Saturday January 22nd, 2022 12:16AM

California may cut rooftop solar incentives as market booms

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — California’s 26-year-old program to get more people to put solar panels on their homes has been wildly successful, but state regulators may reduce the incentives for people to go solar in a bid to reduce electricity bills for the rest of residents in the most populous U.S. state.

Current incentives allow residential solar customers to sell whatever energy they don’t use back to power companies at the retail rate for power, usually resulting in a big discount on their energy bills. But power companies say the savings are now so great that solar customers no longer pay their fair share for the operation of the overall energy grid.

The future of the program, known as “net energy metering,” has prompted a fierce debate between the state's major utilities and the solar industry.

Regulators at the California Public Utilities Commission, which oversees the state's major utilities and the rates they can set, are expected to issue proposed reforms on Monday. It comes as California strives to achieve its ambitious clean energy goals.

California’s net metering program launched in 1995 with the goal of boosting solar adoption in the famously sunny state. California now has more than 1.3 million residential solar installations, more than any other state, according to the solar industry. That number will only grow because since 2020 all newly constructed homes in California must have solar panels.

But as solar panels proliferated, criticism about the program grew. The major utility companies — Pacific Gas & Electric, San Diego Gas & Electric and Southern California Edison — say the current setup allows solar customers to sell their energy back into the grid for more than it's worth. They say more needs to be done to make sure solar customers — most of whom still rely on power from utilities at nighttime — are paying for all the parts of the energy grid they use.

Power rates include many costs unrelated to energy generation, like transmission, distribution and even wildfire prevention work. When solar households pay significantly lower electricity bills — or no bills at all — they’re contributing less to those things. That means more of the cost is shouldered by other customers. The utilities peg that cost at $3 billion, though the solar industry disputes that number.

The California Public Utilities Commission began a process for reforming the program last year with an eye toward ensuring energy grid maintenance costs are spread equitably and making it easier for residents of all backgrounds to purchase solar panels. Currently, higher-income households are more likely to have solar panels than lower-income households because solar costs a lot of money up front.

There are a wide array of opinions on potential reforms — 18 groups including the solar industry, the utilities, ratepayer advocates and environmental groups submitted proposals to state regulators. A five-member commission will vote on the final PUC reform proposal, likely in January.

The solar industry warns a dramatic decrease in financial incentives would entice fewer people to add solar panels to their homes, jeopardizing the market and hurting the state's ability to reach its clean energy goals. California is working to power all retail electricity with renewable or zero-carbon energy by 2045.

Solar panels on average cost between $20,000 and $25,000 to install on a California home, said Bernadette Del Chiaro, executive director at the California Solar and Storage Association, which represents 700 businesses involved in the solar market.

It now takes about three to four years for homeowners to recoup installation costs by selling extra energy to the utilities, according to the utilities.

The utilities have proposed lowering the amount of money solar customers get back, meaning it would take longer — 11 to 15 years — for homeowners to recover their costs. All residential solar customers would also have a “grid benefits charge” and a “customer charge” added to their bills that could be upwards of $70 per month.

The utilities' desired changes wouldn't apply to people who already have solar panels on their homes, only those who choose to install solar panels going forward. Low-income customers who install them within three years would pay lower fees.

The Utility Reform Network, a consumer advocacy group that frequently clashes with the utilities over rates, also wants to lower what households with solar panels are paid back for excess energy.

The group has suggested locking in a 10-year price so homeowners know what they’ll be paid for excess energy before they install solar. They also want to increase the financial incentives for low-income households to participate.

“We are focused on affordability for everyone,” said Matt Freedman, staff attorney for the group.

The solar industry and its allies, including some environmental justice and clean energy organizations, say regulators should be looking for ways to boost incentives for California residents to buy solar panels, not decrease them.

Del Chiaro said the state should also make it easier for people to buy solar storage systems alongside the panels. The systems cost about $15,000 to install and allow people with solar panels to store their own energy for use when it gets dark, making them less reliant on the energy grid.

