clearn.png
Saturday October 16th, 2021 10:59PM

Elizabeth Holmes drawn as villain, underdog as trial begins

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAN JOSE, Calif. (AP) — Prosecutors and defense attorneys sketched dueling portraits of fallen Silicon Valley star Elizabeth Holmes as her trial got underway Wednesday, alternatively describing her as a greedy villain who faked her way to the top and as a passionate underdog whose spent years trying to shake up the health care industry.

The two sides are now expected to spend the next three months trying to sway a 12-person jury impaneled to hearing the evidence in a case airing allegations that Holmes used her startup, Theranos, as a scheme to realize her dreams of becoming rich and as famous as one of her role models, late Apple co-founder Steve Jobs.

Once hailed as a billionaire on paper, Holmes is now facing a sentence of up to 20 years if convicted of the felony charges.

Holmes' rise and fall has already been the subject of documentaries, books and podcasts, feeding the fervor that has built up around a trial that has been delayed twice since she was indicted nearly three years ago. With roughly only 75 spots available for the media and general public to observe the proceedings, people began to line up outside the San Jose, California, courthouse before 5 a.m. Wednesday.

After the jury was seated and U.S. District Judge Edward Davila gave his preliminary instructions, federal prosecutor Robert Leach wasted little time vilifying Holmes.

He cast Holmes in a dark light, depicting her as a conniving entrepreneur who duped investors, customers and patients for years, even though she knew her startup, Theranos, was nearly bankrupt and its much-hyped blood-testing technology was a flop.

“This case is about fraud, about lying and cheating to get money,” Leach said during his roughly 45-minute opening statement.

He said the evidence would show that Theranos was already in deep trouble as far back as 2009, about six years after Holmes founded the Palo Alto, California, company. At that point, Leach said, Holmes resorted to a pattern of lying and hyperbole in an effort to fool major media outlets, wealthy investors such as media mogul Rupert Murdoch, well-connected Theranos board members such as former U.S. Secretaries of State George Shultz and Henry Kissinger, and customers such as Walgreens.

Some of the most damning evidence may be presented by a former top finance officer at Theranos who will testify that the company only had $650,000 in revenue from 2011 through 2014, according to Leach. Yet Holmes was telling investors and other people that Theranos would generate $140 million in revenue in 2014, Leach said.

Holmes, 37, is also accused of promising that Theranos would be able to quickly test small vials of blood in a small company-designed machine named after the famed inventor Thomas Edison. Leach said the samples were actually sent out to outside parties for testing using standard-issue machines he described as “big" and “clunky.”

Theranos eventually failed in 2018, a few years after a series of explosive stories in The Wall Street Journal exposed serious flaws in its technology and spurred regulatory investigations that shut down the testing.

The fraud committed by Holmes “is a fraud on Main Street and it's a fraud in Silicon Valley," Leach told the jury.

Holmes’ defense team countered with a more heroic narrative describing her as a tireless worker who poured more than 15 years of her life in pursuit of a faster, cheaper and less invasive way to test blood samples and screen for disease.

Defense attorney Lance Wade, argued that Holmes was simply trying to wrest control of the blood-testing technology market from two dominant laboratories, Quest Diagnostics and Labcorp. “She did her best day in and day out to make Theranos successful," Wade said of Holmes as he began a roughly 90-minute presentation.

Although she didn't succeed, Wade insisted that Holmes never stopped believing she was on the verge of a breakthrough that would realize her ambitions. Many investors thought she would too, one of the reasons that Theranos once was valued at $9 billion —- with half that amount belonging to Holmes.

“Failure is not a crime," Wade said. “Trying your hardest is not a crime. A failed business does not make a CEO a criminal."

In court documents unsealed just before the trial started, Holmes' lawyers also disclosed that she may take the witness stand to assert some of her statements and actions while running Theranos were the result of “intimate partner abuse” inflicted by the company’s chief operating officer and her secret lover, Ramesh “Sunny” Balwani.

