fog.png
Wednesday December 8th, 2021 10:04AM

California high court: Judges must weigh ability to pay bail

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — The California Supreme Court ruled Thursday that judges must consider suspects’ ability to pay when they set bail, essentially requiring that indigent defendants be freed unless they are deemed too dangerous to be released awaiting trial.

“The common practice of conditioning freedom solely on whether an arrestee can afford bail is unconstitutional,” the justices said in a unanimous decision.

Judges can require electronic monitoring, regular check-ins with authorities or order the suspect to stay in a shelter or undergo drug and alcohol treatment, Associate Justice Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar wrote on behalf of the court — conditions that “in many cases protect public and victim safety as well as assure the arrestee’s appearance at trial.”

However, “what we hold is that where a financial condition is nonetheless necessary, the court must consider the arrestee’s ability to pay the stated amount of bail — and may not effectively detain the arrestee ‘solely because’ the arrestee ‘lacked the resources’ to post bail.”

There are times when protecting the community means the suspect cannot be released at all, they said, but then “a court must first find by clear and convincing evidence that no condition short of detention could suffice.”

The decision comes after voters in November rejected a state law that would have ended California’s cash bail system entirely by substituting risk assessments for every suspect, and after months when a judicial order set bail at zero for lower-level offenses during the coronavirus pandemic. The court’s ruling allows cash bail, so long as defendants can afford it.

The justices adopted the same argument that state lawmakers used in passing the 2018 law ending cash bail, and that is driving new proposed legislation that would set bail at $0 for misdemeanors and low-level felonies.

“Hallelujah!" Democratic state Sen. Robert Hertzberg, who is backing both reform efforts, said in a statement. "Cash bail is unjust, and what the court made clear is that cash bail does not work. It does not make us safer, it wastes tax payer money, and it is discriminatory. We still have more to do, but this is a great day.”

While it considered the case, the high court in August took the extraordinary step of requiring California judges to follow a lower court ruling and set bail amounts based on what suspects can afford to pay.

Bail is money or property that can be forfeited if suspects fail to appear for trial. If the suspect can’t afford bail, judges can consider alternatives like releasing them on their own recognizance, potentially with restrictions like ankle monitors.

Previously, judges set bail based on suspects’ criminal records and pending charges. Critics said that let wealthy suspects go home to prepare for trial while lower-income defendants stayed locked up, a system they said encouraged some innocents to plead guilty to get out of jail.

The appeals court ruling had support including from then-Attorney General Xavier Becerra, who said judges should consider if suspects are dangerous or likely to flee when deciding whether to keep them in jail while awaiting trial.

Becerra was confirmed last week as President Joe Biden’s health and human services secretary, and Gov. Gavin Newsom on Wednesday nominated Assemblyman Rob Bonta to replace him. Bonta is one of the Legislature’s main proponents of ending cash bail, backing both the law rejected by voters and identical Assembly and Senate bills this year that would set bail at $0 for low-level felonies and misdemeanors.

“The jailhouse door should not swing open and closed based on how much money someone has,” Bonta said in January when he and other Democratic lawmakers introduced the new legislation. “There is no disputing the present system wrongly treats people who are rich and guilty better than those who are poor and innocent.”

Judicially creating a new “ability to pay” consideration would violate the Victims’ Bill of Rights Act, also known as Marsy’s Law, approved by California voters in 2008, the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation argued in a friend of the court brief.

The foundation, which represents the interests of crime victims, contended that making cash bail contingent on suspects’ ability to pay violates state law, which allows for considering the safety of the public and victim, the seriousness of the alleged crime, the suspect’s criminal record, and the likelihood that he or she will flee.

Judges already had the ability to release suspects on their own recognizance, foundation attorney Kymberlee Stapleton said after the ruling.

“The money bail is there to ensure that they do come back for their trial date, and they’re incarcerated to protect the victim or the public,” she said. ”It’s hard to tell what impact this will have on victim and public safety going forward.”

The high court’s ruling came in the case of 66-year-old Kenneth Humphrey of San Francisco, who was jailed for more than eight months because he couldn’t post $350,000 bail on charges of stealing $5 and a bottle of cologne from a neighbor in a senior housing complex in May 2017.

