Friday October 22nd, 2021 6:10AM

Wyoming backs coal with $1.2M threat to sue other states

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

CHEYENNE, Wyo. (AP) — While most states pursue ways to boost renewable energy, Wyoming is doing the opposite with a new program aimed at propping up the dwindling coal industry by suing other states that block exports of Wyoming coal and cause Wyoming coal-fired power plants to shut down.

The law signed April 6 by Republican Gov. Mark Gordon creates a $1.2 million fund for an initiative that marks the latest attempt by state leaders to help coal in the state that accounts for the bulk of U.S. coal production, which is down by half since 2008.

“Wyoming is sending a message that it is prepared to bring litigation to protect her interests,” Gordon spokesman Michael Pearlman said of the fund signed into law April 6.

The law puts West Coast states and Colorado on notice — all seek to get a large share of their electricity from renewables but still get juice from aging Wyoming coal-fired power plants. The approach may run into legal troubles, though, according to one constitutional expert.

Lawsuits between states aren't unusual and often involve natural resources, such as water rights. Such cases can go directly to the U.S. Supreme Court, if the justices agree to hear them.

Last year, Wyoming and Montana — another major coal state — asked the Supreme Court to override a decision by Washington state to deny a permit to build a coal export dock on the Columbia River. The interstate lawsuit followed years of unsuccessful attempts by the dock's developer, Utah-based Lighthouse Resources, to contest the permit denial in federal court.

The Supreme Court hasn’t said yet if it will hear the case but the new legal fund approved resoundingly by the Wyoming Legislature and overseen by Gordon could help cover the cost of that litigation, Pearlman said.

All the while, prospects for Wyoming's coal industry are as dim as ever, even after then-President Donald Trump rolled back regulations on mining and burning the fossil fuel.

Wyoming coal production, which accounts for about 40% of the nation's total, has been in decline as utilities switch to gas, which is cheaper to burn to generate electricity. Solar and wind power also are on the rise as coal's share of the U.S. power market shrinks from about half in the early 2000s to less than 20% now.

Hope that other countries will use more U.S. coal, meanwhile, are fading fast. Lighthouse Resources filed for bankruptcy in December, further setting back the coal dock proposal.

So can state vs. state lawsuits help the coal industry?

"We're supportive of all the efforts of the state right now to protect and defend the industry," Wyoming Mining Association Executive Director Travis Deti said.

Wyoming could waste a lot of money trying to convince courts to help coal, countered University of Maryland environmental law professor Robert Percival.

“I don't think they have a legal leg to stand on,” Percival said.

The Constitution's Commerce Clause prohibits states from barring goods and services based on their state of origin. States are free, however, to regulate or outright prohibit certain goods and services — coal and coal-fired electricity included — as long as they don't intentionally target other states, Percival said.

Who might be targets of future Wyoming coal litigation isn’t yet known. Pearlman declined to speculate, saying Gordon and Attorney General Bridget Hill would need to study their chances of success, but they could include West Coast states including, again, Washington.

Portland, Oregon-based utility PacifiCorp plans to reduce its coal-fired generation by two-thirds by 2030, partly by retiring generators at two southwestern Wyoming power plants starting in 2023, as much as five years sooner than envisioned just a few years ago. The utility serves four states with renewable energy standards or goals — California, Oregon, Utah and Washington — and two that don't: Idaho and Wyoming.

PacifiCorp has been meeting renewable standards by getting electricity from the lowest cost and least risky sources like it has always done, so the standards haven't factored into its decisions to retire coal-fired power, company spokesman David Eskelsen said.

PacifiCorp has no position on the legal fund but the Wyoming Rural Electric Association supports the message it sends to states such as Colorado, which has renewable energy standards and gets coal-fired electricity from southeastern Wyoming, Executive Director Shawn Taylor said.

“It’s just kind of part and parcel of folks feeling that states and state agencies and entities outside Wyoming are having more of an impact on our energy resources than we do,” Taylor said.

The coal litigation fund followed a 2020 bill that established a $1 million fund to promote Wyoming coal. Wyoming is paying a nonprofit, the Energy Policy Network, $250,000 a year from the fund to contest plans in other states to shut down coal-fired power.

“I will not waver in my efforts to protect our industries, particularly our coal industry. The use of coal is under assault from all directions. And we have stood firm in our support of it throughout,” Gordon said in his state of the state address in March.

He called for Wyoming to be carbon negative — capturing more of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide than it emits — by investing in technology and infrastructure to trap carbon dioxide at power plants and keep the gas out of the atmosphere.

Carbon capture remains economically unproven on a scale needed to meaningfully reduce current carbon dioxide emissions. Wyoming has been funding research into the technology, however, including $10 million in a just-approved bill that slashed Wyoming's budget by over 10% amid weak revenue from oil, gas and coal extraction.

Connie Wilbert, director of the Sierra Club's Wyoming chapter, said the state should put its tight budget to more productive use than coal lawsuits.

“Coal is on the way out," Wilbert said. "The sooner our elected leadership acknowledges that and starts looking for things the state can do to actually help us through the transition, the better.”