Without going into specifics, Wade told the jury that she believed she was bringing in “the best businessman she knew" when she hired Balwani but now realizes it was one of her biggest mistakes.

“You will learn that Mr. Balwani did not take well to people who disagreed with him," Wade said while asserting Balwani's tempestuous behavior caused many Theranos employees to leave the company.

Balwani also was responsible for overseeing the Theranos lab that the government alleges provided misleading results of blood tests that endangered some people's lives, Wade noted.

“If what government is trying to show is that Theranos' clinical lab was not well run from 2013 to 2016, we will likely agree with what they have to say," Wade said. “Poor operations in the lab was one of Theranos' biggest failures, but it wasn't fraud."

Balwani faces multiple fraud charges in a separate trial scheduled to begin next year. His attorney has denied Holmes' allegations.

____

This story has been corrected with the official names of Quest Diagnostics and Labcorp and Elizabeth Holmes' current age, which is 37.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Health, AP Entertainment, APOnline Celebrity News, AP Business, AP Business - Careers, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Stocks slip as Fed report signals 'downshift' in economy
Stocks are down on Wall Street in afternoon trading Wednesday following a Federal Reserve report that shows U.S. economic activity slowed this summer amid rising worries over resurgent coronavirus cases and mounting supply chain problems and labor shortages
3:11PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Elizabeth Holmes drawn as villain, underdog as trial begins
The highly anticipated fraud trial of fallen Silicon Valley star Elizabeth Holmes began Wednesday with dueling portraits that drew stark contrasts of her as a dastardly, greedy villain and a passionate underdog who spent years trying to shake up the health care industry
3:03PM ( 17 minutes ago )
The Latest: Judge: Florida can't enforce ban on school masks
A Florida judge has ruled the state cannot enforce its ban on mask mandates in public schools while an appeals court sorts out whether the ban is legal
2:47PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Q&A: James Bond director Cary Fukunaga on 'No Time to Die'
The film business is inherently full of starts and stops, but few have experienced the phrase “hurry up and wait” quite like “No Time to Die” director Cary Fukunaga
12:52PM ( 2 hours ago )
Trial set to begin for fallen tech star Elizabeth Holmes
Opening statements are scheduled Wednesday in the trial of Elizabeth Holmes
11:41AM ( 3 hours ago )
Christian Siriano kicks off New York Fashion Week in color
With Katie Holmes and Lil’ Kim on his front row and singer Marina on the mic high above his runway, Christian Siriano helped kicked off New York Fashion Week Tuesday night
9:10AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Elizabeth Holmes' trial to dissect downfall of a tech star
Elizabeth Holmes once seemed destined to fulfill her dream of becoming Silicon Valley's next superstar
3:02PM ( 1 day ago )
London honors Muppets creator Jim Henson with blue plaque
London has honored American Jim Henson, the creator of the Muppets, with a blue plaque outside his former home in the British capital
9:50AM ( 1 day ago )
Andrea Constand writes of Cosby trial, #MeToo in new memoir
Bill Cosby accuser Andrea Constand has penned a memoir out Tuesday that offers a view from her seat at the center of a high-profile #MeToo case
12:05AM ( 1 day ago )
APOnline Celebrity News
Moroccans elect new leaders in shadow of virus
Moroccans are choosing a new parliament and local leaders in elections reshaped by the pandemic
2:11PM ( 1 hour ago )
Blinken to Taliban: Any legitimacy 'will have to be earned'
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken says that any legitimacy or international support for the Taliban “will have to be earned” after Afghanistan’s new rulers announced an interim government that drew a deeply skeptical Western response
2:10PM ( 1 hour ago )
Ida curfew lifted in New Orleans; 250K students still out
New Orleans has lifted a nightly curfew as the city moves closer to regaining full power, but 96% of utility customers in Louisiana's hardest-hit communities are still without electricity
