Monday November 28th, 2022 1:04AM

Indiana doctor: AG shouldn't get abortion patient records

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Lawyers for an Indianapolis doctor who provided an abortion to a 10-year-old rape victim from Ohio told a judge Friday that Indiana’s attorney general should not be allowed to access patient medical records for an investigation into undisclosed complaints.

Dr. Caitlin Bernard; her medical partner, Dr. Amy Caldwell; and their patients sued Republican Attorney General Todd Rokita on Nov. 3 to try to stop him from accessing the records. The doctors claim Rokita's conduct “violates numerous Indiana statutes,” including a state requirement that his office first determine consumer complaints have “merit” before he can investigate physicians and other licensed professionals.

The state argued it is allowed to access the records to investigate three consumer complaints that accuse Bernard of improper care.

“The consumer complaints were 100% filed by people who had never met Dr. Bernard, had never gotten medical care from Dr. Bernard, were not involved in the care of this patient in any way shape or form,” attorney Kathleen DeLaney refuted in a press conference after the hearing. “They’re complaining about something that they saw on television or heard about on social media.”

Bernard first received national attention after she told The Indianapolis Star about a 10-year-old girl who traveled to Indiana from Ohio for an abortion in June, shortly after Ohio’s “fetal heartbeat” law took effect following the U.S. Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. Such laws ban abortions from the time cardiac activity can be detected in an embryo, which is typically around the sixth week of pregnancy.

Rokita told Fox News in July that he would look into whether Bernard violated child abuse notification or abortion reporting laws. He offered no specific allegations of wrongdoing, and court records from Thursday indicate he is no longer investigating Bernard “for failing to comply” with the abortion reporting law.

Records obtained by The Associated Press and other news outlets show Bernard submitted her report about the girl’s abortion July 2, which is within Indiana’s required three-day reporting period for an abortion performed on a girl younger than 16.

A 27-year-old man was charged that month in Columbus, Ohio, with raping the girl, confirming the existence of the case, which initially was met with skepticism by some media outlets and Republican politicians. President Joe Biden expressed empathy for the child while signing of an executive order protecting some abortion access.

Kelly Stevenson, a spokesperson for the attorney general’s office, said in an email that “our team always follows the law and pursues the truth — as that is the role of the Attorney General.”

“We put the highest value on patient privacy and ethical standards in medicine. We will continue to push forward in this legal battle to ensure every patient’s privacy is protected in Indiana,” she added.

But DeLaney said that because of the 27-year-old man's arrest, “the notion that Dr. Barnard didn’t cooperate with law enforcement is simply not true.”

State lawyer Caryn Nieman-Szyper on Friday also questioned whether anything Bernard said to The Indianapolis Star violated federal medical privacy laws. Nieman-Szyper honed in specifically on rules under the federal privacy law known as HIPAA, for Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, that prohibit a physician from divulging certain dates associated with their patients.

“Though Dr. Bernard purports to bring suit as the champion of her patient’s privacy rights, she is the one who exposed her patient’s private medical journey to the public and thus the one who has jeopardized her patient’s privacy,” the state wrote in court filings.

At the court hearing, the doctors' lawyers called three physicians — two bioethicists and an obstetrician-gynecologist — who described before Marion County judge Heather Welch that honoring the doctor-patient relationship is a cornerstone of medical care.

Dr. Kyle Brothers, a pediatrician from Louisville, described the link as “an agreement, a promise" and that if the government were to seize a patient's medical records, the patient's trust in their doctor could be broken and dissuade them from seeking care.

“This kind of disclosure, especially for a minor, is heartbreaking, or something like that," he said. "Something really horrible.”

Welch plans to rule over the weekend whether Bernard, who was out of the country Friday, will testify.

“Every patient needs to know that their medical records will not be handed over to any politician who decides to open an unfounded investigation based on their own political agenda,” Bernard said in a statement.


Arleigh Rodgers is a corps member for the Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues. Follow Arleigh Rodgers on Twitter at


