Saturday June 12th, 2021 7:40PM

Down syndrome abortion bans gain traction after court ruling

By The Associated Press

It’s a ban that even supporters acknowledge will be hard to enforce. Yet 2021 has been a breakthrough year for legislation in several states seeking to prohibit abortions based solely on a prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome.

Governors in Arizona and South Dakota recently signed such bills into law, and similar measures are pending in North Carolina and Texas. Most significantly, a federal appellate court said Ohio could begin to implement a 2017 law that has been on hold.

Although that ruling by the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals conflicted with other federal court decisions, anti-abortion activists say it increases the chances that the U.S. Supreme Court will agree to consider a case addressing the challenging issues the legislation poses. That could clear the path for bans to be enacted in some other states where courts are blocking them.

Just this week, the high court – with a 6-3 conservative majority resulting from three appointments by former President Donald Trump – signaled its willingness to reconsider the 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling establishing a nationwide right to abortion. The justices agreed to consider a Mississippi law that seeks to ban abortions after 15 weeks. Roe essentially legalized any abortion taking place before a fetus could survive outside the mother’s womb, generally around 24 weeks.

Katherine Beck Johnson, a lawyer with the conservative Family Research Council, acknowledged that the Down syndrome laws might be easy to circumvent. Doctors could tell women not to share their specific reasons for wanting an abortion.

“But even if it’s hard to enforce, it’s worth being passed,” she said, “It’s important for a state to show they're not supporting eugenics; they want to remove the stigma of people who have Down syndrome.”

Opponents of the bills, including some parents with children who have Down syndrome, argue that elected officials should not be meddling with a woman’s deeply personal decision on whether to carry a pregnancy to term after a Down syndrome diagnosis.

“There’s something condescending about these bans, suggesting people don’t have the ability to make their own decisions,” said Holly Christensen, a teacher and newspaper columnist in Akron, Ohio, whose 8-year-old daughter, Lyra, has Down syndrome.

Christensen said she believes that anti-abortion activists’ push for such laws, in hopes of getting a case before the Supreme Court, has undercut efforts to disseminate more information about Down syndrome so more families would be willing to raise children with the condition.

She would like to see Ohio lawmakers increase funding for education and services for children with disabilities.

According to the National Down Syndrome Society, about one in every 700 babies in the United States, or roughly 6,000 annually, is born with the condition, which results from a chromosomal irregularity. There are no official figures on how many prenatal diagnoses of Down syndrome prompt a decision to abort; a 2012 study by medical experts estimated the abortion rate was 67%.

In the past, many children with Down syndrome were institutionalized. Christensen said these days, they frequently acquire job skills and some degree of self-sufficiency. Their life expectancy is more than 60 years, triple the expectation just a few decades ago.

“If you tell a woman, ’We’re going to force you to have a baby with Down syndrome. she’ll think, ‘Oh my God, is it really that bad that you’re going to force me?’” Christensen said.

In past years, courts routinely blocked state laws seeking to ban abortion if it was based on a diagnosis of Down syndrome or other fetal anomalies. Trump’s judicial appointments to lower-level federal courts as well as the Supreme Court has altered the legal landscape.

“It feels like the ground is shifting,” said Elizabeth Nash, who tracks state legislation for the Guttmacher Institute, a research group that supports abortion rights.

Nash noted that court rulings already have allowed enforcement of the laws in Missouri, Tennessee and Ohio.

Last month's decision by a divided 6th Circuit court, which includes six justices nominated by Trump, reversed two earlier decisions that had blocked enforcement of the 2017 Ohio law. Doctors could face a felony charge, be stripped of their medical license and be held liable for legal damages if they are aware of a Down syndrome diagnosis when performing an abortion.

The majority opinion said the Ohio law is aimed at protecting the Down syndrome community from “the stigma it suffers from the practice of Down-syndrome-selective abortions.”

Arizona’s new Down syndrome measure, part of a sweeping anti-abortion bill Republican Gov. Doug Ducey signed last month, is set to take effect later this year. Similar to the Ohio law, it calls for felony charges against doctors who perform an abortion based on a diagnosis of Down syndrome or other genetic abnormalities.

Opponents plan a lawsuit seeking to block it.

