Saturday December 4th, 2021 5:02PM

Census data spurred GOP's largest partisan edge in decades

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Fresh off sweeping electoral victories a decade ago, Republican politicians used census data to draw voting districts that gave them a greater political advantage in more states than either party had in the past 50 years, according to a new Associated Press analysis.

That advantage, measured by a formula designed to detect potential gerrymandering, allowed Republicans to hold decade-long majorities in some congressional delegations or statehouses even as Democrats in those states won top-of-the-ticket races for president or statewide offices. In short: Republicans won more seats than would have been expected based on the percentage of votes they received.

The GOP's power will be put to the test starting Thursday, when the U.S. Census Bureau releases 2020 population data that will kick off the next round of the once-a-decade redistricting process. The redrawn districts will take effect in most states starting with the 2022 elections and, if the maps survive expected court challenges, remain in place through the 2030 elections.

Though redistricting can seem wonky, it has big implications for public policy. Republicans who benefited from favorable districts this past decade used their power in state capitols to cut taxes, restrict abortion and curb union bargaining rights.

In Congress, redistricting has resulted in fewer competitive seats for both Republicans and Democrats, leaving less incentive to compromise as politicians appeal further to the right and left. With Republicans needing to gain just five seats to take control of the U.S. House from Democrats, the redistricting getting underway this year ultimately could determine the fate of President Joe Biden's agenda to create new national voting rights and spend more on social programs.

Like 10 years ago, Republicans will have an advantage over Democrats. The GOP will control redistricting in the pivotal states of Texas, Florida and North Carolina — three of the six states gaining seats in the U.S. House. Independent commissions will draw maps in Colorado and Montana, each gaining a seat. Oregon also is adding a seat, but majority Democrats in the House have agreed to share control of the redistricting process with Republicans.

Because of recent redistricting reforms, it could be more difficult for Republicans to maintain their advantage in some states. But in an era of increased political polarization among voters, the past decade showed that it's “really hard for one party to win when the other party has designed the maps,” said Chris Warshaw, a political scientist at George Washington University who analyzes election data.

The AP used a mathematical formula called the “efficiency gap” to calculate the size of partisan advantage in elections for U.S. House seats and in state House and Assembly contests for the 2016, 2018 and 2020 elections.

The formula identifies which parties are more effective at turning their votes into victories. It can point to partisan gerrymandering — when a party maximizes its chances of winning elections by drawing maps that spread voters for the other party among multiple districts or pack large numbers of their political opponents into a single district. The formula also can reveal natural redistricting advantages that occur when like-minded voters cram together, such as the edge that New York Republicans get when Democrats cluster tightly in New York City.

The AP compared its findings to data compiled by Warshaw using a similar formula for hundreds of congressional and state legislative elections dating to the 1970s.

The analysis showed that Republicans' advantages early in the decade generally decreased from 2016 to 2020, as would be expected with changing demographics and shifts in voters' political preferences. But the analysis also showed that the Republican edge lasted longer in more states than for either party in previous decades.

In each election from 2012 to 2020, Republicans in Florida, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, South Carolina and Texas won about one more U.S. House seat than would have been expected based on their average share of the district votes. Republicans controlled the redistricting process after the 2010 census in each of those states except New York, where courts drew the map because the Democratic-led Assembly and Republican-led Senate failed to agree.

Democrats benefited from a similar one-seat congressional advantage in Connecticut and Massachusetts, where they wielded more influence over the redistricting process.

All told, there were eight states with a decade-long partisan tilt of about one congressional seat from 2012-2020 — matching the combined total from 1972-2010, according to Warshaw's data.

For state House and Assembly races this past decade, the data showed a roughly one-quarter percent increase in the proportion of states consistently favoring the same party. Nearly all of those were Republican advantages — in contrast to the 1980s, when Democrats enjoyed an edge in more states.

The Republican-controlled swing states of Florida, North Carolina and Ohio showed a persistent Republican tilt in both their congressional and state House districts.

In Ohio, Republicans won 12 of the 16 U.S. House districts in each election since the last redistricting — taking 75% of the seats even though Republican candidates never received more than 58% of the total two-party votes.

