Saturday December 4th, 2021 5:01PM

Himalayan glacier disaster highlights climate change risks

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW DELHI (AP) — When Ravi Chopra saw the devastating deluge of water and debris crash downstream from a Himalayan glacier on Sunday, his first thought was that this was exactly the scenario that his team had warned the Indian government of in 2014.

At least 31 people have died, 165 people are missing and many are feared to have died. The deluge first smashed into a small dam, gathering more energy as it grew heavier from the debris it collected along the way. Then, it smashed into a larger, under-construction dam and gathered even more energy.

Chopra and other experts had been tasked by India's Supreme Court to study the impact of receding glaciers on dams. They had warned that warming due to climate change was melting the Himalayan glaciers and facilitated avalanches and landslides, and that constructing dams in the fragile ecosystem was dangerous.

“They were clearly warned, and yet they went ahead,” said Chopra, director of the non-profit People’s Science Institute.

Scientists had first suspected that a glacial lake had burst Sunday. After examining satellite images, they now believe that a landslide and avalanche were the more likely causes of the disaster. It isn't clear whether the landslide induced an avalanche of ice and debris, or whether falling ice resulted in the landslide, said Mohammad Farooq Azam, who studies glaciers at the Indian Institute of Technology at Indore.

What is known is that mass of rock, boulders, ice and snow came crashing down a 2-kilometer (1.2-mile) near vertical mountain slope on Sunday. And now scientists are trying to figure out if the heat produced due to friction would be enough to melt the snow and ice to result in the flood of water, he said.

Experts say that the disaster underscores the fragility of the Himalayan mountains where the lives of millions are being altered by climate change.

Even if the world meets its most ambitious climate change targets, rising temperatures will melt away a third of the Himalayan glaciers by the end of the century, a 2019 report by the International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development found. Himalayan glaciers are melting twice as fast since 2000 as they were in the 25 years before due to human-caused climate change, researchers reported in Science Advances in 2019.

Whether this particular disaster was caused by climate change isn't known. But climate change can increase landslides and avalanches. As glaciers melt due to warming, valleys that were earlier crammed with ice open up, creating space for landslides to move into. In other places, steep mountainous slopes may be partially "glued" together by ice frozen tightly inside its crevices.

“As warming occurs and the ice melts, the pieces can move downhill more easily, lubricated by the water,” explained Richard B. Alley, a professor of earth sciences at Pennsylvania State University.

With warming, ice is also essentially becoming less frozen: Earlier its temperature would range between minus 6 degrees Celsius to minus 20 C and it it is now minus 2 C (from 21.2 degrees Fahrenheit to minus 4 F earlier to 28.4 F now), said Azam. The ice is still frozen, but is closer to its melting point, so it takes less heat to trigger an avalanche than some decades ago, added Azam.

Another threat is that of a glacial lake bursting — what some first suspected was the cause of Sunday's disaster. The hazard posed by these expanding lakes can't be ignored, said Joerg Michael Schaefer, a climate scientist who specializes in ice and especially Himalayan glaciers at Columbia University.

The water the lakes release into rivers contain the energy equal to “several nuclear bombs” and can provide clean, carbon-free energy through hydropower projects, Schaefer said. But it's dangerous to set up power plants without looking uphill and mitigating the risk by siphoning water from the lakes to control levels, he said.

“The brute force of these things just kind of just really mind blowing," especially if they break, he said. “You cannot tame that tiger. You have to prevent that.”

The Uttarakhand state government said it continually faced “acute power shortage” and was forced to spend $137 million each year to buy electricity, documents submitted to India's Supreme Court show. The state has the second-highest potential for generating hydropower in India, but experts say that solar energy and wind energy offered more sustainable and less risky alternatives in the long-run.

Development was needed for the upliftment of the impoverished region, but experts said such projects should take into account the ecological fragility of the mountains and the unpredictable risks posed by climate change.

For instance, during the 2009 construction of the second dam that got hit by flood water on Sunday, workers accidentally punctured an aquifer. Enough water for 2 million to 3 million people to drink drained out at the rate of up to 70 million liters (18.5 million gallons) every day for a month and villages in the area faced water shortages.

Development plans need to “go along with the environment” and not against it, said Anjal Prakash, a professor at the Indian School of Business who has contributed to research into the impacts of climate change in the Himalayas for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

“Climate change is here and now. It is not something that is going to happen later on,” he said.


Victoria Milko in Jakarta, Indonesia, and Seth Borenstein in Kensington, Maryland, contributed to this report.