This story has been corrected to show the doctor's lawyer is called Kathleen DeLaney, not Kathleen Delaney.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Indiana doctor: AG shouldn't get abortion patient records
Lawyers for an Indianapolis doctor who provided an abortion to a 10-year-old rape victim from Ohio told a judge Friday that Indiana’s attorney general should not be allowed to access patient medical records for an investigation into undisclosed complaints
4:36PM ( 3 minutes ago )
LPGA purses will top $100M in 2023, a record for tour
More than $100 million will be awarded to LPGA players for the first time in 2023
4:26PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Trump 2024 rivals court his donors as primary season begins
Republican 2024 presidential prospects descend upon Las Vegas this weekend as anxious donors and activists openly consider whether to embrace former President Donald Trump for a third consecutive bid
4:15PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Feds: Oath Keepers sought 'violent overthrow' of government
A federal prosecutor says Oath Keepers founder Stewart Rhodes and four associates discussed using violence to overturn the results of the 2020 election for weeks and saw an opportunity to do it when rioters started attacking the Capitol
3:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
New York hasn't licensed any pot shops, yet they abound
New York state's first licenses to sell recreational marijuana could be awarded as soon as next week
3:16PM ( 1 hour ago )
Special counsel in Trump cases vows independent judgment
The newly named special counsel picked to lead investigations related to Donald Trump says he plans to conduct the probes “independently and in the best traditions of the Department of Justice.”
2:59PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Top progressive Jayapal passes on Dem leadership race
Congresswoman Pramila Jayapal has taken herself out of the running for Democratic leadership in the next Congress
9:30AM ( 7 hours ago )
Hungary will not support EU aid plan to Ukraine, Orban says
Hungary will not support a European Union plan to provide Ukraine with billions in budget assistance next year, Prime Minister Viktor Orban said on Friday
9:26AM ( 7 hours ago )
Pelosi, dominant figure for the ages, leaves lasting imprint
When Speaker Nancy Pelosi announced that she won't re-up as a House leader next year, even her adversaries acknowledged that hers was a remarkable era
12:46AM ( 15 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
'Viral jambalaya': Early flu adding to woes for US hospitals
A rapidly intensifying flu season is straining U.S. hospitals already overburdened with patients sick from other respiratory infections
3:26PM ( 1 hour ago )
Elizabeth Holmes faces sentencing for her Theranos crimes
A federal judge on Friday will decide whether disgraced Theranos CEO Elizabeth Holmes should serve a lengthy prison sentence for duping investors and endangering patients while peddling a bogus blood-testing technology
1:36PM ( 3 hours ago )
Berlin Zoo closes door to visitors over bird flu case
The Berlin Zoo has shut its doors to visitors due to a case of avian flu among one of its aquatic birds
10:44AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Health
US stocks edge higher, but on track to end week with losses
Stocks were mostly higher on Wall Street Friday afternoon, though major indexes remained on pace to finish lower for the week after several days of bumpy trading
3:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
Twitter risks fraying as engineers exit over Musk upheaval
Elon Musk’s managerial bomb-throwing at Twitter has so thinned the ranks of the software engineers who keep it up and running that programmers who were fired or resigned this week say Twitter may soon fray so badly it could actually crash
2:44PM ( 1 hour ago )
Commanders settle with Md. over season-ticket holders' money
The Washington Commanders have agreed to return security deposits to former season ticket holders and pay a $250,000 penalty in a settlement with the state of Maryland
2:42PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Senators to FTC: Probe Twitter security, take needed action
A group of Democratic senators have asked federal regulators to investigate any possible violations by Twitter of consumer-protection laws or data-security commitments
6:08PM ( 22 hours ago )
House panel to hold hearing on crypto exchange FTX collapse
Lawmakers plan to investigate the failure of FTX, the large crypto exchange that collapsed last week and filed for bankruptcy protection, leaving investors and customers staring at losses that could total in the billions of dollars
5:52PM ( 1 day ago )
Frontier, 5 other airlines to refund more than $600 million
Frontier Airlines and five foreign carriers are paying more than $600 million in refunds to consumers whose flights were canceled or significantly delayed since the start of the pandemic
7:30PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
LPGA purses will top $100M in 2023, a record for tour
More than $100 million will be awarded to LPGA players for the first time in 2023
4:26PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Stocks end higher on Wall Street but still fall for the week
Stocks ended higher on Wall Street but still wound up with weekly losses after several days of bumpy trading
4:07PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Garland names special counsel to lead Trump-related probes
Attorney General Merrick Garland has named a special counsel to oversee the Justice Department’s investigation into the presence of classified documents at former President Donald Trump’s Florida estate and aspects of a separate probe involving the Jan. 6, 2021, insurrection and efforts to undo the 2020 election
4:04PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Russian strikes force Ukraine to face hours-long power cuts
Ukraine’s electricity grid chief is warning of hours-long power outages as Russia zeroed in on Ukraine’s energy infrastructure with renewed artillery and missile attacks
3:49PM ( 51 minutes ago )
Ex-CFO says Trump kids raised pay after learning of scheme
The Trump Organization’s former chief financial officer has testified that Eric Trump hiked his pay by $200,000 after an internal audit spurred by Trump’s 2016 election found that he had been scheming to dodge taxes on lavish corporate perks
3:35PM ( 1 hour ago )