Wednesday August 4th, 2021 2:56PM

Supreme Court win for college athletes in compensation case

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court ruled unanimously Monday the NCAA can’t limit education-related benefits — like computers and paid internships — that colleges can offer their sports stars, a victory for athletes that could help open the door to further easing in the decades-old fight over paying student-athletes.

Schools recruiting top athletes could now offer tens of thousands of dollars in education-related benefits that also include study-abroad programs and graduate scholarships. However, the case doesn’t decide whether students can simply be paid salaries for the benefits their efforts bring — measured in tens of millions for many universities.

The high court agreed with a lower court’s determination that NCAA limits on the education-related benefits that colleges can offer athletes who play Division I basketball and football violate antitrust laws.

The case is important in the short term for students who may see schools competing for talent by sweetening their offers with a variety of education-related benefits. It's also important in the long term because it sets the stage for future challenges to NCAA rules limiting athletes' compensation.

Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote for the court that the NCAA sought “immunity from the normal operation of the antitrust laws,” an argument the court rejected. Gorsuch said that allowing colleges and universities to offer "enhanced education-related benefits ... may encourage scholastic achievement and allow student-athletes a measure of compensation more consistent with the value they bring to their schools.”

Under current NCAA rules, students cannot be paid, and the scholarship money a college can offer is capped at the cost of attending the school.

The NCAA had defended its rules as necessary to preserve the amateur nature of college sports, preventing a blurring of the line between them and professional teams, with colleges trying to lure talented athletes by offering over-the-top benefits. A lower court had upheld the NCAA’s limits on scholarships and cash awards, and the high court wasn’t asked to weigh in on those.

Writing for only himself, Justice Brett Kavanaugh signaled where Monday's decision may lead. He said there are “serious questions” about whether the NCAA’s other restrictions on compensating athletes can stand. Kavanaugh wrote that “traditions alone cannot justify the NCAA’s decision to build a massive money-raising enterprise on the backs of student athletes who are not fairly compensated.”

“Nowhere else in America can businesses get away with agreeing not to pay their workers a fair market rate on the theory that their product is defined by not paying their workers a fair market rate. ... The NCAA is not above the law,” wrote Kavanaugh, who as a college student played on Yale's junior varsity basketball team.

The case was brought by former athletes, including West Virginia football player Shawne Alston. It followed a separate, earlier lawsuit brought by athletes including former UCLA basketball player Ed O'Bannon and NBA legends Oscar Robertson and Bill Russell where an appeals court concluded NCAA rules aren't exempt from antitrust law. That case ended with the Supreme Court declining to weigh in.

As a result of Monday's ruling, the NCAA itself can’t bar schools from offering Division I basketball and football players additional education-related benefits. But individual athletic conferences can still set limits if they choose.

“It is our hope that this victory in the battle for college athletes’ rights will carry on a wave of justice uplifting further aspects of athlete compensation," said Steve Berman, an attorney for the former college athletes, in a statement following the ruling. “This is the fair treatment college athletes deserve.”

The court's ruling comes at a time when the NCAA has already been debating how to amend its rules to allow college athletes to profit from their names, images and likenesses, often abbreviated NIL. That would allow athletes to earn money for sponsorship deals, online endorsement and personal appearances.

NCAA President Mark Emmert last week urged member schools to pass a long-stagnant names-and-images reform proposal before the end of the month. If they don't, he will take action himself, he said.

Emmert told The Associated Press on Monday that the high court’s ruling makes going about the NIL reforms “more complicated" but "doesn’t mean we can’t and we shouldn’t.”

An NCAA governing body with the power to adopt changes is scheduled to meet this week. Meanwhile, six state laws that allow athletes to receive names-and-images compensation will go into effect July 1. The NCAA has asked Congress for help in the form of a federal law, but lawmakers are nowhere near passing legislation.

The players associations of the NFL, the NBA and the WNBA had all urged the justices to side with the ex-athletes, as did the Biden administration.

White House press secretary Jen Psaki said Monday of the athletes: The “decision recognizes that, as with all Americans, their hard work should not be exploited.”