Dr. Julie Kwatra, an OB-GYN practicing in Arizona, is among people on both sides of the issue who suggest the law, if it takes effect, would be difficult to enforce.

“Women who want to terminate their pregnancies will do it, whether they do it in a safe, legal way or an unsafe, illegal way,” she said. “It’s still completely legal to terminate your pregnancy for any number of other reasons.”

However, Kwatra said the new measure, by threatening criminalization, “puts a black cloud over the practice of medicine and the doctor-patient relationship.”

Dr. Jamila Perritt, CEO of Physicians for Reproductive Health, said it would be damaging if doctors in states with the Down syndrome laws became defensive in their interactions with patients.

“When you go to see your health care provider, who do you want them to be protecting -- your welfare or theirs?” she said.

Cathi Herrod, president of the Center for Arizona Policy, a conservative group that backed the state legislation, said the law will be valuable even if women are free to give another reason for seeking an abortion.

“Doctors will be on notice, women will be on notice that you don’t secure an abortion simply because there’s a diagnosis of a nonterminal genetic condition,” she said.

Michael New, an abortion opponent who teaches social research at Catholic University of America, said the laws are a good strategy for the anti-abortion movement even if their enforceability is questionable.

“If these laws are upheld, that would create a precedent that would increase the likelihood that other types of protective pro-life laws would be upheld,” he said via email.

He also suggested the laws could help shape public opinion, drawing attention to the high percentage of abortions in cases of a Down syndrome diagnosis.

Erika Christensen, along with her husband, Garin Marschall, decided in May 2016 to terminate a pregnancy after learning during the third trimester that the fetus likely would be unable to breathe after birth. The couple lived in New York, where abortions were banned after 24 weeks of gestation. They traveled to Colorado, where Christensen had an abortion at 32 weeks.

Christensen and Marschall now oppose bills banning abortion for reasons related to genetic anomalies, saying they oversimplify the difficult decisions women and families must make.

“All decisions in these cases are necessarily complicated,” said Christensen, who was grateful for the discussions she had with her doctors.

The couple noted that the 6th Circuit decision upholding the law in Ohio implies that patients seeking abortions in similar cases could lie to their doctors about their reasons.