Follow Mead Gruver at https://twitter.com/meadgruver

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: UK increases aid to India's health care system
Britain has rushed to increase aid for India’s teetering health care system, promising more ventilators and expert advice as doctors grapple with a surge in coronavirus infections that is killing thousands of people a day
12:58PM ( 1 minute ago )
Man United's game off after fans storm stadium in protest
Manchester United’s Premier League game against Liverpool was postponed after supporters stormed into the stadium and onto the pitch
12:48PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Wyoming backs coal with $1.2M threat to sue other states
Most states are encouraging renewable energy but a new program in Wyoming does the opposite
12:45PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Police fatally shoot gunman who killed 2 at Wisconsin casino
Authorities in Wisconsin say a gunman killed two people at a Green Bay casino restaurant and seriously wounded a third before he was shot and killed by police
12:00PM ( 1 hour ago )
US denies Iran's claims of prisoner, cash swap; UK downplays
The United States has denied a report by Iran’s state-run television broadcaster that deals had been reached between the Islamic Republic, Washington and the United Kingdom that would see prisoners swapped and Tehran receive billions of dollars
11:18AM ( 1 hour ago )
US general: Afghan forces could face 'bad possible outcomes'
The top U.S. military officer says Afghan government forces face an uncertain future and the potential for “bad possible outcomes” on the battlefield against Taliban insurgents as the withdrawal of American and coalition troops accelerates
11:10AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Celebrity politicians test voter interest in post-Trump era
From Ronald Reagan and Arnold Schwarzenegger to Al Franken and Donald Trump, there’s a rich history of celebrities trying out new careers in politics
9:17AM ( 3 hours ago )
Puerto Rico groans under pandemic as health, economy suffer
A spike in COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations in Puerto Rico has put health experts at odds with government officials
9:08AM ( 3 hours ago )
Indian leader's party takes electoral hit amid virus surge
Preliminary voting trends released by India’s electoral body indicate the prime minister's Hindu nationalist party failed to make gains in four recent state elections
8:34AM ( 4 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Latin America looks to space, despite limitations on ground
Space-related news is not just flowing from the world’s richest, biggest nations
9:40AM ( 3 hours ago )
Baidu rolls out paid driverless taxi service in Beijing
Chinese tech giant Baidu has rolled out its paid driverless taxi service, making it the first company that's commercialized autonomous driving operations in China
9:11AM ( 3 hours ago )
New stage in Rome's Colosseum will restore majestic view
Italy’s culture minister says a project to build a high-tech, light-weight stage inside the Roman Colosseum will allow visitors a central viewpoint from within the ancient structure “to see the majesty of the monument."
7:57AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business
Eli Broad, billionaire entrepreneur who reshaped LA, dies
Eli Broad, the billionaire philanthropist, contemporary art collector and entrepreneur who co-founded homebuilding pioneer Kaufman and Broad Inc. and launched financial services giant SunAmerica Inc., died Friday in Los Angeles
11:24PM ( 1 day ago )
Jags line up potential replacements for Henderson, Robinson
The Jacksonville Jaguars used the second night of the NFL draft to line up potential replacements for three starters
9:55PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Canada puts J&J vaccine rollout plans on hold
Plans to distribute the first 300,000 doses of the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine in Canada next week are on hold after Health Canada learned part of them were manufactured at a Maryland facility that messed up the ingredients in 15 million doses bound for the U.S. market
8:50PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
The Latest: India opens vaccination to all adults amid surge
India has opened vaccinations to all adults in hopes of taming a monstrous spike in COVID-19 infections
3:11PM ( 21 hours ago )
India launches effort to inoculate all adults against COVID
India has opened vaccinations to all adults in hopes of taming a monstrous spike in COVID-19 infections
1:20PM ( 23 hours ago )
The Latest: Las Vegas casino capacity, crowds increase
Casino capacity on the Las Vegas Strip has increased to 80% and person-to-person distancing dropped to 3 feet on Saturday
12:56PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Industries
Exxon posts $2.7B quarterly profit after unprecedented year
Exxon Mobil has reported profits of $2.73 billion in the first quarter after a tumultuous year led to major spending reductions
3:36PM ( 1 day ago )
UN report says Myanmar poverty could double from coup chaos
A United Nations report says political turmoil and disruptions following the coup in Myanmar could undo years of progress and double the number of its people living in poverty to nearly half the population
4:28AM ( 2 days ago )
Water bill may open spigot for Biden infrastructure plan
Rarely has a routine water resources bill generated so much political buzz
10:01PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Utilities
Man United's game off after fans storm stadium in protest
Manchester United’s Premier League game against Liverpool was postponed after supporters stormed into the stadium and onto the pitch
12:48PM ( 12 minutes ago )
The Latest: Pakistan restricts border travel to fight virus
Pakistan’s coronavirus control agency has decided to temporarily restrict the country’s borders to people coming in from Afghanistan and Iran
12:41PM ( 18 minutes ago )
UK rushes to increase aid to India's health care system
Britain is rushing to increase aid for India’s teetering health care system, promising more ventilators and expert advice as doctors grapple with a surge in coronavirus infections that is killing thousands of people a day
12:40PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Hamilton wins Portuguese GP, extends lead over Verstappen
Formula One champion Lewis Hamilton wins the Portuguese Grand Prix for a 97th career win and extends his championship lead over Max Verstappen to eight points
12:22PM ( 37 minutes ago )
US denies Iran claims of prisoner deal; UK plays it down
The United States has denied a report by Iran’s state-run television broadcaster that deals had been reached for the Islamic Republic to release U.S. and British prisoners in exchange for Tehran receiving billions of dollars
12:20PM ( 40 minutes ago )