Friday October 22nd, 2021 5:16AM

UK top court gives Uber drivers benefits in landmark ruling

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

LONDON (AP) — Uber drivers in Britain are entitled to benefits like paid holidays and minimum wage, the country’s top court ruled Friday, in a decision that threatens the company’s business model and holds broad implications for the gig economy.

The ruling that the drivers should be classed as “workers” and not self-employed is a big defeat for the ride-hailing giant. And it could inspire similar legal action against other companies who rely on gig workers as well as influence courts in other countries grappling with the issue, experts said.

The seven Supreme Court judges who heard the case unanimously rejected Uber's appeal against an employment tribunal ruling that two Uber drivers were “workers" under British law.

Yaseen Aslam and James Farrar, the two drivers, cheered the outcome.

“This ruling will fundamentally re-order the gig economy and bring an end to rife exploitation of workers by means of algorithmic and contract trickery,” said James Farrar said by email. The pair took Uber to the tribunal in 2016, which ruled in their favor. The decision was upheld in two rounds of appeals before it arrived at the Supreme Court.

San Francisco-based Uber, which has 65,000 active drivers and 5 million regular users in the U.K., had argued that Aslam and Farrar were independent contractors. The company said it respected the court's decision, which it argued focused on a small number of drivers who used the Uber app in 2016.

“Since then we have made some significant changes to our business, guided by drivers every step of the way,” Jamie Heywood, Uber’s regional general manager for Northern and Eastern Europe, said in a statement. “These include giving even more control over how they earn and providing new protections like free insurance in case of sickness or injury.”

Heywood said the company would consult with its U.K. drivers to understand the changes they want.

The ruling clarified that drivers are considered to be on the job when they are logged in to the Uber app in their territory and ready and willing to accept rides, which could be used to calculate minimum wage and holiday pay. Uber had argued that drivers were only working when they were making a journey with a paying passenger.

The case is now expected to return to the employment tribunal for decisions on compensation over lost pay for about two dozen drivers involved in the original claim. Another 2,000 drivers' cases had been stayed pending the decision. Drivers could be entitled to an average of 12,000 pounds ($16,800), estimated law firm Leigh Day, which is representing drivers.

Uber drive Conrad Delphine looked forward to getting paid time off after years of working without holiday or sick pay.

“I am very pleased. It means I can go on holiday without having to worry about how to pay for it," Delphine said. “Things have been worse because of coronavirus. If we catch the virus we should be entitled to sick pay. It’s about time we had some decent pay and conditions.”

Uber and other app-based ride-hailing services avoided a similar attempt in California to classify drivers as employees eligible for benefits and job protections. The companies bankrolled Proposition 22, a ballot measure exempting them from the state’s gig-economy laws by keeping drivers classified as independent contractors able to set their own hours. Voters approved it in November.

The British judges on Friday cited a number of factors in their decision: Uber sets fares and contract terms and penalizes drivers who reject or cancel rides. It also uses passenger ratings to control drivers and minimizes communications between drivers and passengers, which results in the service being “very tightly defined and controlled by Uber.”

“Drivers are in a position of subordination and dependency to Uber,” with little ability to improve their economic position and the only way to increase their earnings is by “working longer hours while constantly meeting Uber’s measures of performance,” said judge George Leggatt, as he read out a summary of the ruling on a court livestream.

Uber said some features cited in the ruling no longer exist, noting that since 2017 drivers face no repercussion for rejecting multiple consecutive trips.

Providing more benefits for its drivers is likely increase costs for Uber, which already was struggling to make a profit and had previously run into regulatory trouble in London, where authorities had sought to revoke its license. The changes could ultimately push up fares for riders, experts say.

The decision also comes as the coronavirus has upended Uber's operating environment. The company slashed more than 6,000 jobs last year as the virus decimated demand for trips while boosting demand for its Uber Eats food delivery service. The ruling doesn't affect Uber Eats couriers.

Experts said the ruling does not have a major immediate impact on other companies because the judges cited business practices specific to Uber, which in the U.K. has to operate under specific regulations governing minicabs.

“That being said, whilst it’s not going to automatically make all gig economy workers have those rights, it’s obviously going to make people alive to the potential for bringing those claims" in court, said Joe Aiston, a senior associate at law firm Taylor Wessing. “And you wouldn’t be surprised to see more claims coming in against other similar businesses.”

Aiston said the ruling could act as reference for courts and regulators outside Britain grappling with similar issues, such as the European Union’s executive Commission, which is due to publish recommendations next week on how to regulate gig economy platform workers.

Ahead of that review, Uber CEO Dara Khosrowshahi published a white paper this week urging the EU to adopt laws that encourage “flexible and decent earning opportunities" and suggested they could adopt legislation similar to California’s, along with other ideas such as a portable benefits fund.


