Sunday September 26th, 2021 11:55PM

EXPLAINER: Why a rural pipeline is a climate battleground

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

As Enbridge Energy prepares to finish rebuilding an oil pipeline across rural northern Minnesota, protesters are occupying part of the construction area and pledging a “summer of resistance” on the ground and in court.

Enbridge, which has obtained all necessary state and federal permits for the Line 3 project, says it will be finished by year's end.

The Canadian company describes it as essential for reliable oil supplies in both nations, saying the plan has undergone rigorous environmental permitting and will boost Minnesota's economy. Opponents contend it endangers waterways, violates indigenous treaty rights and abets dependence on fossil fuels that will further overheat the planet.

What's beyond dispute is that the project fits into an escalating battle over the future of energy pipelines, which federal regulators say are generally safer than hauling fuels by rail or highway but pose their own hazards, particularly spills in ecologically sensitive places.


The 1,097-mile (1,765-kilometer) line is part of an Enbridge network that moves oil from fields in Canada's Alberta province to refineries in southern Ontario and the U.S. Midwest. It crosses the far northeastern tip of North Dakota, then cuts through northern Minnesota to a terminal at Superior, Wisconsin.

The line carries nearly 16.4 million gallons (62 million liters) of oil used in fuels and other products.

Enbridge says the original 1960s pipe is deteriorating and carrying about half its capacity. The company is replacing it with pipe made of stronger steel that it says would enable resumption of a normal flow — about 32 million gallons (121 million liters) daily.

Work is finished in Canada, North Dakota and Wisconsin and 60% complete in Minnesota, where 337 miles (542 kilometers) of new pipe is being laid. A new section veers south around reservation land of the Leech Lake tribe, which objected to the project. The detour adds about 50 miles (80 kilometers) to the length.


They await a ruling from the Minnesota Court of Appeals on whether the state Public Utilities Commission's approval was lawful. A pending suit challenges the Army Corps of Engineers' issuance of a permit. State and federal judges have refused to halt construction while the cases proceed.

Also, groups are pushing President Joe Biden to order the Corps to withdraw the Clean Water Act permit. During a protest Monday, actress Jane Fonda carried a placard with Biden's image and the words, “Which side are you on?”

Although Biden pleased environmentalists by canceling the Keystone XL project, his administration has not done likewise with other disputed pipelines, including the Dakota Access line near the Standing Rock Reservation in the Dakotas.

Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz has stayed on the sidelines while the legal process over Line 3 unfolds. His hands-off approach differs from that of Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, a fellow Democrat who ordered Enbridge to shut down Line 5, which moves oil from Superior, Wisconsin, through Michigan to Sarnia, Ontario.

Whitmer's demand focuses on a roughly 4-mile (6.4-kilometer) section beneath a channel that connects Lake Huron and Lake Michigan, where the state granted an easement for the pipeline in 1953 and now seeks to revoke it. That action is also tied up in court.

Line 3 opponents are focusing on blocking the rebuilding project instead of shutting down the line, although their long-term goal is making it obsolete through conversion from fossil fuels to renewable energy.


The day after Fonda joined Line 3 protesters in Minnesota, the National Wildlife Federation in Michigan announced a radio and television ad campaign against Line 5 featuring actor Jeff Daniels. While environmental and indigenous activists have fought energy pipelines for years, the involvement of celebrities is one illustration of widening resistance.

It comes after high-profile spills in the past decade, including a 2010 rupture of an Enbridge line in southern Michigan that sent oil into the Kalamazoo River. A resulting federal consent decree required Enbridge to upgrade the U.S. portion of Line 3.

Another factor: rising awareness that racial minorities suffer disproportionate harm from environmental damage.

Native Americans have been on the front lines of opposition to pipelines, some of which run through or near reservations. They say Line 3 threatens their waters and rights to gather wild rice, fish and hunt on ancestral lands. Enbridge says it consulted with tribes in rerouting the line to protect cultural resources and has employed more than 500 native people for the project.

Also fueling the battle against pipelines is climate change. Many activists consider virtually any project — whether new, an expansion or a replacement of existing pipes — a lifeline for fossil fuels that delays the transition to cleaner energy that scientists say is needed quickly to avoid catastrophic warming.

