sunny.png
Monday September 27th, 2021 12:46PM

Watching the watchers: Who's at helm of EU's border agency?

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

BRUSSELS (AP) — The European Union’s border and coast guard agency Frontex, the pride of the 27-nation bloc’s vast effort to keep watch over its frontiers and anyone who might try to enter without authorization, is itself under surveillance — and under fire.

Almost literally sometimes: In the Aegean Sea, Turkish fighter jets and ships have buzzed Frontex aircraft or intimidated the agency’s boats monitoring migrant movements in the narrow strip of sea between Turkey and Greece's eastern islands. Turkish troops allegedly fired warning shots in the air at the land border too.

And in the European Parliament, calls have come for Executive Director Fabrice Leggeri to resign. Some lawmakers say he’s mishandled allegations that the agency was involved in fundamental violations of migrants' rights.

Charity groups and media outlets accuse Frontex of denying people their right to apply for asylum — which is illegal under EU law and refugee treaties. They say it was also complicit in, or failed to prevent, alleged pushbacks at sea by Greece's coastguard, where migrants were returned to Turkish waters.

Although the agency was supposed to have hired 40 fundamental rights officers by December, it still hasn’t.

An inquiry found no link between Frontex and Aegean pushbacks. But the Parliament has set up a “scrutiny group,” to delve into the reports and human rights concerns. The EU’s anti-fraud office is also looking at them, and at claims of misconduct by senior managers.

Even as criticism mounts, Frontex’s powers are growing. In coming years, the agency is projected to swell to a 10,000-strong standing force, with armed officers and hi-tech surveillance equipment. Its budget has ballooned to 5.6 billion euros ($6.7 billion) over the next seven years.

In 2014, the year before the EU's migrant challenge hit its peak, the agency had an annual budget of around 100 million euros and had to request border staff from member countries.

Its role is expanding too. Recently, when the United Kingdom left the EU, it insisted that Frontex handle border controls at the airport in the British territory of Gibraltar rather than Spanish officers.

But as Frontex’s powers and duties grow, so does the need for oversight.

“It is, in my view, the most important agency in the whole European Union. And with power and funding comes responsibility, and of course safeguards and scrutiny,” EU Migration Commissioner Ylva Johansson told investigating EU lawmakers on March 4.

Moreover, any failures at Frontex are an added embarrassment for nations that for years have been deeply divided over who should take responsibility for people entering without authorization and whether other member states should be obliged to help out.

“In the absence of the EU agreeing on migration management, what happens on the ground firmly shapes how the EU is viewed from the outside,” Hanne Beirens, at the Migration Policy Institute, told The Associated Press.

The question is: who exactly is at the helm when it comes to Frontex?

The agency is supervised by a management board of national interior ministry, police and border officials which establishes its work plan and operations. The Commission, which supervises the respect of EU laws, has two of the 28 board seats.

Leggeri, a French civil servant named Executive Director in 2015 just as hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees were arriving in Europe, is tasked with carrying out the board's strategy. The posts of deputy director and a number of other senior positions are unfilled.

On paper, Frontex is legally accountable to the 27 member countries and the European Parliament. The Commission, through Johansson, has political but not legal responsibility for Frontex’s actions.

Out on the sea, or at land borders, though, Frontex operations are controlled by the country whose territory they take place on. In the Aegean, where many pushbacks have been reported, that means the Greek coastguard. This is where the lines of responsibility get muddy.

Frontex and Greece vehemently deny carrying out pushbacks, and the inquiry cleared the agency, although it did expose “monitoring and reporting” failures. But Leggeri requested twice last year that Athens probe the conduct of the Greek coastguard.

He also told the EU lawmakers that when Turkey waved thousands of migrants through to its borders with Greece last March, Athens decided in an emergency measure “to make optimal use of the provisions on interception” to stop the attempted influx.

That means, Leggeri said, “that in some cases the migrants’ boats can be instructed not to stay in the territorial waters or not to enter.” To some, that might appear to be the very definition of a pushback, and it begs the question: should Frontex comply when an order to intercept a migrant boat might actually be breaking the law?

These blurred legal definitions, unclear lines of command and the conflicting interests of coastal or inland EU member countries make the Frontex ship a complex one to command.

German conservative lawmaker Lena Duepont — a European Parliament “scrutiny group” member — told the AP that there's plenty of room to improve “the management ecosystem of the agency,” especially the way Frontex is growing.

“It’s the first time that we have someone wearing a gun, someone wearing a European uniform,” as part of a standing corps rather than officers sent on request from member countries, she said. Frontex is more “European than ever before, and this is a drastic change within the agency.”