For all of AP’s tech coverage, visit


Follow Kelvin Chan at

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP World News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Economy, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2021
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
UK top court gives Uber drivers benefits in landmark ruling
The U.K. Supreme Court has ruled that Uber drivers should be classed as “workers” and not self-employed
5:27AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Biden to lay out his foreign policy at G-7, Munich summit
Joe Biden will make his first big appearance on the global stage as president Friday
5:27AM ( 15 minutes ago )
Australian leader urges Facebook to lift its news blockade
Australia’s prime minister has urged Facebook to lift its blockade of Australian users and return to the negotiating table with news publishing businesses
5:22AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Facebook makes a power move in Australia - and may regret it
For years, Facebook has been in a defensive crouch amid a slew of privacy scandals, antitrust lawsuits and charges that it was letting hate speech and extremism destroy democracy
3:01AM ( 2 hours ago )
The lighter days of CNN's Cuomo Brothers show are long gone
New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo is in the news because of questions about nursing home COVID deaths, but it's not a story you'll hear on his brother Chris' prime time show on CNN
3:00AM ( 2 hours ago )
Lights come back on in Texas as water woes rise in the South
Many Texans finally have electricity back after a deadly blast of winter this week overwhelmed the electrical grid and left millions shivering in the cold for days
1:55AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP National News
10 years after Christchurch quake, survivors share stories
One woman channeled her anger to ensure buildings are safer
11:46PM ( 5 hours ago )
'Obviously a mistake': Cruz returns from Cancun after uproar
Texas Sen. Ted Cruz says his family vacation to Mexico was “obviously a mistake” as he returned stateside following an uproar over his disappearance during a deadly winter storm
10:02PM ( 7 hours ago )
Texas crisis has governor facing big backer: energy industry
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott wants mandates that would require power plants to withstand extreme winter weather
9:49PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Global stocks higher after weak US jobs, economic data
Global stock markets and U.S. futures are mostly higher after disappointing American jobs and economic data
4:30AM ( 1 hour ago )
Honda taps tech expert as chief to steer in ecological times
Toshihiro Mibe, a research expert, has been tapped president of Japanese automaker Honda
4:28AM ( 1 hour ago )
Column: NBA makes the wrong call on All-Star Game
The NBA had done a lot of things right during the pandemic
2:56AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
Ford loses track of dangerous air bags, forcing 2 recalls
Ford has lost track of some older Takata air bags that can explode and hurl shrapnel, so it’s recalling more than 154,000 vehicles in North America
7:11PM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Georgia to open 4 COVID-19 vaccination sites
Georgia is opening up four mass vaccination sites to inoculate people against COVID-19, with locations chosen to try to increase the lagging share of Black and Latino residents who are getting the shots
6:14PM ( 11 hours ago )
Nestle selling North American bottled-water brands for $4.3B
Global food giant Nestle is selling its North American bottled-water brands for $4.3 billion to a pair of private-equity firms that hope to reinvigorate sales
6:14PM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Myanmar protests focus on junta's economic support
State railway workers in Myanmar are continuing to strike despite a police rampage the previous night targeting them in a sign of the military junta’s concern over growing civil disobedience by public workers protesting the coup
1:42PM ( 16 hours ago )
The Latest: Czech Republic lawmakers act to end crisis
The lower house of the Czech Republic's Parliament has approved new legislation that defines the state's responsibilities and rights in fighting the pandemic in a hard-hit European Union country
12:44PM ( 16 hours ago )
The Latest: Officials in Italy cancel coronavirus conference
Officials in Italy have canceled a conference planned to commemorate the anniversary of the country's coronavirus outbreak
11:51AM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Biden to lay out his foreign policy at G-7, Munich summit
Joe Biden will make his first big appearance on the global stage as president Friday
5:27AM ( 15 minutes ago )
Australian leader urges Facebook to lift its news blockade
Australia’s prime minister has urged Facebook to lift its blockade of Australian users and return to the negotiating table with news publishing businesses
5:22AM ( 19 minutes ago )
UK vows to share vaccines, but details thin as G-7 meets
Leaders of the Group of Seven economic powers are holding their first meeting of 2021, and getting coronavirus vaccines to people around the world is top of the agenda
5:19AM ( 23 minutes ago )
Africa reaches 100,000 known COVID-19 deaths as danger grows
Africa has surpassed 100,000 confirmed deaths from COVID-19
5:17AM ( 25 minutes ago )
'Alone': How Italian town with 1st known virus death fared
Italy delivered the first shocking confirmation of locally transmitted coronavirus infections outside of Asia a year ago Sunday, with back-to-back revelations of cases in the country’s north
5:15AM ( 26 minutes ago )