sunny.png
Monday August 15th, 2022 7:07PM

Iowa court upholds gender identity discrimination case

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — The Iowa Supreme Court on Friday upheld much of a 2019 jury verdict that found the state discriminated against a transgender state prison employee by denying him the use of men’s restrooms and locker rooms, but the court dismissed a portion of the case that centered on sex discrimination.

The ruling means Jesse Vroegh, a former nurse at the state’s Mitchellville prison for women, has won his discrimination lawsuit based on gender identity and the jury's $120,000 damages verdict for emotional distress.

The decision in which the full court recognized gender identity discrimination for transgender workers under state civil rights law is a significant LGBTQ victory.

American Civil Liberties Union of Iowa lawyer Melissa Hasso has said the lawsuit was the first related to transgender rights that’s been filed since lawmakers amended the Iowa Civil Rights Act in 2007 to bar discrimination on the basis of gender identity and sexual orientation.

Vroegh, who filed the lawsuit in 2017, said the victory was a long time coming.

“I'm so happy that my state Supreme Court has recognized that transgender people like me should be treated the same as everyone else and that if a doctor says I should receive medical treatment I get the treatment,” he said. “It is important for all people to be treated with dignity and respect.”

An Iowa Department of Corrections spokesman said in a statement that a new agency director and prison warden are in place since this case occurred.

“The DOC does everything it can to create a safe and accommodating environment for all its employees,” said the statement provided by spokesman Nick Crawford.

The court determined that the amended act added sexual orientation and gender identity to the list of protected characteristics, which allowed the jury to consider gender identity discrimination in Vroegh’s case. The court, however found the sex discrimination allegation should not have been before the jury.

The high court explained that it has previously separated sex from gender with sex meaning whether one is male or female and gender relating to behavior, feelings and thoughts that do not always correlate to one's physiological status.

Vroegh claimed that discrimination based on sex included discrimination based on gender identity. The court rejected that argument.

“Discrimination based on an individual’s gender identity does not equate to discrimination based on the individual’s male or female anatomical characteristics at the time of birth (the definition of `sex'). An employer could discriminate against transgender individuals without even knowing the sex of the individuals adversely affected,” the court said,

In February 2019 a jury found that the Corrections Department discriminated against Vroegh and the state executive branch further discriminated against him by offering medical benefits that would not cover his gender confirmation surgery.

While the court on Friday upheld that verdict, damages award and payment of more than $348,000 in attorney fees, it denied Vroegh's attempt to pursue a case against the state's insurer, Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield, for denial of coverage for surgery that was recommended by Vroegh's doctors to treat gender dysphoria. Wellmark said its plan did not cover any gender confirmation surgery. That benefit was later covered for state employees beginning in 2017.

The ruling comes as transgender rights have become the center of legal and political fights in several states. Gender identity employment discrimination cases are pending in states including Alaska, Arizona, Georgia, Kentucky, Michigan, Oklahoma and Texas. Also, Iowa is among several states where Republican lawmakers have passed laws to limit transgender athlete participation in sports.

ACLU of Iowa Legal Director Rita Bettis Austen said the case is part of an important legal trend in the U.S. that recognizes equal rights for transgender people.

