sunny.png
Saturday June 12th, 2021 8:25PM

Minnesota 3rd-degree murder law at issue in ex-cop's appeal

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — A prosecutor urged the Minnesota Supreme Court on Wednesday to uphold the third-degree murder conviction of a former Minneapolis police officer who fatally shot an Australian woman who had called 911 in 2017, saying a reversal would make it impossible to prosecute other officers on the same charge.

But defense attorney Caitlinrose Fisher argued that the Minnesota Court of Appeals erred in February when it affirmed Mohamed Noor's conviction. She argued that the language of Minnesota's third-degree murder statute, backed by case law, requires that a defendant's actions be directed at more than one person, and that the law is meant for cases such as indiscriminate killings.

The state law defines third-degree murder as “an act eminently dangerous to others and evincing a depraved mind, without regard for human life.” A central dispute is whether “dangerous to others” must be read as plural, or if the fatal act can be directed at a single, specific person. The high court’s ultimate decision has repercussions for four other ex-officers charged in the death of George Floyd, another high-profile police killing.

Hennepin County prosecutor Jean Burdorf told the justices that nearly all killings by officers are directed at a specific person. Noor testified in his 2019 trial that a loud bang on the squad car made him fear for his and his partner's life, so he reached across his partner from the passenger seat and fired through the driver’s window, believing it was necessary to protect his partner’s life. His shot killed Justine Ruszczyk Damond, a dual U.S.-Australian citizen engaged to a Minneapolis man, who had called 911 to report a possible sexual assault behind her home.

“If you maintain that a person can not be convicted of third-degree murder ... if their actions are directed at a particular person, there is not going to be an officer-involved shooting that can be prosecuted under Minnesota's depraved-mind murder statute,” Burdorf said.

It was associate Justice Anne McKeig who raised the question of whether police officers could ever be convicted of third-degree murder if the high court agrees with Noor's interpretation of the statute. Fisher replied that “it would be very hard to imagine” that an officer's “split-second reaction to a perceived threat” would count as a “depraved-mind murder” but that other charges could be justified instead, such as manslaughter.

Fisher pointed out that Noor isn't contesting his conviction on a lesser charge of second-degree manslaughter. She urged the justices to send the case back to the trial court for resentencing on that count. While Noor was sentenced to 12 1/2 years on the murder count, which matched the prison term recommended by the state's sentencing guidelines, those guidelines recommend just four years for the manslaughter count.

“Mohamed Noor did not act with a depraved mind. Mohamed Noor was not indifferent to human life," Fisher said. "With the benefit of hindsight we now know that Mr. Noor made a tragic split-second mistake. But if there is to be any meaningful difference between murder and manslaughter, that mistake is not sufficient to sustain Mr. Noor's conviction for third-degree murder.”

Burdorf asked the justices to make the law clear because the proper interpretation of the statute has become unclear amid conflicting rulings over the years.

“We have this confusion. I think it exists and we have to acknowledge it." Burdorf said. "The solution, I think, is to go back to the fundamentals.”

The decision in Noor's appeal is expected to affect the cases of the four ex-officers charged in Floyd's death.

Former Minneapolis police Officer Derek Chauvin was convicted in April of second- and third-degree murder, as well as second-degree manslaughter, and is appealing. Prosecutors are seeking 30 years in prison for Chauvin, who will be sentenced June 25. The sentence wouldn't change even if the Supreme Court rules in Noor's favor, but that decision could become significant if Chauvin's second-degree murder conviction were overturned on appeal. Prosecutors are seeking to add charges of aiding and abetting third-degree murder to the existing counts against three other ex-officers, who are due to go on trial in March.

The judge overseeing Chauvin's trial initially threw out the third-degree murder charge against Chauvin, but later reinstated the count after the Court of Appeals affirmed Noor's conviction. All four former officers also face federal civil rights charges.

Prosecutors wrote in their brief that over 40 states have some form of “depraved mind” or “depraved indifference” homicide statute, but “only a handful" require a defendant to endanger more than one person for prosecutors to get a conviction.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Minnesota 3rd-degree murder law at issue in ex-cop's appeal
A prosecutor has urged the Minnesota Supreme Court to uphold the third-degree murder conviction of Mohamed Noor, a former Minneapolis police officer who fatally shot an Australian woman who had called 911 in 2017
2:04PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Nadal drops set, beats Schwartzman to reach French Open SF
Rafael Nadal’s French Open set streak is over but his pursuit of a record-breaking 21st Grand Slam title remains very much intact
1:49PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Pacers fire Bjorkgren as coach after just 1 season
The Indiana Pacers have fired Nate Bjorkgren after missing the playoffs in his only season as coach
1:45PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
US drops Trump order targeting TikTok, plans its own review
The White House dropped Trump-era executive orders that attempted to ban the popular apps TikTok and WeChat and will conduct its own review aimed at identifying national security risks with software applications tied to China
1:20PM ( 50 minutes ago )
US deaths from heart disease and diabetes climbed amid COVID
The U.S. saw remarkable increases in the death rates for heart disease, diabetes and some other common killers last year
1:19PM ( 50 minutes ago )
Slap to Macron puts focus on ultra-right groups
Bubbling beneath France’s political landscape is an assortment of ultra-right groups, an invisible subculture that shot to the nation’s attention when a young man slapped President Emmanuel Macron and blurted out a centuries-old royalist cry
1:11PM ( 58 minutes ago )
AP National News
Kasim Reed files to campaign for comeback as Atlanta mayor
Former Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed has filed paperwork to enter the race for his old job four years after he left City Hall
12:30PM ( 1 hour ago )
Judge appoints ex-judge to oversee Giuliani devices' review
A New York judge has formally appointed a former judge to ensure attorney-client privilege is protected in an examination of multiple electronic devices seized from Rudy Giuliani
11:24AM ( 2 hours ago )
Russia expected to outlaw opposition leader Navalny's groups
A court is expected to outlaw the organizations founded by Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny
11:08AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Belarus opposition leader urges international probe of govt
A Belarusian opposition leader has called for the creation of an international tribunal to investigate and prosecute the reported crimes of the government and its longtime strongman Alexander Lukashenko
7:10AM ( 7 hours ago )
UK, EU seek to avert 'sausage war' in post-Brexit talks
The U.K. is calling on the European Union to show pragmatism and “common sense,” as the two sides meet to resolve differences over the implementation of their post-Brexit trade deal in Northern Ireland
5:55AM ( 8 hours ago )
Justices to decide if charge fits Minneapolis police killing
The Minnesota Supreme Court hears oral arguments Wednesday in the case of Mohamed Noor
5:50AM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Nadal drops set, beats Schwartzman to reach French Open SF
Rafael Nadal’s French Open set streak is over but his pursuit of a record-breaking 21st Grand Slam title remains very much intact
1:49PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Pacers fire Bjorkgren as coach after just 1 season
The Indiana Pacers have fired Nate Bjorkgren after missing the playoffs in his only season as coach
1:45PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Sweat against Washington persuading players to get vaccine
Washington pass rusher Montez Sweat says he isn't a fan of the team attempting to persuade players to get vaccinated against COVID-19
1:33PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Man sentenced to death for murder of Nebraska store clerk
A man who admitting to killing and dismembering a Nebraska hardware store clerk in 2017 has been sentenced to death
1:33PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Federal appeals court blocks sweeping Missouri abortion law
A federal appeals court panel has blocked Missouri from enforcing a sweeping state abortion law that bans the procedures at or after eight weeks of pregnancy
1:26PM ( 44 minutes ago )