Monday January 30th, 2023 3:04AM

Justices skeptical of elections case that could alter voting

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Wednesday seemed skeptical of making a broad ruling that would leave state legislatures virtually unchecked in making rules for congressional and presidential elections.

In nearly three hours of arguments, liberal and conservative justices appeared to take issue with the main thrust of a challenge asking them to essentially eliminate the power of state courts to strike down legislature-drawn, gerrymandered congressional district maps on grounds that they violate state constitutions.

But it was harder to see exactly where the court would land. In particular, a trio of conservative justices who probably control the outcome, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett, indicated they might be open to imposing restraints on state court power in limited circumstances.

The case has profound potential effects on elections and democracy, and it is also a fresh test for the court that increasingly has been criticized as having become politicized.

Republicans from North Carolina who brought the case to the high court argue that a provision of the U.S. Constitution known as the elections clause gives state lawmakers virtually total control over the “times, places and manner” of congressional elections, including redistricting. That means cutting state courts out of the process, they say.

The Republicans are advancing a concept called the “independent legislature theory,” never adopted by the Supreme Court but previously cited approvingly by four conservative justices. In the courtroom Wednesday, Justice Elena Kagan, a liberal, branded it “a novel challenge” that “that gets rid of the normal checks and balances.”

A broad ruling could threaten hundreds of election laws, require separate rules for federal and state elections on the same ballot and lead to new efforts to redraw congressional districts to maximize partisan advantage.

“This is a theory with big consequences,” Kagan said, that would allow for the “most extreme forms of gerrymandering from legislatures.” The other liberal justices, Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson, also appeared favorable to the role of state courts in the process.

David Thompson, the lawyer representing the North Carolina Republicans, said overly partisan redistricting was a problem that the framers of the Constitution thought should be addressed in the political arena, not state or federal courthouses.

On the other side, lawyers defending the role of state courts told the justices that major changes to elections could result from their decision.

Fully embracing what Thompson argued for “would wreak havoc in the administration of elections across the nation,” Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar said, representing the Biden administration. Neal Katyal, representing North Carolina voters and voter advocacy groups, warned of a large “blast radius” from a ruling for the North Carolina Republicans.

If there seemed a lack of support for the broadest outcome, Roberts on several occasions talked about the tension between federal and state judicial power.

“So you do accept the proposition that there is a role for this court in particular to assess ... how that conflict is worked out in a particular case?” Roberts asked Prelogar.

Barrett also asked questions suggesting that she believes state courts could go too far in trying to police federal elections in a way that could violate the U.S. Constitution.

The court's decision in the North Carolina case also might suggest how the justices would deal with another part of the Constitution — not at issue in the current case — that gives legislatures the authority to decide how presidential electors are appointed. That provision, the electors clause, was central to efforts to try to overturn the outcome of the 2020 presidential election in several closely contested states.

The North Carolina state Supreme Court struck down districts drawn by Republicans who control the legislature because they heavily favored Republicans in the highly competitive state. The court-drawn map used in last month's elections for Congress produced a 7-7 split between Democrats and Republicans.

North Carolina is among six states in recent years in which state courts have ruled that overly partisan redistricting for Congress violated their state constitutions. The others are Florida, Maryland, New York, Ohio and Pennsylvania.

State courts have become the only legal forum for challenging partisan congressional maps since the Supreme Court ruled in 2019 that those lawsuits cannot be brought in federal court.

Roberts, writing then for the court and joined by four other conservative justices, noted that state courts remained able to act.

“Provisions in state statutes and state constitutions can provide standards and guidance for state courts to apply,” Roberts wrote, in an opinion joined by Justices Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, Clarence Thomas and Kavanaugh.

But Alito, Gorsuch and Thomas seemed mostly to favor North Carolina's arguments Wednesday limiting state courts' authority.

“What is the source of the authority for the state of North Carolina’s Supreme Court to be involved in a federal election?” Thomas asked.

Alito suggested that elected state court judges have no role to play in congressional redistricting.

"So there’s been a lot of talk about the impact of this decision on democracy. Do you think that it furthers democracy to transfer the political controversy about districting from the legislature to elected supreme courts where the candidates are permitted by state law to campaign on the issue of districting?” he asked.

Gorsuch said that preserving the North Carolina court ruling might be politically popular because it was aimed at combating partisan line-drawing, but that the same logic might have led in earlier eras to upholding politically odious positions enshrined in state constitutions, including counting enslaved Black people as three-fifths of a person under Virginia's constitution.