1:41PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Jill Biden heads back to classroom as a working first lady
Jill Biden is going back to her whiteboard
10:17AM ( 1 day ago )
US hiring slows as delta variant weakens travel and tourism
America’s employers added just 235,000 jobs in August, a modest gain after two months of robust hiring at a time when the delta variant’s spread has discouraged some people from flying, shopping and eating out
2:48PM ( 5 days ago )
US hiring slows to just 235,000 jobs after 2 strong months
America’s employers added just 235,000 jobs in August, a modest gain after two months of robust hiring at a time when the delta variant’s spread has discouraged some people from flying, shopping and eating out
9:38AM ( 5 days ago )
AP Business - Careers
Stocks move lower as investors wait for Federal Reserve
Stocks fell in morning trading Wednesday, as investors remain on the sidelines until they get more guidance from the Federal Reserve as well as the direction of the coronavirus pandemic
11:26AM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: WHO chief wants moratorium on booster shots
The head of the World Health Organization is calling on rich countries with large supplies of coronavirus vaccines to refrain from offering booster shots through the end of the year
11:10AM ( 4 hours ago )
Stocks fall slightly as investors wait for Federal Reserve
Stocks were edging lower in early trading Wednesday, as investors remain on the sidelines until they get more guidance from the Federal Reserve as well as the direction of the coronavirus pandemic
10:36AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
After Ida deaths, Louisiana revokes nursing home licenses
Louisiana health officials are revoking the licenses of seven nursing homes that were evacuated to a warehouse where residents died after Hurricane Ida amid conditions deemed squalid and unsafe
7:23PM ( 19 hours ago )
Idaho hospitals begin rationing health care amid COVID surge
Idaho public health leaders are letting the state's northern hospitals ration health care because there are more coronavirus patients than the institutions can handle
7:13PM ( 20 hours ago )
The Latest: N. Carolina has 170 clusters in schools, centers
North Carolina health officials on Tuesday released a report showing 170 ongoing COVID-19 clusters in K-12 schools or child care settings
6:09PM ( 21 hours ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Researchers complete first-ever detailed map of global coral
Researchers have completed a comprehensive online map of the world’s coral reefs by using more than 2 million satellite images
11:37AM ( 3 hours ago )
Private expedition to dive into wreck of M/S Estonia ferry
A privately-funded expedition, commissioned by the relatives of the victims of the M/S Estonia ferry that sank into the Baltic Sea nearly 27 years ago, will conduct a dive into the vessel’s wreck this month
9:13AM ( 6 hours ago )
Amazon to open 2 cashier-less Whole Foods stores next year
There will be something missing at two Whole Foods stores opening next year: the rows of cashiers
3:47AM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Technology News
Stocks slip as Fed report signals 'downshift' in economy
Stocks are down on Wall Street in afternoon trading Wednesday following a Federal Reserve report that shows U.S. economic activity slowed this summer amid rising worries over resurgent coronavirus cases and mounting supply chain problems and labor shortages
3:11PM ( 9 minutes ago )
The Latest: Judge: Florida can't enforce ban on school masks
A Florida judge has ruled the state cannot enforce its ban on mask mandates in public schools while an appeals court sorts out whether the ban is legal
2:47PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Idaho patients in hospital halls amid COVID rationed care
Idaho’s move to crisis standards of care this week is allowing some hospitals to ration health care amid an onslaught of coronavirus patients and officials are warning the the rationing could spread to hospitals statewide
2:40PM ( 40 minutes ago )
Qualifier Raducanu, 18, tops Bencic in US Open quarterfinals
British teenager Emma Raducanu has become the first qualifier in the professional era to reach the U.S. Open semifinals
2:35PM ( 45 minutes ago )
6 rookies on Ryder Cup team; Berger, Scheffler in, Reed out
Steve Stricker has filled out his U.S. Ryder Cup team with six captain's picks
2:23PM ( 57 minutes ago )