poland has increased to seven after two miners were brought to the surface and pronounced dead
5:42AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
Rescuers reach 4 of 10 miners missing at coal mine in Poland
Coal mining authorities in Poland say rescue workers have reached four of the 10 miners who went missing following an underground tremor and methane gas discharge Saturday at a mine in southern Poland
3:58PM ( 17 hours ago )
Sanctions hit Russian economy, although Putin says otherwise
Nearly two months into the Russian-Ukraine war, the Kremlin has taken extraordinary steps to blunt an economic counteroffensive from the West
12:05PM ( 20 hours ago )
Thousands protest plan to raze German village for coal mine
Thousands of people are protesting against plans to bulldoze a village in western Germany for a coal mine that environmental activists say should be shut down, not expanded
11:48AM ( 21 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Japan approves Novavax as 4th COVID vaccine amid new surge
Japan’s health ministry has approved Novavax’s COVID-19 vaccine, and people could start getting the shots by late May
9:12PM ( 4 days ago )
J&J suspends COVID-19 vaccine sales forecast
Johnson & Johnson is suspending sales forecasts for its COVID-19 vaccine only a few months after saying the shot could bring in as much as $3.5 billion this year
10:41AM ( 4 days ago )
Japan approves Novavax COVID-19 vaccine
Japan’s health ministry formally approved Novavax’s COVID-19 vaccine, a fourth foreign-developed tool to combat the infections
1:02AM ( 5 days ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Remains of 17 French WWI soldiers buried at Gallipoli
The remains of 17 missing French soldiers who fought in the World War I Battle of Gallipoli have been handed over to French military officials and put to rest alongside other fallen comrades more than a century after their deaths
8:38AM ( 20 minutes ago )
Ukraine marks Orthodox Easter with prayers for those trapped
The sun came out as Ukrainians marked Orthodox Easter in Kyiv with prayers for those fighting on the front lines and others trapped beyond them
8:27AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Lebanese military finds 5 bodies from sunk migrant boat
State media is reporting that the Lebanese military has recovered the bodies of five migrants whose boat carrying nearly 60 people sank the night before, raising the death toll to six
8:20AM ( 38 minutes ago )
Ads from soft-spoken Arkansas Sen. Boozman reflect GOP fury
Two-term Republican Sen. John Boozman is known in Arkansas as a soft-spoken figure, but his reelection message seems to be taking a combative tone
8:02AM ( 55 minutes ago )
Ukraine leader pushes for more arms; US officials to visit
Ukraine’s leader is petitioning for more powerful Western weapons as he prepares to meet with top U.S. officials in the war-torn country’s capital
7:56AM ( 1 hour ago )