“The political saliency point depends on whose ox is being gored at a particular point in time,” Gorsuch said.

Donald Verrilli, representing North Carolina in defense of its court ruling, said the Supreme Court should not ignore what he described as rising opposition to partisan gerrymandering.

“It’s more than whose ox is being gored. This is a very important issue in this country,” said Verrilli, who previously served as the Obama administration's top Supreme Court lawyer.

Kavanaugh has separately written about a need for federal courts to police the actions of state courts when it comes to federal elections, citing an opinion by three conservatives in the Bush v. Gore case that settled the 2000 presidential election. Thomas was one of the three justices on that 22-year-old opinion, but the court decided the case on other grounds.

In North Carolina, Republican lawmakers won't have to wait for the high court's decision in Washington to produce a new congressional map that is expected to have more Republican districts.

Even as Democrats won half the state's 14 congressional seats, Republicans seized control of the state Supreme Court. Two newly elected Republican justices give them a 5-2 edge that makes it more likely the state court would uphold a map with more Republican districts.


Follow the AP's coverage of the U.S. Supreme Court at https://apnews.com/hub/us-supreme-court.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News
© Copyright 2023 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Justices skeptical of elections case that could alter voting
At least six Supreme Court justices are sounding skeptical of making a broad ruling that would leave state legislatures virtually unchecked when making rules for elections
11:33AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Jaguars' Lawrence sits out practice with sprained big toe
Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Trevor Lawrence won’t practice Wednesday because of a sprained big toe on his left foot
11:24AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Duke Energy: All equipment damaged in NC shooting now fixed
Duke Energy says it has completed repairs on substation equipment damaged when it was shot up and that it expects power to be fully restored by the evening
11:20AM ( 27 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
US Jews fear collision with expected Israeli government
Israel’s ties to the Jewish American community are about to be put to the test, with Israel’s emerging far-right government on a collision course with Jews in the United States
10:16AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP source: Aaron Judge, Yankees reach $360M, 9-year deal
A person familiar with the deal says that Aaron Judge has agreed to return to the New York Yankees on a $360 million, nine-year contract
9:53AM ( 1 hour ago )
Electricity, telecoms return to parts of Ethiopia's Tigray
Basic services like electricity and telecoms have been restored to key parts of Ethiopia’s Tigray region following the signing of a cease-fire deal a month ago, but most areas are still cut off from the world
9:46AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Justices take up elections case that could reshape voting
The Supreme Court is taking up a case with the potential to reshape elections for Congress and the presidency
7:18AM ( 4 hours ago )
Germany: 25 arrested on suspicion of planning armed coup
Officials say thousands of police officers have carried out raids across much of Germany against suspected far-right extremists who allegedly sought to overthrow the government in an armed coup
7:15AM ( 4 hours ago )
Donors race to get generators, other aid to hard-hit Ukraine
When Russian forces launched a military campaign against infrastructure in Ukraine, they opened a front that carried the war along power lines and water mains to homes, schools, hospitals and Ukrainian livelihoods
7:01AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Bombing at Indonesian police station kills officer, hurts 7
A man has blown himself up at a police station on Indonesia’s main island of Java, killing an officer and wounding seven people in what appeared to be the latest in a string of suicide attacks blamed on Muslim militants
1:26AM ( 10 hours ago )
China announces roll-back of strict anti-COVID-19 measures
In a sharp reversal, China has announced a series of measures rolling back some of the most draconian anti-COVID-19 restrictions
1:16AM ( 10 hours ago )
China trade shrinks amid virus pressure, interest rate hikes
China’s imports and exports shrank in November under pressure from weakening global demand and anti-virus controls at home
12:48AM ( 11 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Coast Guard faults pilot in Chesapeake Bay ship grounding
A Coast Guard investigation into the grounding in March of a cargo ship in the Chesapeake Bay is faulting the pilot tasked with helping the ship navigate the waterway
11:00AM ( 48 minutes ago )
Emhoff: 'Epidemic of hate' exists in US, can't be normalized
Doug Emhoff, the husband of Vice President Kamala Harris, says a rise in antisemitism in the United States shows that an “epidemic of hate” exists in the country and that it cannot be normalized
8:51AM ( 2 hours ago )
Nepal votes counted, but new government could take days
