clearn.png
Tuesday August 16th, 2022 6:48AM

Supreme Court reinstates Trump-era water rule for now

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Wednesday reinstated for now a Trump-era rule that curtails the power of states and Native American tribes to block pipelines and other energy projects that can pollute rivers, streams and other waterways.

In a decision that split the court 5-4, the justices agreed to halt a lower court judge’s order throwing out the rule. The high court’s action does not interfere with the Biden administration’s plan to rewrite the rule. Work on a revision has begun, but the administration has said a final rule is not expected until the spring of 2023. The Trump-era rule will remain in effect in the meantime.

The court’s three liberal justices and Chief Justice John Roberts dissented. The court’s other conservative justices, including three nominated by President Donald Trump, voted to reinstate the rule.

Writing for the dissenters, Justice Elena Kagan said the group of states and industry associations that had asked for the lower court’s ruling to be put on hold had not shown the extraordinary circumstances necessary to grant that request.

Kagan said the group had failed to demonstrate their harm if the judge’s decision were left in place. She said the group had not identified a “single project that a State has obstructed” in the months since the judge’s decision and had twice delayed making a request, indicating it was not urgent.

Kagan said the court’s majority had gone “astray” in granting the emergency petition and was misusing the process for dealing with such requests. That process is sometimes called the court’s “shadow docket” because the court provides a decision quickly without the full briefing and argument. The liberal justices have recently been critical of its use.

As is typical, the justices in the majority did not explain their reasoning.

Kagan wrote that her colleagues’ decision “renders the Court’s emergency docket not for emergencies at all.”

The Biden administration had told the justices in a court filing that it agreed that the U.S. District Court Judge William Alsup lacked the authority to throw out the rule without first determining that it was invalid. But the administration had urged the court not to reinstate the rule, saying that in the months since the Alsup’s ruling, officials have adapted to the change, reverting to regulations in place for decades. Another change would “cause substantial disruption and disserve the public interest,” the administration said.

Alsup was nominated to the bench by President Bill Clinton.

EPA spokesman Tim Carroll said in an email that the agency is reviewing the Supreme Court’s order as well as “moving forward with rulemaking to restore state and Tribal authority to protect water resources that are essential to public health, ecosystems, and economic opportunity.”

LeRoy Coleman, a spokesman for the National Hydropower Association, one of the groups that had sought to halt the lower court judge's order, said in a statement that the court's decision will “ensure that the Biden administration properly considers this important rule as it considers changes promulgated by the Environmental Protection Agency less than two years ago.”

The section of federal law at issue in the case is Section 401 of the Clean Water Act. For decades, it had been the rule that a federal agency could not issue a license or permit to conduct any activity that could result in any discharge into navigable waters unless the affected state or tribe certified that the discharge complied with the Clean Water Act and state law, or waived certification.

The Trump administration in 2020 curtailed that review power after complaints from Republicans in Congress and the fossil fuel industry that state officials had used the permitting process to stop new energy projects. The Trump administration said its actions would advance then-President Donald Trump’s goal to fast-track energy projects such as oil and natural gas pipelines.

States, Native American Tribes and environmental groups sued. Several mostly Republican-led states, a national trade association representing the oil and gas industry and others have intervened in the case to defend the Trump-era rule. The states involved in the case are: Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, West Virginia, Wyoming and Texas.