As more people build storage systems, the utilities will need to spend less on new power plants or transmission lines, she said. But it also means they'll have fewer customers relying on them for energy.

“Utilities are really threatened now by batteries,” Del Chiaro said. “They’re really putting up a big fight to try to slow this market down.”

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities, AP Business - Personal Finance, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2022
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Tornado toll in dozens, yet not as high as initially feared
Dozens of people in five states have been killed by tornadoes that leveled entire communities on Friday night, but the toll at a Kentucky candle factory is not as devastating as initially feared
12:17AM ( 23 minutes ago )
Navy to hold hearing for sailor accused of igniting warship
The Navy will hold a hearing Monday to review whether there is enough evidence to order a court martial for a San Diego-based sailor charged with setting the fire that destroyed the USS Bonhomme Richard in the summer of 2020
12:09AM ( 31 minutes ago )
California may cut rooftop solar incentives as market booms
California's rooftop solar market is the largest in the nation but is poised for changes by state regulators who could lower financial benefits for homeowners who install solar panels
12:05AM ( 34 minutes ago )
U.S. News
White House group's annual Christmas ornament honors LBJ
The White House Historical Association is honoring President Lyndon Johnson with its 2021 annual Christmas tree ornament
12:09AM ( 31 minutes ago )
LeBron scores 30, Lakers top Magic 106-94 for 5th win in 7
The Los Angeles Lakers rolled past the Orlando Magic 106-94 for their fifth victory in seven games
12:06AM ( 34 minutes ago )
Michigan's Aidan Hutchinson wins Lott IMPACT Trophy
Aidan Hutchinson of Michigan has won the Lott IMPACT Trophy as the college defensive player having the biggest influence on his team
11:56PM ( 44 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Vicente Fernández, revered Mexican singer, dies at 81
Vicente Fernández, a beloved Mexican singer who was awarded three Grammys and nine Latin Grammys and inspired a new generation of performers, including his son Alejandro Fernández, has died
9:45PM ( 2 hours ago )
Photo from tornado-damaged home lands almost 130 miles away
A photo from a tornado-damaged home in Kentucky landed almost 130 miles away in Indiana
8:32PM ( 4 hours ago )
Planning questions emerge at tornado-destroyed candle plant
The Mayfield Consumer Products factory was the third-biggest employer in this corner of western Kentucky, an important economic engine that churned out candles that lined the shelves of malls around the U.S. But why its Friday night-shift workers kept making candles as a ferocious tornado bore down on the region remains unknown as rescuers continue scouring the wreckage of the plant for signs of life
7:20PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP National News
EXPLAINER: Will ex-official clear up Noem nepotism probe?
South Dakota lawmakers are preparing to hear from a former state employee at the center of questions over whether Gov. Kristi Noem interfered in an agency that was evaluating her daughter’s application for a real estate appraiser license
2:32PM ( 10 hours ago )
Crews search for the missing after devastating tornadoes
Kentucky’s governor is warning the state’s death toll from an outbreak of tornadoes could top 100
1:56PM ( 10 hours ago )
Will new bacon law begin? California grocers seek delay
A coalition of California restaurants and grocery stores has filed a lawsuit to block implementation of a new farm animal welfare law
12:01PM ( 12 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Top US diplomat says China needs more ambitious climate goal
The top U.S. diplomat in China says the countries had a very good year for collaboration on dealing with climate change, but Washington is still pushing Beijing to adopt more ambitious carbon reduction goals
8:51PM ( 3 hours ago )
Cowboys deliver on coach's guarantee, beat rival Washington
The Dallas Cowboys made good on coach Mike McCarthy’s guarantee by holding on to beat Washington 27-20 and snap their rival’s winning streak at four
5:30PM ( 7 hours ago )
Scholz, Polish prime minister discuss migration, energy, EU