Associated Press writers Ralph D. Russo and Josh Boak contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP Online Basketball, AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, College Sports, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Sports - College Football, AP Sports - Men's College Basketball, AP Sports - NBA
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Supreme Court win for college athletes in compensation case
The Supreme Court has ruled unanimously in favor of athletes in the latest case in the decades-long fight over whether and how colleges can compensate their sports stars
9:01PM ( 4 minutes ago )
The Latest: Thompson earns the javelin title at trials
Curtis Thompson captured the javelin title at the Olympic track trials
8:54PM ( 11 minutes ago )
The Latest: Murphy in, Brazier out in 800-meter stunner
Clayton Murphy won the 800 meters at U.S. Olympic trials to lead a field that will not include the reigning world champion Donavan Brazier
8:40PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
High court win for college athletes in compensation case
The Supreme Court has ruled unanimously in favor of athletes in the latest case in the decades-long fight over whether and how colleges can compensate their sports stars
7:36PM ( 1 hour ago )
Searching for sticky stuff: MLB umps start checking pitchers
Major League Baseball has started its crackdown on sticky stuff and foreign substances
7:35PM ( 1 hour ago )
DeGrom dominates after shoulder scare, Mets beat Braves 4-2
Jacob deGrom shouldered the load for New York in his return from another injury scare, pitching one-hit ball over five scoreless innings as the Mets beat the Atlanta Braves 4-2 to open a doubleheader
7:29PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
High court sides with former athletes in dispute with NCAA
In a ruling that could help push changes in college athletics, the Supreme Court has unanimously sided with a group of former college athletes in a dispute with the NCAA over rules limiting certain compensation
10:28AM ( 10 hours ago )
Namath excited for Wilson, says Jets fans 'deserve' a title
The New York Jets have been on a mostly fruitless search for the next Joe Namath since he last played for the team in 1976
12:02PM ( 1 day ago )
NFL retirees mentoring players on fatherhood playbook
Long before Usama Young’s father co-starred with him in a Super Bowl commercial, he influenced his love for football
12:30PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Online Football
AP source: Harden commits to US Olympic men's team for Tokyo
James Harden has committed to playing for U.S. men's national basketball team that will play in the Olympics that begin next month, says a person familiar with the situation
3:20PM ( 5 hours ago )
Head games: Ben Simmons' future uncertain after playoff flop
The Philadelphia 76ers face an uncertain future after an early exit in the playoffs
2:28PM ( 6 hours ago )
Bust the Process: Hawks head to 1st East final since 2015
The Atlanta Hawks are headed to their first Eastern Conference finals since 2015
2:19AM ( 18 hours ago )
AP Online Basketball
NASA sends squid from Hawaii into space for research
Dozens of baby squid from Hawaii are in space for study
7:04PM ( 2 hours ago )
US hits encouraging milestones on virus deaths and shots
The U.S. has reached a pair of encouraging milestones as the COVID-19 pandemic’s grip on the nation continues to loosen
6:49PM ( 2 hours ago )
Ransomware gangs get paid off as officials struggle for fix
The dilemma surrounding ransomware payments has left U.S. officials fumbling about how to respond to such demands
6:46PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Companies give vaccines to workers, boosting Japan's rollout
Thousands of Japanese companies began distributing COVID-19 vaccines to workers and their families Monday in an employer-led drive that aims to rev up the nation’s slow vaccine rollout
4:10PM ( 4 hours ago )
Taliban take key Afghan district, adding to string of wins
Police say Taliban fighters took control of a key district in Afghanistan’s northern Kunduz province and encircled the provincial capital, as the insurgent group added to its string of recent victories on the battlefield
3:45PM ( 5 hours ago )
Iran president-elect takes hard line, refuses to meet Biden
Iran’s president-elect says he’s not willing to meet with President Joe Biden or negotiate over Tehran’s ballistic missile program and its support for regional militias
2:41PM ( 6 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Conferences urge stopgap for NCAA on NIL until federal law
Six Division I conferences are urging the NCAA to implement a stopgap measure that would allow college athletes to earn money off their fame before a federal law is passed
10:20AM ( 10 hours ago )
Michaels, Abbott lead Virginia past Vols 6-0 in CWS opener
Logan Michaels homered for the first time this season and Andrew Abbott pitched six shutout innings as Virginia beat Tennessee 6-0 at the College World Series