___

Associated Press reporter Matthew Daly in Washington contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Ukrainians pore over grisly aftermath of atrocities
Ukrainian authorities are poring over the grisly aftermath of alleged Russian atrocities around Kyiv, as both sides prepare for an all-out push by Moscow's forces to seize Ukraine’s industrial east
9:15AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Zoos hiding birds as avian flu spreads in North America
Zoos across North America are moving their birds indoors and away from people and wildlife as they try to protect them from the highly contagious and potentially deadly avian influenza
9:11AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Residents clear trees, assess damage from southern storms
Weather forecasters planned to survey damage from several possible tornadoes in Georgia and South Carolina, but said that effort could be interrupted by the potential for more storms Wednesday
9:06AM ( 23 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Russian nationalist lawmaker Vladimir Zhirinovsky dies at 75
A senior Russian lawmaker whose sulphurous rhetoric and antics alarmed the West but appealed to citizens' aggrievement and wounded pride has died at age 75
6:54AM ( 2 hours ago )
Live updates | Ukraine accuses Moscow of weaponizing hunger
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy is accusing Russia of using hunger as a weapon of war by deliberately targeting Ukraine’s essential food supplies
5:59AM ( 3 hours ago )
Sri Lanka president will not resign despite growing protests
A government minister says Sri Lanka’s president will not resign and instead will face the political and economic crisis that has sparked huge protests demanding his resignation
3:51AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Live Updates | Call for sanctions to hit closer to Putin
The top ally and chief strategist of Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny is welcoming reports that the U.S. might impose sanctions on Russian President Vladimir Putin’s daughters — and says his “most important confidante” should be sanctioned too
8:27AM ( 1 hour ago )
China calls for probe into Bucha killings, assigns no blame
China says the reports and images of civilian deaths in the Ukrainian town of Bucha are “deeply disturbing" but that no one should be blamed until all facts are known
8:24AM ( 1 hour ago )
US premarket, global shares fall on rate hike fear, Russia
U.S. markets were on track to open lower on Wednesday, after a Federal Reserve official’s comments fueled expectations of more aggressive rate hikes and the White House announced more sanctions on Russia
8:08AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Live updates | EU chief backs asylum for Russian deserters
A senior European Union official says the bloc’s member countries should think about ways of offering asylum to Russian soldiers willing to desert Ukraine battlefields
5:31AM ( 3 hours ago )
World stocks sink amid worries over US rate hikes, Russia
Global stocks and Wall Street futures have fallen after a Federal Reserve official’s comments fueled expectations of more aggressive U.S. rate hikes and the White House announced more sanctions on Russia
5:18AM ( 4 hours ago )
Live updates | China urges investigation into Bucha deaths
China says the reports and images of civilian deaths in the Ukrainian town of Bucha are “deeply disturbing” and is calling for an investigation
4:51AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Live updates | US OKs $100M transfer of missiles to Ukraine
President Joe Biden has approved a $100 million transfer of Javelin anti-armor missiles to Ukraine on Tuesday
9:47PM ( 11 hours ago )
EPA rule would finally ban asbestos, carcinogen still in use
The Environmental Protection Agency has proposed a rule to finally ban asbestos, a carcinogen still used in some chlorine bleach, brake pads and other products that kills thousands of Americans every year
5:40PM ( 15 hours ago )
Live updates | Some get out of Mariupol, bus convoy blocked
 A Ukrainian official says Russian troops has allowed 1,496 civilians to evacuate the besieged city of Mariupol by private vehicle but blocked a convoy of evacuation buses from entering the port city
5:38PM ( 15 hours ago )
AP Business - Utilities
Ukrainians pore over grisly aftermath of atrocities
Ukrainian authorities are poring over the grisly aftermath of alleged Russian atrocities around Kyiv, as both sides prepare for an all-out push by Moscow's forces to seize Ukraine’s industrial east
9:15AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Zoos hiding birds as avian flu spreads in North America
Zoos across North America are moving their birds indoors and away from people and wildlife as they try to protect them from the highly contagious and potentially deadly avian influenza
9:11AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Residents clear trees, assess damage from southern storms
Weather forecasters planned to survey damage from several possible tornadoes in Georgia and South Carolina, but said that effort could be interrupted by the potential for more storms Wednesday
9:06AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Jury deliberations enter 3rd day in Gov. Whitmer kidnap plot
Jurors are back for a third day of deliberations in a trial that centers on a plot to kidnap Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer
8:55AM ( 35 minutes ago )
Hong Kong's No. 2 official resigns, announces leadership bid
Hong Kong’s No. 2 official, a staunch supporter of a Beijing-backed crackdown on pro-democracy activists, has tendered his resignation to pave the way for his run in the city’s upcoming leadership race
8:54AM ( 35 minutes ago )