clearn.png
Tuesday January 18th, 2022 5:45AM

Ohio Supreme Court rejects GOP-drawn congressional map

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — Ohio's Republican-drawn congressional map was rejected by the state's high court Friday, giving hope to national Democrats who had argued it unfairly delivered several potentially competitive seats in this year's critical midterm elections to Republicans.

In the 4-3 decision, the Ohio Supreme Court returned the map to the Ohio General Assembly, where Republicans hold supermajorities in both chambers, and then to the powerful Ohio Redistricting Commission. The two bodies have a combined 60 days to draw new lines that comply with a 2018 constitutional amendment against gerrymandering.

The commission was already in the process of reconstituting so it can redraw GOP-drawn legislative maps the court also rejected this week as gerrymandered. That decision gave the panel 10 days to comply.

With Feb. 2 and March 4 looming as the filing dates for legislative and congressional candidates, respectively, the decisions have raised questions of whether the state's May 3 primary may have to be extended.

Ohio Republican Party Chair Bob Paduchik called the situation a mess, criticizing the Ohio Supreme Court for giving the commission less than two weeks to come up with new legislative maps.

“That’s a lot to dump on a commission with a very short period of time,” he said during a forum at the City Club of Cleveland on Friday. “It’s hard to say what’s going to happen.”

Justices chastised Republicans in both decisions for flouting the voters' wishes and the Constitution and directed them to move with haste.

Writing for the majority, Justice Michael Donnelly wrote, ”(T)he evidence in these cases makes clear beyond all doubt that the General Assembly did not heed the clarion call sent by Ohio voters to stop political gerrymandering.”

Donnelly and the court's other two Democrats were joined by Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor, a moderate Republican set to depart the court due to age limits at the end of the year.

The court’s three other Republicans — including Justice Pat DeWine, son of Republican Gov. Mike DeWine, a named plaintiff in the cases — raised their objections in an unprecedented “joint dissent” that failed to identify its author. The majority called the format “unusual and inexplicable.”

In it, the three said it was unclear how it should be determined that a map “unduly favors” one party over another.

“When the majority says that the plan unduly favors the Republican Party, what it means is that the plan unduly favors the Republican Party as compared to the results that would be obtained if we followed a system of proportional representation,” the dissent said.

They explained that the U.S. has never adopted a system that requires congressional seats to be proportionally distributed to match the popular vote, nor does Ohio’s Constitution require it.

In her separate opinion, O'Connor said voting-rights and Democratic groups that challenge the maps never argued strict proportionality was required.

“The dissenting opinion’s dismissive characterization of all the metrics used by petitioners’ experts as simply being measures of ‘proportional representation’ is sleight of hand,” she wrote. “No magician’s trick can hide what the evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates: the map statistically presents such a partisan advantage that it unduly favors the Republican Party.”

Friday's decision affects separate lawsuits brought by the National Democratic Redistricting Commission’s legal arm, as well as the Ohio offices of the League of Women Voters and the A. Philip Randolph Institute. The groups calculated that either 12 or 13 of the map’s 15 districts favor Republicans, despite the GOP garnering only about 54% of votes in statewide races over the past decade.

Republicans had defended the map — which was pushed through the approval process in a flurry — as fair, constitutional and “highly competitive.”

Voting rights advocates and Democrats praised the court's ruling, their second victory this week.

“The manipulation of districts is the manipulation of elections and voters have had enough,” said Catherine Turcer, executive director of Common Cause Ohio, a plaintiff. “We expect legislative leaders to learn from their mistakes and finally listen to the people’s call for fair maps.”

Ohio and other states were required to redraw their congressional maps to reflect results of the 2020 census, under which Ohio lost one of its current 16 districts due to lagging population.

___

Associated Press writer John Seewer in Toledo, Ohio, contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
5 players are unanimous choices for AP's NFL All-Pro Team
Five players, including dynamic pass catchers Cooper Kupp and Davante Adams, are unanimous choices for The Associated Press 2021 NFL All-Pro Team
12:30PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Cyberattack in Ukraine targets government websites
Ukrainian officials say a cyberattack has left a number of government websites temporarily unavailable
12:29PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Waukesha parade suspect to stand trial for murder
A Wisconsin court commissioner has ordered a Milwaukee man accused of plowing his SUV through a suburban Christmas parade, killing six people and injuring dozens more, to stand trial
12:20PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Treasury: Arizona risks relief funds over anti-mandate rules
The Biden administration is threatening to recoup COVID-19 relief funds sent to Arizona over state provisions that it says discourage families and school districts from following federal guidance recommending face coverings in schools
11:57AM ( 46 minutes ago )
US official: Russia prepping pretext for Ukraine invasion
The Biden administration has determined that a Russian effort is underway to create a pretext for its troops to potentially further invade Ukraine
11:16AM ( 1 hour ago )
December retail sales fall 1.9% after early holiday rush
Americans, beset by product shortages, rising prices and the arrival of omicron, sharply cut their spending in December after a burst of early spending in the fall that helped bolster the holiday season
11:06AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Bad luck: Pope acknowledges he got caught at record store
Pope Francis has long lamented that he can’t walk around town unnoticed like he used to before becoming pope
9:20AM ( 3 hours ago )
December retail sales slide 1.9% amid shortages, omicron
Americans, beset by product shortages, rising prices and the arrival of omicron, sharply cut their spending in December after a burst of spending in the fall that helped bolster the holiday season
8:43AM ( 4 hours ago )
Djokovic faces deportation as Australia revokes visa again
Tennis star Novak Djokovic faces deportation again after the Australian government revoked his visa for a second time
8:43AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
5 players are unanimous choices for AP's NFL All-Pro Team
Five players, including dynamic pass catchers Cooper Kupp and Davante Adams, are unanimous choices for The Associated Press 2021 NFL All-Pro Team
12:30PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Cyberattack in Ukraine targets government websites
Ukrainian officials say a cyberattack has left a number of government websites temporarily unavailable
12:29PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Waukesha parade suspect to stand trial for murder
A Wisconsin court commissioner has ordered a Milwaukee man accused of plowing his SUV through a suburban Christmas parade, killing six people and injuring dozens more, to stand trial
12:20PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Japan’s Kobayashi among favorites in wide-open ski jumping
Three-time Olympic ski jumping champion Kamil Stoch has an injured left leg that is knocking him out of World Cup competition this week in his native Poland
12:14PM ( 29 minutes ago )
#BettyWhiteChallenge raising money and awareness for animals
The late Betty White was a tireless advocate for animals for her entire life, from caring for homeless animals as a child to launching her own weekly TV show “The Pet Set” dedicated to her celebrity friends and their pets
12:03PM ( 40 minutes ago )