sunny.png
Sunday August 1st, 2021 12:52PM

Governors evade sunshine laws to keep records from public

By The Associated Press

PIERRE, S.D. (AP) — South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem's outspoken business-as-usual approach throughout the coronavirus pandemic has made her a darling of national conservatives and allowed her to hopscotch across the country as a fundraising force.

But the public cannot see emails on how she made her decisions or how much state taxpayers are spending for her traveling security detail.

Despite Noem’s 2018 promise “to throw open the doors” of government, the South Dakota governor's office has denied requests for both records, citing broad exemptions to the state's sunshine law. Her state is among half a dozen where governors' offices routinely block access to executive records, keeping the public in the dark about decision making and possible influence peddling by special interests.

“Things that are in the public’s interests are still being hidden from the public," said Jack Marsh, a former executive editor of The Argus Leader newspaper and co-founder of the nonprofit South Dakota News Watch.

He said South Dakota's open-records laws are “some of the weakest in the country" and noted that there has been little advancement of transparency under Noem's administration other than a 2019 law that shields reporters from being forced to reveal sources.

In most states, sunshine laws give the public insight into the governor’s decisions. Since last year, governors across the country have provided thousands of pages of emails in response to requests filed by The Associated Press, revealing how some pushed economic interests ahead of public health guidance as they battled the pandemic.

But Noem and governors in five other states — Arkansas, California, Massachusetts, Michigan and New Jersey — have thwarted records requests by citing exemptions.

Her administration has refused to disclose how much it costs to send state troopers with her as she travels the country campaigning for former President Donald Trump and raising her own campaign cash. The governor’s office has cited state law exempting security details from records requests and argued that providing the information would “put lives in danger.”

Several GOP lawmakers pushed the governor's office to disclose its annual security costs to the Legislature. But Noem, a fellow Republican, pressured them to drop the matter.

“I just think it’s important the taxpayers know where every dollar goes,” Republican Rep. Taffy Howard said.

When the AP sought records detailing how businesses belonging to Noem's brothers received over $600,000 from a state pandemic grant program pushed by the governor, those too were denied under the state's exemptions for disclosure.

In California, Gov. Gavin Newsom's office last year denied an AP request for communications showing how the Democratic governor made decisions related to the virus outbreak.

California's exemption dates to 1968 with legislation enacted under then-Gov. Ronald Reagan that shielded all documents belonging to the governor's office.

David Snyder, executive director of the First Amendment Coalition in San Francisco, called the exemption a “big barrier” to gaining insight into how Newsom’s office was communicating with public agencies.

Such a blanket rule “sweeps far too broadly and keeps out of public view a range of communications that really should not be exempt from public scrutiny,” Snyder said.

Lawmakers, newspapers and open-government advocates have pressed over the years to narrow the exemptions. But after the Los Angeles Times sued in 1988 to get appointment calendars and other records that would show the governor's daily activities, the state Supreme Court ruled the public interest was better served by not disclosing the calendar.

Today, Newsom discloses his monthly calendars, as Gov. Jerry Brown did before him. But they come with caveats. Pointing to the earlier court decisions, Newsom’s lawyers write that they “will not disclose entries that reveal the deliberative process” and note the calendars are an incomplete look at the governor's activities.

Massachusetts' exemptions can be traced to a 1997 ruling in a case seeking access to a questionnaire completed by the governor's nominee to the state's high court. The ruling denied the request to make the questionnaire public while also finding that the state’s public records law does not expressly include the Legislature, judicial branch or governor's office.

Secretary of the Commonwealth William Galvin, the state’s top public records official, said he agrees that a governor needs the freedom to seek a range of opinions. But he said the interpretation of the 1997 court decision has become too broad, sweeping up nearly all information a governor wants to keep secret.

In New Jersey, the pandemic has given the governor another way to deny records requests. Gov. Phil Murphy, a Democrat, has said his administration is dedicated to transparency, but the governor’s office also has blocked multiple requests for information.

