clearn.png
Saturday October 16th, 2021 11:18PM

Fox hosts Dobbs, Bartiromo strike back in voting fraud suit

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Three Fox News hosts — Maria Bartiromo, Lou Dobbs and Jeanine Pirro — are seeking the dismissal of claims against them and their employer as part of a $2.7 billion libel lawsuit brought by the voting technology company Smartmatic.

Bartiromo, Dobbs and Pirro, as well as Donald Trump lawyers Rudolph Giuliani and Sidney Powell, were sued this month for the eye-popping amount by Smartmatic, which accused them of conspiring to spread false claims that the company was involved in an effort to steal the presidential election from Trump.

In its motions, lawyers from Kirkland & Ellis, which is also defending Fox, argue Bartiromo, Dobbs and Pirro were doing their job in covering the biggest story of the day: unprecedented allegations by the president that the integrity of the electoral process was marred by fraud.

Smartmatic, in its 285-page complaint filed Feb. 4 in state court in New York, had cited at least 13 reports on Fox News in which guests or personalities falsely stated or implied that the company had somehow helped steal the election through easily tampered technology or in cahoots with Venezuela’s socialist government.

The complaint alleged that the “disinformation campaign” continued even after then-Attorney General William Barr said the Department of Justice could find no evidence of widespread voter fraud.

“Smartmatic is confident in its case and looks forward to briefing these issues for the Court,” J. Erik Connolly, attorney for Smartmatic, wrote Friday in a statement.

The lawsuit is being closely watched as the rise of far-right voices on social media and pro-Trump outlets like Newsmax and One America News challenge long-held assumptions about the limits of free speech.

The filings by the Fox personalities note instances in which they questioned Powell and Giuliani for evidence to back their claims, as well as Smartmatic's own denial of the charges. It also argues that Dobbs' statements appearing to validate the claims of his guests were constitutionally protected opinions, not statements of fact.

“The First Amendment protects the press when it informs the public about judicial proceedings regardless of the accuracy of the underlying allegations,” according to the motion filed on behalf of Dobbs.

All three hosts later aired a segment with an expert debunking some of the claims that had been made on its networks against Smartmatic and another voting technology company, Dominion.

The Fox Business Network dropped Dobbs’ show Feb. 5, a day after the lawsuit was filed. The network said the move was part of a planned programming shift and not related to the lawsuit.

Bartiromo in her motion suggests an alternate motive for what she calls Smartmatic's “headline-seeking” lawsuit: an attempt by the company to fill its coffers after reporting losses of $17 million on $144 million in revenue in 2019.

“This complaint is not just meritless; it is a legal shakedown designed to chill speech and punish reporting on issues that cut to the heart of our democracy,” her lawyers argue.

Roy Gutterman, a media law professor at Syracuse University, said Fox in its motion made reasonable arguments about First Amendment rights and its duty to fuel public discourse on important political issues.

“Whether the broadcaster is liable for providing a forum for speakers and what responsibility they have for dealing with false factual statements will be central to the court’s decision,” he said.

Still, he said, if Fox succeeds in persuading the court to dismiss the case, the individual guests — Giuliani and Powell — could still be liable for potentially false and damaging statements.

Smartmatic's participation in the U.S. election was restricted to a single district, Los Angeles County, which votes heavily Democratic.

That limited role notwithstanding, the company and its technology were widely and baselessly blamed by Trump supporters for somehow tilting the race in favor of Joe Biden. The effects of the negative publicity were swift and included death threats against an executive's 14-year-old son, the loss of business and an enduring stain on its reputation, Smartmatic says.

The company fears its entire business, once worth billions as it expanded to countries around the world — from Belgium to the Philippines — could now be valued near zero.

Like many conspiracy theories, the alleged campaign against Smartmatic was built on a grain of truth. The company's founder and CEO is Venezuelan, and Smartmatic’s initial success is partly attributable to major contracts from Hugo Chávez’s government, an early devotee of electronic voting.

