cloudyn.png
Wednesday August 17th, 2022 3:32AM

Bills deal renews debate over public dollars for arenas

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) — New York looks poised to become the next place to give a huge subsidy to a professional sports arena, despite questions about whether the civic pride of having a team justifies giving so much public money to a private business.

Gov. Kathy Hochul proposed a deal Monday that would give the Buffalo Bills $850 million in public funds to help the team build a new $1.4 billion stadium. In return, the Bills would agree to play in Buffalo's suburbs for at least 30 years.

The deal, which still needs approval from the state legislature, immediately renewed a debate about government's role in supporting privately-owned businesses.

Just three years ago, a deal to that would have given Amazon nearly $3 billion in tax and other incentives to build a headquarters for 25,000 workers in New York City fell apart amid a backlash from activists and progressive politicians who called it a giant corporate giveaway.

Some similar criticism rolled in over the Bills deal.

State Assemblymember Ron T. Kim, a Queens Democrat, used a curse word on Twitter to refer to the proposal. Sochie Nnaemeka, the director of the influential Working Families Party, called the deal “a continuation of trickle-down economic development schemes that have enriched wealthy investors on the backs of Black, brown, and working class communities.”

U.S. Rep. Thomas Suozzi, a Long Island Democrat running against Hochul, said he supported the idea of a new Bills stadium, but that it could be built without having New Yorkers “fork over their tax dollars to help a billionaire donor get even richer.”

A few barbs came from the right, too.

“I like the Bills as much as anyone but this is outrageous,” said Republican state Sen. Mike Martucci, who represents a district in the Catskill Mountains and Hudson Valley. “Republicans are often criticized for being buddies with billionaires. What would you call this?”

The deal negotiated by the Hochul administration would require the Bills’ owners, billionaires Terry and Kim Pegula, whose fortune is linked to natural gas fracking, to put up around 39% of the construction cost.

New York state taxpayers would pay $600 million, with Erie County, where the team is located, spending another $250 million.

Hochul, a western New York native and Bills fan, insisted the deal made good economic sense.

She also highlighted the intangible benefits of having pro sports in Buffalo — a rust belt city that the state has already spent hundreds of millions of dollars reviving following the decline of U.S. manufacturing in the 1970s and 80s.

It “goes to our identity,” she told reporters Monday.

“We are known globally for being the home of the Buffalo Bills, and it’s part of our local psyche, and it makes us so proud,” Hochul said, adding, “that’s not quantifiable.”

That, probably more than anything else, is what has prompted numerous cities and states to put up big bucks for sports arena projects, either to keep teams from moving or luring them away from elsewhere.

Nevada poured $750 million into a new stadium to get the NFL's Raiders to move from Oakland last year. In Atlanta, the Falcons’ owner said he’s expecting to get as much as $700 million in public dollars from future tax revenues over coming decades as part of the deal struck to build the $1.5 billion Mercedes-Benz Stadium.

A number of cities and states have poured public money into arena deals, even to replace venues that are still relatively new.

New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft bucked the trend of taxpayer support by privately funding his new stadium in Foxborough, Massachusetts — after exploring plans to move the team to Boston; Rhode Island; and Hartford, Connecticut.

A more comparable market to Buffalo is Jacksonville, Florida, where the Jaguars TIAA Bank Field was built on part of the former Gator Bowl Stadium in 1995 at a cost of $134 million (about $368 million in today's dollars), with 45% of that money coming from the city. Last year, Jaguars owner Shad Khan unveiled a $450 million plan to redevelop the area around the stadium, with taxpayers providing $233 million in investments and incentives.

The promise of economic development tied to sports has also led numerous small cities and counties to invest public dollars in minor league teams.

Public officials often argue that they amount of tax dollars spent will be eclipsed be revenue brought in by a team, including taxes on player salaries, jobs created and tourism dollars spent.

That argument doesn’t carry much weight with economists, who say decades of research shows sport stadiums don’t do much to boost a local economy.

“This is one of those topics where you have almost universal agreement among economists: that stadiums really do not bring a significant financial benefit to the cities that house them,” said Michael Leeds, an economics professor at Temple University.

Sports teams do bring in out-of-town fans who patronize local hotels and restaurants, but the jobs created and tax revenue generated rarely come close to the rosy projections, experts say.

“We don’t want to kid ourselves,” Leeds said. “What they do bring is very limited geographically and very limited financially.”

Buffalo, the NFL’s second smallest market, does draw some out-of-state fans, with southern Ontario, Canada, making up more than 15% of its season-ticket base.

