Thursday October 21st, 2021 2:19AM

FDA revives federal effort to ban menthol cigarettes

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — U.S. health regulators pledged again Thursday to try to ban menthol cigarettes, this time under pressure from African American groups to remove the mint flavor popular among Black smokers.

The Food and Drug Administration has attempted several times to get rid of menthol but faced pushback from Big Tobacco, members of Congress and competing political interests in both the Obama and Trump administrations. Any menthol ban will take years to implement and will likely face legal challenges from tobacco companies.

Thursday’s announcement is the result of a lawsuit filed by anti-smoking and medical groups last summer to force the FDA to finally make a decision on menthol, alleging that regulators had “unreasonably delayed” responding to a 2013 petition seeking to ban the flavor.

The deadline for the agency’s response was Thursday. The FDA said it aims to introduce the regulations banning the flavor in the coming year.

The action would also ban menthol and fruity flavors from low-cost cigars, which are increasingly popular with young people, especially Black teens.

“Taken together, these policies will help save lives and improve the public health of our country as we confront the leading cause of preventable disease and death,” Mitch Zeller, the FDA's head of tobacco, said in a statement.

Menthol is the only cigarette flavor that was not banned under the 2009 law that gave the FDA authority over tobacco products, an exemption negotiated by industry lobbyists. The act did, though, instruct the agency to continue to weigh banning menthol.

The flavor’s persistence has infuriated anti-smoking advocates, who point to research that menthol’s numbing effect masks the harshness of smoking, likely making it easier to start and harder to quit. The mint-flavored cigarettes are overwhelmingly used by young people and minorities, particularly Black smokers, 85% of whom smoke menthols. That compares to about a third of white smokers.

“The science is there, the data is there, so why are these products still on the market?” said Carol McGruder of the African American Tobacco Control Leadership Council.

Her group sued along with Action on Smoking and Health, the American Medical Association and the National Medical Association, which represents Black physicians.

For decades, companies focused menthol marketing and promotions on Black communities, including sponsoring music festivals and neighborhood events. Company documents released via 1990s litigation also show companies viewed menthol cigarettes as good “starter” products because they were more palatable for teenagers .

“There was a specific, intentional focus on creating the next generation of smokers by making menthol cigarettes available in those communities,” said Dr. Nia Heard-Garris, who chairs the American Academy of Pediatrics’ group on minority health and equity.

In the late 1990s, new restrictions banned cigarette advertising from billboards, public transit and most event sponsorships. Companies shifted more promotions to retail locations like gas stations and convenience stores, which researchers have shown are heavily concentrated in Black neighborhoods

About a third of all cigarettes sold in the U.S. are menthol and its elimination would be a huge blow to tobacco companies, including Altria and Reynolds American, maker of the leading menthol brands, Newport and Kool. With the slow decline of smoking, tobacco companies have been diversifying into alternative products, including electronic cigarettes and tobacco pouches. But those ventures still account for a tiny slice of industry sales.

An Altria spokesman said in a statement ahead of the announcement that “criminalizing menthol” would have “serious unintended consequences.”

Reynolds American did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Smoking can cause cancer, strokes and heart attacks and is blamed for 480,000 annual deaths. About 14% of Americans smoke cigarettes, with rates roughly even between white and Black populations. But Black smokers are less likely to successfully quit, a trend that the U.S. Surgeon General and others have attributed to menthol cigarettes.

Menthol occurs naturally in mint plants. Known for its cooling effect, the chemical is used in cough drops and other medicines. Cigarette makers began adding the chemical in the 1920s after realizing it reduced the throat hit of cigarettes.

Past government efforts targeting menthol have faced opposition from lawmakers from traditional tobacco states like North Carolina, but also some members of the Congressional Black Caucus, many who have received campaign contributions from cigarette makers.

Some caucus members warned that banning menthol would create an illegal market for the products, subjecting Black communities to increased law enforcement.

But calls for action have been growing and last year the House of Representatives voted to ban the flavor with support from the majority of Black members. The bill stalled in the Republican-controlled Senate after Trump made clear he opposed the measure.

The FDA's attempts to get rid of menthol have repeatedly been delayed or derailed by forces inside and outside government.

In 2011, an outside panel of FDA advisers recommended banning menthol after concluding that it increases smoking among young people and minorities and makes it harder for them to quit. But cigarette makers challenged the findings in court, claiming some panel members had conflicts of interest they hadn't disclosed.

In 2013, the FDA conducted its own internal study and reached similar conclusions, but the Obama administration did not move ahead with a ban.

Under the Trump administration, FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb tried to again restart the process but it was never greenlighted by the White House.