Dobbs, in his motion to join the Fox request for dismissal, points out that he first covered Smartmatic a decade earlier, in 2006, when employed by CNN. At the time the company was facing scrutiny from U.S. lawmakers concerned about its purchase of an American competitor so shortly after it had helped organize elections in Venezuela that were marred by allegations of fraud.

___

Follow Goodman on Twitter: @APJoshGoodman

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Entertainment, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: Japan expected to approve Pfizer vaccine
Japan’s health minister says the efficacy of Pfizer vaccine was endorsed by a ministry panel
10:09AM ( 9 minutes ago )
Fox hosts Dobbs, Bartiromo strike back in voting fraud suit
Three hosts for Fox News have filed motions to dismiss claims against them and their employer as part of a $2.7 billion libel lawsuit brought by a voting technology company
10:03AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Chinese vaccine will pull Hungary ahead of EU, PM says
Hungary's prime minister is predicting his country could pull ahead of other European Union members in giving COVID-19 vaccinations due to its plan to use a vaccine made in China
9:50AM ( 27 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Singer fined by German court for son's stage performance
A Bavarian court has found a folk singer guilty of violating Germany’s strict child labor laws for having his 4-year-old son perform on stage with him during an evening concert
7:31AM ( 2 hours ago )
China bans BBC news broadcasts in apparent retaliation
China has banned BBC World News from airing in China, a week after threatening to retaliate for the revocation of the British broadcasting license for China’s state-owned CGTN
5:14AM ( 5 hours ago )
ABC News to air newsmagazine on the Black experience
ABC News says it will air “Soul of a Nation” next month, which it believes is the first prime-time network newsmagazine focused on Black life in America
10:44PM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Huawei takes HSBC to UK court for docs in extradition fight
Huawei took U.K. bank HSBC to court on Friday seeking documents the Chinese company says are key to its legal efforts to stop its chief financial officer from being extradited to the U.S. from Canada
8:51AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Fauci: Keep wearing masks as vaccines roll out
Dr. Anthony Fauci says people will need to wear masks “for several, several months” to avoid the coronavirus as vaccinations are rolled out
8:42AM ( 1 hour ago )
UK economy suffers biggest drop since 1709
Britain’s economy suffered its biggest decline in more than 300 years in 2020 as the coronavirus pandemic closed shops and restaurants, devastated the travel industry and curtailed manufacturing
7:29AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
Australia report says make Google and Facebook pay for news
Australia’s Parliament will debate making Google and Facebook pay for news after a Senate committee recommended no changes to the world-first draft laws
1:55AM ( 8 hours ago )
Kim lays blame at officials for N. Korea's economic failures
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un ripped into the performance of his Cabinet and fired a senior economic official he appointed a month ago, saying they’d failed to come up with new ideas to salvage an economy in decay
12:14AM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Australia's 2nd largest city to begin lockdown
Australia’s second-largest city will begin its third lockdown due to a rapidly spreading COVID-19 cluster centered on hotel quarantine
11:38PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
The Latest: Japan expected to approve Pfizer vaccine
Japan’s health minister says the efficacy of Pfizer vaccine was endorsed by a ministry panel
10:09AM ( 9 minutes ago )
Chinese vaccine will pull Hungary ahead of EU, PM says
Hungary's prime minister is predicting his country could pull ahead of other European Union members in giving COVID-19 vaccinations due to its plan to use a vaccine made in China
9:50AM ( 27 minutes ago )
Djokovic not sure if he can keep playing at Australian Open
Novak Djokovic says he has a torn muscle after falling during his five-set victory over American Taylor Fritz in the Australian Open's third round
9:37AM ( 40 minutes ago )
Biden views Valentine's Day decorations on WH lawn
First lady Jill Biden had installed before dawn Friday special Valentine’s Day artwork on the north lawn of the White House: giant pink, white and red hearts that resemble the popular candy
9:31AM ( 46 minutes ago )
Int'l Criminal Court member states to elect new prosecutor
Member states of the International Criminal Court are electing a new prosecutor to replace incumbent Fatou Bensouda when her nine-year term expires later this year
9:30AM ( 47 minutes ago )