Government handouts to big corporations, of course, aren't just for sports. Automakers, aerospace manufacturers, tech companies and others have gotten billions of dollars in tax breaks from U.S. states. New York state pledged more money to help build a Tesla solar panel factory outside Buffalo — $750 million — than it is giving to the Bills.

Smith College economics professor Andrew Zimbalist said some wealthy sports team owners have, in recent years, taken on a bigger percentage of up-front costs of new stadiums in response to public outcry over sweetheart mega deals.

“If you go back 25 years, you’ll see that 70% of the funding was basically public,” Zimbalist said.

The leaders of New York's Assembly and Senate, whose approval is needed for public financing on the Bills deal, have so far been silent, but Hochul looked to have gotten support from at least some top Democrats.

Senate Majority Leader Crystal Peoples-Stokes praised the deal and called it a “once in a generation opportunity for advancement.”

Pegula Sports and Entertainment executive Ron Raccuia, who represented the Bills in negotiations with the state and county, called the deal a “good investment for everyone.”

“We are very thankful that the governor and county executive showed the leadership that they did. But I think people need to realize that we contribute a lot from a tax standpoint. Every dollar that goes into this stadium will be paid back,” he said.

John Kaehny, executive director of the government-reform group Reinvent Albany, said that while some downstate progressives were opposed to public funding for a Bills stadium as “a gross corporate handout,” they might lack the political traction to block the deal.

