sunny.png
Saturday May 8th, 2021 6:35PM

Over Thomas dissent, high court rejects West Point case

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Monday rejected an appeal from a woman who says she was raped as a West Point cadet, with Justice Clarence Thomas alone arguing that the court should have heard her case.

The woman, who attended the U.S. Military Academy from 2008 to 2010, had sued saying the academy's leadership tolerated a culture that was hostile toward women and failed to provide adequate support for cadets who are assaulted, among other things. But lower courts said her lawsuit against the U.S. government couldn't go forward.

Thomas said in a dissent that the high court should have taken the case to reconsider a 70-year-old precedent that prevents members of the military from suing the United States when they are injured while doing their duties.

It is the second time in as many years he has noted his disagreement when the court has declined to revisit the issue. Thomas says the case the court decided decades ago has led to bizarre and surprising results, including barring the former cadet's case.

“Under our precedent, if two Pentagon employees—one civilian and one a servicemember—are hit by a bus in the Pentagon parking lot and sue, it may be that only the civilian would have a chance to litigate his claim on the merits," Thomas wrote in a 3-page dissent.

In the West Point case, lower courts said the woman's claims were barred by the so-called Feres doctrine, which comes from a 1950 Supreme Court case. In it, the Supreme Court held that the Federal Tort Claims Act does not give members of the military the ability to sue the United States for injuries that “arise out of or are in the course of activity incident to" their active duty service in the military.

Thomas wrote that “Feres was wrongly decided; and this case was wrongly decided as a result.” Thomas gave one reason the court may be unwilling to take up the issue.

“Perhaps the Court is hesitant to take up this issue at all because it would require fiddling with a 70-year-old precedent that is demonstrably wrong. But if the Feres doctrine is so wrong that we cannot figure out how to rein it in, then the better answer is to bid it farewell,” he wrote. Thomas cited about half a dozen cases where the court had overturned a precedent including the landmark Brown v. Board of Education case, which outlawed segregation in public schools and overturned the court's Plessy v. Ferguson decision.

Some liberals are particularly concerned now about the court agreeing to revisit precedents. They're worried that the court, which now includes six conservatives and three liberals, might also revisit and overturn Roe v. Wade, the 1973 Supreme Court decision legalizing abortion nationwide. Thomas has previously said that the court's "abortion precedents are grievously wrong and should be overruled."

In 2019, however, both Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, a liberal, and Thomas, a conservative, indicated they wanted to revisit the Feres doctrine. They said they would have taken a case involving a Navy lieutenant, Rebekah Daniel, who gave birth at a naval hospital and died due to a complication. Her husband was barred from suing because of the Feres doctrine. Ginsburg has since been replaced on the court by Justice Amy Coney Barrett.

The Biden administration had urged the court not to take the West Point case. It noted that if Congress wants, it can change the law to permit lawsuits currently barred by the Feres doctrine.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Biden pushes education spending at stops in Virginia
President Joe Biden traveled to coastal Virginia to promote his plans to increase spending on education and children, part of his $1.8 trillion families proposal announced last week
2:49PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Over Thomas dissent, high court rejects West Point case
The Supreme Court has rejected an appeal from a woman who says she was raped as a West Point cadet
2:34PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Storms spawn twisters in Mississippi, kill driver in Georgia
Multiple tornadoes have caused damage across Mississippi, destroying homes and uprooting trees before the storm system moved into Georgia and prompted a tornado warning in Atlanta
2:34PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
US and UK reject reports of imminent prisoner deal with Iran
The U.S. and the U.K. are dimissing reports coming out of Iran that they are thrashing out a prisoner exchange deal with Tehran that could see the imminent release of a British-Iranian woman, Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe, and four Americans, among others
1:54PM ( 57 minutes ago )
EPA rule to phase out gases used in refrigerators, coolants
The Environmental Protection Agency is proposing to phase down production and use of hydrofluorocarbons, highly potent greenhouse gases commonly used in refrigerators and air conditioners
1:21PM ( 1 hour ago )
Democrats must find narrow path to curb high medicine prices
President Joe Biden’s call for authorizing Medicare to negotiate lower prescription drug prices has energized Democrats on a politically popular idea they’ve been pushing for nearly 20 years only to encounter frustration
12:59PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
St. Louis couple who confronted protesters back in court
A St. Louis couple accused of waving guns at racial injustice protesters last summer are due back in court
6:02AM ( 3 days ago )
Dems laud racial diversity as panel turns focus to judges
The first Senate hearing for President Joe Biden’s judicial nominations featured two African American nominees for appeals court openings
3:33PM ( 4 days ago )
Tim Scott, only Black GOP senator, set to respond to Biden
Tim Scott of South Carolina is the only Black Republican senator
10:58AM ( 5 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Biden pushes education spending at stops in Virginia
President Joe Biden traveled to coastal Virginia to promote his plans to increase spending on education and children, part of his $1.8 trillion families proposal announced last week
2:49PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Storms spawn twisters in Mississippi, kill driver in Georgia
Multiple tornadoes have caused damage across Mississippi, destroying homes and uprooting trees before the storm system moved into Georgia and prompted a tornado warning in Atlanta
2:34PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Albania’s Socialists seek to impeach nation's president
An Albania lawmaker says the governing left-wing Socialist Party legislators have started the impeachment process against the country’s president who they accuse of violating the constitution during the last election
2:34PM ( 18 minutes ago )
UK's Johnson voices optimism over lockdown easing route
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson says there's a “good chance” that social distancing rules in England will be scrapped on June 21 if coronavirus infections and deaths stay low
2:29PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Calls for justice at N.C. funeral of Andrew Brown Jr.
The funeral for Andrew Brown Jr., a Black man shot and killed by deputies in North Carolina, brought calls for justice from the Rev. Al Sharpton and attorneys for the family
2:26PM ( 25 minutes ago )