“We have some of the most rigged districts in the country," Luke Feeney, a Democrat who is mayor of the south-central Ohio city of Chillicothe, asserted during an online forum on redistricting last month.

Ohio Senate President Matt Huffman, a Republican, said new redistricting criteria limiting the splitting of counties should put an end to oddly shaped districts, such as the so-called “snake on the lake” that stretches from Toledo to Cleveland to squeeze together a bunch of Democratic voters. However, Hoffman maintains Democrats could have won more seats under the current map if they had run better campaigns in closely contested districts.

“Those who want to simply say, `Well, it’s all because of what the districts are,' well that’s just simply false,” Huffman said. "It’s not just about indexes and parties; it’s about candidates.”

Since the last redistricting, Ohio voters approved a pair of constitutional amendments meant to discourage gerrymandering by requiring bipartisan support for new maps to last a full decade. If Republicans pass maps without a certain level of Democratic support, those districts can last just four years before being redrawn again.

Florida voters also backed a pair of “Fair Districts” constitutional amendments in 2010 prohibiting lawmakers from drawing districts favoring a political party or incumbents. The state Supreme Court approved new districts that took effect with the 2016 election after finding the Republican-led Legislature violated the party-favoritism ban. That cut the GOP advantage in half in the 2016-2018 congressional elections, compared to the two preceding elections under the original Republican-drawn map.

Although Republicans will control redistricting in twice as many states as Democrats, their advantage won't be as strong as it was last time in some key states. Republican-led legislatures will be paired with Democratic governors in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, which both had full GOP control after the 2010 census. In Michigan, a voter-approved citizens commission will handle redistricting instead of lawmakers and the governor.

The AP's analysis showed the Republican advantage in Michigan's state House districts was so large after the GOP drew the maps that it could have played a role in determining control of the chamber in every election this past decade. The analysis also showed a significant Republican tilt in Michigan's U.S. House races from 2012 to 2018.

Though Democrats are likely to make gains in Michigan under maps drawn by the new citizens commission, Republicans may continue to hold an edge because their voters are more geographically dispersed than those favoring Democrats, said Matt Grossmann, a political scientist who directs the Institute for Public Policy and Social Research at Michigan State University.

