clearn.png
Tuesday January 18th, 2022 6:00AM

Transgender athlete ban, backed by Noem, clears committee

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

PIERRE, S.D. (AP) — A South Dakota legislative committee on Friday approved a bill championed by Gov. Kristi Noem to ban transgender women and girls from participating in school sports leagues that match their gender identity.

With the Republican governor's full-fledged lobbying, the bill received enthusiastic approval in the Republican-dominated Senate State Affairs committee, clearing a legislative hurdle that has been a key roadblock to similar South Dakota bills in the past. It was the first bill the committee took up this year as lawmakers try to fast-track it through the Statehouse.

Every Republican on the committee approved the bill, despite warnings from opponents that it alienates and bullies transgender students and exposes public schools to legal action for a political cause that has not been an issue in South Dakota. Proponents say it protects girls’ sports from trans athletes who may be bigger, faster and stronger than their peers.

“Passage of this bill would directly hurt children,” said Jennifer Phalen, whose transgender daughter aspires to participate in school gymnastics. “It would directly hurt my daughter and take away her freedom to participate in activities with her peers.”

“As a parent, I don’t really care if she becomes an elite athlete, but I want her to have the experiences of being on a team,” she told the committee in an emotional testimony.

If the bill passes the Legislature, South Dakota could be the 10th Republican-dominated state to adopt such a ban on transgender women or girls. In two of those states — Idaho and West Virginia — the laws have been halted by federal judges. The U.S. Department of Justice has challenged bans in other states, slamming them as violations of federal law.

But lawmakers have used as ammunition the Pennsylvania case of a 22-year-old transgender woman who has had a dominant year swimming for the University of Pennsylvania, as proof that trans athletes possess an unfair advantage over their competition.

“Allowing males to compete destroys fair competition and athletic opportunities for girls," Rachel Oglesby, the governor's policy advisor, told the committee. "Similarly gifted and trained males will always have physical advantages over females.”

The high school activities association asserted that it already has a policy in place that ensures fair competition. The schools evaluate applications from transgender athletes on a case-by-case basis and have only once allowed a trans girl to play in a girls’ league. She did not spoil the competition, the athletics association has said.

Groups representing public schools said politicians are forcing them to choose between violating state law or federal policy. The Associated School Boards warned that schools could lose federal funds if an investigation from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services found them to have violated students' rights.

“This particular bill does nothing, does absolutely nothing as far as helping young people," said Dianna Miller, representing South Dakota's largest school districts. “What it is is discriminatory, unfair, and it’s not necessary.”

In an acknowledgment that schools were being put at legal risk, the governor's office amended the bill to stipulate that the state would provide legal representation and pay the costs of any lawsuits. Mark Miller, the governor's chief of staff, insisted that the proposed law complied with the Constitution, that other states had successfully implemented similar laws and the state would prevail in court if sued.

Noem last year shied away from signing a similar bill, issuing a “style and form veto” and arguing that it was flawed because it put the state at risk of litigation and retribution from the NCAA.

But this year, she seized on the momentum of a cause taking hold among Republicans and trumpeted her support for “protecting fairness in women's sports" as she tries to rehabilitate her standing with social conservatives.

Noem launched a campaign ad this week that claimed she “never backed down” on the issue. And if there was any doubt that her political ambitions lie beyond South Dakota — the state where she is running for reelection and where the proposed law would take effect — the ad is running on channels nationwide.

That's led critics to decry the bill as nothing more than propaganda.

“This isn’t about an issue that’s really happening in South Dakota,” said Roger Tellinghuisen, representing the Human Rights Campaign, an organization that advocates for LGBTQ people. “It’s a political statement — that’s all it is.”

Noem warming to the issue shows the growing clout of social conservatives in the GOP and their ability to cajole politicians into supporting legislation that discriminates against LGBTQ people.

Jon Schweppe, the director of policy at the social conservative group, American Principles Project, praised Noem's bill after last year slamming her for effectively killing the legislation.

“To see her now coming out with a stronger bill, to see her championing this issue and making it her priority, we haven’t really seen anything like that before with Republicans," he said. "I think it’s a significant moment."