6:44PM ( 1 day ago )
Butler drives Wolfpack past Stanford 10-4 in CWS opener
Jonny Butler homered and drove in a career-high five runs, Reid Johnston pitched six strong innings and North Carolina State opened the College World Series with a 10-4 victory over Stanford
1:01AM ( 1 day ago )
College Sports
The Latest: Italy to ease outdoor mask-wearing requirement
Mask-wearing outdoors in Italy will no longer be required in virtually all of the country starting on June 28
6:35PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Companies boost vaccine rollout in Japan
Thousands of Japanese companies have started distributing COVID-19 vaccines to workers and their families in an employer-led drive reaching more than 13 million people that aims to rev up the nation’s slow vaccine rollout
5:08PM ( 3 hours ago )
Biden White House launches public push for child tax credit
The White House is working to raise awareness of the federal government's new expanded child tax credit
3:35PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business
Spielberg's Amblin to make several films a year for Netflix
Steven Spielberg, a filmmaker synonymous with big-screen enchantment, has set a new deal with Netflix in which his production company, Amblin Partners, will make multiple feature films per year for the streaming giant
12:35PM ( 8 hours ago )
The Latest: Vaccinated Canadians won’t have to quarantine
Canada’s health minister says fully vaccinated Canadian citizens will be exempt from two weeks quarantine when returning to the country as of July 5
11:46AM ( 9 hours ago )
In surprise move, Norwegian low-cost airline names new CEO
Low-cost carrier Norwegian Air Shuttle has tapped the carrier’s CFO Geir Karlsen as new chief executive on Monday, a day after the board decided to immediately terminate its contract with CEO Jacob Schram
11:10AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
CFP expansion could increase annual revenue to $2 billion
A new College Football Playoff with triple the number of teams involved could bring in three times as much money to the conferences and schools that share the wealth
5:59PM ( 1 week ago )
The Latest: South Carolina ends academic year with deficit
The South Carolina athletic department says it will end its academic year with a $27 million deficit
11:48AM ( 1 week ago )
What if? College Football Playoff matchups in 12-team format
Looking back at the College Football Playoff era, what would the postseason matchups have been using the proposed 12-team format
2:24AM ( 1 week ago )
AP Sports - College Football
Former Michigan State star to remain in jail in murder case
A former Michigan State University basketball star has been ordered to remain in jail during his first court appearance on murder and other charges in Detroit
7:28AM ( 1 week ago )
Duke's Krzyzewski eager for a final run with the Blue Devils
Duke’s Mike Krzyzewski says he feels the time is right to step away from a Hall of Fame coaching career
3:39PM ( 2 weeks ago )
Duke's Krzyzewski to coach 1 final year, hand off to Scheyer
Mike Krzyzewski says next season will be his last leading the Duke program
7:58PM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Sports - Men's College Basketball
Sore knee threatens Bogdanovic's status for Hawks in Game 7
The Atlanta Hawks may be forced to play Game 7 of their Eastern Conference semifinal series without Bogdan Bogdanovic, the team's top 3-point shooter
2:18PM ( 2 days ago )
NBA playoff notebook: Clippers leading the comeback craze
The Los Angeles Clippers are the kings of the NBA's playoff comeback
11:44AM ( 2 days ago )
Spain includes Pau Gasol in preliminary squad for Olympics
Spain has included Pau Gasol in its preliminary squad for the Tokyo Olympics
7:40AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Sports - NBA
The Latest: Thompson earns the javelin title at trials
Curtis Thompson captured the javelin title at the Olympic track trials
8:54PM ( 12 minutes ago )
The Latest: Murphy in, Brazier out in 800-meter stunner
Clayton Murphy won the 800 meters at U.S. Olympic trials to lead a field that will not include the reigning world champion Donavan Brazier
8:40PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Paid in full? Biden, GOP struggle over infrastructure costs
Congressional negotiators and the White House appear open to striking a roughly $1 trillion deal on infrastructure, but they are struggling with the hard part — deciding who will pay for it
8:35PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Nassib becomes first active NFL player to come out as gay
Las Vegas Raiders defensive end Carl Nassib on Monday became the first active NFL player to come out as gay
8:34PM ( 32 minutes ago )
The Latest: Purrier St. Pierre wins 1500 in meet-record time
Elle Purrier St. Pierre won the 1,500-meter race in an Olympic trials-record time to earn a spot at the Tokyo Games
8:29PM ( 37 minutes ago )