Nepal has finished counting the votes that were cast in the Nov. 20 parliamentary elections
3:23AM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Indonesia's Parliament votes to ban sex outside of marriage
Indonesia’s Parliament unanimously voted on Tuesday to ban sex outside of marriage and insulting the president and state institutions
7:42PM ( 16 hours ago )
Polls closing in Georgia runoff to decide final Senate seat
Polls are closing in the country’s final Senate contest, as Georgia voters await a winner in the runoff election between Democratic Sen. Raphael Warnock and Republican football legend Herschel Walker
7:23PM ( 16 hours ago )
Biden visits Arizona computer chip site, highlights jobs
President Joe Biden has visited the building site for an Arizona computer chip plant to emphasize how his policies are fostering job growth in what could be a challenge to the incoming Republican House majority
6:39PM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Federal judge OKs Oregon's new high-capacity magazine ban
A federal judge in Portland, Oregon, will allow a new voter-passed ban on high-capacity gun magazines to go into effect Thursday
2:07PM ( 21 hours ago )
Justices spar in latest clash of religion and gay rights
The Supreme Court’s conservative majority is sounding sympathetic to a Christian graphic artist who objects to designing wedding websites for gay couples
9:29PM ( 1 day ago )
Same-sex couples wary despite federal marriage rights bill
Same-sex couples say they're happy that Congress is moving quickly to ensure nationwide recognition of gay marriage
1:24PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
For Trump, tax fraud case just one of several legal problems
A New York jury has convicted Donald Trump’s company of tax fraud
7:15PM ( 16 hours ago )
Outgoing elections head in key Nevada county details threats
The elections director in the largest county in one of the nation’s most important battleground states details the threats he and his co-workers have received since the 2020 presidential election and how he responded to protect his staff
5:08PM ( 18 hours ago )
Outgoing elections chief in Nevada county details threats
The elections director in the largest county in one of the nation’s most important battleground states details the threats he and his co-workers have received since the 2020 presidential election and how he responded to protect his staff
4:59PM ( 18 hours ago )
AP Elections
Trump rebuked for call to suspend Constitution over election
Former President Donald Trump is facing rebuke from both parties after calling for the “termination” of parts of the Constitution over his lie that the 2020 election was stolen
5:17PM ( 2 days ago )
Defeated election conspiracists seek to lead Michigan GOP
The Republicans who lost their races for Michigan’s top three statewide offices after promoting falsehoods about the 2020 presidential election are not planning to go quietly
9:59AM ( 4 days ago )
GOP's Duarte takes California Central Valley US House seat
Republican John Duarte defeated Democrat Adam Gray in a new California U.S. House district in the Central Valley farm belt that produced the closest congressional contest in the state this year
11:00PM ( 4 days ago )
General Election News
Supreme Court weighs 'most important case' on democracy
The Supreme Court is about to confront a new elections case that could dramatically alter voting in 2024 and beyond
5:20PM ( 2 days ago )
Jan. 6 panel interviews Wisconsin GOP Assembly speaker
Republican Wisconsin Assembly Speaker Robin Vos has been interviewed by the House committee investigating the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol
5:01PM ( 6 days ago )
Haley signals 2024 openness despite pledge to back Trump
Former U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley says she would take the Christmas holiday to mull a possible 2024 presidential bid
11:21PM ( 1 week ago )
General Presidential Election News
Jaguars' Lawrence sits out practice with sprained big toe
Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Trevor Lawrence won’t practice Wednesday because of a sprained big toe on his left foot
11:24AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Duke Energy: All equipment damaged in NC shooting now fixed
Duke Energy says it has completed repairs on substation equipment damaged when it was shot up and that it expects power to be fully restored by the evening
11:20AM ( 28 minutes ago )
Putin calls nuclear weapons a tool of deterrence in Ukraine
Russian President Vladimir Putin has hailed the illegal annexation of Ukrainian territories into Russia as a major achievement of what the Kremlin calls a “special military operation.”
11:14AM ( 34 minutes ago )
FBI: Polygamous leader had 20 wives, many of them minors
Authorities say the leader of a small polygamous group near the Arizona-Utah border had taken at least 20 wives and punished followers who didn't treat him as a prophet
11:13AM ( 35 minutes ago )
US to boost natural gas exports to UK in energy partnership
The United States will increase exports of liquefied natural gas to Britain under a new agreement calling for the two countries to work together to boost energy security and drive down prices following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine
11:01AM ( 47 minutes ago )