clearn.png
Sunday April 11th, 2021 12:22AM

High court sympathetic to college athletes in NCAA dispute

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Wednesday seemed sympathetic to college athletes in a dispute with the NCAA over rules limiting their education-related compensation.

With the March Madness basketball tournament in its final stages, the high court heard arguments in a case about how colleges can reward athletes who play Division I basketball and football. Under current NCAA rules, students cannot be paid, and the scholarship money colleges can offer is capped at the cost of attending the school. The NCAA defends its rules as necessary to preserve the amateur nature of college sports.

But the former athletes who brought the case, including former West Virginia football player Shawne Alston, say the NCAA’s rules are unfair and violate federal antitrust law designed to promote competition.

The case is not about whether students can be paid salaries. Instead, the outcome will help determine whether schools can offer athletes tens of thousands of dollars in education benefits for things such as computers, graduate scholarships, tutoring, study abroad and internships.

During an hour and a half of arguments conducted by phone because of the coronavirus pandemic, there were both liberal and conservative justices who sounded supportive to the athletes' case.

Justice Elena Kagan suggested that what was going on sounded a lot like price fixing. "Schools that are naturally competitors ... have all gotten together in an organization,” she said, and used their power to “fix athletic salaries at extremely low levels.”

Justice Brett Kavanaugh agreed, saying "antitrust laws should not be a cover for exploitation of the student-athletes." He told a lawyer for the NCAA that “it does seem ... schools are conspiring with competitors ... to pay no salaries for the workers who are making the schools billions of dollars."

The NCAA's argument that what makes college sports distinctive is that players are not paid got a cool reception from Justice Samuel Alito. He said athletes “get lower admission standards” and “tuition, room and board, and other things.” "That’s a form of pay,” he said, adding that the question is “the form in which they’re going to be paid and how much.”

Other justices expressed concerns about the consequences of ruling for the athletes. Chief Justice John Roberts suggested doing so could mean there will be a "wide number of rules that are subject to challenge, if not in this litigation, in subsequent cases.”

Justice Stephen Breyer called the case “tough." “I worry a lot about judges getting into the business of deciding how amateur sports should be run,” he told the former players' lawyer, Jeffrey Kessler, at one point.

A ruling for the former players would not necessarily mean an immediate infusion of cash to current college athletes. It would mean that the NCAA could not bar schools from sweetening their offers to Division I basketball and football players with additional education-related benefits. Individual athletic conferences could still set limits.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor asked the NCAA's lawyer, Seth Waxman, about that at one point, asking why conferences wouldn't just "impose those limits?”

Waxman responded that a national agreement is the “only solution" because of the pressures schools would face to offer additional benefits to lure top talent. If the NCAA's restrictions are removed, that could create bidding wars for the best players. The NCAA says that could turn off fans and erase the distinction between professional and college sports.

In comments Wednesday, NCAA President Mark Emmert called the case “very, very important to the way in which college sports is governed.”

Whatever happens at the high court, changes seem on the way for how college athletes are compensated.

The NCAA is in the process of trying to amend its rules to allow athletes to profit from their names, images and likenesses. That would allow athletes to earn money for things like sponsorship deals, online endorsement and personal appearances. For some athletes, those amounts could dwarf any education-related benefits.

The NCAA wasn’t happy with the outcome the last time its rules were before the Supreme Court. In 1984, the high court rejected NCAA rules restricting the broadcast of college football. The justices’ ruling transformed college sports, helping it become the multibillion-dollar business it is today.

This time around, the former college athletes have some big-time supporters. The players associations of the NFL, NBA and WNBA all urged the justices to side with the ex-athletes, as did the Biden administration. So far, the former players have won every round of the case.

A decision from the justices is expected before the end of June, when the high court traditionally breaks for summer.