___

AP sports writer John Wawrow contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Economy, AP Sports - NFL
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Relief for Kyiv? Russia vows to scale back near the capital
Russia’s military says it will “fundamentally” cut back operations near Ukraine’s capital and a northern city, as talks brought a possible deal to end a grinding war into view
9:07PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Live updates: Ukraine ambassador: Russia being demilitarized
Ukraine’s U_N_ Ambassador Sergiy Kyslytsya told the U_N_ Security Council on Tuesday that the “demilitarization of Russia is well under way.”
9:02PM ( 47 minutes ago )
Will Smith would face little more than a slap if charged
Legal experts say Will Smith’s slap seen ’round the world at the Oscars was clearly a crime
8:20PM ( 1 hour ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Close to reaching World Cup, US looks to avoid last-day flop
American soccer’s harrowing memory of the loss in Trinidad 4 1/2 years ago remains omnipresent, if no longer raw
7:32PM ( 2 hours ago )
NFL owners approve rule change for OT in playoffs
The NFL is changing its sometimes controversial overtime rules to guarantee each side gets the ball in the playoffs
6:37PM ( 3 hours ago )
Goodell: No timetable on NFL investigation of Deshaun Watson
A resolution to the NFL’s investigation into Deshaun Watson’s conduct could take some time, Commissioner Roger Goodell said Tuesday
6:16PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Sports
Bills deal renews debate over public dollars for arenas
New York looks poised to become the next place to give a huge subsidy to a professional sports arena, despite questions about whether the civic pride of having a team justifies giving so much public money to a private business
2:01PM ( 7 hours ago )
NFL's Inspire Change ahead of monetary schedule in Year 5
When the NFL launched its Inspire Change program in 2017, the goal was to reach $250 million over 10 years in its commitment to social justice initiatives
3:04AM ( 18 hours ago )
NFL makes adjustments to Rooney Rule to aid minority hiring
To ensure more opportunities for diverse candidates, the NFL has added requirements on the hiring of offensive assistant coaches, and women in general
4:58PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Football
Energy agency: 'Radical action' needed to hit climate goals
The head of the International Renewable Energy Agency says “radical action” is needed to shift away from fossil fuels and ensure global warming doesn’t pass dangerous thresholds
7:23PM ( 2 hours ago )
Biden signs bill making lynching a federal hate crime
President Joe Biden has signed a bill into law to make lynching a federal hate crime, more than 100 years after such legislation was first proposed
7:22PM ( 2 hours ago )
Live updates: UN food chief: Ukraine war has a global impact
The United Nations food chief is warning that the war in Ukraine has created “a catastrophe on top of a catastrophe.”
7:14PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
US opens second COVID boosters to 50 and up, others at risk
Americans age 50 and older can get a second COVID-19 booster if it’s been at least four months since their last vaccination
5:22PM ( 4 hours ago )
Gunman kills 5 in mass shooting spree in central Israel
Israeli officials say at least five people have been killed by a gunman who opened fire in a crowded city in central Israel
4:43PM ( 5 hours ago )
Live updates: Pentagon sees 'small' shift away from Kyiv
The Pentagon says it has detected “small numbers” of Russian ground forces moving away from the Kyiv area
4:36PM ( 5 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Biden is skeptical Russia is scaling back operations in Kyiv
President Joe Biden says he's not yet convinced that Russia’s announcement that it will scale back military operations near the Ukrainian capital of Kyiv will lead to a fundamental shift in the war
6:09PM ( 3 hours ago )
EXPLAINER: What's behind the new federal anti-lynching law?
The history of racial violence in the U.S. is the backdrop as President Joe Biden signs the Emmett Till Anti-Lynching Act into law
5:10PM ( 4 hours ago )
Senate advances Fed nominee Lisa Cook on party-line vote
The Senate on Tuesday agreed to consider the nomination of Lisa Cook for a position on the Federal Reserve’s Board of Governors on a 50-49 party-line vote
4:22PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Senate advances controversial Fed nominee on party-line vote
The Senate on Tuesday agreed to consider the nomination of Lisa Cook for a position on the Federal Reserve’s Board of Governors on a 50-49 party-line vote
1:33PM ( 8 hours ago )
Live updates: U.S. general says more forces may be needed
The U.S. European Command leader says the country will likely need to add more permanent or rotational forces in Europe due to the Russian invasion of Ukraine
12:32PM ( 9 hours ago )
Live updates: Russian delegate says talks show progress
 The head of the Russian delegation in talks with Ukraine says that Moscow sees the latest meeting as a step toward compromise
11:29AM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Work starts to free Ever Forward stranded in Chesapeake Bay
Tug boats began working to dislodge a stranded container ship Tuesday, more than two weeks after it ran aground in the Chesapeake Bay
5:17PM ( 4 hours ago )
Wall Street builds on gains as talks on Ukraine progress
Wall Street built on its recent gains and closed higher Tuesday as talks on ending the war in Ukraine showed signs of progress
5:00PM ( 4 hours ago )
FTC sues Intuit to stop 'bait-and-switch' TurboTax ads
The Federal Trade Commission is suing TurboTax maker Intuit, saying its ads for “free” tax filing misled consumers
4:31PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business
US consumers still confident, but outlook not as rosy
U.S. consumer confidence bounced back in March and remains high, though consumers’ short-term outlook is not quite as rosy
12:13PM ( 9 hours ago )
Shanghai lockdown tests 'zero-COVID' limits, shakes markets
A two-phase lockdown of Shanghai's 26 million people is testing the limits of China's hard-line “zero-COVID" strategy whose effects are being felt beyond the country's borders
11:16AM ( 10 hours ago )
US job openings, quitting at near record high in February
Job openings stayed at a near-record level in February, little changed from the previous month, continuing a trend that Federal Reserve officials see as a driver of inflation
10:51AM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Mariota eager to live up to expectations as Falcons new QB
Marcus Mariota has already addressed the most immediate issue with his new team
7:03PM ( 4 days ago )
Browns' QB Deshaun Watson: "I've never assaulted any woman"
New Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson maintained his innocence and strongly denied committing any sexual misconduct despite allegations made by 22 women against him
5:59PM ( 4 days ago )
Black News Channel shuts down days after ratings high
The Black News Channel shut down on Friday after failing to meet its payroll and losing the support of its chief investor, Jacksonville Jaguars owner Shahid Kahn
4:27PM ( 4 days ago )
AP Sports - NFL
Relief for Kyiv? Russia vows to scale back near the capital
Russia’s military says it will “fundamentally” cut back operations near Ukraine’s capital and a northern city, as talks brought a possible deal to end a grinding war into view
9:07PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Live updates: Ukraine ambassador: Russia being demilitarized
Ukraine’s U_N_ Ambassador Sergiy Kyslytsya told the U_N_ Security Council on Tuesday that the “demilitarization of Russia is well under way.”
9:02PM ( 48 minutes ago )
Will Smith would face little more than a slap if charged
Legal experts say Will Smith’s slap seen ’round the world at the Oscars was clearly a crime
8:20PM ( 1 hour ago )
EXPLAINER: Alopecia 'strips people of their identity'
Alopecia is an autoimmune disorder that affects millions of people around the world
8:04PM ( 1 hour ago )
El Salvador forces encircle neighborhoods in gang crackdown
El Salvador’s security forces have intensified their operations against the country’s street gangs with mass arrests, the cordoning off of entire neighborhoods and house-by-house searches under a state of emergency sought by President Nayib Bukele
7:59PM ( 1 hour ago )