The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute’s Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP World News, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2021
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Himalayan glacier disaster highlights climate change risks
After examining satellite images, scientists believe that last weekend's glacier disaster in northern India is linked to a landslide and an avalanche
5:29AM ( 13 minutes ago )
Trump's trial starting: 'Grievous crime' or just 'theater'?
Donald Trump’s historic second impeachment trial in the Senate is an undertaking like no other in U.S. history
5:25AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Iran starts limited COVID vaccinations with Russian shots
Iran has launched a coronavirus inoculation campaign among healthcare professionals with recently delivered Russian Sputnik V vaccines as the country struggles to stem the worst outbreak of the pandemic in the Middle East
5:24AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Mary Wilson, longest-reigning original Supreme, dies at 76
Mary Wilson, the longest-reigning original Supreme, has died at 76 years old
4:07AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Interview: Salvador Illa, Catalonia's quiet gamechanger
A former health minister of Spain hopes to become a quiet political disruptor in the country's Catalonia region when voters go to the polls this weekend
4:04AM ( 1 hour ago )
Rescuers look for survivors of Indian glacier flood disaster
Hundreds of rescue workers were scouring muck-filled ravines and valleys in northern India for survivors after part of a Himalayan glacier broke off, sending a devastating flood downriver that has left at least 31 people dead and 165 missing
3:00AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Sources: Biden officials snub Salvadoran leader in DC trip
The Biden administration turned down a meeting request with El Salvador’s president on an unannounced trip to Washington last week, as criticism of the Central American leader mounts among Democrats, according to three people with knowledge of the decision
11:35PM ( 6 hours ago )
Vaccine drive gains speed, but maskless fans fuel worries
The drive to vaccinate Americans against the coronavirus is gaining speed and newly recorded cases have fallen to their lowest level in three months, but authorities worry that raucous Super Bowl celebrations could fuel new outbreaks
10:05PM ( 7 hours ago )
Man charged in US Capitol riot worked for FBI, lawyer says
A lawyer for a Virginia man charged in the attack on the U.S. Capitol as part of the far-right Oath Keepers militia group says the man has held a top secret security clearance for decades and previously worked for the FBI
9:30PM ( 8 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Syrian who fled to Germany 5 years ago runs for parliament
A 31-year-old Syrian man who came to Germany as an asylum-seeker in 2015 has just launched his campaign to run in Germany's federal election on Sept. 26
2:59AM ( 2 hours ago )
UN experts: North Korea using cyber attacks to update nukes
U.N. experts say North Korea has modernized its nuclear weapons and ballistic missile arsenals by flaunting United Nations sanctions, using cyberattacks to help finance its arsenal
1:55AM ( 3 hours ago )
Hong Kong denies bail for opposition publisher Jimmy Lai
A Hong Kong court has denied bail for government critic and newspaper publisher Jimmy Lai who is facing charges under a sweeping new national security law
10:25PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP World News
German exports down 9.3% last year, biggest fall since 2009
Official data show that Germany’s exports plunged by 9.3% last year as the coronavirus pandemic dragged down demand, the biggest drop since the financial crisis in 2009
4:11AM ( 1 hour ago )
Global stocks mixed on optimism over recovery, stimulus
Global stock markets are mixed after another record-setting rally on Wall Street
4:09AM ( 1 hour ago )
Asian stocks higher after Wall Street rises to new record
Asian stock markets are higher after Wall Street rose to a new record
3:05AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
The Latest: Miss. says out-of-staters showing up for vaccine
Officials in Mississippi say about 2% of the coronavirus vaccinations given so far in the state have gone to people with out-of-state addresses
7:02PM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Judge ends pandemic charge against hair stylists
A judge in Michigan has dismissed disorderly conduct charges against six hair stylists who were ticketed last spring during a protest at the state Capitol
6:10PM ( 11 hours ago )
Stocks push to more gains, and record highs, on Wall Street
Stocks pushed to more gains and record highs on Wall Street, just as the market came off its biggest week since November
4:40PM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
140 are missing after glacier breaks in India's Himalayas
At least nine people are dead and 140 are missing in India after part of a glacier in the Himalayas broke off, releasing a torrent of water and debris that slammed into two hydroelectric plants
8:06PM ( 1 day ago )
Ecuadorians to pick president under strict pandemic measures
Ecuador is choosing a new president while facing unprecedented health measures due to the coronavirus pandemic
11:40AM ( 1 day ago )
Glacier breaks in India's north; flood kills 9, 140 missing
Indian authorities have launched a search operation after a Himalayan glacier broke, sending a massive flood of water and debris slamming into two dams and damaging a number of homes
11:39AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Utilities
Trump's trial starting: 'Grievous crime' or just 'theater'?
Donald Trump’s historic second impeachment trial in the Senate is an undertaking like no other in U.S. history
5:25AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Iran starts limited COVID vaccinations with Russian shots
Iran has launched a coronavirus inoculation campaign among healthcare professionals with recently delivered Russian Sputnik V vaccines as the country struggles to stem the worst outbreak of the pandemic in the Middle East
5:24AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Polish pride, free speech at stake in Holocaust libel case
A Warsaw court is scheduled to deliver a verdict in a closely watched libel case in which Polish national dignity and the independence of Holocaust research are said to be at stake
5:22AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Nadal, Barty advance in straight sets at Australia Open
Rafael Nadal showed no signs of a back problem that hampered his preparation for the Australian Open
5:20AM ( 22 minutes ago )
What to watch as Trump's 2nd impeachment trial kicks off
Former President Donald Trump’s second impeachment trial begins on Tuesday
5:18AM ( 24 minutes ago )