cloudy.png
Monday January 17th, 2022 3:06PM
12:00AM ( 15 hours ago ) Weather Alert
3:00PM ( 2 days ago ) Weather Alert

Trump attorneys cite immunity, want Jan. 6 lawsuits tossed

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Attorneys for former President Donald Trump and his associates argued Monday that incendiary statements by Trump and others last Jan. 6 prior to the Capitol riot were protected speech and in line with their official duties.

In response to civil suits running parallel to Congress' own Jan. 6 inquiry, Trump's lawyers claimed he was acting within his official rights and had no intention to spark violence when he called on thousands of supporters to “march to the Capitol” and “fight like hell” to disrupt the Senate's certification of the 2020 election results.

“There has never been an example of someone successfully being able to sue a president for something that happened during his term of office,” said Trump lawyer Jesse Binnall. “That absolute immunity of the presidency is very important.”

The five-hour hearing in Washington before U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta concerned Trump's attempts to have the civil suits dismissed. Democratic Rep. Eric Swalwell of California brought one of the suits against Trump and a host of others, including Donald Trump Jr., Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani, Alabama Republican Rep. Mo Brooks and right-wing group the Oath Keepers, charging responsibility for the violent breach of the Capitol building by Trump supporters.

The other lawsuits, brought by Democratic representatives and two Capitol Police officers, claim that statements by Trump and Brooks on and before Jan. 6 essentially qualify as part of a political campaign, and are therefore fair game for litigation. Plaintiffs are seeking damages for the physical and emotional injuries they sustained during the insurrection.

“What he spoke about was a campaign issue, seeking to secure an election,” said Joseph Sellers, one of the attorney's representing Swalwell's suit. “This was a purely private act.”

Sellers said Trump's statements were an overt and unambiguous call for political violence.

“It's hard to conceive of a scenario other than the president traveling down to the Capitol himself and busting through the doors ... but of course he did that through 3rd-party agents, through the crowd,” he said.

Binnall argued that Trump's calls to derail the Senate vote certification process were in line with any executive's right to comment or criticize a co-equal government branch.

“A president always has the authority to speak on whether or not any of the other branches, frankly, can or should take action,” he said, refencing cases where former President Barack Obama publicly commented on Supreme Court decisions.

Binnall argued that Trump has already been subject to a trial over Jan. 6 — his second impeachment trial, where he was acquitted by the then-Republican-majority Senate.

“That was their remedy and they failed," he said. “They don’t get another bite of the apple here.”

Mehta repeatedly cut off lawyers on both sides with questions and challenges.

Giuliani lawyer Joseph Sibley at one point stated, “There's simply no way you can construe the statements that were made by any of the speakers to be an invitation to join a conspiracy to go to the Capitol and commit crimes.”

Mehta immediately asked, “Why not?”

The judge then refenced Trump's own Jan. 6 speech in detail.

“His last words were ‘go to the Capitol’ and before that it was ‘show strength’ and ‘fight.’ Why isn't that a plausible invitation to do exactly what the rioters ended up doing?” Mehta asked. ”Those words are hard to walk back."

Mehta at one point focused on the hours-long silence from Trump as his supporters battled Capitol Police and D.C. police officers and rampaged through the building. He questioned Binnall at length about whether that failure or refusal to condemn the assault as it was happening could be interpreted as approval.

Binnall responded, “You can not have a situation where the president is obligated to take certain actions or say certain things or else be subject to litigation.”

Brooks has invoked the Westfall Act, a statue that protects federal employees from being sued over actions taken while performing their official duties. However, Justice Department lawyer Brian Boynton told the court that Brooks should be denied such protection.

The fact that Brooks was “advocating for the election of President Trump with these remarks at a Trump rally does make this a campaign activity,” Boynton said.

Brooks, who represented himself in Monday's proceedings, told the court that a House of Representatives ethics committee declined to pursue charges against him. He added that there was no ongoing campaign to participate in on Jan. 6.

“The campaign for election ended on November 3,” Brooks said. “Everything after that was a legal proceeding.”

