Monday May 23rd, 2022 6:34AM

Suit highlights suburban unease with addiction centers

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

CHICAGO (AP) — A Chicago-based addiction treatment center, which like others nationwide has faced fierce opposition to opening suburban branches, filed a federal lawsuit Tuesday to force one suburb to stop blocking its expansion plans.

The suit brought by the Haymarket Center, the largest nonprofit treatment service in Chicago, says the city of Itasca’s rejection of a 240-bed facility in a former hotel violates U.S. laws, including the Americans with Disabilities Act, that bar discrimination against those recovering from addictions.

Elsewhere, including in Florida, Massachusetts, New Jersey and Michigan, communities have also thwarted the opening of such facilities. Treatment advocates say the resistance highlights how everyone seems to recognize the need for the facilities amid the ongoing opioid crisis — but bristle at putting them in their neighborhoods.

In November, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said drug overdoses spiked during the pandemic, registering over 100,000 overdose deaths from April 2020 to April 2021 — a U.S. record for a 12-month stretch. It was an increase of nearly 30% from the roughly 78,000 deaths for the same period the year before.

Many residents in Itasca, a middle-class community of 9,000, mounted a two-year battle against the Haymarket facility, saying they feared it would lead to an uptick in crime and lost tax revenue, as well as strain Itasca’s one-ambulance emergency service.

Some in Itasca and from nearby suburbs supported the plans, saying a dearth of facilities makes treatment for suburbanites less accessible.

Opponents held multiple street protests. During one in 2019, a supporter of the facility, Felicia Miceli, held a photo of Louie Miceli, her son who died in 2012 of a heroin overdose at 24, as marchers passed.

“There were people who approached me and would say, ‘Sorry for your loss, but we don’t want it here,’” she recalled Tuesday in a phone interview with The Associated Press. “Other people glared at me.”

She added: “I don’t want to hold up a picture of my beautiful son who is gone. But it’s necessary.”

Miceli, who also founded a treatment advocacy, believes increased isolation during the pandemic explains the rise in overdoses. She said she has gone to a funeral or wake of someone who overdosed every few weeks for the last four months.

“The opposite of addiction is connection,” she said. “And those connections have been lost during COVID.”

The lawsuit alleges Itasca officials “strategically fostered, intentionally contributed to, and were unduly negatively influenced by this ‘not in my backyard’ opposition.” It accused them of seeking pretexts to reject the proposal amid “discriminatory stereotyping of Haymarket’s mission” and the patients it would serve.

Village Administrator Carie Anne Ergo declined to comment on Tuesday.

After some 35 hearings, Itasca’s plan commission and board voted unanimously late last year against approving Haymarket’s plans.

The lawsuit says Haymarket went out of its way to address some of Itasca’s concerns, including by agreeing to contract a private ambulance to respond to calls from the treatment facility.

Before Tuesday’s filing in Chicago federal court, Itasca Mayor Jeff Pruyn denied discrimination underpinned opposition, saying the proposed facility didn’t comply with criteria applied to everyone.

Pruyn said at a hearing before votes against the plans that his primary concern was a financial one. He contended that Itasca, one of the region's smallest communities, “was going to have to absorb 100% of the cost, risk and burden of servicing a facility ... accepting residents beyond Itasca.” He said he ultimately concluded that “Haymarket’s request on our village is unreasonable.”

Interest in the plan in Itasca was intense from the start. One early hearing at a high school gym meant to give the public a chance to comment was postponed because the venue couldn’t accommodate the more than 1,300 people who showed up.

Pressure on Itasca won’t only come from the new civil litigation.

Two months ago, Chicago-based U.S. Attorney John Lausch sent a letter to Itasca’s mayor telling him prosecutors are investigating whether the city violated federal anti-discrimination laws in rejecting Haymarket’s proposal. The letter included a three-page list of documents investigators sought, including communications between Itasca officials.

The lead attorneys in the Haymarket suit are from Access Living, a Chicago-based advocacy group that has helped win landmark cases for the rights of people with disabilities.

Haymarket says that between 2017 and 2018, nearly 2,000 people recovering from addictions who reside in communities outside Chicago sought treatment at its Chicago facility, which included hundreds from the Itasca area, the lawsuit says.

Those unable to pay for treatment at for-profit centers are particularly vulnerable, according to the filing. Haymarket cites figures that only some 10% of those who qualify for such services actually get it.

The lawsuit names, among others, the village, Pruyn and the Itasca Plan Commission as defendants. It seeks an order allowing the facility to open, unspecified damages and payment of attorneys’ fees.


