clearn.png
Sunday May 9th, 2021 12:40AM

US court sides with photographer in fight over Warhol art

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — A U.S. appeals court sided with a photographer Friday in a copyright dispute over how a foundation has marketed a series of Andy Warhol works of art based on one of her pictures of Prince.

The New York-based 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the artwork created by Warhol before his 1987 death was not transformative and could not overcome copyright obligations to photographer Lynn Goldsmith. It returned the case to a lower court for further proceedings.

In a statement, Goldsmith said she was grateful to the outcome in the 4-year-old fight initiated by a lawsuit from the Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts. She said the foundation wanted to “use my photograph without asking my permission or paying me anything for my work.”

"I fought this suit to protect not only my own rights, but the rights of all photographers and visual artists to make a living by licensing their creative work — and also to decide when, how, and even whether to exploit their creative works or license others to do so,” Goldsmith said.

Warhol created a series of 16 artworks based on a 1981 picture of Prince that was taken by Goldsmith, a pioneering photographer known for portraits of famous musicians. The series contained 12 silkscreen paintings, two screen prints on paper and two drawings.

“Crucially, the Prince Series retains the essential elements of the Goldsmith Photograph without significantly adding to or altering those elements,” the 2nd Circuit said in a decision written by Judge Gerard E. Lynch.

A concurring opinion written by Circuit Judge Dennis Jacobs said the ruling would not affect the use of the 16 Warhol Prince series works acquired by various galleries, art dealers, and the Andy Warhol Museum because Goldsmith did not challenge those rights.

The ruling overturned a 2019 ruling by a Manhattan judge who concluded that Warhol's renderings were so different from Goldsmith's photograph that they transcended copyrights belonging to Goldsmith, whose work has been featured on over 100 record album covers since the 1960s.

U.S. District Judge John G. Koeltl in Manhattan had concluded that Warhol transformed a picture of a vulnerable and uncomfortable Prince into an artwork that made the singer an “iconic, larger-than-life figure.”

In 1984, Vanity Fair licensed one of Goldsmith’s black-and-white studio portraits of Prince from her December 1981 shoot for $400 and commissioned Warhol to create an illustration of Prince for an article titled “Purple Fame.”

The dispute emerged after Prince's 2016 death, when the Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts licensed the use of Warhol's Prince series for use in a magazine commemorating Prince’s life. One of Warhol's creations was on the cover of the May 2016 magazine.

Goldsmith claimed that the publication of the Warhol artwork destroyed a high-profile licensing opportunity.

Attorney Luke Nikas said the Warhol Foundation will challenge the ruling.

“Over fifty years of established art history and popular consensus confirms that Andy Warhol is one of the most transformative artists of the 20th Century,” Nikas said in a statement. “While the Warhol Foundation strongly disagrees with the Second Circuit’s ruling, it does not change this fact, nor does it change the impact of Andy Warhol’s work on history.”

Attorney Barry Werbin, who represented Goldsmith in the lower court, called Friday's ruling “a long overdue reeling in of what had become an overly-expansive application of copyright “transformative” fair use.”

“The decision helps vindicate the rights of photographers who risk having their works misappropriated for commercial use by famous artists under the guise of fair use,” he said.

The three-judge 2nd Circuit panel said its ruling should help clarify copyright law. It cautioned against judges making “inherently subjective” aesthetic judgments, saying they “should not assume the role of art critic and seek to ascertain the intent behind or meaning of the works at issue.”

It repeatedly compared the copyright issues to what occurs when books are made into movies. The movie, it noted, is often quite different from the book but yet retains copyright obligations.

The appeals court also said the unique nature of Warhol's art should have no bearing on whether the artwork is sufficiently transformative to be deemed “fair use” of a copyright, a legal term that would free an artist from paying licensing fees for the raw material it was based on.

“We feel compelled to clarify that it is entirely irrelevant to this analysis that “each Prince Series work is immediately recognizable as a ‘Warhol,’” the appeals court said. “Entertaining that logic would inevitably create a celebrity-plagiarist privilege; the more established the artist and the more distinct that artist’s style, the greater leeway that artist would have to pilfer the creative labors of others.”