It rejected the AP's email request on the grounds it was “overbroad,” a kind of catch-all denial under the state’s Open Public Records Act. It also cited the 2005 Emergency Health Powers Act, which dates to Hurricane Katrina and says reports and other records made during an emergency are not considered public. The state has been under such an order for a year because of the pandemic.

Murphy used the Katrina-era law to deny AP's request for reports to the governor's office on hospital and nursing home capacity. Other news organizations say they have been denied on the same grounds. That includes The USA Today Network, which operates across New Jersey and had sought records showing how the state managed protective gear.

NJ Advance Media, which publishes the Newark Star-Ledger, unsuccessfully sought agreements the state made with laboratories and consultants related to the coronavirus.

That was not lawmakers’ intent when the bill passed, said Democratic Senate Majority Leader Loretta Weinberg, who was a co-sponsor of the law.

“When we are in a crisis like this, people have to have faith in their leadership because they’re asking us — demanding of us — some pretty big personal sacrifices and with good reason,” she said in an interview last year. “I’m not questioning any of that. But because our residents need to have complete faith in the leadership, then it is more important that they be completely honest.”

___

Associated Press writers Mike Catalini in Trenton, New Jersey; Steve LeBlanc in Boston; David A. Lieb in Jefferson City, Missouri; and Kathleen Ronayne in Sacramento, California, contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online President, White House, advisers News, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Business
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Watching the watchers: who's at the helm of EU's Frontex?
The European Union's border and coast guard is under pressure following a series of allegations that it was involved in illegal pushbacks of migrants
3:29AM ( 1 hour ago )
Call me? US-Turkey reset faces long list of hurdles
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has toned down his anti-Western and anti-US rhetoric in an apparent effort to reset the rocky relationship with his NATO allies
3:14AM ( 1 hour ago )
German election year opens with tough test for Merkel party
Elections in two German states on Sunday pose a difficult test for Chancellor Angela Merkel’s party, six months before a national vote that will determine who succeeds the country’s longtime leader
3:11AM ( 1 hour ago )
Associated Press (AP)
China, NKorea loom as Blinken, Austin head to Asia
Threats from China and North Korea will loom large over the Biden administration’s first Cabinet-level trip abroad
12:05AM ( 3 hours ago )
Myanmar civilian leader vows 'revolution' against junta
The civilian leader of Myanmar’s government in hiding has vowed to continue supporting a revolution to oust the military that seized power in last month’s coup
10:49PM ( 4 hours ago )
FEMA to help manage unaccompanied minors at US-Mexico border
The Biden administration is turning to the Federal Emergency Management Agency for help managing and caring for record numbers of unaccompanied immigrant children who are streaming into the U.S. from Mexico
10:18PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP National News
For Biden, there's no place like a weekend home in Delaware
For President Joe Biden, there's no place like a weekend home in Delaware
7:51PM ( 7 hours ago )
Chicago River dyed green in surprise move by city's mayor
The Chicago River has been dyed a bright shade of green after Mayor Lori Lightfoot reversed an earlier decision not to tint the waterway for second year because of the coronavirus pandemic
4:58PM ( 10 hours ago )
Critics call Sen. Ron Johnson's insurrection comments racist
Critics of Republican U.S. Sen. Ron Johnson are calling him racist after he told an interviewer that he wasn’t worried about the supporters of former President Donald Trump who stormed the U.S. Capitol in January, but might have been concerned if they had been Black Lives Matter protesters
2:44PM ( 12 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Hondurans to vote in primaries amid corruption allegations
At a time when Honduras President Juan Orlando Hernández’s name keeps popping up in the New York trial of an alleged drug trafficker, one of the candidates running to replace Hernández in Sunday’s primary elections was convicted in the same court of laundering money for the same cartel
12:03AM ( 3 hours ago )
California governor admits mistakes, says recall unjustified
California Gov. Gavin Nlewsom said he has made mistakes in his handling of the coronavirus pandemic
8:31PM ( 7 hours ago )
How Cuomo investigation, possible impeachment could play out