“This case shows how important it is to bring these enforcement cases and we’re just so grateful and proud of Jesse for being willing to take this important fight for justice and equality to the courts,” she said.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Iowa court upholds gender identity discrimination case
The Iowa Supreme Court has upheld much of a 2019 jury verdict that found the state discriminated against a transgender prison employee by denying him the use of men’s restrooms and locker rooms
2:04PM ( 4 minutes ago )
House votes to decriminalize marijuana, but Senate fate dim
The House has approved a bill decriminalizing marijuana and letting states set their own policies on pot
1:58PM ( 9 minutes ago )
COVID-19 asylum limits at US-Mexico border to end May 23
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says it's ending a policy that limited asylum at the U.S.-Mexico border to prevent the spread of COVID-19
1:54PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Census records from 1950 could solve some family mysteries
The first-ever publication of 1950 census records promises to solve some family mysteries for amateur genealogists and family historians
1:36PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Politically charged US-Iran in first Middle East World Cup
The most controversial World Cup ever will feature in Qatar the most politically charged matchups
1:35PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Oscars producer says police offered to arrest Will Smith
Oscars producer Will Packer says Los Angeles police were ready to arrest Will Smith after Smith slapped Chris Rock at the Academy Awards
1:31PM ( 36 minutes ago )
AP National News
Officer killed in Pennsylvania was 1 month from retirement
Authorities say a police lieutenant killed on duty in Pennsylvania was one month away from retirement when a man suspected of breaking into a family member’s home opened fire on responding officers
12:36PM ( 1 hour ago )
Jury hearing closing arguments in Gov. Whitmer kidnap trial
Jurors are hearing closing arguments in the trial of four men accused of plotting to kidnap Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer
11:49AM ( 2 hours ago )
$14M jury award for protesters could resonate around US
A federal jury’s $14 million award to Denver protesters injured during 2020 demonstrations over the police killing of George Floyd could resonate nationwide as courts weigh more than two dozen similar lawsuits
10:23AM ( 3 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Vulnerable Dems plead with Biden to delay reopening asylum
The Biden administration’s decision to end sweeping asylum limits at the border this May satisfied demands by prominent Democrats
12:46PM ( 1 hour ago )
Will Trump be charged for Jan. 6? Committee floats crimes
The Senate acquitted former President Donald Trump last year of inciting the Capitol insurrection
12:38PM ( 1 hour ago )
UK opens criminal probe into P&O Ferries over crew firings
Britain has launched a criminal investigation has begun into P&O Ferries after the company fired almost 800 U.K.-based crew without warning so they could be replaced by cheaper contract staff
11:43AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
NCAA president decries pace of basketball investigations
NCAA President Mark Emmert says investigations into allegations of major violations against several high-profile men’s college basketball programs have taken “way too long.”
7:50AM ( 6 hours ago )
Live updates | EU proposes exchange of Ukraine bank notes
The European Union’s executive arm is proposing that the 27-nation bloc’s countries allow the millions of refugees fleeing the war in Ukraine to exchange their hryvnia banknotes into the currencies of host member nations
6:51AM ( 7 hours ago )
Ukraine war tops agenda at EU-China summit
The European Union is seeking China’s assurances that it won’t assist Russia in circumventing economic sanctions leveled over the invasion of Ukraine
5:43AM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Alaska Airlines cancels dozens of flights as pilots picket
Dozens of flights along the West Coast are being canceled as Alaska Airlines pilots picket during ongoing contract negotiations with the airline
1:33PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Stocks edge lower, Treasury yields soar after jobs data
Stocks edged lower on Wall Street Friday while Treasury yields soared, after a healthy report on the U.S. job market strengthened expectations for coming interest rate hikes
12:51PM ( 1 hour ago )
US added 431,000 jobs in March in sign of economic health
America’s employers extended a streak of robust hiring in March, adding 431,000 jobs in a sign of the economy’s resilience in the face of a still-destructive pandemic, Russia’s war against Ukraine and the highest inflation in 40 years
12:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
House votes to decriminalize marijuana, but Senate fate dim
The House has approved a bill decriminalizing marijuana and letting states set their own policies on pot
1:58PM ( 9 minutes ago )
COVID-19 asylum limits at US-Mexico border to end May 23
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says it's ending a policy that limited asylum at the U.S.-Mexico border to prevent the spread of COVID-19
1:54PM ( 13 minutes ago )
New vehicles must average 40 mpg by 2026, up from 28 mpg
New vehicles sold in the U.S. will have to average at least 40 miles per gallon of gasoline in 2026 under new rules unveiled by the government
1:44PM ( 24 minutes ago )
US to play England, Iran and possibly Ukraine at World Cup
The United States will play either Ukraine, Wales or Scotland in its World Cup opener, then meet England and Iran in its return to the tournament
1:40PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Russia: Push to pay for gas in rubles not disrupting supply
Russian officials say their demand that natural gas be paid for in rubles doesn’t mean supplies will be immediately interrupted
1:38PM ( 30 minutes ago )