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Entertainment, AP Online Recordings News, APOnline Celebrity News, AP Business
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
EU vaccine politics reach fever pitch; Britain a target
European Union vaccine politics are reaching fever pitch with charges of British blackmail and unfair practices among EU members flying about as the bloc frantically seeks to ramp up production and impose export controls to stave off another deadly surge in coronavirus infections
12:59PM ( 14 minutes ago )
France launches 2-year experiment with medical marijuana
France’s government has launched a two-year nationwide experiment with medical cannabis with a view to eventual legalization
12:59PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Putin hails Russian military's performance in Arctic drills
Russian President Vladimir Putin has hailed the military’s performance during recent Arctic drills, part of Moscow’s efforts to expand its presence in the polar region
12:54PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
US court sides with photographer in fight over Warhol art
A federal appeals court has sided with a photographer in her copyright dispute against a foundation that has marketed a series of Andy Warhol works of art based on her pictures of Prince
12:41PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Pulitzer Prize-winning author Larry McMurtry dies at 84
Pulitzer Prize-winning Texas author Larry McMurtry has died at the age of 84
12:24PM ( 49 minutes ago )
Live long in sculpture: 20-foot art planned for Spock symbol
The Museum of Science in Boston is paying tribute to city native Leonard Nimoy with a 20-foot high sculpture shaped like Mr. Spock's split-fingered “live long and prosper” gesture
11:41AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Entertainment
China attacks foreign clothing, shoe brands over Xinjiang
Chinese state TV is urging people to boycott H&M as Beijing blasts clothing and footwear brands following Western sanctions on Chinese officials accused of human rights abuses in the Xinjiang region
5:13PM ( 20 hours ago )
Acclaimed French director Bertrand Tavernier dies at age 79
The family of French filmmaker Bertrand Tavernier says he has died at age 79
2:42PM ( 22 hours ago )
Acclaimed French director Bertrand Tavernier is dead aged 79
The family of French filmmaker Bertrand Tavernier says he has died at age 79
12:02PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Recordings News
'Arrested Development' actor Jessica Walter dies at 80
Jessica Walter, who played a scheming matriach in TV’s “Arrested Development,” has died
5:55PM ( 19 hours ago )
Spielberg donates Genesis Prize money to justice nonprofits
Steven Spielberg said Thursday that he will donate his $1 million Genesis Prize to ten nonprofits working for racial and economic justice
3:30PM ( 21 hours ago )
UK court rejects Depp bid to appeal 'wife beater' ruling
A British court has refused Johnny Depp permission to appeal a judge’s ruling that he assaulted ex-wife Amber Heard
7:38AM ( 1 day ago )
APOnline Celebrity News
A year after pandemic cleared out offices, WeWork is back
After a year in which a global pandemic turned offices across the world into ghost towns WeWork, the embattled communal office-space company, is making a second attempt at going public
12:34PM ( 40 minutes ago )
Trains collide in southern Egypt, killing at least 32
Egyptian officials say two trains collided on Friday, apparently after someone activated an emergency brake
12:12PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Fauci: Vaccine study to involve college students
Dr. Anthony Fauci says scientists are trying to answer the two most pressing questions for millions of Americans already fully vaccinated against COVID-19: Can they become infected without showing any symptoms, and if so, can they transmit the coronavirus to someone else
12:03PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
EU vaccine politics reach fever pitch; Britain a target
European Union vaccine politics are reaching fever pitch with charges of British blackmail and unfair practices among EU members flying about as the bloc frantically seeks to ramp up production and impose export controls to stave off another deadly surge in coronavirus infections
12:59PM ( 14 minutes ago )
France launches 2-year experiment with medical marijuana
France’s government has launched a two-year nationwide experiment with medical cannabis with a view to eventual legalization
12:59PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Putin hails Russian military's performance in Arctic drills
Russian President Vladimir Putin has hailed the military’s performance during recent Arctic drills, part of Moscow’s efforts to expand its presence in the polar region
12:54PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Attorney for Georgia lawmaker calls charges 'overreach'
An attorney for a Georgia lawmaker who was criminally charged after knocking on the door to the governor’s private office says authorities overreached in the case
12:54PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Russia wins rhythm dance to extend command at skating worlds
Russia is extending its dominance at the World Figure Skating Championships in Stockholm
12:51PM ( 22 minutes ago )