Gov_ Andrew Cuomo has urged New Yorkers to “wait for the facts.”
1:39PM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Biden was Sheriff Joe on '09 aid, now salesman on COVID law
In 2009, then-Vice President Joe Biden acted as “Sheriff Joe” in making sure federal dollars from a massive economic aid package were getting to the right places and getting there quickly
1:37PM ( 1 day ago )
Former presidents, first ladies urge Americans to get shots
Four former presidents are urging Americans to get vaccinated as soon as COVID-19 doses are available to them, as part of a campaign to overcome hesitancy for the shots
8:54AM ( 2 days ago )
Amanda Gorman says she was racially profiled near her home
Poet Amanda Gorman says a security guard racially profiled her while she was walking home Friday night
12:17PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Online President, White House, advisers News
Stay or go? Fence, Guard pose Capitol security questions
Nobody, it seems, wants to keep the security fence around the U.S. Capitol anymore — except the police who fought off the horrific mob attack on Jan. 6
12:08AM ( 1 day ago )
Top Dems call on Cuomo to resign amid harassment allegations
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and U.S. Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand have called on New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo to resign, adding the most powerful Democratic voices yet to calls for the governor to leave office in the wake of allegations of sexual harassment and groping
10:37PM ( 1 day ago )
Top Democrats call on Cuomo to resign as allegations mount
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and U.S. Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand have called on New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo to resign, adding the most powerful Democratic voices yet to calls for the governor to leave office in the wake of allegations of sexual harassment and groping
8:05PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Congress News
Senate confirms Fudge to lead housing agency, Regan for EPA
The Senate has confirmed Ohio Rep. Marcia Fudge to head the Department of Housing and Urban Development and North Carolina regulator Michael Regan to lead the Environmental Protection Agency
6:17PM ( 3 days ago )
Senate confirms Ohio Rep. Fudge as housing secretary
The Senate has confirmed Marcia Fudge to head the Department of Housing and Urban Development
5:35PM ( 3 days ago )
Senate confirms Merrick Garland to be US attorney general
The Senate has confirmed Merrick Garland to be the next U.S. attorney general with a strong bipartisan vote, placing the widely-respected, veteran judge in the post as President Joe Biden has vowed to restore the Justice Department’s reputation for independence
4:21PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
The Latest: All Duke University undergrads must quarantine
Duke University issued a quarantine order for all of its undergraduates effective Saturday night due to a coronavirus outbreak caused by students who attended recruitment parties, the school said
9:25PM ( 6 hours ago )
UK: Hundreds defy virus restrictions to remember slain woman
Hundreds of people in London have defied coronavirus restrictions to pay their respects to a 33-year-old woman who disappeared while walking home from a friend's apartment and was found dead a week later
3:36PM ( 12 hours ago )
Spacewalkers take extra safety precautions for toxic ammonia
Spacewalking astronauts are back safe inside the International Space Station after ridding their suits of any toxic ammonia
3:34PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Business
Watching the watchers: who's at the helm of EU's Frontex?
The European Union's border and coast guard is under pressure following a series of allegations that it was involved in illegal pushbacks of migrants
3:29AM ( 1 hour ago )
Call me? US-Turkey reset faces long list of hurdles
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has toned down his anti-Western and anti-US rhetoric in an apparent effort to reset the rocky relationship with his NATO allies
3:14AM ( 1 hour ago )
German election year opens with tough test for Merkel party
Elections in two German states on Sunday pose a difficult test for Chancellor Angela Merkel’s party, six months before a national vote that will determine who succeeds the country’s longtime leader
3:11AM ( 1 hour ago )
Devoe, Georgia Tech beat No. 15 FSU 80-75 for ACC title
Michael Devoe scored 20 points and Georgia Tech shot 52% after halftime to beat No. 15 Florida State 80-75 in the Atlantic Coast Conference Tournament championship
1:56AM ( 1 hour ago )
NBA has a record day with 5 triple-doubles
An NBA-record five players had triple-doubles Saturday, including former MVPs Giannis Antetokounmpo and Russell Westbrook in the same game
1:52AM ( 1 hour ago )