___

AP College Sports Writer Ralph D. Russo in New York contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, College Sports, AP Business, AP Sports - College Football
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Blinken reaffirms Trump-era ruling on Hong Kong autonomy
Secretary of State Antony Blinken has reaffirmed a determination made last year by the Trump administration that Hong Kong is no longer autonomous and remains undeserving of special treatment by the United States
12:48PM ( 11 minutes ago )
High court sympathetic to college athletes in NCAA dispute
The Supreme Court seems ready to give college athletes a win in a dispute with the NCAA over rules limiting education-related compensation for the athletes
12:46PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Ruh roh! Biden pooch drops doggie doo in White House hallway
One of President Joe Biden's dogs has left some poop in a White House hallway
12:38PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
After backlash, Delta CEO says Ga. voting law 'unacceptable'
The CEO of Georgia-based Delta Air Lines says the state’s new election law overhaul is “unacceptable” and “based on a lie,” after the company faced criticism that it didn’t speak out forcefully enough in opposition to the bill
12:09PM ( 50 minutes ago )
LEADING OFF: Crowds back on opening day, Cole starts season
From Fenway Park to Petco Park, ballparks will again be buzzing with real fans, rather than pumped-in crowd noise, as Fernando Tatis Jr., Juan Soto and MVPs José Abreu and Freddie Freeman step to the plate on opening day
11:46AM ( 1 hour ago )
UConn's Paige Bueckers is AP women's player of the year
UConn star Paige Bueckers is the first freshman ever to win The Associated Press women's basketball player of the year
11:00AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
Jones, Smith, Harris reconnect at Alabama's pro day No. 2
DeVonta Smith was there for quarterback Mac Jones once again
6:10PM ( 18 hours ago )
Supreme Court case could change the nature of college sports
A Supreme Court case being argued this week amid March Madness could erode the difference between elite college athletes and professional sports stars
3:41PM ( 21 hours ago )
State police to probe deadly Virginia Beach police shooting
Virginia Beach police say they've turned over their investigation of an officer-involved shooting of a Black, former college football player to state police
2:47PM ( 22 hours ago )
AP Online Football
1 of Biden's pooches drops doggie doo in White House hallway
One of President Joe Biden's dogs has left some poop in a White House hallway
12:09PM ( 50 minutes ago )
Wisconsin Supreme Court strikes down governor's mask mandate
The Wisconsin Supreme Court has struck down Gov. Tony Evers’ statewide mask mandate, ruling that the Democratic governor exceeded his authority by unilaterally extending the mandate for months through multiple emergency orders
11:48AM ( 1 hour ago )
Biden administration quietly ramping up aid to Palestinians
The Biden administration is quietly ramping up assistance to the Palestinians after former President Donald Trump cut off nearly all such aid
11:44AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Some Capitol riot suspects apologize as consequences sink in
Dozens of people arrested in the siege at the U.S. Capitol have apologized and expressed regret as the consequences of their actions sink in
6:04AM ( 6 hours ago )
Ethics panel affirms Rep. Gohmert fine over metal detector
The House Ethics Committee is upholding a $5,000 fine against Rep. Louie Gohmert
9:09PM ( 15 hours ago )
Beyond bridges: Biden redefines infrastructure to add people
President Joe Biden is preparing to unveil the first phase of what he calls his “Build Back Better” package
8:26PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Quite a show: Zags stay undefeated with 85-66 win over USC
Gonzaga got on a roll and put on a show, moving to 30-0 on the season and cruising into the Final Four with an 85-66 victory against Southern California
12:12AM ( 12 hours ago )
1st-timer Arizona joins mainstays in women's NCAA Final Four
Adia Barnes will part of a couple of firsts in the women's NCAA Final Four
11:24PM ( 13 hours ago )
South Carolina drubs Texas 62-34 to reach Final Four
Zia Cooke scored 16 points and South Carolina used its stifling defense to advance to the Final Four for the third time, shutting down Texas for a 62-34 victory
11:18PM ( 13 hours ago )
College Sports
Blinken reaffirms Trump-era ruling on Hong Kong autonomy
Secretary of State Antony Blinken has reaffirmed a determination made last year by the Trump administration that Hong Kong is no longer autonomous and remains undeserving of special treatment by the United States
12:48PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Ruh roh! Biden pooch drops doggie doo in White House hallway
One of President Joe Biden's dogs has left some poop in a White House hallway
12:38PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Suspect in attack on Asian American woman in NYC is arrested
Police say a parolee who was convicted of killing his mother nearly two decades ago has been arrested on charges including felony assault as a hate crime for a brutal attack on an Asian American woman near New York City’s Times Square
12:36PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Prosecutors detail incident that led to Floyd's arrest
The convenience store cashier who sold cigarettes to George Floyd and was handed a counterfeit $20 bill in return has taken the stand at Officer Derek Chauvin’s murder trial as prosecutors lay out the sequence of events that led to Floyd’s ill-fated arrest outside
12:32PM ( 27 minutes ago )
After backlash, Delta CEO says Ga. voting law 'unacceptable'
The CEO of Georgia-based Delta Air Lines says the state’s new election law overhaul is “unacceptable” and “based on a lie,” after the company faced criticism that it didn’t speak out forcefully enough in opposition to the bill
12:09PM ( 50 minutes ago )