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Trump attorneys cite immunity, want Jan. 6 lawsuits tossed
Attorneys for former President Donald Trump and his associates argue that incendiary statements by Trump and others last Jan. 6 prior to the Capitol riot were protected speech and in line with their official duties
9:01PM ( 8 minutes ago )
US sanctions Nicaragua officials as Ortega inaugurated again
The U.S. Treasury Department has slapped sanctions on more Nicaraguan officials, on the day President Daniel Ortega is to be sworn following highly questionable elections
8:44PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Report: Bob Saget found dead lying in hotel bed, no trauma
Comedian and actor Bob Saget was found dead lying face up on his bed in a luxury hotel room in Florida with no signs of trauma
8:41PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Home COVID tests to be covered by insurers starting Saturday
Starting Saturday, private health insurers will be required to cover up to eight home COVID-19 tests per month for those on their plans
6:25PM ( 2 hours ago )
California's Newsom wants health coverage for all immigrants
Gov. Gavin Newsom wants to make California the first state to cover all low-income state residents under its Medicaid plan regardless of their immigration status
4:58PM ( 4 hours ago )
Biden raises concerns to Ethiopian PM about Tigray conflict
President Joe Biden expressed concerns on Monday to Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed about detentions and civilian killings in the conflict in the country's Tigray region, while commending Abiy for the recent release of several political prisoners
4:03PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Inflation up, virus down as priorities in US: AP-NORC poll
The coronavirus pandemic is beginning to recede as a top priority in the minds of Americans
2:02PM ( 7 hours ago )
GOP election needs could dominate 2022 Georgia session
Georgia’s General Assembly has opened for business with Republican primary politics shaping the agenda
1:11PM ( 7 hours ago )
Dutch king swears in new ruling coalition, Rutte's 4th
Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte has embarked on a fourth term
8:00AM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Macron talks up security in French conservative stronghold
French President Emmanuel Macron has traveled to the country's Mediterranean coast to talk about internal security
11:40AM ( 9 hours ago )
Former Biden adviser Symone Sanders to host MSNBC show
MSNBC says it has hired former Biden aide Symone Sanders to host a weekend television show and another on its Peacock streaming service
10:33AM ( 10 hours ago )
Opposition candidate wins in Venezuela's cradle of Chavismo
Voters in the home state of Venezuela’s late President Hugo Chávez have picked an opposition candidate for governor in a closely watched special election called after the contender representing that faction in November’s regular contest was retroactively disqualified as he was ahead in the vote count
10:55PM ( 22 hours ago )
AP Elections
Biden warns of US peril from Trump's 'dagger' at democracy
President Joe Biden is forcefully accusing Donald Trump and his supporters of holding a “dagger at the throat of democracy” with his election lies that sparked last year’s deadly assault on the U.S. Capitol
12:05AM ( 3 days ago )
Biden decries Trump backers' 'dagger at throat' of democracy
President Joe Biden is accusing Donald Trump and his supporters of holding a “dagger at the throat of democracy."
2:08PM ( 4 days ago )
What if? Path was uncertain if Pence objected to Biden's win
In the weeks before the Jan. 6, 2021, certification of President Joe Biden’s victory, a small group of House Democrats huddled to contemplate what they would do if then-Vice President Mike Pence tried to overturn the presidential election
3:38PM ( 5 days ago )
General Election News
In South Korea, hair loss emerges as new election issue
South Korean presidential candidate Lee Jae-myung isn’t bald
1:41PM ( 4 days ago )
Biden decries 'big lie,' blames Trump for insurrection
President Joe Biden has marked the anniversary of the violent Capitol insurrection by forcefully condemning Donald Trump’s election “big lie” that sparked the deadly breaching of the building and continues to motivate deep national division
10:17AM ( 4 days ago )
Biden marks year since attack: 'I will stand in this breach'
President Joe Biden and members of Congress are solemnly marking the first anniversary of the Jan. 6 U.S. Capitol insurrection
9:45AM ( 4 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
Rights group verifies Polish senator was hacked with spyware
Amnesty International says it has independently confirmed that an Israeli company's powerful spyware was used to hack a Polish senator when he was running the opposition’s 2019 parliamentary election campaign
2:27PM ( 4 days ago )
As South Dakota campaigns launch, Thune mulls retirement
South Dakota political candidates are revving into full campaign mode this week, with one big exception — Republican Sen. John Thune
5:11PM ( 1 week ago )
Judge denies Rep. Fortenberry's motions to dismiss charges
A federal judge has rejected U.S. Rep. Jeff Fortenberry’s attempts to dismiss charges accusing the Nebraska Republican of making false statements to FBI agents who were investigating an illegal foreign donation to his campaign
3:42PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
US sanctions Nicaragua officials as Ortega inaugurated again
The U.S. Treasury Department has slapped sanctions on more Nicaraguan officials, on the day President Daniel Ortega is to be sworn following highly questionable elections
8:44PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Report: Bob Saget found dead lying in hotel bed, no trauma
Comedian and actor Bob Saget was found dead lying face up on his bed in a luxury hotel room in Florida with no signs of trauma
8:41PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Damaged O'Keeffe painting on display again after restoration
A damaged Georgia O’Keeffe painting is back on display after conservators spent 1,250 hours and $145,000 restoring the piece
8:38PM ( 31 minutes ago )
N. Korea fires possible missile into sea amid stalled talks
South Korea and Japan say North Korea has fired what appeared to be a ballistic missile into its eastern sea
8:33PM ( 36 minutes ago )
14-year-old girl shot by police remembered at LA funeral
Family, friends, civil rights activists and community members memorialized a 14-year-old girl shot and killed in a clothing store dressing room when Los Angeles police fired at a suspect and a bullet pierced a wall
8:24PM ( 45 minutes ago )