“Even if you’re not trying to gerrymander on behalf of Republicans, the fact that Democrats are concentrated in cities and in the inner-ring suburbs means that it is easier to accidentally gerrymander on behalf of Republicans,” Grossmann said.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General House Election News
© Copyright 2021
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Live updates: Cuomo resigns as New York governor
An attorney for a former aide of Gov. Andrew Cuomo said his resignation shows “the growing power of women’s voices” since the #MeToo movement began
4:03PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Census data spurred GOP's largest partisan edge in decades
An Associated Press analysis shows that Republicans have benefited from the biggest political advantage in decades because of potential gerrymandering in U.S. House districts and state legislative boundaries
4:00PM ( 9 minutes ago )
British tennis pro Konta: 'massive range' of COVID symptoms
Three-time Grand Slam semifinalist Johanna Konta tells The Associated Press after her return to competition that she dealt with a "massive range of symptoms” when she was sick with COVID-19 last month
3:53PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Kathy Hochul to be 1st female NY governor after Cuomo leaves
As New York’s lieutenant governor, Kathy Hochul has spent years on the road as the friendly face of the administration
3:37PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Prosecutor: Man admitted killing cop during traffic stop
A prosecutor says a man charged with killing a Chicago police officer admitted to investigators that he pulled his handgun out of his waistband during a traffic stop and opened fire
3:16PM ( 53 minutes ago )
'We fought a great battle': Greece defends wildfire response
As Greece’s massive wildfires are being largely tamed, the country’s civil protection chief has strongly defended the country's firefighting efforts
3:15PM ( 55 minutes ago )
AP National News
Dry California tourist town to guests: 'Please conserve'
Tourists flock to the coastal town of Mendocino, California, for its Victorian homes and cliff trails
1:33PM ( 2 hours ago )
Missouri judge says Medicaid expansion must be allowed
A Missouri judge says Gov. Mike Parson can no longer deny Medicaid health care to thousands more newly eligible adults
1:23PM ( 2 hours ago )
Wisconsin governor vetoes GOP bills to restrict absentees
Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers has vetoed bills passed by the state’s Republican-controlled Legislature that would have imposed new restrictions on absentee ballots in the key battleground state
1:12PM ( 2 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Poles protest bill that would silence US-owned TV network
Nationwide demonstrations have begun across Poland against a bill seen as an effort by the country’s nationalist ruling party to silence an independent, U.S.-owned television broadcaster that is often critical of the government
3:30PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Senate debates Dems' $3.5T budget, GOP launches attacks
Democrats have started pushing their $3.5 trillion framework for bolstering family services, health, and environment programs through the Senate
3:19PM ( 50 minutes ago )
Nursing home overhaul bill would boost staffing, oversight
Senior Democratic senators are introducing legislation that responds to the ravages of COVID-19 in nursing homes
2:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Poles to protest bill that would silence US-owned TV network
Nationwide demonstrations are planned across Poland against a bill seen as an effort by the country’s nationalist ruling party to silence an independent, U.S.-owned television broadcaster that is often critical of the government
10:53AM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: Lithuanian protestors decry COVID health passes
Some five thousand people rallied outside Lithuania’s parliament to protest COVID-19 health passes that Lithuanians will need shortly to enter cafes, shops, public transportation and other venues as the Baltic government ponders new restrictions
10:34AM ( 5 hours ago )
Without 'right to repair,' businesses lose time and money
As software and other technologies get infused in more and more products, manufacturers are increasingly making those products difficult to repair, potentially costing business owners time and money
10:32AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Elections to test Zambia's standing as a stable democracy
Zambia’s standing as one of Africa’s most stable democracies is being tested this week in the vote in which President Edgar Lungu is seeking re-election
4:16AM ( 11 hours ago )
Biden imposes sanctions against Belarus' Lukashenko regime
President Joe Biden says the United States is levying new sanctions against Belarus, marking the one-year anniversary of Alexander Lukashenko's election win that the U.S. and international community said was fraught with irregularities
4:33PM ( 23 hours ago )
Infrastructure push slowed by Tennessee senator's objection
A freshman senator has ground the Senate to a crawl in order to slow the passage of a bipartisan $1 trillion infrastructure package
12:58PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections
Trump-backed Carey, centrist Brown win Ohio US House races
Mike Carey, a Donald Trump-backed coal lobbyist, topped Republicans in central Ohio, while Cuyahoga County Council member Shontel Brown scored a victory for the Democratic establishment in Cleveland, in two primary elections for open House seats Tuesday
1:20AM ( 6 days ago )
Brown wins primary for 1 of 2 open House seats in Ohio
County Councilwoman Shontel Brown has held off progressive Nina Turner to win the Democratic primary for an open U.S. House seat in Ohio
10:45PM ( 6 days ago )
Carey, backed by Trump, wins primary for House seat in Ohio
Political newcomer Mike Carey has won the crowded Republican primary for an open U.S. House seat in central Ohio
10:19PM ( 6 days ago )
General House Election News
Live updates: Cuomo resigns as New York governor
An attorney for a former aide of Gov. Andrew Cuomo said his resignation shows “the growing power of women’s voices” since the #MeToo movement began
4:03PM ( 7 minutes ago )
New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo resigning over sexual harassment
New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo says he will resign over a barrage of sexual harassment allegations
3:51PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Landlord kills 2, wounds 1 in rent dispute, Vegas police say
Las Vegas police say a landlord argued with his live-in tenants over unpaid rent before a shooting at a small house near downtown Las Vegas killed two women and left a man with nine gunshot wounds
3:48PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Hospitals run low on nurses as they get swamped with COVID
Right when the coronavirus is roaring back in the United States, hospitals across the country are running short of beds and nursing staff
3:46PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Stocks edge higher as banks, industrials offset tech slide
Stocks are modestly higher on Wall Street as gains in banks and elsewhere in the market outweigh a slide in technology companies
3:40PM ( 30 minutes ago )