Follow Matthew Perrone on Twitter: @AP_FDAwriter


The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute’s Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Business
© Copyright 2021
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
FDA revives federal effort to ban menthol cigarettes
U.S. health regulators are going to try again to ban menthol cigarettes
9:54AM ( 10 minutes ago )
More gains for Big Tech push stocks back to record highs
Stocks are solidly higher in early trading on Wall Street, powered by more gains in big technology companies
9:47AM ( 17 minutes ago )
EU study: GMO laws needs overhaul; environmentalists protest
 A new European Union study finds that the two-decade old legislation on Genetically Modified Organisms should be revamped, a process environmentalists claim will open the door to a new generation of bioengineered crops being allowed onto the EU market without proper checks
9:46AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
US pushes ahead with nuclear plans despite watchdog concerns
The federal agency that oversees U.S. nuclear research and bomb-making has signed off on the first planning and design phase for a multibillion-dollar project to manufacture key components for the nation's nuclear arsenal
9:06AM ( 57 minutes ago )
Gone Fission: Controversial nuke plant near NYC shuts down
Indian Point north of New York City will permanently stop producing nuclear power Friday
8:11AM ( 1 hour ago )
Biden's declaration: America's democracy 'is rising anew'
President Joe Biden declares “America is rising anew” as he calls for an expansion of federal programs to drive the economy past the coronavirus pandemic and broadly extend the social safety net on a scale not seen in decades
8:08AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
North Carolina body camera law comes under harsh glare
A North Carolina law that gives local courts authority over the release of body camera video has come under a harsh glare after a judge refused to make public footage of deputies shooting and killing Andrew Brown Jr. The 2016 law says that law enforcement video is not a public record and generally cannot be released without court approval
12:44AM ( 9 hours ago )
Some Californians can't get vaccine despite surge in supply
Just a few weeks ago, California was struggling to meet demand for COVID-19 vaccinations
12:12AM ( 9 hours ago )
EXPLAINER: Is it legal to shoot suspects in the back?
Video released in Chicago shows an officer shooting an armed suspect in the back as he sought to elude capture
10:16PM ( 11 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
EU Parliament: COVID-19 pass should guarantee free movement
European lawmakers want to ensure that COVID-19 certificates aimed at facilitating travel across the European Union will be enough to move freely this summer
8:19AM ( 1 hour ago )
Pope aims to cut down on corruption among Vatican managers
Pope Francis has issued tough new anti-corruption regulations Thursday to ensure his own cardinals and managers are clean and honest
8:13AM ( 1 hour ago )
Meet 'SGOTUS': Emhoff settles in as second gentleman of US
The husband of Vice President Kamala Harris, Doug Emhoff, is settling in and defining his groundbreaking new role as second gentleman of the United States
6:18AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: Biden says US government is about all Americans
President Joe Biden has ended his first address to a joint session of Congress by reaching to evoke the sweep of history
10:41PM ( 11 hours ago )
The Latest: Biden's take on college, new public works jobs
President Joe Biden says 12 years of education is no longer enough to compete in the 21st century
10:30PM ( 11 hours ago )
Biden to the nation and world: 'America is rising anew'
President Joe Biden is declaring in his first address to a joint session of Congress that “America is rising anew."
10:25PM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
UN-led informal Cyprus talks stall, new round planned
U_N_ Secretary-General Antonio Guterres says that Turkish Cypriots and Greek Cypriots failed to make headway in informal talks on the future of their ethnically divided island, but talks will continue and “I do not give up.”
9:15AM ( 49 minutes ago )
Daimler Truck, Volvo to make fuel cells in Europe from 2025
Daimler's AG's truck business and Volvo Group are getting ready to start making climate-friendly fuel cells for long-haul trucks together
9:07AM ( 57 minutes ago )
McDonald's comes roaring back as restrictions ease
The bounce back for McDonald’s as restrictions were lifted across the U.S. was so strong in the first quarter that the company surpassed sales during the same period even in 2019, long before the pandemic broadsided the country
7:56AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
More gains for Big Tech push stocks back to record highs
Stocks are solidly higher in early trading on Wall Street, powered by more gains in big technology companies
9:47AM ( 17 minutes ago )
EU study: GMO laws needs overhaul; environmentalists protest
 A new European Union study finds that the two-decade old legislation on Genetically Modified Organisms should be revamped, a process environmentalists claim will open the door to a new generation of bioengineered crops being allowed onto the EU market without proper checks
9:46AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Black inmate's death in Texas jail struggle ruled homicide
The death of a Black man who struggled with detention officers at a Texas jail during what his family members say probably was a mental health crisis has been ruled a homicide
9:38AM ( 25 minutes ago )
Pandemic weighs on Merck in the first quarter, sales dip
Drugmaker Merck’s first-quarter profit dipped 1%, due to flat sales as the COVID-19 pandemic continued to limit doctor and hospital visits, along with higher spending on research and medicine production
9:37AM ( 27 minutes ago )
Feds raid Giuliani's home, office, escalating criminal probe
Former President Donald Trump is defending Rudy Giuliani, his longtime personal lawyer, after federal investigators executed search warrants at Giuliani’s Manhattan residence and office
9:32AM ( 32 minutes ago )