Enbridge says people will need oil for years to come and shutting down pipelines will mean more shipments by train and truck.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Entertainment, APOnline Celebrity News, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2021
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
US increasingly unlikely to meet Biden's July 4 vax goal
For months, President Joe Biden has laid out goal after goal for taming the coronavirus pandemic and then exceeded his own benchmarks
6:08PM ( 7 minutes ago )
EXPLAINER: Why a rural pipeline is a climate battleground
An oil pipeline that crosses rural northern Minnesota is an emerging focal point of the battle over climate change and energy production
5:58PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Biden nominee for public lands boss hits GOP opposition
President Joe Biden’s nominee to oversee vast expanses of public land in the U.S. West is being criticized by Republicans because of her involvement in partisan politics as a longtime Democratic aide and environmentalist
5:56PM ( 20 minutes ago )
U.S. News
Biden ends GOP infrastructure talks, starts bipartisan push
President Joe Biden has ended talks with a group of Republican senators on a big infrastructure package
5:47PM ( 28 minutes ago )
The Latest: Tsitsipas beats Medvedev to reach French Open SF
Stefanos Tsitsipas has reached the French Open semifinals for the second year in a row
5:40PM ( 35 minutes ago )
Natis put pitcher Voth on injured list with fractured nose
The Washington Nationals have put pitcher Austin Voth on the 10-day injured list with a fractured nose
5:40PM ( 35 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
'For the culture': The moment arrives for 'In the Heights'
A street-level song-and-dance spectacle to rival the MGM musicals of old, “In the Heights” is an exuberant celebration of the Latino immigrant experience, of a neighborhood, of a teeming summertime New York, of life
5:06PM ( 1 hour ago )
Harrison exits 'Bachelor' in wake of racial insensitivity
Chris Harrison, the longtime host of ABC’s “The Bachelor” and its spinoffs, is leaving the franchise
3:51PM ( 2 hours ago )
Sheryl Underwood of 'The Talk' to host Daytime Emmys
Sheryl Underwood of “The Talk” will host the Daytime Emmy Awards on June 25
3:41PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Rejuvenated Paul leads Suns over Nuggets 122-105 in Game 1
Chris Paul and his rejuvenated right shoulder scored 21 points and dished 11 assists, Mikal Bridges added 23 points and the Phoenix Suns beat the Denver Nuggets 122-105 in Game 1 of the Western Conference semifinals
12:26AM ( 17 hours ago )
Copeland, Ingram among winners of Blues Music Awards
Singer Shemekia Copeland and guitarist Christone “Kingfish” Ingram are among this year's the top winners at the Blues Music Awards
3:12PM ( 1 day ago )
Chef Molly Yeh's lockdown life full of recipes, baby firsts
Food blogger and cookbook author Molly Yeh has been balancing the pitfalls of pandemic life with the joyful firsts of her toddler, Bernie
8:47AM ( 1 day ago )
APOnline Celebrity News
Stocks end mostly higher; Wendy's becomes latest meme stock
Major indexes closed mostly higher on Wall Street, thanks largely to gains in a handful of Big Tech companies
5:11PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: US unlikely to meet July 4 vaccination goal
For months, President Joe Biden has laid out goal after goal for taming the coronavirus pandemic and then exceeded his own benchmarks
5:10PM ( 1 hour ago )
In Mexico, Harris defends against criticism over border
Vice President Kamala Harris has brushed off questions about her decision not to visit the U.S.-Mexico border as part of her work to address the spike in migration to the U.S. She says it's “legitimate” to be concerned about the situation at the border but a simple visit wouldn't address that
4:53PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Pipeline CEO: Ransom payment 'hardest decision' of career
The chief executive of the massive fuel pipeline hit by ransomware last month says authorizing a multi-million-dollar payment to hackers was the right thing to do to bring an end to fuel shortages affecting much of the eastern United States
3:02PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Pfizer expands vaccine tests in kids under 12
Pfizer says it is expanding testing of its COVID-19 vaccine in children younger than 12
1:21PM ( 4 hours ago )
Union vote authorizes strike at South Dakota pork plant
The union at a Smithfield Foods pork processing plant in South Dakota says it will head to contract negotiations armed with the authorization to call a strike
11:52AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Automakers face a threat to EV sales: Slow charging times
If the auto industry is to succeed in its bet that electric vehicles will soon dominate the roads, it will need to overcome a big reason why many people are still avoiding them: fear of running out of juice between Point A and Point B
6:22PM ( 23 hours ago )
Biden invites Ukrainian president to White House this summer
President Joe Biden has invited Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy for a White House visit this summer
5:03PM ( 1 day ago )
Stocks slip on Wall Street, pulling back from record highs
Stocks edged lower in afternoon trading Monday after briefly approaching the record highs they reached a month ago
2:55PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Utilities
US increasingly unlikely to meet Biden's July 4 vax goal
For months, President Joe Biden has laid out goal after goal for taming the coronavirus pandemic and then exceeded his own benchmarks
6:08PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Biden nominee for public lands boss hits GOP opposition
President Joe Biden’s nominee to oversee vast expanses of public land in the U.S. West is being criticized by Republicans because of her involvement in partisan politics as a longtime Democratic aide and environmentalist
5:56PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Democrats push bill aimed at family that owns Purdue Pharma
A congressional committee has heard grievances against the owners of OxyContin maker Purdue Pharma as it considered legislation that would keep them from using a corporate bankruptcy as a shield for personal liability
5:43PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Protesters maintain blockade at Minnesota oil pipeline site
Protesters fighting Canadian-based Enbridge Energy's push to replace an aging oil pipeline across northern Minnesota are pressing ahead with their summer drive to stop the project before it can go into service later this year
5:42PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Crews work to reopen Floyd square, activists close it again
Crews returned to a Minneapolis intersection where a memorial to George Floyd was assembled after his death last year and worked to reopen it to traffic by removing debris and makeshift barriers
4:44PM ( 1 hour ago )