“That is a really dangerous place to go with regard to the law,” Marschall said.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2021
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: German FM trip to Israel, West Bank confirmed
 Germany’s foreign ministry is confirming that the nation’s top diplomat will make a one-day trip to Israel and the West Bank on Thursday for talks with senior Israeli and Palestinian officials
11:33AM ( 5 minutes ago )
McConnell says he'll oppose Jan. 6 commission to probe riot
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell says he will oppose legislation to create 9/11-style commission on the deadly Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol
11:24AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Germany welcomes US sanctions waivers on Russia gas pipeline
Germany’s foreign minister has welcomed the Biden administration’s decision to waive sanctions against entities and individuals involved in a controversial Russian pipeline
11:22AM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Israeli strikes kill 6 in Gaza; rockets fired from Lebanon
Israeli airstrikes have killed at least six people overnight across the Gaza Strip and destroyed the home of an extended family
10:43AM ( 55 minutes ago )
More drops in Big Tech pull stocks lower; Bitcoin drops 19%
Stocks were broadly lower in early trading Wednesday, as the market’s downturn entered into a third day
10:29AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Biden tells Netanyahu he expects de-escalation
President Joe Biden has called for “significant de-escalation” from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
10:21AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
The Latest: Palestinian leader accuses Israel of war crimes
the Palestinian president says Israel is carrying out “organized state terrorism and war crimes” in Gaza that are punishable under international law
7:52AM ( 3 hours ago )
'City in transition': New York vies to turn page on pandemic
More than a year after coronavirus shutdowns sent “the city that never sleeps” into a fitful slumber, New York could soon be wide awake again
7:26AM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: Israel says Palestinian rocket misfired in Gaza
Israeli military officials say a mysterious explosion that killed eight members of a Palestinian family on the first day of the current round of fighting in the Gaza Strip was caused by a misfired Palestinian rocket, not an Israeli airstrike
6:53AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Russian lawmakers vote to follow US out of overflight treaty
The Russian parliament’s lower house has voted to withdraw from an international treaty allowing surveillance flights over military facilities
9:53AM ( 1 hour ago )
Angry French police hold huge, emotional rally at parliament
French police officers are holding a huge demonstration outside parliament to press for a law that protects the protectors
8:46AM ( 2 hours ago )
Russian lawmakers vote to abandon overflight treaty
The Russian parliament’s lower house has voted to withdraw from an international treaty allowing surveillance flights over military facilities following the U.S. departure from the pact
7:00AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
AP source: US encouraging Israel to wind down Gaza offensive
President Joe Biden and administration officials have encouraged Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and other top Israeli officials to wind down their bombardment of Gaza
8:16PM ( 15 hours ago )
Arizona auditors backtrack, say no election data destroyed
Firms hired to run a partisan audit of the 2020 election for Senate Republicans in Arizona said Tuesday that data was not destroyed, reversing earlier allegations that election officials eliminated evidence
7:10PM ( 16 hours ago )
Lawmakers quiz Boeing, FAA about recent issues with planes
Lawmakers are asking Boeing and the Federal Aviation Administration for records detailing production problems with two of the company's most popular airliners
6:16PM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Court clears way for Samoa to get its first woman leader
Samoa appears set to get its first woman leader after the nation’s top court on Monday reinstated the results of a knife-edge election last month
6:38AM ( 2 days ago )
Judge dismisses NRA bankruptcy case in blow to gun group
A federal judge has dismissed the National Rifle Association’s bankruptcy case
10:13PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
EU takes big step toward relaxing travel for vaccinated
The European Union has taken a step toward relaxing travel rules for tourists from outside the 27-nation bloc
10:35AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: France outdoor cafes reopen after 6 months
It’s a grand day for the French as cafe and restaurant outdoor terraces are reopening after a pandemic shutdown of more than six months
9:46AM ( 1 hour ago )
Malawi burns 20,000 expired AstraZeneca doses despite pleas
Malawi has burned nearly 20,000 doses of AstraZeneca vaccines because they had expired
7:58AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Health
More drops in Big Tech pull stocks lower; Bitcoin drops 20%
U.S. stocks are opening broadly lower, extending a weak streak into a third day
9:47AM ( 1 hour ago )
How to ease out of mortgage forbearance, avoid foreclosure
American homeowners were given greater opportunity to hit pause on their mortgage payments because of the the pandemic, but that relief is slowly coming to an end
8:16AM ( 3 hours ago )
Target's profit surges as Americans cast restrictions aside
Target has reported surging sales and profits for its fiscal first quarter thanks to shoppers who bought more apparel as they emerge from the pandemic
7:55AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
Supreme Court throws abortion fight into center of midterms
The Supreme Court has agreed to hear a potentially ground-breaking abortion case, probably this fall, and the news is energizing activists on both sides of the contentious issue
8:55AM ( 1 day ago )
China adds few babies, loses workers as its 1.4B people age
The number of working-age people in China fell over the past decade while the population barely grew, adding to strains in an aging society
5:31AM ( 1 week ago )
1.4B but no more? China's population growth closer to zero
China’s weak population growth is falling closer to zero, adding to strains on an aging society with a shrinking workforce as fewer couples have children
12:54AM ( 1 week ago )
AP Health - Women's health
The Latest: German FM trip to Israel, West Bank confirmed
 Germany’s foreign ministry is confirming that the nation’s top diplomat will make a one-day trip to Israel and the West Bank on Thursday for talks with senior Israeli and Palestinian officials
11:33AM ( 6 minutes ago )
McConnell says he'll oppose Jan. 6 commission to probe riot
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell says he will oppose legislation to create 9/11-style commission on the deadly Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol
11:24AM ( 15 minutes ago )
Grand day for the French: Cafe and bistro terraces reopen
It’s a grand day for the French
11:18AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Malawi destroys 20,000 expired doses of AstraZeneca vaccine
Malawi has burned nearly 20,000 expired AstraZeneca vaccines, amid conflicting advice over what to do with the doses
11:07AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Former girl group members unite on BET to form supergroup
BET is forming the next big R&B girl group with the help of members from platinum-selling ensembles like 702, Total, Danity Kane, 3LW, Blaque and Cherish
11:04AM ( 34 minutes ago )