Saturday March 25th, 2023 1:25PM

Deliberations in Paul Haggis rape lawsuit set to start

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — Jury deliberations are due to start Thursday in a rape civil case against filmmaker Paul Haggis, tasking a six-person panel with sifting through dueling narratives about what happened between him and a publicist on a night in 2013.

In accuser Haleigh Breest's telling, she reluctantly agreed to a drink at the “Crash” and “Million Dollar Baby” screenwriter's apartment, then was subjected to unwelcome kisses, forced to perform oral sex and raped as she repeatedly refused.

“This is a horror film by Paul Haggis, and only you can end it,” one of her lawyers, Ilann Maazel, told the jury in a summation Wednesday.

By Haggis' account, he's fighting a false claim by a show-business publicist who took a shine to an Oscar winner, signaled interest for months and was a partner — by turns hesitant and eager — in a consensual encounter.

“This lawsuit has utterly destroyed him,” defense lawyer Priya Chaudhry said in her closing argument, urging jurors to “set Paul free of these false allegations.”

Breest sued Haggis in 2017; she never brought her allegations to police or prosecutors. She's seeking unspecified damages.

Breest, now 36, and Haggis, 69, met while she was moonlighting as a staffer at movie premieres in New York. They chatted at events and exchanged emails, interactions that he sees as flirtatious feelers but she says were a typical public relations person's efforts to build rapport.

After a screening on Jan. 31, 2013, both sides agree, Haggis offered Breest a ride home and invited her to his loft for a nightcap. She suggested a bar instead.

When he remained set on the apartment, she accepted but said she wasn't going to spend the night. She calls that a clear message that sex wasn't on the table; he said he took it as a “playful” gambit.

Shortly after they arrived, he went to kiss her. And after that, their accounts and characterizations of the night and its aftermath diverge substantially.

Chaudhry portrays Breest as a star-struck young woman who was excited about her night with the screenwriter-director, became disappointed that he didn't ask her out again and twisted “a consensual, somewhat awkward one-night stand” into a sexual assault to try to get a payout — and payback.

“She’s lying. She’s not upset about what happened in Paul Haggis’ apartment that night. She’s upset that he never invited her back,” Chaudhry said in a closing argument. “There are three ‘r’ words in this case: reject, regret, revenge. None of them are rape."

Breest's lawyers paint Haggis as a scheming narcissist who repeatedly used his cinematic chops and Hollywood status to prey on women who came into his professional orbit.

“When it comes to young women he’s attracted to, he uses that manipulation to get sex, one way or the other,” regardless of consent, Maazel said.

Besides Breest, four other women testified that Haggis sexually assaulted them at separate points going back to the 1990s — claims that he denies and his lawyer suggested were manufactured to bolster Breest's lawsuit. The other women aren't suing.

There are no criminal charges associated with the case.

The Associated Press generally does not identify people who say they have been sexually assaulted unless they come forward publicly, as Breest has done.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Entertainment, AP Online Movies News, APOnline Celebrity News
© Copyright 2023
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
EXPLAINER: What's known about delays in Nevada vote count
Nevada’s high-profile contests for governor and Senate are too early to call, and details about outstanding ballots are unclear
5:26PM ( 4 minutes ago )
Deliberations in Paul Haggis rape lawsuit set to start
Jurors are expected to start deliberating Thursday in a rape lawsuit against filmmaker Paul Haggis
5:21PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Election takeaways, take 2: Congress control on knife's edge
Wednesday was a day for sorting, sifting and framing of an expensive, exhaustive and highly negative midterm election campaign
5:20PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
2022 midterms live updates: Latest election news from AP
Despite the conclusion of the final day of voting in the 2022 midterm elections, much remains uncertain
4:55PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Snoop Dogg biopic is in development with Universal Pictures
Snoop Dogg is getting a big-screen biopic
2:52PM ( 2 hours ago )
Griner sent to Russian penal colony to serve sentence
American basketball star Brittney Griner's lawyers say she has been sent to a penal colony in Russia to serve her sentence for drug possession
12:44PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
'Black Panther' cast pushes Wakanda forward after Boseman
Letitia Wright hit the Marvel Cinematic Universe scene as King T’Challa’s joyfully witty sister in 2018’s blockbuster “Black Panther.”
6:56PM ( 1 day ago )
New this week: Bruce Springsteen, 'The Big Brunch' and Sonic
This week’s new entertainment releases include albums by Bruce Springsteen and Louis Tomlinson, Olivia Wilde's “Don't Worry Darling” hits HBO Max, and Dan Levy of Emmy-winning “Schitt’s Creek” fame has “The Big Brunch,” a cooking competition he created and hosts
12:36PM ( 2 days ago )
Jimmy Kimmel to host Oscars again: 'Great honor or a trap'
Jimmy Kimmel is ready to host the Oscars again
9:42AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Online Movies News
American Brittney Griner moved to a penal colony in Russia
The jailed American basketball star Brittney Griner has been moved to a penal colony in Russia
1:56AM ( 15 hours ago )
Trump ally faces election defender in Arizona governor race
The appeal of Donald Trump’s movement will be put to the test Tuesday in the race for governor of Arizona
2:27PM ( 1 day ago )
Kim Kardashian honored at CFDA awards, calls for inclusivity
Kim Kardashian was honored at Monday’s annual Council of Fashion Designers of America Fashion Awards for her shapewear line and used the honor to call for designers to be inclusive for all body shapes
12:46PM ( 1 day ago )
APOnline Celebrity News
Election takeaways, take 2: Congress control on knife's edge
Wednesday was a day for sorting, sifting and framing of an expensive, exhaustive and highly negative midterm election campaign
5:20PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Abortion supporters win in conservative, liberal states
Abortion rights supporters won in the four states where access was on the ballot
5:18PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Warnock, Walker advance to runoff for Senate seat in Georgia
Democratic Sen. Raphael Warnock and Republican challenger Herschel Walker will meet in a Dec. 6 runoff in Georgia after neither reached the general election majority required under state law
5:16PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Facebook parent Meta cuts 11,000 jobs, 13% of workforce
Facebook parent Meta is laying off 13% of its employees as it contends with faltering revenue and broader tech industry woes
5:15PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Biden hopes Putin will negotiate WNBA star Griner's release
President Joe Biden says he hopes Russian President Vladimir Putin will be more willing to negotiate the release of WNBA star Brittney Griner now that the U.S. midterm elections are over
5:12PM ( 17 minutes ago )