___

Follow AP’s global migration coverage at https://apnews.com/hub/migration

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP World News, AP Business
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
'Big burden' for schools trying to give kids internet access
Schools had to figure out quickly how to get kids online after the coronavirus pandemic shut them down
8:21AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Democrats bank on relief aid to win back wary working class
When President President Franklin D
8:14AM ( 13 minutes ago )
With Cuomo under fire, No. 2 Kathy Hochul treads carefully
New York Lt. Gov. Kathy Hochul is known as a loyal promoter of the Cuomo administration’s agenda and tireless campaigner for races at every level
8:08AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Watching the watchers: who's at the helm of EU's Frontex?
The European Union's border and coast guard is under pressure following a series of allegations that it was involved in illegal pushbacks of migrants
3:29AM ( 4 hours ago )
Call me? US-Turkey reset faces long list of hurdles
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has toned down his anti-Western and anti-US rhetoric in an apparent effort to reset the rocky relationship with his NATO allies
3:14AM ( 5 hours ago )
German election year opens with tough test for Merkel party
Elections in two German states on Sunday pose a difficult test for Chancellor Angela Merkel’s party, six months before a national vote that will determine who succeeds the country’s longtime leader
3:11AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP National News
Myanmar civilian leader vows 'revolution' against junta
The civilian leader of Myanmar’s government in hiding has vowed to continue supporting a revolution to oust the military that seized power in last month’s coup
10:49PM ( 8 hours ago )
FEMA to help manage unaccompanied minors at US-Mexico border
The Biden administration is turning to the Federal Emergency Management Agency for help managing and caring for record numbers of unaccompanied immigrant children who are streaming into the U.S. from Mexico
10:23PM ( 9 hours ago )
The Latest: All Duke University undergrads must quarantine
Duke University issued a quarantine order for all of its undergraduates effective Saturday night due to a coronavirus outbreak caused by students who attended recruitment parties, the school said
9:25PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Hondurans to vote in primaries amid corruption allegations
At a time when Honduras President Juan Orlando Hernández’s name keeps popping up in the New York trial of an alleged drug trafficker, one of the candidates running to replace Hernández in Sunday’s primary elections was convicted in the same court of laundering money for the same cartel
12:03AM ( 7 hours ago )
California governor admits mistakes, says recall unjustified
California Gov. Gavin Nlewsom said he has made mistakes in his handling of the coronavirus pandemic
8:31PM ( 10 hours ago )
Critics call Sen. Ron Johnson's insurrection comments racist
Critics of Republican U.S. Sen. Ron Johnson are calling him racist after he told an interviewer that he wasn’t worried about the supporters of former President Donald Trump who stormed the U.S. Capitol in January, but might have been concerned if they had been Black Lives Matter protesters
2:44PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Democratic push to revive earmarks divides Republicans
A dirty word for many Republicans is making the rounds on Capitol Hill — earmarks
12:30AM ( 1 day ago )
Democrats find support for Biden in small-city America
Democrats are looking for new sources of political strength as the election map is shifting
12:23AM ( 1 day ago )
Biden played 'sheriff' on '09 aid, now salesman on COVID law
In 2009, then-Vice President Joe Biden acted as “Sheriff Joe” in making sure federal dollars from a massive economic aid package were getting to the right places and getting there quickly
12:16AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Congress News
UK: Hundreds defy virus restrictions to remember slain woman
Hundreds of people in London have defied coronavirus restrictions to pay their respects to a 33-year-old woman who disappeared while walking home from a friend's apartment and was found dead a week later
3:36PM ( 15 hours ago )
Spacewalkers take extra safety precautions for toxic ammonia
Spacewalking astronauts are back safe inside the International Space Station after ridding their suits of any toxic ammonia
3:34PM ( 15 hours ago )
The Latest: Italy plans 80% vaccinated by end of September
The new Italian government says it aims to have 80% of the population vaccinated against COVID-19 by the end of September
1:27PM ( 18 hours ago )
AP Business
'Big burden' for schools trying to give kids internet access
Schools had to figure out quickly how to get kids online after the coronavirus pandemic shut them down
8:21AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Democrats bank on relief aid to win back wary working class
When President President Franklin D
8:14AM ( 13 minutes ago )
With Cuomo under fire, No. 2 Kathy Hochul treads carefully
New York Lt. Gov. Kathy Hochul is known as a loyal promoter of the Cuomo administration’s agenda and tireless campaigner for races at every level
8:08AM ( 20 minutes ago )
Beyoncé, Taylor Swift could have historic night at Grammys
It could be a night for the history books for Taylor Swift and Beyoncé at Sunday’s Grammy Awards — for both good and bad reasons
8:07AM ( 21 minutes ago )
The Latest: Extra flights to Mallorca laid on from Germany
A German airline says it is laying on extra flights to Mallorca over the Easter period after the lifting of a German travel warning for the Spanish island prompted a big increase in bookings
7:45AM ( 43 minutes ago )