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz has stressed that Europe won’t tolerate attempts at undermining the territorial integrity of its nations and said that diplomatic tools like the Normandy Format should be used to de-escalate tensions after Russia massed troops near Ukraine’s border
5:09PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Business
Biden choice for Justice antitrust post wins Senate approval
President Joe Biden’s choice to lead enforcement of competition laws at the Justice Department has won Senate approval
7:15PM ( 3 weeks ago )
Strict vaccine mandate begins for Los Angeles businesses
A new mandate in the city of Los Angeles now requires people visiting shopping malls, theaters, gyms or nail salons in Los Angeles to verify they are vaccinated against COVID-19
5:17AM ( 1 month ago )
Vaccine proof required in LA as strict mandate takes effect
People going to shopping malls, theaters, gyms or nail salons in Los Angeles must now verify that they are vaccinated against COVID-19
6:01PM ( 1 month ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
G7 warns Russia of 'massive' consequences if Ukraine invaded
The Group of Seven economic powers have told Russia  to “de-escalate” its military buildup near the Ukrainian border, warning that an invasion would have “massive consequences” and inflict severe economic pain on Moscow
10:36AM ( 14 hours ago )
At G7, UK warns Russia of 'severe' cost of Ukraine incursion
British Foreign Secretary Liz Truss has said the "world’s largest economies are united" in warning Russia that an invasion of Ukraine would have “massive” consequences
6:45AM ( 17 hours ago )
Major multi-day storm headed toward Northern California
A major storm is headed toward Northern California this weekend, promising to drop heavy snow in the Sierra Nevada and rain throughout the region
12:40AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Industries
Navy blames Hawaii water contamination on jet fuel spill
Navy officials say they believe that contaminated tap water that went to Hawaii military households came from a one-time spill of jet fuel last month
9:51PM ( 2 days ago )
UK warns over reliance on Russian gas as G7 ministers meet
Britain’s top diplomat is warning that “free democratic nations” must wean themselves off Russian gas and Russian money to preserve their independence
7:02PM ( 2 days ago )
US hostage envoy visited Venezuela to meet jailed Americans
The Associated Press has learned that a senior U.S. diplomat quietly traveled to Venezuela this week and met with imprisoned Americans in an ongoing effort to secure their release
7:01PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Utilities
AP-NORC Poll: Income is up, but Americans focus on inflation
Americans’ overall income has accelerated since the pandemic, but so has inflation — and a new poll finds that far more people are noticing the higher prices than the pay gains
11:11AM ( 3 days ago )
Average US long-term mortgage rates hold firm another week
The average interest rate on a long-term mortgage in the U.S. held firm again this week
10:05AM ( 3 days ago )
California plans to be abortion sanctuary if Roe overturned
State lawmakers may help pay for people from other states to come to California for abortions if the U.S. Supreme Court overturns Roe v
7:59PM ( 4 days ago )
AP Business - Personal Finance
Tornado toll in dozens, yet not as high as initially feared
Dozens of people in five states have been killed by tornadoes that leveled entire communities on Friday night, but the toll at a Kentucky candle factory is not as devastating as initially feared
12:17AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Navy to hold hearing for sailor accused of igniting warship
The Navy will hold a hearing Monday to review whether there is enough evidence to order a court martial for a San Diego-based sailor charged with setting the fire that destroyed the USS Bonhomme Richard in the summer of 2020
12:09AM ( 32 minutes ago )
Potter trial enters second week with medical examiner on tap
The trial of a Minnesota police officer charged in the shooting death of Daunte Wright opens its second week of testimony Monday
11:28PM ( 1 hour ago )
Teen accused in Michigan high school shooting due in court
A 15-year-old boy accused of opening fire at his Michigan high school, killing four students, is due in court for a procedural hearing
11:27PM ( 1 hour ago )
Tornado survivor: 'Not knowing is worse than knowing'
Autumn Kirks and her boyfriend, Lannis Ward, were both working the night shift at a candle factory in Mayfield, Kentucky, when a massive tornado struck
9:53PM ( 2 hours ago )