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Ohio Supreme Court rejects GOP-drawn congressional map
The Ohio Supreme Court has rejected a new map of the state’s 15 congressional districts as gerrymandered, sending the blueprint back for another try
2:18PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Transgender athlete ban, backed by Noem, clears committee
A South Dakota legislative committee has approved a bill championed by Gov. Kristi Noem to ban transgender women and girls from participating in school sports leagues that match their gender identity
2:14PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Dutch government eases lockdown, but not for hospitality
The Dutch government has eased its coronavirus lockdown, allowing non-essential stores, universities, sports clubs and “contact businesses” like hairdressers to reopen for the first time in nearly a month
1:55PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Djokovic faces deportation as Australia revokes visa again
Tennis star Novak Djokovic faces deportation again after the Australian government revoked his visa for a second time
1:21PM ( 1 hour ago )
December retail sales slip after a record holiday season
Americans overlooked shortages, spiking prices and uncertainty over the omicron variant to break spending records during the critical holiday shopping season
1:15PM ( 1 hour ago )
Goodbye 'godsend': Expiration of child tax credits hits home
For the first time in half a year, families on Friday are going without a monthly deposit from the child tax credit
12:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Michigan AG asks feds to investigate fake GOP electors
Michigan’s attorney general is asking federal prosecutors to open a criminal investigation into 16 Republicans who submitted false certificates stating they were the state’s presidential electors despite Joe Biden’s 154,000-vote victory in 2020
10:19AM ( 4 hours ago )
Hearing to decide if Waukesha parade suspect will face trial
A Wisconsin court commissioner is poised to decide whether a Milwaukee man accused of plowing his SUV through a suburban Christmas parade, killing six people and injuring dozens more, will stand trial
10:15AM ( 4 hours ago )
Wisconsin Gov. Evers' reelection pitch: democracy is at risk
Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers is known for his folksy demeanor, sprinkling his speeches with “by gollys” and the occasional PG-rated swear word
11:51PM ( 14 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
US official: Russia prepping pretext for Ukraine invasion
The Biden administration has determined that a Russian effort is underway to create a pretext for its troops to potentially further invade Ukraine
11:16AM ( 3 hours ago )
Bill would require Senate confirmation for US prison chief
Lawmakers want the Senate to have a say in who leads the troubled federal Bureau of Prisons
11:08AM ( 3 hours ago )
Biden nominates 3 for Fed board, including first Black woman
President Joe Biden nominated three people for the Federal Reserve’s Board of Governors, including Sarah Bloom Raskin, a former Fed and Treasury official, for the top regulatory slot and Lisa Cook, who would be the first Black woman to serve on the board
10:05AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
In Washington, a day of snapshots of divisions and futility
Thursday saw a closed-door huddle by an embattled President Joe Biden with his own party’s senators, apparently for naught
1:34AM ( 12 hours ago )
Biden all but concedes defeat on voting, election bills
President Joe Biden is all but conceding defeat for this year on the Democrats' big elections and voting rights legislation
1:24AM ( 12 hours ago )
Biden chooses 3 for Fed board, including first Black woman
President Joe Biden will nominate three people for the Federal Reserve’s Board of Governors, including Sarah Bloom Raskin, a former Fed and Treasury official, for the top regulatory slot and Lisa Cook, who would be the first Black woman to serve on the Fed’s board
12:05AM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Ohio Supreme Court rejects GOP-drawn congressional map
The Ohio Supreme Court has rejected a new map of the state’s 15 congressional districts as gerrymandered, sending the blueprint back for another try
2:18PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Dutch government eases lockdown, but not for hospitality
The Dutch government has eased its coronavirus lockdown, allowing non-essential stores, universities, sports clubs and “contact businesses” like hairdressers to reopen for the first time in nearly a month
1:55PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Cyber attack in Albuquerque latest to target public schools
Around 75,000 New Mexico schoolchildren are missing school Friday for the second day after a cyber attack hit the state's largest school district on Wednesday
1:51PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Ex-EPA workers ask Virginia senators not to confirm Wheeler
More than 150 former Environmental Protection Agency employees are writing to the Virginia Senate, asking the Democrat-controlled chamber to oppose the nomination of former EPA administrator Andrew Wheeler to GOP Gov.-elect Glenn Youngkin’s Cabinet
1:43PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Waukesha parade suspect to stand trial for murder
A Wisconsin court commissioner has ordered a Milwaukee man accused of plowing his SUV through a suburban Christmas parade, killing six people and injuring dozens more, to stand trial
1:40PM ( 42 minutes ago )