Follow Michael Tarm on Twitter at

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Health, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Watson to be honorary Masters starter with Nicklaus, Player
Tom Watson is returning to the first tee at the Masters as an honorary starter
11:33AM ( 1 minute ago )
Suit highlights suburban unease with addiction centers
A Chicago-based addiction treatment center has filed a federal lawsuit to force one suburb to stop blocking its plans to set up a new treatment branch
11:28AM ( 5 minutes ago )
Grand Ole Opry under fire for Morgan Wallen performance
The Grand Ole Opry, country music's most historic and storied stage, is getting heavy criticism for an appearance by troubled country star Morgan Wallen
11:28AM ( 5 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Chicago union leaders OK plan to resume in-person class
Students in the nation's third-largest school district will resume classes this week after leaders of the Chicago Teachers Union accepted a proposal with the district over COVID-19 safety protocols
10:39AM ( 55 minutes ago )
US announces $308 million in aid for Afghans as crisis grows
The United States has announced $308 million in additional humanitarian assistance for Afghanistan
10:34AM ( 59 minutes ago )
China locks down 3rd city, raising affected to 20 million
A third Chinese city has locked down its residents because of a COVID-19 outbreak, raising the number confined to their homes in China to about 20 million people
10:33AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Safety doors failed in NYC high-rise fire that killed 17
Investigators are trying to determine why safety doors failed to close in a New York City high-rise when a deadly fire broke out
3:17AM ( 8 hours ago )
Sorrow, grief shatter Bronx community after deadly fire
Sorrow is welling across a Bronx community Monday, a day after a fire and choking smoke engulfed a high-rise apartment complex and killed 17 people, eight of them children
11:12PM ( 12 hours ago )
Pilot rescued from wreckage in LA moments before train hits
Police body-camera video shows a harrowing rescue in California, where a small plane crashed on railroad tracks shortly after takeoff from a suburban Los Angeles airfield
10:21PM ( 13 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Author Kwame Alexander to launch new trilogy this fall
A trilogy by award-winning children’s author Kwame Alexander that tells the saga of an African family begins this fall with “The Door of No Return.”
10:43AM ( 50 minutes ago )
Federal Reserve's Powell: High inflation 'exacts a toll'
High inflation is taking a toll on American families
10:39AM ( 55 minutes ago )
Lithuania: Taiwan to set up $1B credit fund amid China spat
Taiwan will set up a $1 billion credit program aimed at funding projects by Lithuanian and Taiwanese companies amid economic pressure from China over an office that the island opened in the European Union country
10:38AM ( 55 minutes ago )
AP Business
Fed vice chair is latest official to quit in trading scandal
Federal Reserve Vice Chair Richard Clarida said he will step down on Friday, the third Fed official to resign in the wake of a trading scandal at the central bank
5:53PM ( 17 hours ago )
Fed Vice Chair Richard Clarida resigns amid trading scandal
Federal Reserve Vice Chair Richard Clarida said he will step down on Friday, the third Fed official to resign in the wake of a trading scandal at the central bank
5:26PM ( 18 hours ago )
Former Biden adviser Symone Sanders to host MSNBC show
MSNBC says it has hired former Biden aide Symone Sanders to host a weekend television show and another on its Peacock streaming service
10:33AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Grand Ole Opry under fire for Morgan Wallen performance
The Grand Ole Opry, country music's most historic and storied stage, is getting heavy criticism for an appearance by troubled country star Morgan Wallen
11:28AM ( 5 minutes ago )
UK's Johnson accused of breaking lockdown with garden party
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson is facing a wave of public and political outrage over allegations that he and his staff flouted coronavirus lockdown rules by holding a garden party in 2020 while Britons were barred by law from meeting up with more than one person outside their households
11:17AM ( 16 minutes ago )
Georgia, Tide, Michigan, Cincinnati, Baylor top final Top 25
Georgia is No. 1 in the final Associated Press college football poll of the season after winning its second national title by beating Alabama
11:06AM ( 27 minutes ago )
Brrr! Some schools close as extreme cold grips US Northeast
A mass of arctic air swept into the Northeast, bringing bone-chilling sub-zero temperatures and closing schools across the region for the second time in less than a week
11:03AM ( 30 minutes ago )
EPA moves to crack down on dangerous coal ash storage ponds
The Environmental Protection Agency is taking its first major action to address toxic wastewater from coal-burning power plants
11:02AM ( 31 minutes ago )