The Association of Deputy District Attorneys in Los Angeles County noted that Humphrey has a long criminal record and so faced a potentially long prison sentence on charges including robbery and residential burglary. He is alleged to have demanded money from a 79-year-old man who uses a walker, then followed the victim into his apartment where he stole the items.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Michigan sees virus surge, but tighter restrictions unlikely
Michigan, which not long ago had among the country’s lowest COVID-19 infection rates, is confronting an alarming spike that some public health experts worry could be a harbinger nationally
1:51PM ( 11 minutes ago )
California high court: Judges must weigh ability to pay bail
The California Supreme Court has ruled that judges must consider suspects’ ability to pay when they set bail, essentially requiring that defendants be freed unless they are deemed too dangerous to be released awaiting trial
1:41PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Wyoming election changes pushed by Donald Trump Jr. fail
Wyoming lawmakers have rejected a measure requiring candidates to win a majority of votes in primaries to avoid runoff elections
12:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
U.S. News
Falcons hope low-cost free agent class will make big splash
With little money to spend in free agency, the Atlanta Falcons are looking to make a splash with high-character players who don’t take a big chunk out of the budget
1:46PM ( 15 minutes ago )
UK extends emergency coronavirus powers by 6 months
British lawmakers have agreed to prolong coronavirus emergency measures for six months, allowing the Conservative government to keep its unprecedented powers to restrict U.K. citizens’ everyday lives
1:42PM ( 20 minutes ago )
The Latest: UN-backed vaccine program expects supply delays
The U.N.-backed program to ship COVID-19 vaccines worldwide has announced supply delays for up to 90 million doses from an Indian manufacturer
1:37PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
High court: More police excessive force suits can go forward
The Supreme Court is siding with a New Mexico woman who was shot by police as she drove away from them
1:02PM ( 59 minutes ago )
EXPLAINER: What we know about a ship blocking the Suez Canal
A giant backhoe and a squadron of tugboats look minuscule against the cargo ship’s bulk, demonstrating the enormity of the challenge at hand: freeing the wedged, skyscraper-sized container ship that has blocked the entire width of the Suez Canal and created a major traffic jam on one of the world’s most crucial trade routes
12:58PM ( 1 hour ago )
Amid growing challenges, Biden to hold 1st news conference
The White House is hoping to use President Joe Biden's first news conference since taking office to celebrate passage of the giant COVID-19 relief package
12:44PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
US general: Afghans need US troops to counter Taliban
The top general for U.S. Special Operations Command has told Congress that Afghanistan’s military forces need U.S. assistance to successfully counter the Taliban
12:43PM ( 1 hour ago )
New US sanctions target military conglomerates in Myanmar
The United States is imposing what it calls its strongest sanctions to date over the military coup in Myanmar
12:39PM ( 1 hour ago )
Israel's Netanyahu appears to fall short of election win
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu appears to have lost his final hopes of winning elections
11:58AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: EU leaders face surge of cases, vaccine issues
European Union leaders are meeting to look for ways to ramp up COVID-19 vaccinations across the 27-nation region amid a shortage of doses
8:22AM ( 5 hours ago )
Greek Independence Day events culminate in military parade
Greece has celebrated its independence bicentennial with a military parade that included fighter jets flying over the ancient Acropolis and tanks rumbling past Parliament in central Athens
8:03AM ( 5 hours ago )
Reforms pushed in Texas as trial nears in George Floyd death
Lawmakers in Texas are taking up a sweeping police reform package named in honor of longtime Houston resident George Floyd
8:00AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Michigan sees virus surge, but tighter restrictions unlikely
Michigan, which not long ago had among the country’s lowest COVID-19 infection rates, is confronting an alarming spike that some public health experts worry could be a harbinger nationally
1:51PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Wyoming election changes pushed by Donald Trump Jr. fail
Wyoming lawmakers have rejected a measure requiring candidates to win a majority of votes in primaries to avoid runoff elections
12:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
Colorado shooting suspect makes his 1st court appearance
The suspected gunman in the Boulder supermarket shooting has appeared in court for the first time
12:52PM ( 1 hour ago )
With drivers confused, Atlantic City to redo BLM road paint
Atlantic City says it will redo a Black Lives Matter tribute on a street because the original painting of the words across the entire road confused motorists who didn’t know where to drive on it
12:13PM ( 1 hour ago )
AstraZeneca confirms strong vaccine protection after US rift
AstraZeneca says that its COVID-19 vaccine provides strong protection even after counting additional illnesses in its U.S. study
11:59AM ( 2 hours ago )